High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1698/2015allowed

The Punjab Pvt Self Financed Dental & Medical Colleges Association v. State Of Punjab Etc

2016-04-07Mr. Justice Rajiv Narain Raina,Mr. Justice Surinder Singh Grewal42 pages

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -1-

! "#$%$&'(')* + ,

* - .... - .

# #

# $ # # % & '

( # # % )

" # # % * ... /

,- -. / " &* &0 '0&1 + 2 3% &')*&'0&1 -

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -2-

4 5 6 07 '0&1,9 1 8/ +

# : # , % '/ ,;:<4 / = " ,9 1/ + :, % '/

+ @ #

5, % )/,;?

+<4 / ( +,/ '0&1 " "

(

= $ : :9 "

4'0&1 ,;=$::<4 / > #:

,9 8/

" ( "

" >A 4 '0&1 + ?

+ , % )/ (" 5 "

(

+ ( " +

&00B

( + " + A "

# +

# +# ( + ,/

( "

" > + ,>/

(

=$::4'0&1

# #

(

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -3- 5 6 ,9 1 8/# "

+ 2 + "

" : # , % &/ '1 0'

'0&1,9 &/ "

$ @ : = , A / 9"-

+ '0&1 ( ( + '1 0) '0&1 ,9 '/ "

$ @ : = , A / 9"-

% 1 ,9 & '/# " "

"=$::4'0&1"

# "

( "

# #

> + ,>/ 9 "

+, % )/ > #

% '7 # "

10B " 6 10B " "A

+6 ( ( &1B6 %4 = ,%=/ "

(

( '8 '0&1 ( ( + ( '7 '0&1

( 0* '0&1

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -4-

9 ( 9 &0 '0&1 : , % '/ 'D '0&1 ,9 )/

+ , % )/ = (

( +# $ "# :

" ,&/ E =$::4'0&1 + "

C ,'/ (

=$::4'0&1 6 + "

5 > ,)/ = "

( "

+ ( # "

% ,&/ ,'/

# " = * ,9 & '/ " C( # #

" =$::4'0&1"

# "

( "

>9 "

+, % )/ , % &/# #

" 0& '0&1,9 */

#( (

" '1 0) '0&1,9 '/ +(

% 1 ( " 4 F@( #

" =$::4'0&1"

# "

( "

G > 9 "

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -5-

+ I ,:"

/ "" ( + (

" =$::4'0&1"

# "

( "

>9 "

" ?

+ , % )/# ( #

(

"# ( (

> 9 "

" HA ?

+ ( ( + 07 '0&1,9 1 8/ +:, % '/# ( "

'0&1# (

=$::4'0&1 +# 07 '0&1,9 8/( + :, % '/( " "

( " >A '0&1 +?

+, % )/ (" 5 "

(

# ( ( " #

" =$::4'0&1"

# "

( + " (

=$::4'0&1

" > C #

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -6-

@ : = , "

# 9 5

/#'008,-'008-4 /#" " + + =

" "

+ 6 + 9 "

+ 07 '0&1 ,9 1 8/ +:, % '/# #

'008 07 '0&1 ,9 1 8/ + : , % '/# # + (

# #

'008 :, % & '/ + + ( +

! #

# : #

= 4 ,(

$ "

+ &0 '0&1

4 ,(

/( (

$ " "

+ '0&1 "

'1 0'

'0&1 ,9 &/

#( F=

$ +

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -7- "" 10B "

5 =$::A=$::4'0&1 @( # #

5( # """

5 *0B +=A=

( "

"" "

=$::4'0&1# $ " ( =# " + # ( "

"" "

@( # #

" =$::4'0&1 "

# "

( "

# #

>9 "

+@ #

5 ,:"

/ = + % & ' =

" ?

+> A:9 "

+( "

" (

A6 + "

9 "

(

A6 +

9 "

0J '0&1,9 &/ ,9 &/( + = """

'8 '0&1

4 ( (

= $ " (

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -8- A A + = "

# + 07 '0&1 ,9 1 8/ + :, % '/

( 0J '0&1,9 &/ + =

= "

+ ( 07 '0&1# ?

+, % )/ ( "

+( $ " ( + + ?

+, % )/ =" + >

+ @ #

+ @( #?

( % * + 0'

0D '0&1( ?

+,( % )/ = $ " '1 0) '0&1,9 '/ "

@ : = , A / 9"-

+ '0&1 ' # (

+ , % )/ H "

= $ A : :9 "

'0&1 +% > :9 "

#%( = = #%( 10B 6 9"-

( +=A= '008 1 #

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -9- $ + "" 10B "

5 =$::A=$::4'0&1 @( #

5( #"

"""

5 *0B

+ =A= = "

( "

"""

=$::4'0&1#$ " ( =#" + #( "

"""

@( # #

" =$::4'0&1"

# "

( "

>9 "

" >

+ , % )/ " )0 '1 0) '0&1,9 '/ ( F "

%= I 4 ,/ )0

( +

$ " ?

( + # " # ( 9 ( >

+@ #

5, % )/ 4 ,/

( " =$::A=$::4'0&1"

= =

; =

#'00J<,-

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -10- # '00J< 4 /

'0 && '00J 9 #'00J(

+ =

0J '0&1,9 *A&( +?

+/ = #

; $ <

# "

+A " + +

, /,

/ $

" $ "

'D '0&1 ,9 *A'( +?

,&/+ ( 6 =$::4'0&1 "

'0&1C,'/ ( 6 +=$::4'0&1 "

5 > ,)/ "

% ,&/ ,'/ " "

+ , % )/# + =$::4'0&1 6 A

( "

" 0& '0&8,9 *A)/ +$ " "

" '1 0) '0&1,9 '/

1 ( " C F@( #

"=$::'0&1"

# "

( "

# #

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -11- 9 "

" HA

80BA*0B6 ( $ $

50* '0&1

!" #

#$ " #"

( ( ""

+, % )/ =

# ( % 1 $ " , : 4 % '/

'D '0&1,9 )/ =$::4'0&16

( "

$ " , :4 % '/

07 '0&1,9 1/ "

# (

=$::4'0&1 = ( " +$ " , :/

07 '0&1 ,9 8/ "

>A '0&1 ( " + >

+ , % )/

(" 5 "

( = >

+ , % )/

&0 '0&1 ,9 *A8 ( + ?

" ( (

(

H ( # >

+ , % )/

&0 '0&1,9 *AJ( +

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -12- ?

+/ 5 " "" +

# ""

= 4 ,(

3 % &8')8 '0&) 3 % 11* '0&*

( " 5 "

" " 6

( (

( "

+ K

% '&1* '0&* -

- ( "

+ ''

0J '0&1 '0&1,*/ &'* 4 ,(

K ,/ % ')1'J'0&1

" = #( '* '0&1 = >

+, % )/ +

( ( #

+ (

4 = " ' '1 0) '0&1,9 '/#?

+ + 10B 6 #'00J F $ I# 4 "

# 10B ( + "

+ "

10B +" " 2 "

" &* &0 '0&1 "

(

( " '#*#1#&'#'7 )0 '1 0) '0&1,9 '/ =( $

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -13- # ( + "

""10B"

5 =$::4'0&1 + *0B "

= # ( (

(

( # ( (

# "

( >9 "

" >

+ "

( " # '00J ( "

( " "" + $ " + "

+ $ "# ?

+A$ ?

" +# "

+ H"

+ "

5 > 9 "

" " ?

+ ( " - "

- ,K % D&D '0&1 0'

0J '0&1/'0&1,)/K (@ ')18,>/ =( # # "

" (

# #

4 2 5

# '00J

+< "

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -14- # '00J

C # #

, 4 / = " " + +

" = "'

0)%"#')")%#1$2(3.#"#$4"2)"#"5"/,'00'/7*7& = 2 5

)# * 1 ,*/ '008 # 2 " &* &0 '0&1

#'00J

+ " #'00J

" "" + $ " + "

+ $ "# ?

+A$ ?

" C +# "

+ H "

+# "

5 >9 "

" " ?

+ # "

> 9 "

"9 "

+ + "

> # "

#'00J#

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -15- - -#

4 " # 10B + "

+ "

10B# + " "

= +

+ " " '1 0) '0&1,9 '/ "

" =$::4'0&1"

# "

( "

>9 "

+ =

'7 "

10B "6 10B " "A"

+6 ( &1B %= ( + 'D '0&1 ,9 )/ + :, % '/ +( (

,&/6 =$::4'0&1 + "

# ,'/ (

=$::4'0&1 6 + "

5 > ,)/ "

( "

+ ( "

% ,&/ ,'/ " #

" 0& '0&1 ,9 */ ( "

1 '1 0) '0&1,9 '/#(

" =$::4'0&1"

# "

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -16-

>9 "

HA ?

+ ( + 07 '0&8,9 1 8/ +( ( " + : , % '/ "

'0&1#

=$::4'0&1 "

" >A '0&1 +

+, % )/ (" 5 "

( 0J '0&1 ,9 *A&/ + = , % */ #

+ (

4 " 5

# $ # #

% & '

( # #

% ).>

4 + $ " ?

+ + = = # ( 0J '0&1 ,9 *A&/#(

> # '00J ( #

$ ( "

" # #

= , % */ #

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -17- '00J " +

'008 = + 0J '0&1 ,9 *A&/+ #'00J(

+ % &) = = , % */ + +

2C( #

(

K # + =4 # =

# '00J " 5 "

# #

> 9 "

" + 9 "

" "?

" >9 "

" + ?

# "

" > 9 "

(

" >

+ , % )/ +

(

'008 " +

" + )#* 1,*/ (

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -18F ) ,&/ $ " "

# 9 " 5

,'/

# $ " " + 6

" # " + "

,)/ $ " "

" 4 "

# + "" : E + :9 "

# " + # (

# + $ " L $ H

$ "" + +

L $ H# 9

" # +

(

,*/ %( + 4 ,)/# $ "" +#9"

+ "

( 4 ,1/ 6 9"

,*/ ""

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -19- 49

" "

+ ( "

+ ,8/ = #

" # $ " ( "

+ 4 *,&/

# " + + $ " " " " ,'/ $ " +

+ # "": " 5 "

#9 #( +9"

" ,)/ "

#9 #( +9"

# = # " "

# ( "" : 1,&/,)/9999 ,*/

# "

+ #" +

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -20- 5 " " +6 I = " ) ,)/ '008 # $ " "

" 4 "

# + "" : E + :9 "

# " + # (

# + $ " L $ H

1 ,*/ '008 (

# "

+ # " +

10B 5 " " +6

# '00J( + ( +

'008 # '00J ;:

+< ; < " ( F* "

, +/ " H > ,> +/ ( + = ?

H &0,'/ # &D*7 6

H + = " ( H 6

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -21-

6 + = "

+ =

( $

" H + = ( ' + ,

" + ( '+ + ( +

"" (

# = " +# +"

# "

( "

" 9

+ C

( + " ( 6 H +

+ . . . .* ,&/ ,/

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -22- ,'/ "

+ " + + (

" , / L "

+ "

+ $ " +"

+ $ " + ?

" C ,

/ L "

+ H "

C ,

/ L

>9 "

# 9 "

" "

+C ,

/ "

, / ,

( "

+ $ "

+ +

H 9 "

+# "

+ "

10B + *0B

4$ " + +"

+ "

+ # +" " "

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -23- #'00J(

; < ;:

"# "

H > ( + = ?

H &0,'/ #&D*7 6

6 H + = " ( H 6

6 + = "

+ ?

+ =

; < "

C # "

+A " + +

" # (

,'/ - - # '00J#

, / "

+ "

+ $ " + "

+ $ " +?

" C ,

/ "

+ H"

C ,

>9 "

# 9 "

" "

+C "

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -24- , / ,

/ = "

( "

+ $ " ?

+ +

H9 "

+# "" "

+ "

10B + *0B

4$ " 10B +"

+ "

10B + " " "

= " (

4 "

0J '0&1 ,9 *A&/ + = , % */ ,9 *A&/(

#'00J " 5 " ; < "+" 5 ;:

+< "

" ( 5

+ = + (

( + "

( $ = ( "

" +

+ #'00J

4 "

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -25- (

4 (+4 ,'&/ L "# ( ,&'/ " >

+ , % )/( ,D/ " # # ,D/

+ ( "

4 ( 6"7$$)#"888$9$*$)$('()(#'#0#$$)#"8.&'$)&$(")%

$($"2&1/ $2:$;02

% % "A < % " + % " ?

+ " ( >

& $ A > >?@

5 '

+ " A "

+ >?@

5 ) ! ( ! A 5 L + >?@

5 * ( A " K (

+ $%?"

A "

+ >?@

! A! ( L + >?@

5 &8 +?

+ 7 + 8 ' "7$ $)#"8 88$9$* "(17$(1 )(#'#0#$ $)#"8 .&'$)&$(/

"2'%5# &7 +?

+ &) + 0 1 "7$$)#"888$9$*'")."9"2$)#"888$9$ "7"9"2")02 &1 +?

+ &) + 0 ' "7$ $)#"8 88$9$* 020 ")"5 $3 $)#"8 88$9$ ")%

$($"2&1)(#'#0#$/.0)"7

% % "A < % " + % " ?

+ " ( >

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -26-

& $ A !"

$ L G # '

" A! H L $ G@

# "

) 5 5( AM

= $ $ #2 "" * "

A 6

= $ $ #2 "" &J +?

+ &) + * 0 "7$ $)#"8 88$9$* "#')"8 $)#"8 88$9$ ")% (;'#"8 08"<9"21/$2"<"(('

% % "A < % " + % " ?

+ " ( >

& @" > A

+ >?@

5 '

A2 !

+ @? " ) %> A >

+ >?@

5 *

5> A> >

+ >?@

5 &) +?

+ D + * "7$ $)#"8 88$9$* "=7' "' )(#'#0#$ $)#"8 .&'$)&$( ")% (;'#"8/ "#'"8"

% % "A < % " + % " ?

+ " ( >

& $+ A " $+ >?@

5 '

$ A5

>?@

5# "

+ ?

+3 % &''7'

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -27- '0&1 0J 0* '0&8 1 +?

+ * + & "7$ $)#"8 88$9$* $(1 1"9"# $)#"8 88$9$ ")% (;'#"8/ 05#("2

% % "A < % " + % " ?

+ " ( >

A5 K >?@

5 '

A2 >?@

5 ) 5!"

A " !"

>?@

5 * M > A

% " >?@

5 > A> $ % " >?@

5 >

A> % " >?@

5 D +?

+ ) + 8 ( ( "

+;:

+< "

( # '00J ;:

+ # '00J( 6

" +

=$::4'0&19 "

@( # = , % */

=$::9 "

" +

; <

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -28- #'00J 0J '0&1,9 *A&/ > #>9 "

" "?

+ = +

" # = , % */ # '00J " 5 "

> 9 "

" + 9 "

" " ?

+ = " +# ( # " + $ "

0& '0&1,9 */#( "

% 1 ') '0&1,9 '/#( "" F@( #

" =$::4'0&1 "

# "

( "

# #

> 9 "

" HA

+ I ,:"

/ > (

+ " + " ?

+ >

+, % )/ " H ?

+ =

+< # "

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -29-

H > ( + = ?

H &0,'/ #&D*7 6

6 H + = C

# " ( H 6

6 + = "

+ ?

+ =

# (

4 + >

+, % )/ #(

; < " #'00J

% ' # '00J ; < " + "

9 "

" + "

> 9 >

+ ?

+#> A:9 "

>+ 6 + 9 "

# ( + ?

+# > A:9 "

9 "

" + = # .'77)( $<<"27" ")% #1$2( 3 .#"#$ 2';02"")%#1$2(/'0&&,*/$ ,K/7*&,>/,$ /# (

( +

> ( + > 6 + 9 "

@ +,&0N'/

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -30- 2 : :9 "

9 "

(

* 1 =

( + 6 "

>> ( @ + 6

9 "

# "+#

> +: # > + : = :9 "

( *0B "

5 + # "

+ > + @ + ,&0N'/ 6

9 "

# ( (

+ = 6 + 9 "

@( #

( ( + > 6 + 9 "

# "+#

> +: 2 : :9 "

9 "

+ = ( + "

( 6 "

5 6 + 9 "

# #( " "

>> 5

# # + >

6 + 9 "

# 2 : :9 "

:9 "

( + "

6 + 9 "

( >>

+ "

>> (

*0B"

5 + #"

+ > + 5 6 + 9 "

,/# "+#

> + : # > + : =

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -31- :9 "

+ =

2 : :9 "

:9 "

" *0B 5 9 "

>> (

+ @< $ @ * 1 = "

+ #( +?

+A > A:9 "

>+#( 6 + 9 "

# "

5 6 + 9 "

( "

+ "

"" *0B "

5 + # "

+ > + 5 6 + 9 "

# ( ( " ?

+A> A:9 "

>+( 6 + 9 "

# "

9 "

" # @< $ @ "" "

>> ( " +

+ "

" ?

A > A:9 "

1,1/,

/ = ( ( 1 ,1/ ,

/ (

&* (

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -32- 6 + " = + K,/'0D&74'0D&D @-

" 'J 0J '0&' ( 4 FK

= ,=/ +

+ "

"# +

( 1,1/,

" ( +

" " + K

+ I

" 'J 0J '0&'(

&J 0* '0&) #@<

" + "

1,1/,

/ = ( "

" "

6 + 9 "

+ > ( ( = 2$$#' .2'3"(#"3" 2! 3 .#"#$ ,&DDD/ J &'0#

2 > @<

" 6 (

"" 6 + "

5# + 5 "

+ =( + "

+ = #&D18#=

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -33- "

(

# # " =9 ( '0 ( )) # = " # ( "

# 9 ( : +'1K === #" 5 (

( +

" + = " =( "" 9 "

(" " ?

"" 9 "

" +

+ "" + 5 = H # + "" 9 "

6 + "

9 "

( "

6 +

" " 5( H ( "

" # # +6 + "

"" 9 "

= "

(

> # "" 9 "

( " " ?

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -34- + ""+ 5 H " +

" 5 #( ( +

" + " # ( 6 + 9 "

5 > :9 "

( ;:

+< " 5 "

9 "

+ "

@( # + #

# 6 "

9 "

5 "

# #

+ ),)/ '008 (

$ " "

" "

# + "" : E + :9 "

# " + # (

# + $ " L $ H # "

" 6 + 9 "

'008

+ # '00J " ;:

+< " #'00J + + ( "

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -35- 6

" 5 "

; < " #'00J "

+ "

" ?

" +"

+ (

( 0J '0&1,9 *A&/ + , % */#( " 5 " +#; < " 5 ;:

#'00J L 0J '0&1 ,9 *A&/ + = # $ " #

# : # >

+ , % & )/ ( " = #

#'00J (

9 + ( 0J '0&1,9 *A&/ = , % */ 0J '0&1,9 *A&/ + , % */

+ 9 #'00J >+

9 +

" + = ( + =

4 +

+ "

C #+ "

( + = "

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -36- 5 "

( "

(( "

@( # + "

6 "

5 "

" 6 # + ( +

+ 6 C # + 9

" K

/ = # (

( ( +

4 9"

" "

+ ( ( =

#9"

" "

( 9 "

= # ( +

+ #'00J

'008 (

" "

" " " = +# '1 0) '0&1,9 '/

"=$::4'0&1"

# "

( "

# #

> 9 "

+ #

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -37-

" >:9 "

" =$::4'0&1 "

'7 '1 0) '0&1,9 '/ "

10B "6 10B " "A"

+ 6 ( &1B %= ( + 'D '0&1 ,9 )/ +:, % '/ =(

,&/6 =$::4'0&1+ "

# ,'/ (

=$::4'0&1 6 +

5 > ,)/ "

( "

+ ( "

% ,&/ ,'/ "

=$::4'0&1 ( # # " (

( #( # : , % '/

'D '0&1 ,9 )/ = : , % '/ $ " > # $ "

" 0& '0&8 ,9 */ (

"=$::4'0&1"

# "

( "

# #

> 9 "

" HA ?

+ ( ( (

'1 0'

'0&1 '1 0) '0&1 ,9 & '/#

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -38- (

> 9 "

+ " >

+ , % )/ =

(

" 0& '0&1 ,9 */ + $ " # : , % '/ 'D '0&1 ,9 )/ 6

" 0& '0&1,9 */(

+ $ " #

" : +(

1 '1 0) '0&1,9 '/( " = " "

(

"=$::4'0&1"

# "

( "

>9 "

" HA ?

+ " 5

> 9 "

" HA ?

>9 "

+ , % )/ ( " #(

4 # 07 '0&8,9 1 8/ +( ( " +:, % '/ "

'0&1#;

=$::4'0&1

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -39- < "

" >A '0&1 + ?

+, % )/ (" 5 "

( 0J '0&1,9 *A&/ + = , % */# ( # +

6+ " " " =

#( + " = "

+ # 0J 0) '0&* + $ "

>>A>

%=( "

5 = 4 ,=/ =(

+# ( =6 (( "

=6 =

# (

10B ( $ "6 "

10B &1B%=6 ( " "A"

+6 = #( " + 5 "

5 6 + 9 "

( "" 5 "

5 6 + 9 "

> #?

+ "

(

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -406 = "" : "" : ( # ( " + ""

#( # '1 0'

'0&1 ,9 &/ +$ "

" =$::4 '0&1"

# "

( "

> 9 "

+, % )/ ( '1 0) '0&1 ,9 '/ + $ " #

" : "( : , % '/

'D '0&1,9 )/ + # : , % '/ $ " > # $ "

" 0& '0&8 ,9 */ (

"=$::4'0&1"

# "

( "

> 9 "

HA ?

+ ( ( (

'1 0'

'0&1 '1 0) '0&1 ,9 & '/(

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -41-

# #

> 9 "

+ " >

+, % )/ =

(

" 0& '0&1,9 */ +$ " # :, % '/ 'D '0&1,9 )/ 6 # " " < ,

: , % '/ 07 '0&1,9 1 8/ " + 0J '0&1,9 *A&/

+ $ " '1 0'

'0&1 '1 0) '0&1,9 & '/ 0J '0&1,9 *A&/

# '00J ; <(

+<#( +

# 07 '0&1 ,9 1 8/ "(( "

(

+ #'00J = (

" + 2 +

" '7 && '0&1 +

" # 07 '0&1,9 1 8/ +:, % '/ (

LPA No. 1698 of 2015 (O&M) -42- +#

( " &* &0 '0&1 + 2 07 '0&1 ,9 1 8/ + : , % '/ 6 #( # ... !

! 0J 0* '0&8 " % 3

MA%