← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1715/2015dismissed

The District Education Officer And ANR v. Raj Pal And ANR

2019-01-29Mr. Justice Ajay Kumar Mittal,Mr. Justice Harnaresh Singh Gill8 pages



        

   !"#"$%&%'()) %&!*%$!#+$ !%' %$"* '# '!,"*     --.."// '!&   0&

1 / '# '!,"*       - "&.'#"'!&  ( 2

 34

     2

 3  33  



     

         

   *' *"&,3%'5,%//6

  !!

"# $% &

'    (   &    #)  

*! 

+ &    (   

  ,

  $ - )   

             

#  .

& $% &

'       #     (   ( /    #      0( )

 , * $%%&   1 2( 

,  +

             1     )  1      

"

+3)

0   +   1  

)  )   4  4 2   , * $%%   )        145 ( 6

2   

$%%   ") 8         "+3)  (   +3  (+  

 +  (

 

$%%&   + )  1  ") ) +(    -( "+3)    +  ()+  ) 

 +  () 9(+  (   )$,%

((  $) :+  ) ) +  (     : 4( *,.;< => ' ) )+   ))      +3   +   (

 + + % )  +1 3 +) (      ) :?)+     1     -(    )8 

+  3

$%%& (+3) +  ' # 1( (

 @ )           ) +(  &% 3 +  ) 

  )     +         88$)++ 

   + 

 1(      

    +3) 

 +3 (( )!

* $%% $7 $ $%%& :+ (   )   )        +3)     )

) +  ) '

1 1  ( )+  + +3  1  

  8  

!,7.   $% $   (   

 ?  0( )

 , * $% &    2(   +   1  & 8     !

A 

0(         

+( 1  (  ( $&A$&- $& +

(" 7"%'%!%'$'!%'++&&"*8%$"9 *!,".+*.&"&!,%& $, .!"*: ;

> @@@@@@@@@@ ;$> +  +3)     ((  +  )   (;

>   @)  1 ) 1(((  )" ;

>     (  + 

) 

+ +  ( 1)

 ( +3 ( )

 " ;>  (   

       +3)  ) 1+(  )B ;>+(  

  B ;1>  @)  (  @  

 )   

 +    +  ( 1)

 ( +3 ( )

 " ;> "



       +3)  )  1+ (  )B ;>(  +

   = 7 '#%!%'&.*"$"#"'!!*"!*"'$,;"'!<*=;"'9  +3) )   (+ 1((

         (   )   1  1 )(" ;

>  +3)    1   )C   +       )         @ +3)  1 ( (    ;1>  +3)    1     )   ) )  +   1 9(   

C      )      ((       @ @)B ;>    1  )         )  ( (  )  1    1 

 )1  6

  D = < *$"#+*"**"!*"'$,;"'!

"8 +3)    1) +   D   :    1  1  (   +3)   1) 1  )1+ )   +3)    1   )       +3)  + +       1 )   (  1 ) +3) = .

  

 $&A;$> + +

+3) ((+)   (;

> $&A    @) 1

) 1(((  )     (  + 

) 

 +    +   (    1 )

  (  +3 ( )  $,%

       +3)  )     ( +   1  ((          (   )   1   1   ) (  )E   +   1

)))  1)  $& 1 ( )  F  ) E  : 1   1 2(  # 1((

@ )  )(  +3) 

) $,%

 $ 

)  

 )  88$)

 +

 ) )

)     +3)  

 (  $,%

     -(  )  +  )

 +( )  +   (   (    (   $&-     ' 8   )++3) +  

 1 1  ) A 4+ +3 8    ()1  9(  1# 1(( +( + 1 + '    1 2( 

(" <'+3) )   : 4( *,.;

<=>+ )  +   +      1  )+   %

+ ( 

 ) )  +     )  )      ' ) +       D  :+  )      @ )+ ()

  '# 1(( )( +3)   )  $,%

      $  

 )   

   )   ' (  1  1

)       88$ )  + +     

  +    ) ) ()) 1+3)  

 88$)

) +3) 

($,%

 

)     )  +  1( 1( +( )  )

 (  (  ( $&-  ' 8  

)++3) +   1 1  )  A  4 +3  8    ( )1  :

 

)0(  

 $&- $& 1 1    1     (1)   ?1 4)           )(   (    + @ (++ "

G$  :

()      +(  1 (  )()    (  

 ) ) + ( +  :   +)( # 1( (      (   +   ( A     () (    

    :

*!,  ,.. +  +( 1  (

)  +   +)  

+ ( ( )(   

    :     )(    +(     

 1# 1(( )( +     ) '# 1(( @  1 (1 3   &%H +  (1       "

) )   3      ()    1  4)   +3) +  )1  +

 + ( ())  + 1 3  5@(    )    

(      +     1  () (  

    ;

*7&> ,  ,  :      +       (

  

  1  +    1       (   +( 1



A   (  $,%

   0( ) ()(         

 !  "# $   

 %# 

 

 

 !  "# $    :

*7!  ,&7   )($,%

  (

(

 

  ( $,%

 ' 1 # 1(   # +  +3)   ) (  $,%

9(     1( $&A  : +(       0(     

 # 1((  (  1   +  

  '  # 1((   - 

  1# 1(( 1 (1 + 0( ( $$!G$$. ( :

= * -(! #& '#  

      ;$%% > *  !  +    @( ( " <  

    9(         )   +3  )   $,%

   +(1(  +( +

( (( $&- : 4( ' 

 1(  +)  1 (  

( 1 '1(    )  1   '1(   1     +    +   1 (     +

1    (  )         1( '(  )      1  :  ()  + 3      '1( 

) 1(0(   +   3       +   ) ' ( =

) ++  31@((  '  ) (   

"* %#+ $ :

$% % $ !

%   #   1 1 (    1 2( +    + +1@(  1)  9( )   )1   1 >4+; * %!! /    +#5"  '+ *>)6)    *' *"&,3%'5,%//

1 & %'%?@5&2  +#5" 8 3G  "& 8 1  "&