← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1264/2016disposed of

Inderjit Singh v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2018-07-17Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain,Mr. Justice Arun Monga8 pages





       

 !

 " #$% & '& & !() *&''+ , !-.#/(0) !1'%2 &3 !45 66'##*!& 7'%,., 3&*&'*%/*!* &5'%,  ',6!1'!&,



  !"# $%&'( #

$#& "( )   !"# $%&'( # ('

*  +++

%','!&-

%3.8''& *5*2*!03'! %1"+*&'9 &5

, *8!'':;*.%01"+*&'0 %&5'*66'##*!&

%!<.% &&*#011 & !*#1"+*&''!'%*#0*%/*!*

%;*!9*#2''&3 !4503'! %1"+*&'9 &5

%2* " %3 !4501"+*&'0 %%',6!1'!&=

%*.&*8;* #'01"+*&'0 %%',6!1'!& >>>>>

('

* ,$

%','!& !&%*?+.%&*66'*#5*,@''!6%''%%'1*4* !,&&5'%1'% 1*&'1(=6*,,'1@/&5'#'*%!'13 !4#''!+5095'%'@/&5'9% & 6'& & !6%''%%'1@/&5'*66'##*!&+5*##'!4 !4&5'%1'%,1*&'1==

?6*,,'1@/&5' !*!+ *#88 ,, !'%0*%/*!*0))

!!'A.%'  ?    &5'  88 ,, !'%0  8@*#*   " , !0  8@*#*  *!1 ) ?B%'!1'%'1@/&5'##'+&%,''< !41 %'+& !% %',&%*& !&5'%1'%1*&'1 ?)&5',, ,&*!& ##'+&%,&%*1'0.5#*0 ,&% +&;* &5*#05*,@''!1 ,8 ,,'1



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

?095 +5*&&* !'1 !*# &/*!1,*#'1''11*&'1)

?C !'A'+.& !&5'1'+%''9*,'A'+.&'1 !*".%&5'

-

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

1  *!1  *66%"'1  @/  &5'  ,, ,&*!&  ##'+&%  !1 %*1'0  .5#*0 95'%' ! &9*,,6'+  +*##/6%" 1'1&5*&*#<*%3 !459.#1@'4 "'! ,'6*%*&'6*%+'##*!1*!195 #'1 !4,06,,',, !*!1&/6'&5'#*!1 9*,&@'&*<'! !&+!, 1'%*& !5'6'%,!,0955*16*%& & !'1&5' .@'9'##  *!1  "*#.*@#'  &%'',0  9'%'  *#,  6%&'+&'1  @/  4 " !4  &5' *%'8'!& !'1,5*%'0 &5'%9 ,'0,. &*@#'+86'!,*& !@2'+& !, 9'%' #'1@/%',6!1'!&=*,8'%3 !45%'4*%1 !4&5'*%'8'!& !'1 6*%& & !095 +59*,*66%"'1@/&5',, ,&*!&##'+&%!1 %*1'" 1' %1'%1*&'1)C,*+!,':.'+'81'6*%& & !

?9*,6%'6*%'1*!1&5'#*!1+86% ,'1 !%'+&*!4#'!.8@'% *%'8'!& !'19*,*##+*&'1&&5'*66'##*!&?6'& & !'%0 '0#*!1,59! 6 !< !, &'6#*!*@.&& !4&5'8* !%*1*!1&5'#*!11'6 +&'1 !/'##909*, *##+*&'1  &  %',6!1'!&  =  *,  5'  9*,  .!1  !  6,,',, !    &5' *%'8'!& !'16*%+'##*!1



*,8'%3 !45?%',6!1'!&= #'1@2'+& !, ?( " ,?*?" ,*<,5*'&&5'''+&&5*&!1'%2 &3 !45@'!&4 "'!&5'#*!1 .& '+&=C0; ##*)E ?=*!1; ##*CE ?=,, ,&*!& ##'+&%0.5#*" 1'%1'%1*&'1 ?)01 ,8 ,,'1 &5'@2'+& !,44% '"'1 *4* !,& &5'*%'8'!& !'1 %1'%0%',6!1'!& =6%''%%'1*!*66'*#@'%'&5'##'+&%095 +59*,*++'6&'1" 1' %1'%  1*&'1  )  !!'A.%'  ?B  66'*#  6%''%%'1  @'%'  &5'

88 ,, !'%9*,*#,1 ,8 ,,'1" 1'%1'%1*&'1)) !!'A.%'

?*!1*,!& +'1*@"'0&5' !*!+ *#88 ,, !'%*#,1 ,8 ,,'1&5'

*66'*#" 1'%1'%1*&'1== ?'*%!'13 !4#''!+5 1 ,8 ,,'1&5'9% &6'& & !@/%'#/ !4.6!&5'%*& 1'+ 1'!1 +.##'1.& ! "./0/ 1&/ ,23$

%3.8''& *5*2*!0#'*%!'13'! %.!,'#*,, ,&'1@/ ,

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

4

*##+*&'1&&5'*66'##*!&?6'& & !'%

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

'%  +!&%*0  %  ;*!9*#2''&  3 !450  #'*%!'1  3'! %  .!,'# *,, ,&'1 @/ %2* " %3 !4501"+*&'0%'6%','!& !4%',6!1'!& = ,.@8 &&'1&5*&&5'2.148'!&&5'#'*%!'13 !4#''!+51',!&,.'% %8*!/'%%%% ! %8 &/*, & , !+!,!*!+'9 &5&5'%*& 1'+ 1'!1 +.##'1.& ! "./!5/  5'%'9*,*+!# +&" '9,*, 'A6%',,'1 !&5'+*,'"./*!1*++%1 !4#/&5'8*&&'%9*,%''%%'1& &5' .##'!+5&5 ,.%&!  1 . 60/".71&7 8. ., 3-    34,  .##'!+5095 #' !&'%6%'& !4&5'

6%" , !,    3'+& !      &5'  %*!,'%     %6'%&/  +&0  5'#1  &5*& 95'!'"'%*#*!1 ,,#1@/*+?,5*%'%%8&5'2 !&<5'9*&@/%''%'!+'& ,6'+  +%'+&*!4#',*!1<5*,%*!.8@'%,0&5',&*&.,&5'"'!1''9.#1@' *+?,5*%'%'!& %'<5'9*&*!1!&,6'+  +



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

@.&8*!/-?

* 5'  ,*#'  1''1,  1*&'1  BBB  *!1  ) 'A'+.&'1@/* @3 !45*!1*#<*%3 !45*!1!@'5*# *,8'%3 !45&5%.45&5'.%&*%'!& !1 ,6.&'F @ 5'  *66# +*& !  %  6*%& & !  9*,  ,.@8 &&'1  ! =)*&'%8%'&5*!&9/'*%,&5'#*,&2.148'!&*!1 1'+%'' ##&5'!0&5'*66'##*!&5*1@''!'!2/ !4&5'6'*+'.# 6,,',, !&5',. &6%6'%&/0 '0 '+&=C0; ##*)E

?=*!1CE ?=&9.#1@' !&5' &!',,&5 !4,& 'A&%*+&&5',&*&'8'!&,,.'%'11.% !46*%& & !6%+''1 !4,@/ +.!,'#,%'6%','!& !4%',6!1'!&,=*!15',*8'%'*1 &5.,-?

3&*&'8'!&+.!,'#%%',6!1'!&=

:

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

?=F

1'    6*%& & !  6%&'+&'1  &5'  6,,',, !    &5' %',6'+& "'6*%& ',F '

$5 #'6%&'+& !4&5' !&'%',&'" *2*!1&5'%+?

,5*%'%,0#'*%!'13 !4#''!+5%'8* !'1@# " .,&5'*+& &5*&'" *2!' &5'%@2'+&'1&&5'81'6*%& & !!%& *<,5*' ,6.&'9*,!#/@'&9''!&5', @# !4,E#'4*#5' %, $*D %3 !45F  5'  #*!1  *##+*&'1  &  &5'  *66'##*!&?6'& & !'%  *!1 %',6!1'!&= ,&5',*8'"*#.'&5&5'6*%+'#,&5' #*!1*%'!&5'8* !%*10 '05''<*?

'59*%*1&5 !4 6%'"'!&'1&5'%',6!1'!&,& #'9% &&'!,&*&'8'!&0%0&5'9% &

3

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

1  *+&,  95 #' 1 ,8 ,, !4&5'9% & 6'& & ! !# 8 !'5'%1'%.!1'%+5*##'!4',.'% %8  ##'4*# &/  *!1  6'%"'%, &/  5'  ,*8'  ,  ,'&?*, 1'  ,  *  !'+',,*%/ +%##*%/0%1'%1*&'1(=#'*%!'13 !4#''!+5*!1%1'%,1*&'1 ==0  ))0  )  86.4!'1  !  &5'  9% &  6'& & !  *%' :.*,5'1$% & '& & ! ,*##9'1 ',.#&*!&#/0&5''&&'%, *&'!

$#& "( )    ('

*  $%);#  $%);# $/ <:,3 1.

*.. =7 8> 6 ?>  *..  @  ?>