High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2461/2012dismissed

Ram Kishan And ORS v. Phoolwati And ORS

2015-11-19Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal4 pages

!"# $%&''

()*+

", $-.-%/ 0

*/ 23* 3 # %,/ *#"4 .5 5#"6&7$", !!"%,. *#"%8"9*"8-,5-"6 %-#&7$", :-,5 *#8"95 45":",6&7$", ;

$"7 ",# "8 .5-%&"!

%&"%,."#

,5-.$ #,""-%.,,5 8 &= %,"%& $#

&!:

$ #,6:5 <9,5", ,#-"!$ #,:".

&"%&,5 . -, %,

:".& $#

%,5 $".

-%5"%&6,5 . -,:". ;

'!"-%,-

#& $!"#",-%"%&'

#="% %,-%8 %$,-%5 "!!

&,5",,5

'#'

#,9-%> .,-%:".' #$5".

&<95 #=-%"7-& &."!

&&", 00?5 #& #'"..

-.,#"#&", & 1

$"%$ !!-%,5

&:"."!.$5"!!

% #,9-%,5 $".

-%5"%&:".:% &<9=,-%"5

5"&-%-,-"!!9 &"# &':

9# "#&-%,5 -%

"7 # "8#"8-%5(# %,A+% 005 "

, #6" .5 & ':

# ",,#% 9 :". & -% "7 # "= B-.5"% ("''

!!"%, + % ? 006 :5-$5 :". $"%$ !!

& <9 :"9 "

&&$ = %,% 1 00?% 00?6,:."!

&.:

'# %, &<

< -.,#"# -.,#",-%6% <9-%"-% "7 #

&", 00?"%&"%,5 #&", 1 00?-%

"7 # !!"%,.;&

%&"%,. ,16 &<9"8#"8-%5".

95!& -%"5 < -.,#"#6:5-!

$,-%,5

& &", & 1 00? '# %, & <9 "''

!!"%,.;&

%&"%,. , 16 &,5

&&", 00?'# %, 5

#& #:".$5"!!

% !!"%,.<

-.,#"#6:5.

,".-&

,5 % 1

"%&&-# $, &# -.,#",-%

&-% "7 #

,5 !!"%,.5 #& #:".-=' % -%,5 . -,

&6< .-& ..

4-%& $!"#",-%,5",.5 -.:% #-%'..

..-% . -, '#'

#,9%,5 <".-.

&&", 00?"!# "&9# &-% "7 # $%, %,-%. 5,,< #"-.

&<9!

&$ %.

"''

!!"%,.:".,5",%$ :"."# &':

9"!# "&9

&<9-%"-% "7 # "8#"8-%5% 006:5-$5:".% $"%$ !!

&65 5"&"!!,5 #-5,.,

&%5 #< 5"!

95!& #5"7-%,,5

&% 1 00?-%

"7 # !!"%,.6,5 .5 !&5"7

%# &6".""-%., ."!

&&", 00?'# %, &<9-%"5 !

&!:

#"''

$ #,5"&# #.

&,5 -%&-%.# $#& ,#-"!$ #,= !9%,5

'# . =',-%,5",% $ ,-% .5':

9<9-%"-% "7 # "=B-.5"%% ? 006,5 "#!- #':

9&", 00 -% "7 # "8#"8-%5.,&# 74 &6< ,,5 :".%,5-%!-4 ,5", % ,5 ,5 # 5"%&6 !

& $ %.

! # # %, ;

$"7 ",#. <=-,, &,5", %- $%, %,-%. 5,,< #"-.

&<9 !

&$ %.

! !!"%,.,5", "8#"8-%55"& ,5 ':

",,#% 9,.

!!,5 #,96.,-!!,5 #--%"!:% #& .%,!.

,5", #-5,6#",5 #65 ##-5,:".. '# = 5 ':

95!& #:".%!9 "$,-%%5 #< 5"!

#,5 #. <=-,, &,5",-,-.:#%,$%, %&,5",

A ,5 ':

# ",,#% 9 5!& & ,5 ."!

&-% "7 # ,5

"''

!!"%,.% 1 00?".-,-.%!9,5",,5 &$ = %,-.&", 1 00? C5-!

"#-%". C0;"8#"8-%56-%5-.$#..;

@"=-%",-%6$!

"#!9 .,", &,5",5 5"&# $ -7 &,5 $%.-& #",-%% 00?",,5 ,-=

'# %,",-%

-.,#",-%"%&:5 %-,:".%,# &6 ,5 =% 9 :". # , #% & <"$4 #,5 # . <=-,, & ,5", ,5 -. % "#

= %,,.

!!'!

"& !!"%,.6:5-$5="95"7

% <9"8#"8-%5< -%"':

95!& #65 %$ 6,'!

"&,5",,5

."!

&5".<

%:#%!9 &-% "7 # -.

=-.$%$ -7 &5 8 &= %,"%&& $#

$ #,& %,$"!! #"%9-%,

%$ "#&!

&$ %.

! '"#,- ."%&'

# .

&,5 '"'

<4 #,9-%&-.' , :".:% &<9-%"7 %- "$,.6 ".$!"-= !!"%,.6"# ,"4 %".. $56-%"5"& &"':

9-% "7 # "8#"8-%5%

&<9"8#"8 -%5-% "7 # !!"%,."%&"%,5 #."!

&<9-%"-%

"7 #

'# %, &<

< -.,#"# %,5 &"96%"= !96 00?5

&-% "7 # %, ;'!"-%,-

:".# &6:5 ".,5 ,5 #:".& $!-% &5 5,5

."!

&:"..

,".-& <9 -.,#"#-%,5 "! !!"%,."%& ,5 ,#-"!$ #,&-.=-..

&,5 . -, 65:

#6,5

& !:

# "''

$ #, 5". 5 !& ,5 ."!

!"%& -% "7 #

,< 7"!-&5 :% #,96 %- ."

96& .%,!.

#-5,,& "!:-,5,5 #,9 -.

"$".

-%:5-$5,5 #--%"!:% &,5

&"%&%,5

&", 6:5 %,5

&$!"-= &,5"7

% ':

",,#% 95!& #:".'# %, -.,#",-%6,5 :".& $!-% &5

95!& #6%"= !96"8#"8-%5 "-#!9.,", &-%5-.$#..;

@"=-%",-%,5",5 5"&# $ -7 &,5 $%.-& #",-%%!9% 00?

"%&:5 %# -.,#",-%

&:".#

&6,5 =% 9:".# , #% ,,5 7 %&

* "%-%,5 <9%."!

$%.-& #",-%:".'"..

%.-& #-%,5 "

."-& "$, "!=",#-@6&%, -%&"%9 ".%,-%,

:-,5,5 -=' % &8 &= %, !:

$ #, . <.,"%,-"!> .,-% !":"#-.

.-%,5 '# %,"''

"!$$#&-%!96,5

."= -.&-.=-..

&%.

> %,!96,5 "$$='"%9-%"''!-$",-%."# "!. &-.=-..

("8 .5-%&"!+ &