Kulwinder Singh v. Union Of India And Others
!"#$ "#"%#& !"#$
'$ ()'
**
* +
()'
* ** * '
"#
"
!
"#
$$$$ *
* +
, %
!
%'%'('%) *+ ,(-
. / # & !
#.
#. #
-&.%-/-&01 "%#!
( .
(1'2%343 # "# (3'(%331 "#!
#
.
. .
8 6 .#
*- ('
:
. #.
;#
0.
*-
"
.
"# <
!
# ;#
/ 0..
2 !
#" 0 0" = !
. !
. / # & !
. . " %'%'('%) " " # + #
!
"
#$ %
&' (
)
)
*
+
,-.&'/& .)
'(0- .)
/ ,-.&'/& .) '(0- .)
1
)
1
/
2
3 ) /
, , ." !
0
#2
#&
"2.34 "% .
>
!
#.
.
.
"#
#
? . 1 " !
# .!
# . " # '3'%('('!
7@ + 0 !
#
!
# 0" A %2% ('('
#. !
; # #
. / # &
#. " 7
0 7 !
. # ?#B ? .B
" #!
!
# # !
.
0
# B .
#B
. # # %'%'('%)!
. / # & ##
4 C" .
!
#
##
0 !
#.
. " #
('%)!
+ 0
.
. 7
0 + # ; #
" # #
. / # & !
!
.
" !
## 7@ + 0
#
. 7" !
0 ?
#
+ 0 #
!" #$!
('('!
. +
#
. #
. / # & !
# #
0 !
# # . %'%'('%)!
. / # & <
.
# #
!" # . '3'%('('!
"
8 * - #
#. D
+ 0
('%4!
!
.
#.
('%)
!
. # ?
.!
!
#
#. ('(%!
# !
#
+#!
. ?
. .
#
. . !
?
!
"" "#
#
3 .
0 ?
"#
# ;# " !
0 ?
;#
.
# . .
# .!
!
.
#. #
"
. D
#.
"# #
#. # %' #
.B #" ;# !
#
E # # *(''(- *.- (''< " B #
+# # ## , #" .
# !
"#
.!
# " !
#. + #
!
1
4
5
)
/
%% " !
B
%
%( / . !
B + #
!
#.
C.
E #
676
& '!
(
((!
( ) *( ( $" " *( &$* (
+! ,!&$(-
$(
( )
+ )) *
! * ( $
( $
&
+ ("
.(( ) &$/ (
!
0 (
) )& "
(!
( )
* "
(!
( $ (
(( !+ !"" $(
)!
) +( 1 ( ) .!
&$
&- &$+!
- - "" (
!
&
) '!
(( ) !
0" ) " (
( !
( * ( - ) ((
( ( $ +
-
- (
"+ !
2 !"" +
- *
! 1 ( ) .!
& 8 9
- * (
+ -!) -!
-& *( ( $
-!
- (
& (
$
-!
- *( *) - "
) *) ) *( ( $ - ! ( !- '! (! -& ( *( $ (
+!
(( "
( - )) *
. 3"
! - "
&)*
((
( + * ( $ - & - !- - ))* (
: 2 4* & *
!
( (
- 5(
( ( *( $
!( ( $ $ - (( "
! &
(( ! - ( ! ((! (& ( "
(!
( + 6 /2
1
#
& (!
& * (
* - 5( ) *(
!) *( $ - ! - ( !
&
( &'! ((!
( +(
* $ !
$ & &$
6 " *( &$ (
* ( !""
) (
!(
/ (
!
"
"-
!
"
-!
- &$ )) *
+ !""
-& () 7
""*) & !
-
'! -
+ !( + &
* - !- 8 %2 A!
+ # " E # # *(''(- *.- (''<!
. # .
# !
.# !
,
(
0
3
# !
? .
#.
## %)
.
"!
?
. .# +. !
#
#. .
#.
.
"#!
!
# B ## !
.!
#
D
#
D .
# %>
" !
# !
.
# # .
# *+ ,2-!
#
#
. #
!
# .
#!
#
8 !
!
. ? * -
#.
"
.
"# %1 .
. # !
.
. ..
#.
# . "
? . # "
.
#!
.# +.!
.
.!
.
" #
.
#. ?
# " !
!
? .
"
# .!
.
!
#. # .
"# D !
.
#. #
#.
"
.
"#
%4
!
?
# !
.
" # .
!
. .
!
.# #
. . B
# .
" . #" !
.
.# +.
#.
. # #?#!
B #
. # ## !
!
# .
? .
#
# !
# ? #" #
#. .
.#
- " G
- #- .
"#
%<
!
# !
. "
#"
. .
.# # ?
..
# !
. . B
#
?
.
# # ",H," !
#
# !
.!
#
. # .
" "!
#
# !
#
#.
"
.
"# ?!
##
%3 " !
# . !
##
.# "#
.
!
.
? # ## !
"# .
?
#
"# # 0 .
##
# "# # / #!
. .
# ## !
"
.!
.
#" .
"# .
!
!
#.
"# #.
# ('
# " #!
!
.
!
#. "
#. "
!
.
(% . # .
.
",H,"
..
# !
.
!
#.
!
..
#.
# .!
. .
#!
.
#
#
#
#
#.
"
.
"#!
#? !
.!
# ; .
76 + 0 !
# 9 *1) #21 % " " # + #
8; 1
<
= $ %!
6
8>?
/ 2
&
.
;@8A
6))$&
+9% $
%
) 2
B&: *&C$ %D $
%
$
%
6
$&;% $ %)
B&C$%D $%)
#
#
BC$ %D $ %)
' ( 2
BC$ %D5 $
%)
' (
6)) AE
' $'
. % 8>>8 F A
= E .
A +@;
9> G
2
(( #" *- " + # #!
# !
#.
..
#.
# .!
# + ('
:
" !
!
# ..
?
" .
?
(2
A !
.
..
#.
# .!
#.
?.
('
:
. !
. "
? # # !
#
#
#.
"
.
"# #
#. ;
&
.
;@8A 6))$&
+9%
()
/ . !
. ",H,"
# .
..
# . ## !
#
#.
!
#
#.
" !
.!
!
## ?
*-
!
.
?
"# ..
# .
. " "
. ?
* - ",H," ## !
. !
#!
. ,# !
!
#.
#. #"
" !
# # #.# "#
## !
#
# I!
#
",H," ## !
? ? .
"# D .
"
.
"#
(>
.
#. #*-
#
## !
- . ### ## .
"#!
.
#.
#
# ",,"
#
" !
#. ##
.
#.
-
!
.
?
#. ##
# !
.
"#
.
"#!
.
# (1
/ !
.#
#
"
# .# +. ##
.!
#.
"#!
!
.
.
"
"#!
* -!
# ? ##
(4 " !
# !
.
#
, JE # *
-!
(''( JC.
E #J (<
!
. . " #!
. . .
.
.# +.
. ",,"
#. # .
.
D .
#. . " !
?
.!
#
!
# + , !
D !
!
. B
#!
",," #"
.
.
"#!
!
0 .
##
?
"# .
#
#.
"
.
"# (3
!
?
# !
# !
# .B #" # # #B!
#
% " !
. .
.# # ?!
"
#B #
# ##!
.!
#. # " !
. .
.
#. ## ? !
? . B
#!
#
.
"#
#.
"
.# .
"# 0 . # ? . B
#!
# ## !
##!
. ##
!
.
.
.
"
#
? #" #D !
# .
"#!
##
# !
#"
#. # #" #
# ##
2' 7" !
" !
0 ?
+ #
# !
#. #
#
*
=H
8 $% )
' (
=
2 $ % )
" $
% ) 5
$
% )
/(
9 - .
.
H
H
- .
8 6 % )
# # (
:. % )
#(# ( :. % )
# # (
;9 )
* < 2%
+ ,2!
# . . B
#
#. . . # * - #
76 + 0 # 9 *1) !" #
# !
. #
" !
!
#. .
.B .
!
# ; . * -
6
. #
? "#!
?
"
",,"
.
"# .
#. # 7" !
# "# #
#
",," !
#
.!
#
# !
"
. .
#B #
# # ## # ?*-!
.
#. "
.
!
#. # #
# .
" !
?
.# !
. #
#.
"
#. .
"# 2( 7" !
+ ,2!
#
# .
"
# + * - # "# . * -
!
!
0 #
"
.#
!
# + ,2 0# # # #
. !
#
? #
#
8 .
0 ?
# .
"# !
?
#
#.
"
.
"#
4#-/ !
"2.34 "% .
22 . 0 . " "!
. 2) . *+ ,(- ?
# ## !
#
#
.
# ; .
76 + 0 # ( #4"#"2#!4-5 -6 .- 6!
* #/4# 2> " + # .
.
21
#
. .
;#
#.!
!
. !
# " #
+ 0 * .""
: 6 .)!
1= # :6 6 6
3 > 1) * .""
:2 2 .)!
1= * #:66 %#
1*9
3 $ (
6 2$
24
# . #
#!
!
#*-!
*- 9*
* +
:
9* * ':
B"
3 .3 ;
-04#1< - "# $
<"
3 .3 ;" .-=/
$
<"