High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1308/2016allowed

Vinod Kumar Datta v. State Of Haryana And ANR

2018-07-04Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan,Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri12 pages

! "#$#%&'() *+

,& -,. -,./ . 0 $ %&

#$ !

% & "

& ( ) !

' + % *! (# !

+,,+,- ./&',-01,("! *# 2!

# "

3##. 4 52. 26"

! ""

( #7 # . % *# "

" '*. 1,9::+ "

#+,-::: ;

! !

3## %

:565656 $

#/)

#! ;

( ! !

3## " <! /)

# % ! ;

! ! <! (!

#( $

#7 ,,0= !

! $

,,,,,,,1( ! > 7#

" "

")# /)

# % "

! #$

#. !

# ,,9"!"

! #(

(#./&',-0,,9(. ( # ! "7# #"

( !) "

#% ' $ #" "

")# /)

#% "

(# ! #! #$

#. ,9,,9##

"" " ""( ! # ' $ #= ( ! ! # "

,1,9,,: ( "!

# " "

")# & ! >!"

% .

" ,,9 "

# # $

# *. % ! # !( #"( #./&'::,,:. " ! !

# ",9,,,9,,,9% ""

! 9,+, . ! ! !

" ( '"

("# ! )#! ! !

! '*. +, " "

= ! -,+, ! $

# ( # % "

% ! # +,./&'+-10,(.

! ,:,+,%. ! ! ( '*. # !! !

!!##(" ?## ! *. ,-,, ! ## $

# ( ("

% % ./&',-01,( . ,-,,% # # !

+,,+,-

* ! ,. ? !

# ( #

( #7 #!

( "! ( " ! !

;

( (#. !! #

#7 # #

! ( . " # (

*! ! ( )(. " "

# #!! # # (

#(! #7 #! #(

# ( "

# # ( % !! # ! " ( #7 #!

( #

4 ! ! ! " #! (. ""!""

4 ! ( #7 # #" ( !

! !! #

2 '

# "

# "*!

!(. ( ! ( ) ( ( # "# <!# ,,9 #"

! ( "# ! ( #7 #! "

# "!"

#5& !6!

:+,,* +09,, # 09,,"!

#7 #"

# !#" ! ,-,,!! # #7 #"

# # #! $

# !

"!"

( !

( " ( * # ( !

(# ( . / ! # / ! ! #

( #7 # ! #

! !

(! (. ,,1,1/ );

" (

!" #$ %## &

' # ( # ) * $

' # *' '

$ '$ $ + & *

'$ #$*

('$ + &' ' $ #

+ # ' ( % , + & %

' ' -#$% * # -

' '* # $' ' # ( -

* # . - % / 0

*1 2 34* 53 6

* $ (

* ' #

# $ ' $" # # ' (

' + & &*

' + #

' '$

$##

* $*

'%'% 7

* # / '$ 8 $ & $,

* % 9

3 !: % '% * ; <

8 $ & $,

*; ' # + #*8 $ * 8&, %'$= +

% # ; < 8&,

# (< #'$0 >:+ 8* # /7

'$ $ ?35 &$

'$0 & / % *; < * 8 $ & $,

*; % # 9 ' !

$ '# + 0% & $

$ 8 $ & $,

*& ) = + 0 #

=$ + & # =$# < # ; < +

< @)#'

$ 9

= =$ 6 ' + < @ )#'

$ 9 ( <

4+ & #

4A # 0 ;% $ ' . (

4 # # ( < * ( < 1B $ 4 0 A

* # ' '$

# + #' # ' 7

% 2*

?35 '$

'# '

# #

$ # $9 % ' !-%

# '$ /- # * #

# * $ '#

# #

7 0'B # *

/ # % A

A 23

9 ! 8C'* # ' - ' #

% < ) 35*

( 8&, 8 $ & $,

,#$0% & %'$ = < 5? 8 $ = ' , 1 +4' % .A@@ @)@8=, 16+4 5 % 2@6@8&, 3

& '

+ #*8 $ % -

% < ) 3?5 @ 35' 8C'8

$* 8 $ & $,

,#$0% & %'$ # $ ' # )) 9= 3 *

; < 1 4* '

'$ $

# ; < 1 4 !+ '

# +* 8 $ -#' % < @)#'

# D. % $@- 8

$ 7 -

$* 9 0% & 8&,*

; < *8&, '

'$ # $ $ #

B B

'$ %

% $

# #

; < % 0% &B ( !

( = !. = "! "

! +,"

(. $

;

( %

(= !% ! " ,"

(= !

"! "

# 0,-,+% !"

( #! # #"! ! ./&'+-10,,:,+,% !! !. !

# ! #

)( !#! ! (. " " ! % ( ( ( " " ""

#(! () !)/ !! +,"

"# # #

?#!

#! (. "! (# ( #7 # #

#7 #! # ! $

(". 7# # ! #$

# "

" ,9,,,9 "

# # ! # ,,0# <!

;

( $

#= ! ! "

,9,,,9". ! $

#" 7# #",9,,,9% " "

( $

#. 7# #",9,,,9 ! "

(

;

<! ;

. "

#" ,9,,,9' "

( ?! !

#(;

# !

(( "

!7# #"

( # % "

! #$

# % !"

! " " #

! / # #* . ! !

! ( . ## "

! #. )#! ! ? #* . "

" "! ) !

( !! "

( $

# ? # ( (###!,,9 " , !# #

( ( ! %(2!! $

## (. !! ( #7 # *"

? ! . !!

! . ! 2!

. )

#" A! B

! ! ! ,

( !!

#'". !# *. ! . !

" #

" ( ! ! ( (#

/) !

) ( " (

!! ? "

)"# @* 56

" C 56 % #

+,,+,- ( #7 #./&',-01, C 56 '*. !

( $

3##. 4 $ #

# #! ",9,,,9" ! ! (

C 5 6 % (

# "

3## . 4 $ #

(,,9,9C 5 6

' !

)

" 9") ! ! ! C 5 6

' (! ! ! (C 5 6 4,9,9! !C 5 6 ! (# ! ' # =!! 5 6 5/ .6 '() *+

/ )#D @ ED' / (@ ED'