Avtar Singh v. Niper And ANR.
,:;
" # ;4:5A0 D(3 #"% '5B)5)5A
E++" < ) !" # $%"!% &!%
& " "% & " " + &" " "' ( ( (
()=),) *& %"#
"++" ) () > &/9*& % "# " + &" )) ()"
!
*& %"# " + &" )) ??? ) ,"" "++" ""> > % " " "9!& # " ""& " !& " &"& 56)56)5 6* / "".- " % $ "
++" # + +" & !-* .""&"
"% "&) ) & +!" "++"
/ -"$+ -"&/
! &
!%
+ 0#
1
23 ! "" 4)56)7@@) " / " + $ $ "& " + # "" 5A))74B) " ++" / #! " + $ "& " &" "" /)"
)#) 6)56)774) +" + # 8"%!" "" / &" "
"&.- &"C 55& "++" ++ "& & !% %%-) "+"&"+$" )")
" .9"%
FG %"#%"& /"& "++" ++" ""%!$"+ %" ) ++" / ! $" -++ "& &"+! 8"%!" "" A))55 ) ""#"* " ++" ."" .
."& "$+ -$" # ))556) ""#" " ++" % $"&
% "# ) &" "&""& !% .""# !& ""- "%"." #"5)5)556* ++" &
% $ /% " # ) ;) "&"% &"C"$+ -"/ +! % " " /+" / %"."" & $ "&) ".""# # /%
" # . "& !+ ##%" $"$ &!$ &"& 7)54)746) ##%" $"$ &!$ # 746 / & " /- .- !. "H!" ##%" $"$ &!$ &"& A)5@)55B) /""* #"
##%" $"$ &!$%$" ." !"& 4)5)557*/ "".- "+" ! ##%" $"$ &!$ &"& 7)54)746* ."" ""& %" "8 "%" )
" "+ ##%"$"$ &!$&"&4)5)557* "+ &!%"& !&"'
! "# ! ! # ! !
$%&%&''$( #! )&* %'
*+
,-,. ! ! '/&'&%0*1 ! 23 )&* %'
*+ , ! !0&'*&%0*+(! ! !
,4 & ! !
'%&'%&''+&5 6) ".
" ##%"$"$ &!$&"&4)5)557/ ! &$>" ++" ".""# &" &"&"&7)54)746*/ ! & & " "& #
" /
/"" !&" % "$" & " ."" ++ "& #"5)5)556) "+" "% "* "++ $" "++" #"
F;G 5)5)556),""& "!& "* ""# "* >""/ ." % " ##"
++ $"#"5)5)556* "
# /% "#
% $ / ! & ."&$ . " "++" ) B) ,""& % ! " # " ++" + %" " %" 9!& " !
! I0 3 )6@6 #5* "&
! " !##$ % & %'!
( ) " %" ."" + %"& . "
!+ + )A&7*/ ""+ &!%"& ""#"': # ! ! (
# & D ) ! ". D )(
! ''0%+
%/$(
! ! 6 (
! & &( , 7 (
! ! ) 8! !
9 ! ! & ! ( ! ". 2
(
! "# #(
(! "# # ! ! "# #
"# #(
(!
# #& 8 :!
( # ) , ( , '%&'%&''+!
"#
!4 ; "#& # '%&'%&''+& ) , ( (
!
( "# # + ) , ( !!
!(: ! , !
F6G
"# #(& &(
( "# #!; "# '%&'%&''+& ! #
! ! "# #(
( )<=438( '$&'*&''+( 9
(
( ) , !! &5 A) " !.$ &%"& ."
# "++" ++ "& .- "% ! " # &"C /
+ ! "#% "% "."# " " !
!/""&##""/ ##" ++ $" " # % "& + $ " # " ++ % $>" ++ % # /% " # " " $" ." % &""&) ) " 9!& " !
! % !% #% "+ &!%"& ""#"': I " " +" " & ."" / > , J &"+! J (* &%"& ""."# "* "% * (*
##""& +" "* &" ("$ &!$*&"&A)@)556*+"$"+ #,.
- "&) ! "0#3 " &("$ &!$*&"&A)@)556* % " & ##" #++ $"*"& !&"': , "
&> ! ! , # ! !
#
, = ( %0/(
! &6 ! # ,4 # ! )<=8 ! #
FBG "# !
! !9 # "# ? ,4 ( ! ! "# 7 )<=8& "
@ # ( &( ! "
, = %0/&5 @) "8$"& " $" + %"& "% &* /" #& " ++" / - ++ "&
& & "& .""#
) " ! " /"" . " " +"% # "$+ -"" #
) ! ! &" "$" !"& .- " " + &" C * ++" / - " &"+! "-"55& "%$" ." ! $" - .
."& " "$+ -$" # ))556) !% %%!$ %" * "&" #"- "%"# "++" / ! &."#" 5)5)556) ! "1 2 ##%"$"$ &!$&"&4)5)557*% " - "" " +" ! + %- # /% " % "& ##%" $"$ &!$&"&7)54)776/ ""8%"+
" % "$" /
" ++ "& #" 5)5)556* / ." " "- % "$") "% " "+" "++" % " -# ""8%"+
##%" $"$ &!$ &"& 4)5)557) " "/ "* /" #& ++" & !+"!"& "-"5)(!% /" # / %" ") " "&"/ " +"%#%+ "++ %. "
##%" $"$ &!$*
% ." % #""& " ++" % $ /% " ) 4) ,""& % ! " # " ++" + %" " %" 9!& " 2. "!+"$"
!%%" %'!
$( '
FAG )%$ % %& * ! %'!
+,,, - .//) " 2. "!+"$"
!+ )B* &>" " "+" ! 9!& $" "% " =) !$ %'!
$ % %& '!
(074@36
BAA*/ / "% "8 #.""# #+ "%"# +!+ " #&""$ # " -) 9!& $"++" -/ " ++ %. - "#% "+" "% ") 7)
" #& "% &"& "".
"* /" #& #$- " 9!& $" + "& .- " ""& " !& " / "#""%") "++" * ""# "*# & & $ "&) 5) +"& $ %)++ % 0 3*#-* && + "& #) *) *) 5B)5)5A 9"
)I " " +"> J" "&K ' " J )I " ""+ . "K ' " J