Union Of India & ORS v. Manjit Singh & ANR
!!
"#$%& '$%&(& !
) " *#!
"#$% + +, -./+0 -1 + -./+0 -1-+-2 %$&$ " %' 3$4 *5!6 37!"$6
%"#$!88$55!
"& 999 # & "%!,7(%"!88$!5( $%5!(&$: "#$$""$%&!"$ "#!& ;$$ 5$ !*!
&""#$% $% !"$
< 8!&&$ ;="#$5$!% *5$ 0( *$ 2 >
5$ ;=!
) " *#%$&8 " #$%$ 6 ! %$" %$ ??!
" "#$ /% $% $7(% "= %7$ /6 @#$%$;="#$!7" "& ?!4 *"#$%$73$%= 8$ !?( *" <B, "#!& ;$$ #$5 ";$ 55$*!5!
"&#!3$;$$ %$7"$ "%$ ( &! !?( ""%$&8 "!5 *@ "# "$%$&"!""#$%!"$ C8$%
(?@ "# !8$% "@? "#& %?"#$ !"$ %$7$ 8" !7$%"
78= "#$% $% #$%$ & $5!= > !=& *"# &!88$!5#(*# !885 7!"
, 5$ ;= "#$ !88$55!
"& % 7 !" $5!=6 &(
7 $ "$D85!
!" #!&;$$ * 3$ % *"#$
, , !88$!5;$= "#$8$% 5 ? "!" 6=$" "#$ "$%$&" )(&" 7$6@$#!3$ #$!% 5$!% $ 7( &$5 % "#$ !88$55!
"& !
#!3$ * $ "#%(*# "#$ ?8(* $ % $%8!&&$ ;="#$5$!% *5$0( *$ "#$8%$&$ "7!&$6"#$ &&($";$ $7 $ &!&"@#$"#$%
"#$ 7$& "#$7!&$6"#$!88$55!
"&@$%$)(&"
$
?!4 *! $ (7" <B, 6;$ *8$ " %77(8= *!E3$% "!55""$ %$& $ " !5 !"$5#
&8("$ 5=6 "#$=$!%
6%$&8 "@!&@%4 * !&!??!
" "#$/!"$5# (% *# &8&"
*!"$5# 6#$@!& !55""$ !E3$% "%$& $ " !5!77?? !" !"$5# "&$5 ' $% $% !"$ <
6 %$&8 " @!& "%!
$%%$ " /! 4( 0!58! *(% 2$&" /$ *!5 77% *5=6 #$ @!& %$5 $3$ %? $5#
"#$%$!
"$%6#$) $ # & (" $&!"/! 4( "#8(%60!58! *(% 2$&"/$ *!5
6;("#$ "&# "# & !? 5=6!&#$@!&" 3!7!"$"#$!77?? !" !"$5# !
"$%"#$%$F( & "$8$% $? "# # &)
*!"/! 4( "#8(%60!58! *(% 2$&"/$ *!5 "#$?$!
@# 5$6 @ "# ! 8$% $ ? "#6 3 $ % $% !"$
6 #$ @!& "%!
$%%$ "(5@!?! 0!??(1!&#? %6! &"(%;$ !%$!#$%$!
"$%6
"$%?& "#$85 7= "&"8$%? "
7$%&8&"$ &"(%;$ !%$!&"%$"!
!55""$ ""#$?!""#$ %$!%5 $%85!7$
8&"
*6 %$&8 " ?! $ ! @% ""$ %$F($&" % %$"$ "
E3$% !"$5# - &%$F($&"@!&!77$8"$ !
#$@!& !55@$ "%$"!
!"$5# (% *"#$8$% #$%$?!
8&"$ "#$ &"(%;$ !%$!(;&$F($ "5=6!
"$%# &"%!
$% %?(5@!?!
, ,
0!??(1!&#? %6#$3!7!"$ "#$!77?? !" !55""$ "# ?!"
$5# "$%# &%$" %$?$ "6"#$!88$55!
"& ( "#!"%$&8 "@!&
"$ " "5$ "%$"!
"#$E3$% !"$5# 6;$7!(&$
%?$5# 6#$@!&"%!
$%%$ "/! 4( "#8(%60!58! *(% 2$&"/$ *!56 "#$%$!
"$%"(5@!?! 0!??(1!&#? %#$%$ %$6#$7(5 "!4$ E3$% !"/! 4( "#8(%60!58! *(% 2$&"/$ *!5!
%$"!
"#$&!?$6;("#$7(5 ";$!55@$ "%$"!
!"
$5# "# &!77( "6!&(? <B,@!& $ (7"$ %?"#$%$" %!5 ;$ "6!&8$ " %%$"!
*"#$E3$% !"$5# # &!7" "&@!&7#!55$ *$ ;= %$&8 ";= *2 >
6@# 7##!&;$$ #$5 " ;$ 55$*!5;="#$5$!% *5$0( *$3 $"#$ ?8(* $ % $%G!
%$7" 6!&?$ " $ "#$$!%5 $%8!%" "# &% $%6#!&;$$ &&($ "$%#$!% *5$!% $ 7( &$5 %"#$!88$55!
"&!
4$$8 *
3 $@"#$!
%$&! 7$& "#$7!&$6@$!%$ " " "$% $%$@ "#"#$ ?8(* $ % $%8!&&$ ;="#$5$!% *5$0( *$ 5= "#!&;$$ !%*($ ;=5$!% $ 7( &$5 %"#$!88$55!
"& "#!"( $%"#$%(5$&!
%$*(5!" &6!
"$%# &"%!
$% %?/! 4( 0!58! *(% 2$&"/$ *!5"(5@!?! 0!??(1!&#? %6%$&8 @!& "$ " "5$ "%$"!
"#$E3$% !"$5# -$ 7(5 %$"!
"#$ !77?? !" 5= !" /! 4( "#8(%6 0!58! *(% 2$&"
/$ *!5 2$ "
=&(;&"!
7$ "#$!
%$&! !%*(?$ ""#!&
";$$ &8("$ "#!""#$!88$55!
"&"#$?&$53$&#! !55@$ %$&8 "%$"!
E3$% !"$5# 6 "#$%$F($&"?! $;=
,>, %$&8 "#(&6%$&8 "@!&!7"(!55=!55@$ "%$"!
!"$5# ;=!
% $%3!5 5=8!&&$ ;="#$!("#% " $&!""#!" " ?$#$ !7"%$?!
&"#!" (% *"#$8$% F($&" 6%$&8 " @!& %$"!
* 5= $ E3$% " !77?? !" 6 $ !" $5#
&8("$ 5=6 #$ @!& " !55""$ !
= !77?? !" !" /! 4( 0!58! *(% 2$&"/$ *!56 %#$%$"!
$ !
=&(7#!77?? !" "$%# & "%!
$%"(5@!?! 0!??(1!&#? % "#!" &&6 " & "!7!&$
%$"!
* (;5$E3$% &/$ *!??!
"6#$ @!&$ " "5$ % $!77?? !" 6@# 7##$@!&!5%$! =#!3 *!"$5# $%$5=;$7!(&$ &?$"$7# 7!5 5!@#$%$!
"#$%$68$ "7(5 "
#!3$;$$ %$73$%$ "6!
"$%# & %$" %$?$ "68!%" 7(5!%5=@#$ #$@!&5$*!55=8$%? ""$ ;="#$7?8$"$ !("#% "="%$"!
!"$5# 2$!%$ "#$8 "#!" "#$8%$&$ "7!&$6"#$!("#% " $& ( $%"#$/#!3$ " ! %5= $!5"@ "# "&
7$%6@# $ "#$% $!
= @% * %85!=$ !
= %!( @# 5$%$"!
*"#$!77?? !" !"$5# #$%$ %$6 "#$&$ 7$&6"#$5$!% *5$0( *$#!& % *#"5= &$" !& $ "#$ !7" "#$ !88$55!
"&6 @# 7# @!& !88!%$ "5= ( %$!& !;5$!
( )(&"
$ ?$% " &? &&$ ! "
#$#%&#' ( ! )"
)