Uhbvn And ORS v. Pawan Kumar




   
  

  !"##$%&%'(  )

""!*!*+!'!%,-%.%"*!'%/!0"1!'1!'"2#* 33#--!'"& 4#*&5&

!6!'750!*!'1"2#*&  #&3'1#'"&
 



 
 
 


   

82#"2#* #3*"#*&-$!-3!3#*&0!+9#!--6#1"&##"2#,51/0#'":
82#"2#*"9#*##**#1""2# #3*"#*&*'":
82#"2#*"2#,51/0#'"&25-19#*#3*"#1%'"2#%/#&":

*#&#'"( * !*1##3; '%!<14$!"#<*"2#!33#--!'"& * 7!-%=<;*14$!"#6%"2 *.%,!+!2%+!<14$!"#<*"2#*#&3'1#'"& >>>> 
 
 
2%& %& !' !33#!- !/!%'&" "2# *1#*  "2# -#!*'#1 ;%'/-# 51/#!--6%'/"2#3#"%"%'9+&#""%'/?!&%1#"2#*1#*1!"#1   "2#;"!'1%'/00%""##5*#!5 59-%$'"#*3*%&#&1#$-%'%'/ "2#3*3&!-"2#!*1%*#$"*&!33#--!'"  2# !33#--!'"& !*# "2# ""!* !*+!'! %,-% .%"*!' %/!0 "1 !'1 %"& %'!'$%!- 14%&* #&3'1#'"&   "  !*# "2# 3#"%"%'#*& #&3'1#'"&   !'1

 !*# "2# *%/%'!- *#&3'1#'"& !'1 <'!0#-+<;"!"#!*+!'!!'1!*+!'!5*#!5 59-%$ '"#*3*%&#&"2*5/2%"&!'!/%'/%*#$"*  2# !*1  %*#$"*&  !*+!'! 6#* #'#*!- *3*!"%' "1   ?!33#--!'"   !" ! 0##"%'/ 2#-1 '



@@$'&"%"5"#1!$00%""##"2#!'!/%'/%*#$"*&A!-- "2#!*+!'! 6#* "%-%"%#&5'1#*"2#2!%*0!'&2%3"2#!'!/%'/ %*#$"*& * 3*3&%'/ "2# 3!+ *#4%&%'< "%0# &$!-#&< !0#'10#'" " #$*5%"0#'"!'1 *0"%' -%$+C*03!'+;#$*#"!*+< %'!'$# $$5'"&51%"!'1 8%'/&2#00%""##%'!-%D#1%"&*#3*" ' E@
' -%'# 6%"2 "2# 1#$%&%' "!=#' 9+ "2#  < "2# 3*3&!-&6#*#35"53*"2#$'&%1#*!"%'!'1!33*4!-"2#!*1 %*#$"*& .?!33#--!'"   2# 3*#&#'" 3#"%"%' $'$#*'& 3&"&  $$5'"& %$#*& !'1;#'%*$$5'" %$#*&2#*#-#4!'"3*3&!-%'"2%&*#/!*1*#!1& !&5'1#*(? B
    

  

 

 

      
         

 

 

       C

33#--!'"   9+ ! #0*!'150 3-!$#1 "2# 3*3&!- 9#*#"2#!*1%*#$"*&*"2#%*$'&%1#*!"%'!'1!33*4!-2# *#-#4!'"3!*""2##0*!'150*#!1&!&5'1#*(? !  "      

#     $      

 
 %  &

    '() (  $(      &  

* +,#+,#-++.#  // // //  *

    
   0 

             **     $"  $**

 

    
1          * 

2  0  3
 (   #

          4205)6     *
   0 

  7 ) '%'"#*'!-$005'%$!"%'*0"2#03!'+;#$*#"!*+ 33#--!'" "%"& %'!'$%!-14%&**#!1&!&5'1#*(? B
1 89 *  

   # & /          0       -:#,,#-++;  
   
1 8
    

                 

               





      

           *

 *  
 < 

   * 
  *    

 
,=#,-#-++;    #7 
" %& %03*"!'" " '"# "2!" "2# -#""#*< 62%$2 *##*& " "2# 0%'5"#&"2#0##"%'/"2#!*1%*#$"*&2#-1'E

@< 1#&'"&"!"#"2!""2#3*3&!-6!&&59,#$""!'+"2%'/#&3#$%!--+"2# 1#$%&%'"2#;"!"#4#*'0#'"8#6%--<26#4#*<*"2#35*3&# "2%& ,51/0#'"< !&&50# "2!" %" 05&" 9# 1##0#1 " 9# &59,#$" " "2# !33*4!-  "2# ;"!"# 4#*'0#'" %' "2# !*+!'! 5*#!5  59-%$ '"#*3*%&#& !& "2# *#&-5"%' !33*4#1 "2# 3*3&!- $'"!%'#1 %' "2# #0*!'15062%$2%'"5*'0!1#"2#3*3&!-&59,#$"""2#!33*4!-  "2# ;"!"# 4#*'0#'" & 6# 6%-- %'1%$!"# -!"#*< "2%& 0!=#& ' 1%#*#'$# " "2# *#&5-" %' "2%& $!&# !& "2# !33*4!- 6!& &5/2" '-+ 9#$!5&#"2#1%*#$"%'&"2#;"!"#4#*'0#'"!'15*!""#'"%'2!&

'"9##'%'4%"#1"!'+3*4%&%'-!6"2!"*#F5%*#&"2#!33*4!- "2#;"!"#4#*'0#'"%'&5$2$!&#& G 2#!33*4!-6!&!33!*#'"-+&5/2"*0"2#4#*'0#'" !*+!'!2#4#*'0#'"!*+!'!9+!-#""#*1!"#1

 @ 1#$-%'#1"2#3*3&!-&"!"%'/"2!"(? B-// // //  >        
  %       

  ?   )* &   ##'()($ ( 

    *



*   %  @/  1
       &<

# >              &  *  *# %%%  HH HH HHC E  1*!" *#3*"  "2# !+ '0!-+ 00%""## 0!1# ! *#$00#'1!"%'%'!45*"2#3#"%"%'#*&%#*#&3'1#'"& "

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

 @
" %& %03*"!'" " '"# "2!" "2# 1#$%&%' "!=#' 9+ "2# !'!/%'/%*#$"*&!'19+"2#82-#%0#%*#$"*&6!&'"&59,#$" " !'+ *#&#*4!"%'  2!4%'/ "2# &!0# !33*4#1 9+ "2# ;"!"# 4#*'0#'"

 82!"!--&*$'&%1#*!"%'<"2#*#*#<%&"2###$""2# ;"!"# 4#*'0#'" 2!4%'/ *#,#$"#1 "2# 3*3&!- *#/!*1%'/ "2# 3!+ %H!"%'62%$26!&!33*4#19+!33#--!'" 33#--!'" 2!1"2# 36#*"1&5'1#*%"&I


  

!'1#4#'"2#*6%&# !33#--!'" 1%1'"%"&#-"2%'=%"'#$#&&!*+"9"!%'"2#!33*4!- "2#;"!"#4#*'0#'"

"%&%03*"!'""'"#3!*!/*!32G"2#6*%""#'&"!"#0#'" %-#1 ' 9#2!-  "2# !33#--!'"& !& 6#-- !& "2# !*+!'!?5*#!5 

59-%$ '"#*3*%&#&< 62 6!& "2# *#&3'1#'" %' "2# 3#"%"%'
' 3!*!/*!32G<"2#!94#!$"&!*#!10%""#1%'$-51%'/"2#!$"*#/!*1%'/ "2#*#$00#'1!"%'"2#00%""##
"%&!-&%03*"!'""'"#"2!" %' 3!*!/*!32 G %" %& &"!"#1 "2!" "2# &!%1 #0*!'150 $'"!%'%'/ "2# *#$00#'1!"%'&  "2# 00%""##  "2# !'!/%'/ %*#$"*& $'&"%"5"#19+"2#!*1%*#$"*& 6!&3-!$#19#*#"2# !*1  %*#$"*&  !33#--!'"   62%$2 &"!"#1 "2!" "2# *#$00#'1!"%'& !*# 5*"2#* &59,#$" " "2# !33*4!-  "2# ;"!"# 4#*'0#'" I!& 3#* "%%$!"%' 1!"#1 

 @@  %'!'$# #3!*"0#'"< **%/#'150 1!"#1 @ @@< -#""#* 1!"#1 )  !'1)A &*!-%=<-#!*'#1;#'%*5'&#-*%/2"-+3%'"#15" "2!""2%&!4#*0#'"0!=#&%"$-#!*"2!""2#3*3&!-6!&&#'"""2#;"!"#

4#*'0#'"'-+15#""2#&#%'&"*5$"%'&2%&%&$-#!**0"2#6*1& I   2# 6*1& I   #&"!9-%&2 "2!" "2# !33#--!'"& $'&%1#*#1 "2#0&#-4#&95'19+"2#%'&"*5$"%'&!'1%"%&*"2!"*#!&'"2!""2#+ &#'""2#3*3&!-""2#;"!"#4#*'0#'"*%"&!33*4!-2#-#""#* 1!"#1)<   <*#F5%*#&"2#;"!"# 59-%$'"#*3*%&#&"/#" "2#%* 3*3&!-& 3#*"!%'%'/ " "2# *#4%&%'  3!+ &$!-#& #"$ !33*4#1 *0 "2# !*1  %*#$"*& !'1 &59&#F5#'"-+ "2# 10%'%&"*!"%4# #3!*"0#'"&25-1"!=#"2#!33*4!-"2#$03#"#'"!5"2*%"+!&3#* "2#&"!'1%'/*1#*"2##3!*"0#'"

 -#!*'#1;%'/-#51/#"2%&5*"9+!,51/0#'"1!"#1 G

 3!&&#1%'%4%-8*%" #"%"%')@@ @@
   

   

2#-1"2!"(? !
#>    A       

 <           *  # >          &     

     ,   

        &      

  *        

 *     A   "$ #       
 ,      
     *       &
  A    $ #  A            &  &           *   

   * &     *

#

   *   

   &       *   A   "$   *   
 -        

#    *   
 -    
 
% #7

 8#1'""2%'=%"'#$#&&!*+*"2#35*3&#"2%&$!&#" #H3*#&& !'3%'%' *#/!*1%'/ "2# $**#$"'#&&  "2#,51/0#'"
" 6!& '"$'"#'1#19#*#5&"2!""2#;"!"#4#*'0#'"2!&"2#36#*5'1#* !'+ &"!"5"# * "2#* 3*%'$%3-#  -!6 " %&&5# "2# 1%*#$"%'& " "2# !*+!'! 6#*#'#*!-*3*!"%'"1   *6!&%""2#%* $!&#"2!""2#*#6!&!'+&#3!*!"#!/*##0#'"*5'1#*&"!'1%'/#'"%"-%'/ "2#;"!"#4#*'0#'""%&&5#&5$21%*#$"%'&"%"
"%&!-&%03*"!'" "'"#"2!"'#%"2#*"2#!*1%*#$"*& ?!33#--!'" '* "2# 00%""##  "2# !'!/%'/ %*#$"*& 0!1# "2#%* 1#$%&%' &59,#$"""2#!33*4!-"2#;"!"#4#*'0#'"'"2#9!&%&"2!""2# ;"!"#4#*'0#'"9#%'/'-+"2#&2!*#?2-1#*5/2""2!4#!&!+%' "2#0!""#*2#1#$%&%'<"2#*#*#<6!&'"*"2#35*3&#9"!%'%'/ "2# $'&#'" "2# ;"!"# 4#*'0#'" !& ! 0!,*%"+ &2!*#?2-1#* 2# 1#$%&%'6!&"!=#'35*#-+'"2#9!&%&"2#&!%1%'&"*5$"%'&


"6!&!10%""#1"2!""2#!33#--!'" 2!&"2#36#*"%H "2#3!+&$!-#!'1J**#04#!'+!'0!-+2#'-+9,#$"%'6!&"2!" %"6!&"9#&59,#$"""2#!33*4!-"2#;"!"#4#*'0#'"
"%&'" '#$#&&!*+< "2#*#*#< " *##* " "2# *"%$-#&  &&$%!"%'  "2# !33#--!'" %'"2%&*#/!*1

'"2#$%*$50&"!'$#&<"2#!33#!-%&1%&0%&&#1  ;.K
 

  ;
    ;
 ;
     



  I*!4%'1#*A