High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/5761/2019dismissed

Sanjeev Juneja And ANR v. Terrace Pharmaceutical Private Ltd

2022-07-22Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul20 pages

" ! "# $ $

% # #$% &'# " ("

# )

&' * &'#+ &'+ $

+ &'( # , "

' &'#" &'#+ &'# +# # , " '

% #& "

- , .

,/ % , % , ,

$ ,

0'1' 2 3# 4 5 )% ""

% 6 //

..,

, "

) % . , #

7 $ # 8$& ' ! "

, 9 "

: %

, , $ % "" , $ + $ "" , $ + 4" 4"

%%) ,

13;5)

;3535, &+# 222 3 , , < # =5'>

, . " ,

13;5)

;3535, # %

$, " ,% ) )

+ $ , ,, 9"

, , $ , + ) , 4" % " ,

, # ' / "" , ",!6 ? , ! , '

()*+,, -./0 123),4 #,2 5 12(0 0)"&

-- 67 ! )

, .

, ) ) % ? =% #"4 . '$ $8(2 9+2((0 54 $3-)9/0/ /+" $ 67 ? , $ ,

, % "

,,9"

" " , $ , + "

" , , $ , +, "

,,9"

% @ % "

, $ " $,, % , " $@" $ ,, "

'! $ "

%" , " $ ," $,, % ,

@ ,

, " $ ,,' ? % " $,, "

" % ,) $ $ ," $,,

: () A : !

+ , , A : !

+ , $' > ) $

, . "$" 2,

) % 4)

# 4:; %

, $ $ , " $ ,, %

% "

,,) % % "

% , , $ " $,,'

, ) " $ '

+(4(-4 1+5/,( #+.+,(2 5 93*1/- ()9/0+)/- :1*4" $3; /,(0, /02 1/2(./1*/4(467& %

)

,, , )

$ % % , ) $ "" ,

+ $ " , ,, ", $'?)

$ " , +) , $'! %

%+$ , " ) , ) % %

) ) . ) $ " $ , ? =% 7 ?

$ .

'-+0+<3(#/=1/,1+(4#+) /0,9(153+)#+.+,(2" +5+- ?%

$ % $ B -+0+<3( #/=1/,1+(4"4 )/4( 43;1/ )

"$ %, 7 B , ? =% 7 ?

$ . ) $ )

$ % $ $' $ " 7

+5+- 6,+,-(2/4'3+)#,2/02/0,9(15-+0+<3(#/=1/,1+(4 #+) /0,9(1"&, %

. $ ,

% $ " '

/>0+49 ??/1@/- /02 ,9(14 5 0/0,/." 76 +5+- A7&) )%" , $% $$,? =% 7 ?

$ . -+0+<3(#/=1/,1+(4"4)/4( 43;1/ '?%

, "$ ) )%" %

)$ ,? =% 7 ?

$. $$ "$ % '? % " ,

13;5 )

;3535 , # % $ " ) "

, " 9"

,, % % 6 //

..' & . , ""

3# 4;5) %%"

,)% %

' ! $

,,9" ) "

)

, , +, "

) )

"" % "

' ?) "

, + , "

@) % ,

'! "" , % " " $ 6 '%/5+1/> /02+, 31?/ 3,, $9/1./ 5 /5/1/,0/

9/1./)(3,+)/-#/=1/,1+(4"B

34,0 104=8 #,259(C/.+02/1/0?+0((1+0?"B 7 $'/,+0/- =(-- /02 0,9(1 5 (,/- 24

# /02 0,9(1"B A $A'1+5/02/02/.5D$/,8/;/-/02 0,9(1"B 6 $3;; 7 'E9/1 344/+0 5 />+5 /029+"B

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

/9?@(021/$9/1/0

$+0?95 /. 1/4/00/$+0?9 (/2 913?9#(?/- (;1(4(0,/,+5( /02 ,9(14"B

'$1+9/1+/03./02/4,/-/5(./0, D+,/-%/./,/02 ,9(14"B#

6 -(-9+'G$0,(1;1+4(4

D#5G$ +5($,/1-(),1+)/-4 02+/ 0,9(1"B

## '/1+$+0?93+-2(14 1.,(14#5/02 0,9(1"B$ 0-+0($7 A'

1(4,0,(10/,+0/-#+.+,(25 +-/0(5(-;(14/023+-2(14

#+.+,(2/020,9(1"B6 $ '8,/ +249/ %/=349+*+ %/+49/ 5 1+34 3, 0234,1+(4 #+.+,(2/02 ,9(14" , " ) "" $

% % "

$ "

$ " , "

3# 4:;5

% ,

, $ " $,,'> ) $

, . "

$ , " $,, ,

' ,

, , $ " $ ,,

;C, # '%

" , %

$ + , "

, " )" "" , +)

, $ "

) ""

, 6 //

.. 3# 4 ;;5 +

$ +) ,, )

"$" 8'

, ""

" " " ,

13;5 )

;3535 , # ' , %

, % , " ,

13;5 )

;3535 , # ) % % "

, + )

' ?)

% "

+ $

9,:

% "

$ +) ,, )

+)$ , " )

' > $ "

$ % % , "

, " %

, , $ , % $ "" $ $ "" $

+ )

% % " ,

13;5 )

;3535 , # ' ! , $ "

)% ""

6 //

.. ), % "

)

'! , " $ ) $ ""

6 //

.. @

) % ) " , ", "

. $ % ' / "" "

" '

/>0+49??/1@/- ,9(145G40/0,/." $ 0-+0( (- 76 '==,, (/-,9)/1( 1+5/,( #+.+,(2 5 /> %3./1

1/4/2/02,9(14"A$ 0-+0((- / , "

" ' / ) % % $ % % " ,6 //

.. +

" ) $ ,

' >

$ " ""

6 //

.. ,

, "

) %

)

" % "

,,'/ )%

% "

", "

$, $ , "

) % ) "

% '

, $ , $ ""

6 //

.. , , , % +

' #

$ "

, "

$ ,

% $%% " ,

13;5, # '/ " , ", "

$ "" , +<& =

, , $ % " $ ) %

%' D ,

, ,

13;5 , # " %) :

# %"

" #

& ? =% " . $ $8(2 9+2((0"4 )/4(

43;1/ &) $)

'"('

) "

" "

# "

# %"

" #

+ "

# #

# "*

& / , $ , "

" "

$ ) , +' > "

) ) $ $ $ $

, + %, . '" :, "

13;5, # $ "" ) % % "

'?)

)% "

, , $

, , $ )" $,,'#"

, % " , + $ ,," $,,' $,, ) ) ,, %

+ % " " , # ' $,,$ E $ ,"

, + " , $ , " $ ,, '' $) "

, " )%

,," $,, $

, +) % %$

, " $ ,,' $ , " $ ,, % ,

, $ # ' ? =% #"4 . $ $8(2 9+2((0"4)/4( 43;1/ &, % .

# !

# -

)

# '

/ -

) " '

- #

" . 0 " $"

# "

" "

# '

/ "

# #

# "

" %"

" #*"

1 - 2

# + 3

,444+ -

/45 + 3

,444 "

# "

4 -

/ -

6 #

+ "

+ #

/ 7 -

8& 9

# !

# -

+ "

# (:(# "

+ #

/ -

5 + 3

,444

# -

0 $ '

5/ "

'"$

# -

# #

7 -

88&+ "

; "

+ #

# -

#" -

<# = < . 0 "

;

> "

? " '"

0 " )

!" #!$ = + #

" -

" # "

" +

9 * # %&'() *%+ ,

% -.!

" @ 9

& * # "

# " "

- &/0 '# + ! !

1!$23+ A-#

0 A

1 , B

3 <

+ "

+ 0 " #

+4(&5) 6#'

22 !"2

2 # +

6 "

+ "

%" !

" %" "

# "

6 "

) # +

)

%" "

" %"#

" "

+ "

# "

;

/ ,%

," $,, ) %

% $ $ "" , &+' / )% "

;C, # ) ,) : 7 8*8 8 ( 8 889 , +

" "

,5 " $"

#( "

" + $"

" "(

" ! $"

(

( "

# "

" (

" "

" #

" C

" (

" "

" #

" C

& , " $

) " ,

% ,

, $ ) ," $,,' . % )

% %

, , $ , <" $,,=) % $

)

, "

, ", "

$ , " $ ,, %' & , < , $ =" ) $

'F )

, )

+ F $ %(1-8"4 -/@ 1/2( /1*4 /02 1/2( /.(4& 31,((0,9 2+,+0& 9.40& $@((, /F@(-- $3,9 4+/0 2+,+0 $ E " " )

," $,,

' / %(1-8"4 -/@ 43;1/ & % ,) : ,D(E-

# "

& / .

% % $ % )' "

) % 6 //

.. "

" % )% % ? =%" . '$(>/- -/44#+.+,(25/5+-/0(1)9/0,4 1+5/,(#+.+,(2"6 $ 6 ) " % "

) % "" % )

, $ '?)

, % , $ )" $,,'? . , "$ ) ""

6 //

..,

) $ % %)' #@ % "

% $ ,

'8 $ %)%

% 4"

% # 3-8&

> "+ $9 G98 > " % G98