State Of Haryana And Others v. Rajni Bhalla
!"
$
%
&#'( # ***++ ,,
- # .
/01),, ***/ +(
!"#$% & '
()*+,% -%).
+!/ $ !"#$% & '
()*+,%
+!/%
0+!1.
0+/.( #
#2.#
,$((,3&#'
# ++ ,, #0)),$(4
# +( 2 '
6) #*.# ++ ,.( #,.
7
#
) "
, (8 0.(8!
(
, # %8, 9.(8 $:) "'$
, ("' +( #
. 8 () #4
+ #( +#
(8 ) # # 8.,# ++
.# #$) "
,,:
(
#! ,:,((:;
, ( '
0( %!/%
3(
&+).
!/
*.%
4)'
0* *%
!/
*.%
( (
:) () #4
: (#
"
.
:#( '
,8: ) ++ ,$++,
28 (
(' ( ,' ,8 ++ ,) , "
, ( <#
( ++, ( ,'
(' ,8 ++ ,
( ( = 6) +( : ++
(
.# # ! () " ;=& #4
:
8.,# ("'++ 8)
)#.8)&#'.", % #4
!! # )# > &%>: = ;;?
: +( ) ).8)) #++
:
#!
( () $".
#,,
(+.#+ : # 8.,# ++ : 8
(+
#+#+ #(4
("' ,,:8 +#
(.# + ++, ", #., ("' (.,' .
,
!!
6).8)$ +( )("
8#
"
() #4
# +.#+ )8) (#( , $
# , $ ,
8#( $".
() #4
)( "
.
:#( '88# (8 ( , "
() #4
# '$ # +( , :#
+#'8 #(#
. #( ) #() #4
,,:
("'# 8.,# :#(
': ),, @.
,"
/ ,
: +,
((
) .# '
0( %!/%
3(
&+).
")
.+#$:) $
( ,++ () " :) ):
,,:
("'
8.,#A $(#
:
.
. () #( #4
:#( ' "
), ++ ,, $ )("
( ) ).8) ;;
, (70* *%
)'
4)'
0( +!/
3(
&+).
)'9 (
( (=
, ("' %
8
%.# ( #B.!#> .+#)("
( ! ($".
0 :+4+$;
)' <= <<> 0* *%
!/
?)'
0( +!/
3(
&+).
)2
)("
.
(
( .#
<
+#
(8
!+
)("
(#
# ! '
( (%8, 9.(8 ) ,( ) !
( ' %: ).
"
8' +
#( #$:.,(
, "
.
( '
"
(
'0( %!/%
3(
") .+#$ # :) : .,,'++, ", +#
#(8,'$
: ,,:
( !
#!
(. , # ++ ,, ) +
(.
)
(%8, 9.(8
$ &>", %.+# .#
) 8#
(, 4 # (% 4( #( #(
(=
& #8.
) +( : ++
(() " ;=$) #4
:
8.,# (= ;;$".
) )( ,
:#
'
#
6). $ !
"
8)8),'"
,
(: ,", "
( ! ( ) # , &
) "
:
) ++ ( ,8
4 ', :
.
):8 ' + ;$ =$ $
(
?,,
', $ +( )( "
):0.#( "
,: ((
,, 2 4 "' %
1.
8 +( # (' .
8#(8
', / +#
,!8 "
() #4
#
': , (,'
,,:
("' ## +#
& .# ##8.
) +( ) !+, (
+ # $:):.,("
(
. * 8 '$
:#
: ,", "
( ! ( ) 8#.( :
,, ; +.
8 (8 (%8, 9.(8 '
0( %!/%
3(
") .+#$)
) : :#8,') ,( ) +
@.# /., &#'C(.
,,
(# 3#.+1% #4
/., $;
# )# D ;
/., E 8.,# #4
# (
#! '? )
$# ,
) "
+,
((
(
=
4 1 ) )
.# ;
=
= , ( '
0( ($ 4)'
0* *%
!/
*.% )'
& ) .# ## , ( 0* *%
4)'
?%*% +!
0 )),+ *+
!/ !
'2
:;
0 $ !* ).
3(
!/ )'
4)'
''.
@$
!/ )'2 <:;
0 A< (0* *%
(!-
!/ !
'
4)'
).@ !+ 3(
!/ )'2
B:;
0 A=
( ) #( () #4
"
.
#
#! '( ) ,'# 8.,# #4
!+,'
"
.
:#( ' #)($(. , # +( ) #8.
) @.# ,' 4 ("' (
'
0( %!/%
3(
")
.+#& ) #8.
) ).8) ++ :
#!
( ( ) $ :
8.,# #4
+#+ #+#
(.# # ,
+ .0"C(.
,% #4
/., = # )# D =/., E ++, ", !
) ,
$)("
,,:
( )4 ) #((. , # +# (+ #.
#( ? '
0( %!/%
3(
") .+# ) .# (
@.
( ,,' .
(+ # $( ,.( ) +#+ #+#
(.#
!+,
("' =/., )("
,,:
($
++ .,( "
( # . . ++ ( * ,8
! "
() #4
# '/ ,
: +,
(
&>", %.+# .# + %,* %, (+* $ ))
!11'
55+,% )C ))!'
!/
*.% 4'
0* *%
& .
).*
!/
*.% )2 :DD;
0 =A( (/
3(
+!
!/
*.% 4'
!+
!/+
!/
*.% )2 :;
0 A:) $ : ) ,( ) :) .!"
++
+
#(8 #., $) ') "
.
#! (
) ++ (
#(8 (
)
#!
?
: .# #
) /., ;
/.,
,8: ) ' : +
@.# 8.,# #4
( : +#4( ) ' ),, "
(
#! ("', 8 )
.. #4
#(8,'$ : (#
( ) ( ) #4
( ("'
# "
.
:#( '6).8)
, ("' %
8 ) (
: ( ! ($".
% , 4 ) "
8#
((
!+ +#
(8 :
(#
# !
'
( = ?4 : 4#. (
&>", %.+# .#
!
:) ) )4 "
#
## ( "' ( %8, 9.(8 '
0( %!/%
3(
") .+# , (
(
=
$ "
( +.
: ) +#+ ) :) + # :)+
@.
@., # + )("
++
( + ++, ", #., "' !+
.
)# '"' ,,:8+#+ +#
(.# (8 ."
4 + ( .
+ # #,'
,8 !
$ .
)++ "
"
() # + 8+() # #4
,", "
.
#+.#+ ' 6) :
#!
(#
,'"'&>", %.+# .# &+!
+1 *+ %E**'
4'
%!/
3(
+E *.+2 :A;
0 B "'),(8 ) (."
".
"4 +# +, G.
++, *
6) (
# , ("' (%
. ,#
:) : ' (8 ) ,++ :
!( "'
!+
.
)# ' #
,'
#(
: ) /., 1.
:
(
8 ) @.
# # ## :) )!+ ,. ( 8#
: ) 4 : (%8, 9.(8 ,,:8 :#
!
,'
,'(!+, (!
(+ # 6) +( : ++
(() " ;=$ #4
:
8.,# (= ;;%) ) "
8#
"
() #4
# +.#+ )8) (#( , $ # , $
,
8#( $".
("
: 8#
# +.#+
'<# ,!8 "
'$ ) , :#
'
#
1
# ) 4 ', )("
.
(( +
8
' + ;$ =$ $
(
C4 ).8)$,,
', $ +( )("
):0.#( "
,: ((
,, 2 4 #"'
%
$ ) (( # ' .
8#(8) '/ +#
,!8 "
() #4
# ': , (,'
,,:
("' ## +#
6). $ ) "
#(
( ,','8 ,! "
) #() #4
#
'$:) ) #!
( ) 8 $:,,.
, '
,
( " 2?
) "
# +
(,') ,("' %.+# .# )
=
')("
F (( ! F
## ",
+ #($' ),, 8 !
).,( "
( ? 0.+#
0.
!F
& .
*
4'
0* *%
+)) :;
0 =2&>", %.+# .# # 4 :
,: ."0
.( # D
!
" # $ % #&
'
$
$
'
(
'
$ &
)!&
*+ $ # ,,- ./ 0.1
" # $ %
'
!
"
!2
3
*+"
! # 4. 55/ 05513 '
6
$
3 "#&$ 3&&
'
#&7! !
$
$
889 *+"#&$ # 54:
;<< 8:=5</ 08:1>551
'
'
3 '
6
$
1?
@ @ @ 5< 1
A
" ,49:1(
A
" 88 ,49: ' )
A
"
B"&"7#
* +# -58=-59 8=./ 081
5 ;
1 @ @ @ .1#
3
13
)
'
'
(
B" &
'
& C
%?#D2
3
*+
%?#D # 9<8 4/ 04
3
$ ?
$ "$
$
$
3
+ /
3 !#!'#7 '
* +# -89 ./ 0. 1 3
'
$
889
'
+ / 3 % A
#&
:
4
889
3 7## #E
)
*+# ,-; 8/ 081
'
889
3
'
889
# % F # 27 "' ! #
E
3 A3
G #
3 %
$
7 #&
3 B &'#B
3
E
'
+H CA
% F#& HBB F&
#) ! F3 G A 2
F # % 2
3 F 7 #" E # 3
%
%
! /
3 B"&
5 ;
5 ;
'
; 6)
, ,", "
( ! (
. *
!+, (!
# :):.,("
("' 8# ,
+( 6)
' !+, (8+ # :):.,("
(4 ,'
("' 8# ,
+( $ # ,
@. )( "
+#'
( #$ ) "
( "' %.+# .#
+# +, ) #( "
+ ("
)( " 2 # ) ),, (4 ,'
)!
? 0* *%
- )*.
4'
,,.
$ ..
!@ $2 :;
0 : ) ,( .( # 7
I
% !
'
#
E 4,< ,,
8< :
,44.
E
)
'
3
$ 3
'B B2
3
*+# 9,4 59/ 059 E
) 7
B
3
$ '
(
3 #$
#27
* +H 'B B # 98< 5.
5:/ 05.1>-9
'
3
+3 #$
# ,-, -9/?
5:3 7
#
&!
*+# 8<.
<: 4 ,</ >41
2 E
&
! "
$
'
& I ,"4
7 ,4<:+
0 7 /
'
2 7
'
# ,;, 7
+H A 7
$#A' ! &'
7 E B ! # ' #
# / ,<3 7 H #27
B
%
#(!
?
3 G#J#27 * +# -:5 5,/ 05,E
$
'
3
'
%
'
'
'
I
% !
<
)
<# # (# $ ) ++ , ,,:
(6) 0.(8!
(#( # (%8, 9.(8 (
(
"
$
( 6)
:#
( ! ( :0 ;
: ;
%,% #%
D2
8 )
# + 28H# I H )
#/ +# ",
I H