High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2633/2012dismissed

Bisne Ram v. Bedo Etc.

2017-07-25Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal8 pages

!!" #!$%#!&$ ''((

)*+ # &* '

!!" $&* ''((

)*+ #!&$ &* '

!!" # &* ''(( )*+ $&* &* '

!!" # &* ''((

)*+ ,&$ &* '

!!" # &* ''(( )*+ )!** &* '

!!" # &* ''(( )*+ #!&$ &* '

-* "

*./!* 0 * !

* &*' !

* &*' ! *'/+$*&*$ 0 * &*' !

* !

#2 &! $$** 3&((4!'!5!65+(*

''(4*!5

&* 3

&((5! 7+5$ '42 &!

!( ! *!

8+5 & ,

!'+ ! &'* !9!

&*'

&+ !

&'*'* 2942: &;&$4+$9&! ;& '(! ! $(2 # +$!

* & ! .!0!( +!

< *+5& *: &;&$4+9&*'(! !

!*$!9!9: &;&$4+;& ! &*! !0!( +!

*$&* ,&$#!$ 9&*: & ;&$4+ ;&'(! !!(+!

*'!5 ** (* !

& &2*9*!'!< & &*! &( $+*!5 ,( =$*(!

+ !)!((53$!( ! *!

& , ;&'(! !&( &((5 & *

'! .!0!(+!

= !

(#!$! &'* +!

&& 4&9#!$);&$4+>!(( ;&'(! !&* & *+*42;&$4+ !0+*#!$9!

&*'

&($+*!5,(=$*( !*+( *+;&$4+! !(9*!

$ *55 +( 3 9 +* &* * &+$4 !$'*! & ((5 +$ &044*! *53 9+* &*'( ('42: &;&$4+9 *(&9 $'

6 + &>!(( ;& !(7! 9*!

$ 3

9+4$!

: &;&$4++*!5&!(! !$6 + >!((! 0+* 4?+ &!5&! !* ;&

+* &* , &((5 *

! +((0!&4 &((542 & ! '* +!

#!$&!('* 9*!

$ & *'!&!0+*;&

#!$(+4$!

: &;&$4+&6 + >!(( & '(! !9*( 9!

&*!5&

(*! * !

&'*'* 2 ;&(* *!(.+* *''* ! !5 &0! 0!(4( &!(+'&( & *

+*42: &;&$4+ !0+*#!$3 9&( '(! !&0 44( '*0 &*+3 9&( : &;&$4+&!$(&''*!

55 +( !(9*!

$ +* $ $!

!5 & (!$#!$9&!(''*!5! 3

9+* &* ! 42 : &;&$4+*$!(!0* '*!@2* *+*!5 & *&0* &((5 .!0!(.+* *;&(* *!(.+* +* &* ! +!

!(42

& &((5!5 & * & (*2 4 !$!!+(

0!A6

. &!( *

&4+'&( ;&(* *!(.+* +* &* ! & 4!*!5&

0 9&''* +(*: &;&$4+$! !0!(+!

&$!

!&! * 6$! ! : &;&$4+$''*

! '+ &! &+$4!$'*!3 $24 ! & 4!* !5&''*9!

4&( &'(! !;&(* *!(.+*

! * &'!!5!042 &B9*!

!5A6'* C!5*-*!

A6'* ;& (* *!( .+* +* &* &( & >!((

& 4'*0! * 9!

& &A0! &

!59!

&46$! ;&+ &(* *!(.+* +'&( & &((5 &>!(( 4+ !$! &+!

&*'

&((5 .!0!(.+* *

C!* 9''(9*'***42 &'(! !9&* &*42#!$ ;&(*C!* ''(( .+*

** ''* ! !5 &0! 0!(4( &!(+'&( &7+5$

'42 &(* *!(.+* 3&0&*(* +(* &'* !9!

& &!*4( ! 5 &*+5& &* * :* +(*

&+4$!

$+ ! *

9 !(2 #*

&.!0!(.+* **$!(2!''*9

!$'($ ! &*0+* * *&( !5!! ;& ! & (* +( * & '(! !

*' ! &2 9* ! ,9(5 & *

A0: &;&$4+9 !,9(5 & * ;&** & *$+ 4!5* :* +(* &+* &*+4$!

*!5 *

9+(&9 (( &$!(2$$4* 9* !$'('* !3 !+* &*+4$!

*!4 $!(2

($ 9!

&+ !$'(!5(( &$!(2$$4* * +(4' 3&0 !* &*5+$ *!42(* +(*

&4 +** (2+42 : & ;&$4++* & * 9!

&*9!(( 0!( !B (2 55(92* &0!(9*!

$ $!

!5 & (!$ +'! &'(! 42#!$;&$4+&(''*!

+* $ ;&'(! !& 44( 4(!& 2 &!5 &!( 4(!& &!* (!$! &'(! & *! *+( *54*! ! !!5 $+ ! ! (2 $!! * !0 0+ + &*!

! ! $+ ! ! (2 * ! ( '+*' ;&**$*(24 +$+ !9 ! &0(!!

2 .!0!(.+* * 4?+ !;&.!0!(.+* *!!( 9 &'* ! &*!5& (9!5 &**$ 9+(

! $*(24 +$+ !& 4 ! 6 +4$!!$42(* +(* !

! (( &$!(2$$4*& 4!$'('* !! +!

!(! &2* 9&! &!*+( ! *

+ & *&* ! &2(9 $24 ! : &;&$4+99* ,( = $*( ( B +* * 9! & *'

(

$+*!5,(=$*(3 9$ !! & !0!(+!

!( ( &;&$4+& '

&9*&!'#!$

&6 ,(=$*(;&$!(2

9&! & &4! & *9 9!

&*'

& !*(942: & ;&$4+;&** &*5+$ (* +(*

! (( &$!(2$$4*9* !$'('* !! &'*0!+ +!

& *!!0(! ! + !4( 5+(* ''( &0 4!(42 &+5& *9!95! &7+5$ '42

*!(.+* !*$42 &C!* ''(( .+* ;&+5& * 9!9&!(+!

&((5!5 &(6 + 42#!$ 9!

&*'

&($+*!5 ,( $*(( ;&'(! !&('*2* ?+ !(*(! ! & *!0+*#!$!4!5+'&( #!$&4&(9*,(=$*('+*+ *

(42#!$9+(4 * (*$&!&*(2 3

#!&$&!(+!

* !7+ ! * *!!5 &! 4* &* *$ ! **!5 ! '! &'(! !9!

&*'

&($+*!5,(= $*(9&! &9+47 $

* *

;&(*

*!(.+* * &+!

!(42#!&$;&''(!(42 ''(( 9!$!;&.!0!(.+* *

&4 +'&(#!$&4&( 49* ,(=$*( ( & '(! ! ! !

( '*

&! '! ;& 7+5$ '42 4(9* ** ;&''(! &+(!4(

4!$!

&4!(42#!$5! !!5 4(9! *!5 &>!(( 6 + 42: &;&$4+# & 4(9&0+ &>!((& 4'*0! * 9!

& &A0! &

!5 9!

&46$!.+(* & 44( !'+ &! ! &>!((!

(& 4'*0! * 9!

& &A0!

&*!$*!

! &5+(* ''(!(42#!$ 5+(* ''(

&4!(42 $&*$&*&( &((5 &!!5 4(99&!(+'&(!5 & *

C* &* !

&!''(!(!$! C* &** *40 ((5+(* ''( !(42!* '* !*!$!

"#$%#$&'($)*+,-.&$)'/,$01 $'./ "#$%#$&&$(/&%)23$1 $'./