High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3655/2017dismissed

Ram Parshad v. Balwan And ANR

2026-02-18Ms. Justice Harpreet Kaur Jeewan4 pages

!"#$!%&'&"( !"#$!%&'&"( !"#$!%&'&"( !"#$!%&'&"())))*++ *++ *++ *++ ,-'.$ +++//!00( ' 1!-'2'

1!-'2'

1!-'2' 03(($(" .!- +++!'/"($!( '

) 45 6+ 6 7 8

) 45 6+ 6 7 8 -!'!( ) -!'!( ) -!'!( ) -!'!( )

-+.& !.-9$:"% !9 #"- -+6.; &72'.&;9$:"% !9 #"- .!//!00( +

-++ + 2/ 9$:"% !9 #"--!'/"($!( "+('2-(%! ",/(<+ 7 89+ 7 89+ 7 89+ 7 89+ -0

-0

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

+ &' .!%'!"# .!%0&,( . '-!'20 "# .!&(B2-&!' '2##!-!$>< .!>2##0"&( .!'&$%%&$!( 9 .!>2##0"$&!$9''2%.9 "+$ !$++?92($!-6!% &"('@ ?@"# .!($&( !(0 "$!9 * 3' -!=&' !-!$ =&(' -!'/"($!( "+ "0&%! 6 &"(96&3(&+.!%0&,( '"2=. %",/!(' &"(-!=-$&(= .!$! . "# .!>2##0"&( .!," "-%%&$!( + + .! $-&:!-%2,"3(!-9 -!'/"($!( "+ $!(&!$ .! %%&$!( +.!('2-(%! ",/(<%"( !' !$ .!/! & &"(+ +?

0 &, !0<9 .! -&>2(0 $&',&''!$ .! %0&, /! & &"( >< /''&(= .!&,/2=(!$"-$!-><-!%"-$&(= .!#"00"3&(=-!'"(') ' /!- .! !' &,"(< "# -+ !:!($!- 72,- ""(&9

":!-(,!( 1! !-&(-<"'/& 09 2-!-989 .!>2##0".$ ("!C !-(0,-;'"#&(B2-<9($.!.'#2- .!-$!/"'!$ . .! !C% %2'! "# $! . %( >! $! !-,&(!$ # !- .! /"' ,"- !, !C,&( &"(D > .!%0&,( .':=2!0<00!=!$ . .&'>2##0"$&!$# !- $<'9>2 .!-!&'("%-!$&>0!!:&$!(%!"(-!%"-$' "3.! .!- .!>2##0".'% 200<$&!$"-(" D % .!%0&,( #&0!$ "0!$!:&$!(%! . .!>2##0">!0"(=!$ " .&,D($ $ .!%0&,( .$#&0!$ "0!$!:&$!(%! . .!>2##0".$,! 3& . ( %%&$!( ($ $&!$ "( %%"2( "# .! &(B2-&!' '2##!-!$ $2-&(= .!%%&$!( + + 5!-(!$ %"2('!0 #"- .! //!00( %"( !($' . !:!( ( 3'-!=&' !-!$-!=-$&(= .!%%&$!( &(E2!' &"(+.!>2##0"3' -! !$><-+!:!($!-72,-""(&89($.&'"-0!:&$!(%!&' "(-!%"-$ . .!>2##0"$&!$$2! " .!%%&$!( &(B2-&!'9''2%.9 .!

//!00( .$/-":!$ . .!$! ."# .!>2##0"3'"(%%"2( "# -'.($(!=0&=!( $-&:&(="#-!'/"($!( "++ ?+ !- %"( -9 0!-(!$ %"2('!0 -!/-!'!( &(= .! ('2-(%!

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

-&(-<$"% "- 0'"&($&% !' . .!>2##0"3'!C,&(!$>2 ("!C !-(0,-;'"# &(B2-<3!-!">'!-:!$9($ .!(&,03'&(-!%2,>!( /"'& &"(+ &' #2- .!-,!( &"(!$ . .!(&,0(!!$!$&( !-(0!C,&( &"(0'"($ #"- 0 -'"2($($F-<9 .!(&,03'-!#!--!$ ".&=.!-%!( -!+ .!//!00( .$#&0!$ "/-":! .!#2- .!-!C,&( &"(-!/"- "# .! (&,0+"F-<"- 0 -'"2($!C,&( &"(-!/"- "# .!(&,0' '2==!' $:&$!&(& &0!C,&( &"(-!/"- C+ .'>!!(/-":!$"( -!

+ .!-!&'("$"%2,!( -</-""#-!=-$&(= .!$ !"#$! . "# .!(&,0+.! !' &,"(<"#89 .." 2,9&'0'", !-&0+ ' /!- .&' ##&$:& 9 8A !C,&( &"(&(%.&!# 9 .! &' '"( "# .! //!00( 9($.!.'' !$ . .!3& (!''$-!'/"($!( "+.& &(= .!>2##0"><-'.($(!=0&=!( $-&:&(="# .!"0!-":!.&%0!+(.&' %-"''!C,&( &"(9.!' !$ . .!-!%.!$ .!/0" >!#"-! .!%%&$!( ($ !C%!/ .&,9 (">"$< !0'! 3' /-!'( .!-! .! &,! "# .! %%&$!( +!.'0'"' !$ . .&'' !,!( 3'(" -!%"-$!$>< .! "0&%!+ -"''!C,&( &"("# .!'&$3& (!''&($&% !' . .!&' .! '"0!!<!3& (!''"# .!%%&$!( 9>2 .!.'%"(#&-,!$ . .!&'(" -!=&' !-!$ .&'&(' (%!+ *+ 7!!/&(= &( :&!3 .! " 0& < "# .! #"-!'&$ %&-%2,' (%!'9 (" $!#&(& !

%"(%02'&"( %( >! $-3( . .! >2##0" >!0"(=&(= " .! //!00( .$ $&!$ "( %%"2( "# .! -'. ($ (!=0&=!( $-&:&(="# .!"0!-":!.&%0!($''2%.9$&',&''0"# .! %0&,/! & &"(>< .!-&>2(0&'>'!$"( .!!:&$!(%!"(-!%"-$($ -!E2&-!'("&( !-#!-!(%!+ @+ ''!E2!0"# .!>":!$&'%2''&"(9(",!-& '-!#"2($&( .!//!0($ .!',!&'%%"-$&(=0<9$&',&''!$+ + !($&(= ,&'%!00(!"

9 &# (<9 '.00 0'" ' ($$&'/"'!$"#+ *++ *++ *++ *++ G 7 8H G 7 8H G 7 8H G 7 8H 20'! .&

8.! .!-'/!;&(=A-!'"(!$) !' " 8.! .!-!/"- >0!) !'