High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2652/2012dismissed

Bir Singh v. Haryana State And Others

2015-07-15Mrs. Justice Raj Rahul Garg10 pages

!"#"$%&%'( )

*+

! " #

$ %$!& '! ((((

, - .

)//0

#**+ ,#

-

"!

.

#**+ ,#

" #

##" "

/ # *0 *1 12*2 .

23 24 12**!. 5# ## 6 11 2+ 1220 *7 24 1220 5 / "

5 6 / " 17 24 122+

!5

##/ "

*44* 5 # #

#880 9

! : 1,

# "

!

-5$ " "

!

#

.

$

#5

5 !.5

##. !-5*; *2 1227 ! . &" "

##"

5 #

1* *2 1227 "" !5 . "

&&: 1; 1* *2 1227 5 6 !

##

5"$ *2 27 1220 # #8801212 <.5

6.

## 5 # .

# "

<.# 5 #

6

##. 6 "

: 41= < *0 2* 1228/ "

. 5.# *+ 2* 1228 #

##

##/ <. > "

27 *1 1228 .

## 6 / ) . "

& <. > "

/

6.

##*0 23 1220 "

: *8; ) . 5

##

1* 23 12205

##/ 6 5 6 !

"

5 : 170 1; 23 1220 100 28 27 1220!.

##/

6 ) .

5

##

#

##/

6*2 27 1220 #

. #.

" .

#

#"*2 27 1220 )

#. .

" 5 <6##"

# "

.

##=

6 *1 28 1220.".

#

# "

!

-5 : 1*3 28 1220 <. *3 *7 #!1220 ) <6##"

.

# " :

.&

.

# *8 *0 !1220 )

## 5

#.

# 14 28 1220 5 6 ! "

: 3*7 27 20 1220. /

6 .

! . # 5 .# #

## # "

2; 20 1220. .".

##/

6 "

: 317 *0 20 1220. .". 55 5 6 !"

11 20 1220 ." #"

.

## .". 5.# :"

14 20 1220.

## )

##5 . .

/

6!.

! / !"

5 : 371 2+ 2+ 1220.

## . > 5

##/

6 )! 6##"

5

."

##.

#

." "

: 078,) 1+ 2+ 1220 ." # 6 11 2+ 1220. #

## .". 5 .# #

## " #

. #

##

"

: +1+=) 14 2; 122;. #

6 =

## ." .

5

##5 .

.## .

#5

28 24 1220 # "

#""" "

.

#

#

##! . # *7 24 1220

## ", > "

6 /

6 # / *2 27 1220 )

" "

#" #

5

##.

" .

# .5 5 "

" "

#" "

5

##

"

" 5 " ##"

! " .

"

6 - ""

".

" "

#" "

5

##.

> 5 6

> " #

##

#

*0 1# /5 "

?> 1! . . #

5 #

### #88012 12 "

. #" 5 # . ""

#

## "

5 ## "

## 5 5

#

##. .# / #

@5

" #

) .

## ##

#

/ # # " #

!"#$"

"

*44*

1228#

# *8 . # .

*0 1!

# 5

$ " 5 #

# # A # & B C

"5

#"# " <" !

5 #

,&# ."" #.""#11*22

*0 1B*C!

5 # . "# ""

>

*0 15"

BC BC <

>

!5 # . "# "" .

!" ## "#" "" .

5 "5

"

##

"

!5 ."". " ""##"

. "5

# # "

5 # . "# ""

>

9

# .

$ " .".

# " #

# #*1 ! . ". "

" 6 # $

.

< / # ! 5

/ " #

!"%& < " 5 # @5

,5

5 # 1*"" < #

#

. 5 5 5

%

. 5

#"! "

# *3 23 *441 # #

#5 . 5

. ) 6 5 # @5

. . "

. ! "" #

5

5 5

D) "# @5

. > .# " #

'()*

+, - .!"%&!"

#5 5

. . "

# . "

#

'

/ 01- $ 2.&$ .

#5 5

. "

# ""

. " ) @5

. " #' @" B C

#

5 **!

@5

5 ,

!!" #$%

&$

' ('

( ) ( '( *'

' ' ' + ( ) '('' (

,"# % ( - !.$ / 00 + ' ' ) 1

23 ) ''

(

( '(

(

(

( '

( '( 4 ( ' ( 4 4 ( ( * ( ) '

' '

(

' ' (

4 2 5 ' 4

6 ( '

,"# % ( )

' ) ''

( ( '(

' ( ' (

(

( ' ( '( 4 (

' ( 4 4 ( ( '

( ' ' ( 4 '

*

((

44 4

( + ( ' 4

( '( )(

)

'

' ' '

*

)

' ( '7

( 4 '

( ' ' ( 4

( '

'(4 ( 44 4

4 ( + ) (

44 ( ( ( 4 ' (( '

)

* '(4 '8 . $ 5 " @" B C5

#

.

" # 34 ',

'()*-!&"%& <"

, $.#" 6""#5

#34# .

!

" 5

#81+## "" )

. # # "" 6

.

5 #81+.##" 5 5

#

#5 5

. # # < **!*1 *3! @5

5 , 5 (

'

0 (

- / 9 :

!,!

; "<$#

%

('

'7

(

4 ' '

)

'

( '

4 ' '=

' 7 ( ( ) 4 '

'

)

' (=

' ) '

'

4

' ) '

44

( ( ( '

'

( '

'

'

'7

( '

( ' +

' '( '

( '

((4 '

4

'7

( ''

' '

' (

)

''

'

' ) ' ' "

' )

'(

-

/ > 0'

' "??.#.%

$,$ )

'

4

'

+

'(

) '

'4

' 4 '

( ( ( '

( '7

( '

'

'

'7

( '

( (

'

( ( '

4 '

( '(

'7

( . +

(

)(

'

44 0 '(

' (

'

' 4 '

$

44 '

4'

' ('

) 4 )

&"< '

'

(( ( 4 '

)1

. !,&

?&? !!, &$ '

"&?< !<.

"@?< !<.

$ '

?$ ? !<<

"? !<@ "? '

.? !<@

?!?& !<@ @ '

"& ? !<!

. ? !<!

, '

??" !@

$?@ !@ @& '

. ? !@$

"" !@$ $? '

8 < #"# " !

. # 5

5 #880

"

)

##. ." "

" 6 # 6

. .". 5.# # ##

# 28 24 1220! . # *7 24 1220 "

5

#880! #

/ # $B C#

"5

"

5 # 880 # . "5

"

## "

*0 1 :5 6 # .

#/" &

)