← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/23/2015dismissed

Gurinder Singh & ORS v. Union Of India & ORS

2015-02-168 pages

       

  

  

      !"#

$ %&' '  ( )  * '    !"

    #$ %   "

     

'+ ',#- #  '..,, ////  

     &'

' 0 '.., #,! 1 !,&'..,   .., .  

 2'  ..,      &  '  3 &0    . !',%&,4 &'5.  . !'..,,0&'0  6,!#'''..,, 5'  & , ,,  ' ' ,& 00  '7  ,8&'5!  # (,,&% ',# 2',$ .  2' ,8&'5! ' ! 

 *   7         . .           .9.&  .    % ',  4       , 8&'5!    ..,,    '      '  .     #'-,  ', '..,,  '  ' 5,, 0'*'' ,!$  5 :$   3  -  5  &;    '  :'  %' ;    ' $  5  5 ,   0    '  .  #  ' # 0',& ,& '. .,,&5 ,  ' 2' & 0 0'. ., ', ,!  0 ' !-,,&# '. . ,' ,  &- 

  2'..,, &' 0  '<&' * 0  ' 5'. . ,  .'% ', 4    ,8&'5!  57 .   #  5''5 -!', , ''.  ' . . ,          .    % ', 4    '  ,8&'5!*5, 0'.*<% =

# .      . -  5'    ' ,#  ' .,   !9 ,55' 0 0' . . #5''. .  .#'5  '  >. 0'#5  .  5' ', 5.'? 0  . *< % = #5'''& ,5'& . -& .5!-0',  0' '    ,,,'. . 

 *  '        '      '  %  , @>  =A''0  ,0'#'?  ,@> 

A# &'' . '  ,& 0%'8$ .  6 7' 5 . 6#5'' +5! 0. #'. .  .2'..,,'-'-,!, . '.,  '' .'. . % ',4  5'  !3   ? 0 " B>' -0 @>   A5 0 !'..,,' &' ,,,& .  '  .      .  '  . . ,         .  C'    .   5  -#  '  ..,, .. ''  !,&C "

  #5''5 .   !' -  @> 

A  &  2'  $,  &9 3   #   3 *0.,0 )@*)A4,' .       .    .7&      '  . 9    5'.  5 0 ' 1 *  0., 5'  '  . ! '   #   , = @>  A' .

!.  #5''&-#'&',&' !' ..,,'. 9,&, #'- ,5'

5',3&'0 2' &''5. #'..,,   ,,!',,&' '5. 5 0 !',%&,4 &- 

' ,& ' '  ' 0. &     ,,!3   '

& . -  0 = *'   ' , '..,,' '  ,  %&,  4 &  '     7        ' & #  5''  5    !  '  ..,,    '  0   '&    '  &'  ..-    '     ..  ' .,&'  0!-  &'   !'0 8  '    '      '  & #  5''  '-    ',. ' 5''' &   7  ! ' ..,,   ' 5  .   '-    2'00.' ' , '..,, '%,@>  =A ''#5''' . &. .     % ',4  #5    '  #  5''  5  ?      !  '  , ,  0    ,0-',@> 

A 2' '  .,  '-  ,    .    -   '     

 ,,,0    '  & ,#    ,   5  !  '  *  <   &@*<A',7,'  0'& '-,  ' , '..,,   '    ' . . 0'' &  '09,& ,& ' .

,    ,&       $  5  %'    '  %'

 0& ' .  C  '-     '   0   0  !  '  , '..,,'-& ' &''  '   ,,'.,#5'''-  !'..,,# 5 ,!  !.  '0. & 

= @>  A . , '05 , ,  0   ' ,,'& # 5'''-  . - ',-&'    ' .# 5' !   *' .  ' '' , 8&'5! ' !-, .&'  ,8&'5! 

 0'7  0 ,-&5!  6 ,D.26 2' . 5 7'  ,E&&, ! 0'B>.  ,# 5' !. &2 5#'5,2 5#$ . !# 6,2 5+' &,2 5,  * #' . -  (' ,).# ,! - 03 3  , ,    2'  . .     '  '  0  &  .  ' &'  .', ,&&5''5 , 07' -,,0 -0C',> &'. 3 '#5 '. ,  '

7  ! .    ,!0 ,7 ' ,).#(' ,).#4  0. -0 D  ',  #5''5#5% ',4   2'. . ,5'& ' .5.  ' !

'0  ,0@ 7% 'A '05 ' 20  'B>.#5' 5'  ,2'0 5 >0 ,&' !' B>. '.. .  . . #    .  '  ? 0     .. -,    '   , 8&'5! ' #5''   5&..,    ,!  '   ,  ).          #  '    

( . -    -    '      ,  ).   ,&'0 -0 , , % ',2 5  2'       '  ..,,  5'  &    ' .  ,! 0'&'-,  ',',  , 5' !&'..  0.,. ,!.-   5''      .   '!. ',  . 0.     0. 8 5-#5''    ' ,). , &5'-  '#  ,!'..,,5,, 

 5 ,,'.

,,&5' 5,,'- ' 0 -0 ' ,8&'5! *'

,''$ 5$  3- 5 &' '%' ',,  0 ' ,).' .5 ,,'0 -0 '.,&09$ 5 %& ' ,8&'5!  2'%,@>  =A# 5'''-!, ' ., !' , '..,,#'  

 ' 5&' ,  & ' , .  '( . ''-  '&',&''0. & 5'''- .,!, 5' , @-A

, @A @AD.?   .  !  5'' .,#5''5,  , &5''0. & # 5''' ,' 5 *'  ' .,#' 0 !'  , '..,,  ..,,!5'' .,#5''' .,  >  =#   .' .  

)   *0!#' 5-# .  ''. . ,  ' % ',2 50 '#. ' ,).# 5'' &. . #5 ,, >-,,&#0 5'' '- 0 '0. & &',    .#' .  '',   5 . 3  5'5?   !'0  ,0 5''..,,5 6*' ' '>&$ . !',,  !.',! . -  $%. '&. 5'' ,. . ,5 0 !'0  ,0+0

==5'3 <  0%'8& .  6  72' . % ',2 5  ' $%. '    C'  &    - ,&  '  *  <    & & ,#' ''.0,! 07&' . 3'&'5!  ''.-' , 2'.0 -  !'.  ,  0'-& !*' .  ' '      %   % !  %' ,#     ,  8,'  #  .-& , % !# D#<,5!%  , '  ,8&'5!% ',2 5$  5#. , . 0.#*$&! &'' ' ,8&'5! ' 5. 0' & 0  ' . ' ' ,8&'5!5'? 0 -0 ', ,. , '% ',2 5 0  ' ,8&'5! ' ' # ' &'!&'#7.,2'  3-#

* , 5 !'*<  &#  '!  '  .#''   ,,, " *-5 '5,, .7&  = @>   A#5'''   -#5'

5''5&0#5  !0'. ..,#' #0'0   #$       

  +,-./-0 (%

.3