Janki & ORS v. Saravmittar And Others
! " #
!"! #$%$&'
%()*$$+,(-#.*/0('$ #'1$(++$22(&'%
#-&)'()&.*/0('$ ##$%+&*$&'3 $%%!&&'()* + 1$ (4(#* *('$* 5 5 +(%%$* 67 '1$ '# 00)*$&'
2()8%#)6-&(2.!)#%(9 #%1#'. '1$#)6-&(2 :1(%6$$&(%%()2$*67'1$ 2$;(2#$+#$%$&'(')/$% (1$&*$#%$$<)&;$&1(&0$8$&' 08+$&%(')& (4(#*$*-&*$#!$0')&== '1$ '#"$1)02$%0'.>
9 #%1#'. '1$ 0' : 1$#$%+&*$&'%)&'1$(++$(2(#$'1$*#)/$# '#(0'#6$(#)&;
#$;)%'#(')&??@= 3=91$#$)&( '$#*$%0#)6$*(% '1$
$&*)&;/$1)02$ :.
4&$# (&* '1$ )&%-#$# 9)$ A &%-#(&0$ 8+(&7 )8)'$*: '1$
$&*)&;/$1)02$ 1$ (0'%&$0$%%(#7 #(*B-*)0(')& '1$+#$%$&'(++$(2(#$ '1('& ?. (1$&*$#(2&;4)'1(B-4(%;)&;'/)22(;$(&)& 8'#0702$6$(#)&;#$;)%'#(')&@ =@@>>?
C1$&'1$7#$(01$*)&
#&' 1(#('(%;$&07('(&)(*.'1$
$&*)&;/$1)02$%'#-0<'1$ 8'#0702$%(#$%-2' '1$)8+(0'. (1$&*$#%-
$#$*%$#)-%)&B-#)$%.1$ *)$**-#)&;'#$('8$&'?35*('$*5 ?4(%#$;)%'$$*('2)0$ !'(')&(&)(
&'1$02()8+$')')&.)'4(%+2$(*$*'1(''1$*$0$(%$*4(% 4#<)&;(%2(6-#$#(&*4(%$(#&)&; . D@+$#8&'1*1(#0(#* '1$ *$0$(%$*4(%+#*-0$*6$ #$'1$#)6-&(2.41$#$)&'1$*('$ 6)#'14(% 8$&')&$*(%>53$4(%?
7$(#%2*(''1$')8$ (00)*$&'1$ 02()8(&'% ()2$*'+#/$'1$$(#&)&; '1$*$0$(%$*6-''1$4)*4)&1$# 0#%%@$E(8)&(')&(*8)''$*'1(''1$7(#$7$2240(#*12*$#%(&*%1$1(* (++2)$*6$ #$!-6)/)%)&(2 (;)%'#('$.22$&(6(* # . . D@& (00-&' *$('1 1$#1-%6(&*1$#)6-&(2(%%$%%$*'1$8&'127$(#&)&; (% ?. D@.3 F -'-#$+#%+$0'%4$#$(4(#*$*.D?'1 *$*-0')& #%$2 @ $E+$&%$%4(%8(*$(%'1$*$0$(%$*4(%%-#/)/$*67 )/$*$+$&*$&'%(&* 8-2')+2)$# ?4(%(++2)$*1$#)6-&(2(4(#*$*(%-8 .
.
D@ (2&; 4)'1 )&'$#$%' G >F +$# (&&-8 1$ (8-&' (4(#*$* )&02-*$* . . D@ #2%% 0&%#')-8.. . D@ #2%% 2/$(&*(
$0')& (&*
. D@ # -&$#(2$E+$&%$% 1$ #)6-&(2 0&%)*$#)&; '1$ (0'% (&* (++#$0)(')&; '1$ $/)*$&0$ (**-0$* 1$2* '1(' '1$ (00)*$&' 4(% 0(-%$* *-$ ' #(%1 (&* &$;2);$&'*#)/)&; '1$
$&*)&;/$1)02$1$)&%-#$#4(%1$2*2)(62$' +(708+$&%(')& $(#*2$(#&$*0-&%$2 #'1$+(#')$%(&*+$#-%$*'1$#$2$/(&'
*0-8$&'%+#*-0$*67'1$8 $(#&$* 0-&%$2 # '1$ (++$22(&'% (#;-$% '1(' '1$ )&08$ (%%$%%$*67'1$#)6-&(2)%&'1$24$#%)*$ $(#&$*0-&%$2 #'1$)&%-#$#0&'$&*%'1(''1$02()8(&'%
()2$*'+#/$'1$8&'127$(#&)&; '1$*$0$(%$*(&*C@ 4)*4 '1$ *$0$(%$*1(*(*8)''$*'1(''1$74$#$7$2240(#*12*$#%$*$ $&*%'1$ )&08$ (%%$%%$* 67 '1$ #)6-&(2 $ -#'1$# %-68)'% '1(' 3 F -'-#$
3 +#%+$0'%1(/$4#&;276$$&(4(#*$*)&%'$(*
F(&*'1$(8-&'
(4(#*$*-&*$#'1$0&/$&')&(21$(*%(#$&'1$1);1$#%)*$ 1$0&'$&')&#()%$*672$(#&$*0-&%$2 #'1$(++$22(&'%)% &'4$22 -&*$*1$#$)%(&(*8)%%)& '1$4)*4'1(''1$74$#$7$224 0(#*12*$#%%+$#'1$+2)07 '1$!'('$ (#7(&(.7$2240(#*%(#$ )%%-$*''1$ (8)2)$%41%$(&&-(2)&08$4(%-+'
. D@(''1$ #$2$/(&'')8$ 1$#)6-&(2(%%$%%$*'1$8&'127$(#&)&; '1$*$0$(%$* 0&%)*$#)&;'1$$&')#$ (0'%)&'' 1$#$)%(&'1$#(%+$0' '1$8(''$#1$*$0$(%$4(%)&'1$ (;$;#-+ ? ' 7$(#%(&* $22)&'1$0('$;#7 %$2 @$8+27$*# 1(/)&; )E$*4(;$%(/)&;*-$#$;(#*''1$*$0)%)&% '1$!-+#$8$ -#')& ', -"
./" 0 .! )'# 1!- 1(&*&"#2 ', -"
.
/) * +0/# )
F -'-#$+#%+$0'%(#$'6$(4(#*$*%( #$%-2'. F $E'#( -'-#$ +#%+$0'% 1(/$ (2#$(*7 6$$& (4(#*$* 67 '1$ #)6-&(2. . D@$(01 #2%% 0&%#')-8(&*2/$(&*(
$0')&(&*
. D@ # -&$#(2$E+$&%$%1(/$6$$&(4(#*$*67'1$#)6-&(2%+$# '1$*$0)%)& '1$!-+#$8$-#')& 0 .! 3 *,
+.'1$ 02()8(&'%(#$$&')'2$*'5 . D@-&*$#'1$0&/$&')&(21$(*%1$#$%-2' )% '1(' .
. D@ 8#$ 1(% 6$$& (4(#*$* 67 '1$ #)6-&(2 -&*$# '1$ 0&/$&')&(21$(*%1$!-+#$8$-#')&4) ', - / !5 .)'# 1!-6 1(%1$2*'1(' ) '1$(8-&'
(4(#*$*-&*$#&$1$(*08+$&%('$% #(2$%%$#(8-&'(4(#*$*-&*$#'1$ '1$#1$(*.'1$#$)%&%0+$ #)&'$# $#$&0$1$#$2$/(&'+(#( '1$%()* B-*;8$&')%#$+#*-0$*6$24
? H C1$& 4$ )&* '1(' -&*$# &$ 1$(*. #$(%&(62$ (8-&' 1(% 6$$& (4(#*$* (&* -&*$# (&'1$# 1$(*. &'1)&;1(%6$$&(4(#*$*'1-;1)'%1-2*1(/$6$$& (4(#*$*(&*(''1$%(8$')8$.4$&')0$'1('$/$&'-(2
);-#$ '1$ (4(#* 08+$&%(')& +(7(62$ ' '1$ 02()8(&'%(++$(#%'6$B-%'(&*#$(%&(62$'1$&)&%-01 $/$&'-(2)'7.4$*&'0&%)*$#)'+#+$#')&'$# $#$)& %-01(4(#*)&-#(++$22('$B-#)%*)0')&-&*$##')02$3= '1$&%')'-')&&'1$#4#*%.) 67(++27)&;'1$ '$%'% (&* ;-)*$2)&$%. 4$ )&* '1(' /$#(22 (4(#*
08+$&%(')&)%B-%'(&* ()#.'1$&.)&-#/)$4.%-01 (4(#**$%$#/$%'6$-+1$2*)&02()8(&'% (/-#C$
)&*)''6$%)&'1$ (0'% '1)%0(%$1(/)&;'(<$&&'$ (22#$2$/(&' (0'%(&*0)#0-8%'(&0$% '1$0(%$I 1$#$)%&%0+$ #$&1(&0$8$&'1$(++$(2)%*)%8)%%$* *$%%!&&'(+ 7(% ? > 8< C1$'1$#%+$(<)&;D#$(%&$*
$%D C1$'1$##$+#'(62$
$%D