← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/253/2015disposed of

Babita v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2018-07-09Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain,Mr. Justice Arun Monga9 pages





       

 !

" ##$% &'(() * !+,-./0# &1 '& 22(--&!'

3(4*,* 5'&'(&4.&!& '6(4*  (*2!7(!'*



  !"# $%&'( #

$#& "( )   !"# $%&'( # ('

*  +++

4(*(!'+

4 &89'&456(4&!079)&'(0 4'6(&22(--&!'

4!:,4 ''&-077-&4.&!&0 44(*2!7(!'*'

43 :4&85 !;6079)&'(0 44(*2!7(!'% <<<<<

('

* ,$  %##= 

4  '6(  4(&*!*  8(!' !(7  !  '6(  &22- )&' !0  >6 )6  * *,224'(71.&!& 7&9 '07(-&.%7&.* ! - !;'6(&22(&- *)!7!(7  *'&!7*7 *2*(7   22(--&!' 82,;!*'6(47(47&'(7%2&**(71.'6( -(&4!(75 !;-(,7;('6 *,4'0>6(4(1. 9 -"4 ' (' ' !##$ %  24((44(7  1.  4(*2!7(!'  %  &;& !*'  '6(  47(4  7&'(7  /%

!!(?,4( =4(!7(4(71.'6( !&!) &-88 ** !(4*('' !;=&* 7(6 *



&22 !'8(!'&*&81&47&406&*1((!&-->(7 6(2*'&81&47&4(--9&)&!' !3 --&;(((!'0 *'4 )'

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

/ =>&*24((44(71(4('6( !&!) &-88 ** !(41. !9: !;

'6(249 * !*5()' !A'6( ,!B&1&!7 (9(!,()'0##$6(

!&!) &-88 ** !(40!'6(1&* *'6(8&'(4 &-!4()470,!7'6&' 4(*2!7(!'%>&*7(&,-'(4(-()'4 ) '.1 --  0$%C=&!70'6 * 1( !;!('6(7 *D,&-  )&' !*06(),-7!'6&9(1((!&22 !'(7&* &81&47&40  6(!)(0  *('=&* 7(  '6(  47(4*    '6(  --()'4  &!7  '6( 88 ** !(4*!' )(7&19(0'6(&4(8(!' !(747(4>&*&**& -(71. 4(*2!7(!'%1( !;>4 '2(' ' !(46(>4 '2(' ' !0&* !7 )&'(7&19(0 6&*1((!&-->(7&!706(!)(0'6(24(*(!'(''(4* &'(!'22(&-

4  &8  9'&4  56(4&!0  -(&4!(7  ),!*(-  4(24(*(!' !;  '6( &22(--&!'0  !  *,224'    '6(  ;4,!7*    &22(&-0  4& *(7  '6(  --> !; *,18 ** !*+= & ,*1&!7'6(&22(--&!' 6&7*(49(7 !5 0>6(4(&* 6(4)=14'6(4 ('6 *&-**(49 !; !5 &!7*6( *'6(



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

 -   &. /0  12  '0  3.  4.

55.. ,

6(,2 7-, 8

 .9.

::,4(- (7,2!1.'6(-(&4!(75 !;-((!)60)&!!'1( '4(&'(7'1(&B,7;8(!' !4(8&* '>&*&B,7;8(!'1&*(7 ,2!'6(8(4 '*&!77(=8(4 '*'6()&!7 7&'(*040 !&! &22(&-24((44(71(4('6(88 ** !(4&;& !*''6(47(4 '6( --()'40 '6( 8&''(4 >&* 4(8 ''(7  ' '6(--()'4 4 '&: !;'6(7() * !&4(*6 (9 * !>&* -(71,''6(*&8(>&* 7 *8 **(7> '6,'*('' !;=&* 7('6(88 ** !(4F*47(4' * !  '6*(  ) 4),8*'&!)(*0  '6(   9 * !  (!)6  6(-7  '6&'  '6(

;

4()88(!7&' !'6(--()'4)&!!'1(*,1*' ','(71.&! 2 ! !'6( !&!) &-88 ** !(41.(9&-,&' !;'6(8(4 '*   '6(  )&!7 7&'(*  &!70  '6,*0  ,4;(7  4  *('' !;=&* 7(  '6( 82,;!(747(4

(4)!'4&0 43 :4&85 !;60-(&4!(7),!*(-4(24(*(!' !; 4(*2!7(!'  %  *,18 ''(7  '6&'  *(9(!  )&!7 7&'(*  6&7  *,18 ''(7  '6( 4 &22- )&' !*4'6(2*'&81&47&4 !()&!7 7&'(0!&8(-.056 *62&-6&7 > '674&>!6 *&22- )&' !?=2&4'(24)((7 !;*>(4( ! ' &'(7&;& !*',4 )&!7 7&'(* !-.'>)&!7 7&'(*0 (0&22(--&!'&!74(*2!7(!'%>(4( -('4)!* 7(4&' !6(--()'40&'(4(9&-,&' !;'6(8(4 '*'6( )&!7 7&'(*&!7)!* 7(4 !;'6(4()88(!7&' !*'6(4(9(!,( )(4* 4 ;6'-.  &22 !'(7  4(*2!7(!'  %  &8(*6  @,8&4  &*  &81&47&4  !

/$ (*2!7(!'% *'62&**&!7%.(&4*-7(8' 9&'(7 ,42(4*!*4&8 -.2-&!! !;&!7>&*!'&7(&,-'(4(-()'4 ) '.1 --* &*6(6&71((!2&. !;(-()'4 ) '.1 --*4(;,-&4-.6((-()'4 ) '.7(2&4'8(!' 6&7 **,(7 !-&'(71 --> '6,'&!.1&* *&!74&' !&- '.6()-& 8'6( &22(--&!'>&*4 ;6'-.)!* 7(4(71.'6(4(9(!,( )(4*1. ;!4 !;'6( 4()88(!7&' !'6(** *'&!'--()'4*'4&7(' **(''-(7-&>'6&' '6()6 )('6(--()'4)&!!'1(*,1*' ','(71.'6(88 ** !(44 '6( !&!) &-88 ** !(4!'6(24(8 *('6&''6(4)&!7 7&'(>&*&1(''(4 )&!7 7&'(!*,224''6(&4(8(!' !(7*,18 ** !06(4((44(7''6( B,7;8(!'4(!7(4(71.'6( 9 * !(!)6'6 *,4' !&< =25 12'03.  4. 55.. 

6(,2 7-,     .9.

&!7,4;(7'6 *,4'47 *8 **&-'6(&22(&-1.,26-7 !; '6(47(4,!7(4)6&--(!;( "(6&9(6(&47'6(-(&4!(7),!*(-4'6(2&4' (*0&224& *(7'6(



2&2(4  1:  &!7  &4(    '6(  9 (>  '6&'  '6(4(  *  4)(  &!7  8(4 '  !  '6( *,18 ** !* 4 &89'&456(4&!0-(&4!(7),!*(-4'6(&22(--&!' &!7'6(4(&*! *!''6(!(1,'8&!. '>,-71(&2''4(247,)( ,-('6( ,-(*6(*&8( 4(&7*'6,*+= G-4 .>>. .

. 5 ==!&--  4*'&22 !'8(!'6(&78&!04(;&47*6&--1(6&7&8!;'6(4 8&''(4*'=

&6 *(?2(4 (!)(&**,1*' ','(C5&41&4&6&81&47&4E

1(?'(!' 242(4'. ! '6((*'&'(2**(**(7 1.'6( )&!7 7&'(E

)*(49 )(4(!7(4(7''6(*'&'(1.6 8*(-41.6 * &8 -.E

76 *2(4*!&- !-,(!)(0)6&4&)'(40&1 - '.&!74((78 48 !7(1'(7!(**E

('6(*'4(!;'6&!7 824'&!)('6()88,! '.48 >6 )6*(-()' !&6(&78&! *'1(8&7(E

*(49 )(4(!7(4(71.6 8*(-41.6 *&8 -. !'6( !&' !&-89(8(!'*'*(),4(4((78!7 & !)&*(&!(?=6(&78&!&!(*'&'(4*,1=7 9 * ! '6(4(  !  '6(  '(44 '4.  !>  )824 * !;  '6(  5'&'(   &4.&!&>66&74(* ;!(74>&*7 *8 **(7!&)),!'   6 *  2&4' ) 2&' !  !  &  !&' !&-  89(8(!'  1(4( 2&4' ' !  &!7  &!'6(4  6(&78&!  >&*  &22 !'(7  !  6 * 2-&)(0'6(24(*(!' !),81(!''6(2*'*6&--1(4(89(7 44(*2()' 9('6(249 * !* 4,-(A &!7 '6( (?= 6(&78&!>,-71(&22 !'(7 !6 *2-&)(0 6(6&*!' 4(!7(4(76 8*(-,! '4&22 !'8(!'4&!.'6( 4(&*!*  ; 9(!  !  4,-(  A  (?)(2'  824 *!8(!'  4  & 2- ' )&-(!)(1(4('6,;,*'0/%$!)&*(0'6( (?=6(&78&! *!-!;(4&- 9(0&2(4*!6 *&8 -. >6  >,-7  ,!7(4 '6( 4,-(*  6&9( 1((!  (!' '-(7  '  1( 6(&78&!    '6(  4(* ;!&' !  4  7 *8 **&-  6&7  !'

?

!'(49(!(70>,-71(&22 !'(7&*6(&78&!,'>6(! !*,)62(4*!(? *''6(4(>,-71(!!((7'4(89( '6((? *' !;-&81&47&4

;*(49 )(*4(!7(4(71.6 8*(-''6()88,! '.&!7 7(9(-28(!'24;4&88(*E

6(*6&--1(!'-(**'6&!.(&4*&;(&''6(' 8(   !9 ' !;  '6(  &22- )&' !  4  '6(  &22 !'8(!'   &81&47&4E 6(*6,-71(- '(4&'(024((4&1-.8 77-(2&**H

,-('6( ,-(*024(*)4 1(*'6(8&''(4*'1()!* 7(4(7 4'6(&22 !'8(!'&*&81&47&45,1=4,-( 7 ,-(249 7(*'6&''6( )&!7 7&'(8,*'1(4((48&-- !7(1'(7!(**78 ''(7-.04(*2!7(!'% >&*  &  )!*,8(4    &:*6 !  &4.&!&   B-  3 '4&!   ;&8  &!7  &  1 --

!!(?,4( =%)--()' 9(-.6&71((! **,(74& * !;&7(8&!7%0//C= &!7&;& !*''6(&4(8(!' !(77(8&!704(*2!7(!'%7(2* '(7&*,8 0C=!$&!7'6&''!'6(&22- )&' !*,18 ''(71.6 8 '  '6( 5,1   9 * !&-   )(4  7&'(7  $%  & 7&. 1(4(  >6(!  '6( ** *'&!'  --()'4  *' 4&7(0  9 7(  47(4  7&'(7  #%0  *,18 ''(7 4()88(!7&' ! !6 *&9,40''6(--()'4  --1(&4 !;/% **,(7!4(9(&-(7'6&''6( ,'*'&!7 !;  7,(*  &;& !*'  4(*2!7(!'  %  >&*  $0C=0  &!7  &'(4 &7B,*'8(!''6(&8,!'04(*2!7(!'%>&*- &1-('2&.A/C=6( &4(8(!' !(77(8&!7$0C=>&*&)),!''6(&44(&4*&!7&*>(-- &*&)',&-)!*,82' ! !)(7(7-.04(*2!7(!'%7(2* '(7&*,8A/C=! /0'6,*0!'6(7&'(4()88(!7&' !1.'6(** *'&!'--()'40 &!7&22 !'8(!'1.'6(--()'49 7(47(47&'(7/$04(*2!7(!' %>&* !&44(&4*C7(&,-'(4'6(&:*6 !&4.&!& B- 3 '4&! ;&8

8

6 *  &*2()'  6&7  !'  1((!  )!* 7(4(7  ( '6(4  1.  '6(  --()'4  4  '6( 88 ** !(40'6,*0 !,49 (>0'6( !&!) &-88 ** !(4&*2(4'6( 249 * !*'6( ,-(00(&4!(*'-.*('=&* 7('6(47(4*'6(--()'4 &!7'6(88 ** !(4 "()&!!'4(8& !1- 9 ,*'6(&)''6&''6 *,4'0>6 -( **, !;!' )(8' !!02&**(7'6(--> !;47(4+= G"(6&9(;!('64,;6'6(47(47&'(7/$2&**(71. '6(--()'4 4 8&=&) (0'6(47(4&22(&4*'1(2(49(4*(0 6(!)(  !'(4(4(!)(  1.  '6(  !&!) &-  88 ** !(4  >&* &22&4(!'-.B,*'  (7 ' )(8' !4 ' )(4(+)!7!&' !7(-&.

(&!>6 -(0  '6(  82,;!(7  B,7;8(!'  2&**(7  1.  '6( -(&4!(75 !;-(,7;(*6&--4(8& !*'&.(7 (*,-'&!'-.0'6(47(4 '6( !&!) &-88 ** !(4*6&--1(; 9(!(()'4'6> '6H 6(47(4'6( !&!) &-88 ** !(46&71((!47(4(7' 1(; 9(!(()'4'6> '6 4&-- !'(!'*&!72,42*(*0'6(&22(--&!'6&7 1((!2(448 !;'6(4-('6(&81&47&46(4( *!7 *2,'(''6(4&'  7() 7(!7 ),--(7,' !'6(B,7;8(!'*) '(7*,24& ! - &. /0!42 ,'6(;(!(* *'6(B,7;8(!'

6&*1((!!'6(24(8 *('6&''6( !&!) &-88 ** !(4> '6,'*('' !;= &* 7('6(47(4*'6(--()'4&!7'6(88 ** !(40&22 !'(7&79(4*( 2&4'.&*&81&47&4' *!'6&';4,!70'6(,4'6&7&!))&* !'7(&- > '6'6(2>(4*'6( !&!) &-88 ** !(4 4'6(*&:(14(9 '.0

&4&'6(B,7;8(!'4(&7*&*,!7(4+=     



                 

   

 

       



   





   

:

             

          

 !             " # $   %&'&%&&(                "            "

  



             )   *   

             

+ 





                  "    

          "      

   ,                            

        

  



      

 ,    

         



            

           "$   ,   





       



      



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

@

6(&4;,8(!' 43 :4&85 !;6 *!'&1-('),' )(&!7 * 6(4(1.  4(B()'(7  6(  -(&4!(7  5 !;-(  ,7;(  6&*  !'  !' )(7  '6( &4(8(!' !(7  &)'  >6 -(  *('' !;=&* 7(  '6(  47(4    '6(  !&!) &- 88 ** !(4&!70'6(4(4(047(40 !,49 (>0*,(4*48 --(;&- '.&!7 2(49(4* '.  6(  *&8(  *  6(4(1.  *('=&* 7(  6(  47(4    '6(  !&!) &- 88 ** !(4 *47(4(7'1(4(*'4(7 (''(4* &'(!'22(&- *4(*,-'&!'-.&-->(7 

$#& "( )    ('

*  $%)A#  $%)A# $2 B@,:

50 *00 C. /D > ED  *00  -  ED