High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/721/2011allowed

Mohinder Ram v. Union Of India & ORS.

2015-08-25Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan3 pages

!"#"$%&%'()*)

+%'#", - .."// '!

0",&1&

'%''#% '#!+",& "&.'#"'!&

( 23 4 3 ,"&"'!(5

,0%6 & +/7"'%,#8$ !"79%!+7

,,:1'41'#, 7#8$ !"7,!+" .."// '!

,+%8;+%,7#8$ !"7,,"&.'#"'!&!< =+"!+",!+"".,!",&/$ /'"9&. .",- ;>" //9"#!&"" !+":1#?-"'!@ >","",,"#!!+"".,!",,'! A =+"!+",!+":1#?-"'!&+1/#>",".,!"#%'!+"#%?"&!@ 55 55 3 7

3 -.1?'"# %' !+" .,"&"'! ,"?1/ , &"$'# .." / %& :1#?-"'! '# #"$,"" # !"# *<B7 . &&"# >; !+" /" ,'"# ##%!%' / %8%/ 1#?" "'%, %8%&%'7 9 '&+ +,7 8%#" 9+%$+ !",?, '!%'?-,"!+ '1,""$!%8"..,!1'%!%"&7!+""8%#"'$" !+"./ %'!%9 &$/&"#>;,#",&,'' .." , '$"!+"9%!'"&& !+"./ %'!% '#,''. ;-"'!$&!&&A 5 '#!+"&1%!

9 &#%&-%&&"#1'#", ,#",1/"A #" %8%/,$"#1,"7 B* 2/&%-.1?'"#%'!+".,"&"'!,"?1/ ,&"$'# .." /%&

55 !+":1#?-"'! '##"$,""# !"#AB7. &&"#>;!+"/" ,'"# ##%!%' /%&!,%$!1#?"7 ? ,79+",">;!+" .." / ? %'&! !+"& %#:1#?-"'! '##"$,""9 &#%&-%&&"# '#!+" ../%$ !%', .",-%&&%'!/" #"8%#"'$"9 & /&#%&-%&&"# + 8"+" ,#!+"/" ,'"#$1'&"/,!+". ,!%"& '#+ 8" /&$ ,"1//;?'"!+,1?+!+"%/" !$-"&1!,-!+":1#?-"'!!+"/9", 1,!!+ !

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

'# '!+",&1-&7 5 &$&!&7'9%-.&"#>;!+%&

1,!7!>"#".&%!"#%'!+"%&!,%$!3"? /%#1'#7 9 '&+ +, +" .." /%& $$,#%'?/; //9"#

)*) &:6&