High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/275/2015dismissed

M/S Mind Tree Eduvation Private Ltd v. Mindtree Ltd And ORS

2019-01-23Mr. Justice Ajay Kumar Mittal,Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul11 pages

!"#"$%&%'()*

+& %'#,""#-. !%' ,%. !"%/%!"# 0011"22 '! 3&

%'#!,""%/%!"# '#!4",& 0 "&1'#"'!& ( 5

6 6

'8 ,%"4,-7 -29

! "# # " # $ % &"

)* + # , (- ./# , 0' 1 '" & 2

# + " 3-456" 78 ' ' 0' 6 7 # -(((9&

: # # # 0' + # * 0'

; ' 0 *

& ' % '0 <

# # # )

' & '

' ((4 ! 0#

!* * " "

(= ((3

6 ># %7 * ; # ; &

' &?! ! ; '"# ! " '* ' 333* @# :

* '

! ; ' ! ; ! # #

;

+# * + # > / 0'

! ' ((, &

"# % % A .

(& '

#+ " 0

# 0 &

# &" #' 0 # # # 0' , (- .2

* & 6 ;7 #0

& * 6># 7 - ; & 0' 0' ": = -( ( .* * *0' + # #

) % # 0' #0 & ' * #

((4 *6 ;7'0? *0 ;'* #

' #

B # #0 0 0 0*6 ;7 #0' 6 7 #0'

* * ' 0

0 * 6 ;7 # * 6 !

1 ;>> >1CD;!A !D;> %! !;>17 *

* 6 !

1;>>%! !;>17 + 0

* '

* 0#

* 0 * 0* * %

# #

# 2# +# "#

33=5)8 +"" ( * 2# 0' 1B "#

! " # 3=) ! 518 )( $ % & # 33454)81%;-

= A # & '* 333 0 33 45 # *

8 )

B##0 & '* 333 ' ! 0# ># C+ !* # & '*

, ! !

;

" ))-E#! -(( (

& '* # 6 ;7 *# # * # 0# 0' & '

% #

# 2# "# ! # ' ( ) * 5%

( -8

(- - * 2# 1 B "# %' * 5 33=8 !% 14) 0 'B "# $ ' $ + , $

) # &)) ((35)8 "4(( , # 0' # # 0 * #0 ' 0' #

& '

## & # " )

333 * 6 !

1;>>"A +C%;!

F!D;>%! !;>17* &

((4 * 6 !

1 ;>> >1CD;!A !D;> %! !;>17

; & ' * & &

' 0 * ; *

0' +

# * 0'

& ' ' 0' 6 ;70'

#+ ( " :

** 0' + #

; ' # + ( " * * :/1 '%"&'!!;","<%&!","#=%!4-'#"&%, ;2"' /"&(> 8 ' 0 0' * " F# 0 5 8 :# 2# ' * *

* ' 0 58 0' * ' / 0#' G 58 * #02

#; 333 ' 0 0 # 0 0' " F* #0& 5 5.8;" F '0 # 0# #58#0& 5 8 # ; 7

: "$!%%$ !%'' /"$/1 '?> 8!# * ' 0' * 0' * 58 " F

* '0 0' * ' / 0 #' * #

' # * &

' 58

0' " F

* ' 0 # #; 333#

8 ' 0' ' # * # " F * * G 08HHH

HH 5 8HHHHH7

+ (" * '*

* '0 0'* '/ '00# 0 0'" F* #0 5 8+ ( " + " *

+ ( " *#0

&" '

' 0 & " '#;

''' " '0# *

; &

' 0 & '* *

#0#

2# # 0' # '0

5# 8* 0'/"# #

# ' #

# '

# 0

# #

# 0 #

# * # 0

# #

# #02'' * ' ## 0

0' # #

* ' 0 ##0

) !

5# 8* 0' 1B "# #* < * #

* < # 0 # * # #

- !$ %

5# 8@# * * * I C A %>%< *

I C A< * # 0 0

0# 9** ** '

!* 0'1B "# ** # *I C A<0#' 0 ; @# * #0'0* ;* 0 *I C A<0** ! * I C A< * I C A< ;#2# * #

; * # #/ 0 B*

# /

= " 2# #0' # '0 ! #

' -# . *

0# #

# ! ?* #0? # ;'* 0# ; * # * ID1B <0#*

0# ;

# + " '

' '* # 0 '*ID1B < / ;#

' * # 0' "# ; 2# #&

6!## )( " # " * " * 6D1B 7 # *# )( " / * * /# & ; ' 0

# # ' "

0# #

# " !?* #0? # ;' 0# ; # *6D1B 70#

0# > *

' ' # " F#+ " !*' ' ' ' # ;

" F # + " !

" '

# + " '

" '

' " ' # 0 " ' *6D1B 7/ ;# * '

' # 0'

!* 0* ' 0' B* " ' J ' * 6D1B 7/ 7

, ! %'

5# 8* # ;* # / * * *

#@#* ; * '

# # * ! * 0' 1 B "# 2# # 0' '* #+ ( " ; 0 #& 65 8 ! @# *

# # 0 2# # *

# * # * ;

0 #

*0# 5 .8

# 0

/ 0#0' ## '0 5+ +#

+# ,335$D!8" 5 (8

/ # $ )

3.) 58 .

. 5

5 )8 ; @# ' 0# * * '# * 2' ' 2# # / ' #

0'* ' '0 #0 *

5+ 12 0 #

# =D !5 8" '1

. >* 5

0 # +

# 0 #

=5D .)8 .

.385 .8 5 -8 ; + ( " 3-4 ' 0 # 0

* ' 0 0' * ' / 0 #'

+ #

' *

* / '0# 0 #0

0' 2#

* 7

!* 0 #* '

' 8 ?7-/ , %!! 2 -#<" '- ,?)9*

'8 ,%"4,-7 -2 @<&5+&'% -#<" : 9 "& : 0 "&