← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1118/2018allowed

New India Assurance Company Ltd v. Reetu And ORS

2023-03-13Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi6 pages

    

       

  !"#"$%&'&'&  ($)"

##*+ $./ )'  0--  +#*# 

* +#  0'

,% $451 +'*# "!

'6'7 + % +'8"$) *-

9)2!

$) +' $: *-

9)2!

 ' +'6 +;;

+( 19)2!

 ' <' $  ++ '=' >>> '6'7 9' 1 '

"$

15. $."#

##,    "$!,    )

)9 8"-"$ ?*, +9 # 1 5*+

#'9=@ "$#

)   #'A'<< - + ,$ 3 ) #-"

 $ " "!

"$ )

''B9 "##* ) 5.  / 5*+ +9  +.

9 *$) "$",*,7 ' '

1 +  !$

 1

 + !!") ",# +"5*$ 19 ?

19  "$!,

)98"-"$?*, +9 )A9 1 5*+

#"'

'#'9=@ + ,$ 3 (3

 #  *;3  3  5

:

$ "$ !!*$  C #'A'<<@- +,$ 3"$2"

( $ " "!

"$"##* "$",*, ' +-"$ #5

+;* )' &'

)!*$# 1 ++ ' <$ +3 $)5. 1."$;$ !"#"$ 

 "$  

DE

1 $#*+ $. / ) 2# 6"

  +# -   '=A   B9 !") ) $ A''B9 !$

 $#*+ $. "# $+, 11. +,"

:

#(3"!3 - +,"##"51 *$) +6 "$<F   +8 3"!1 "##*  "$!, !

$$ 5

:

5 ;+*$)

15 #"

"#$ !

9(3 +)"#"$  +,  1

+.

!

"$3 $)"$212 #!,- $#

"$- (")(9,"$+!3"1)

$) 1) - #   )

) 8"-"$ ?*, + (3 )"

) "$  -+",    3"# .* 3'   "$ ) ) !"#"$ "# + -+)*!

*$) +%   

            

  

     





   

  

      !   "   #$

  

 %  

     "   

      "  



  & '() * +   

      

      

  ,     "               

  -

      .

   

    

           

     /     $0

               , 

  " 1-

 



 

    

 .  2 

 -

  3 ,      

" "   !  4 &'

1# + # $ !"#"$ "$  

   

    

      

 !"#9(3 "$



)!3

+)$ ;+*$)

"$#

)  ##"$; !,- $#

"$$ 5 #"#

#-+ #!+"5 "$",*,7 9F<9"$!,

D&E

#-+ #!+"5 -* +?

19 5.5# +2"$; #*$) +% '    3) 1!3     5  3    

. 67    .

       

    



   $

  &       !       

   3       



 '3#

    

    1 -

  38

 9 ,                   

 "        "    

      ,      

  %     / :  &  -

    -

  

  "           

        !   

         



           / !  

3



%

3    

  "    

    .  

   



           ,      3     $0 

:       

    3              

  9  # 

 ;

    5 $  <3

 !=     !    3     3 

  3   !      

      

 

                  

       "   # 



   

   -

       ) 1!67

    %     

      

 

    ! 

           

       )   7   +3 ('

   3  %   





     5  '

 

 0 8  !  

    3         !    3

           

      )  7  +3('

    

 "3,         

 

    

        

    

 6     3  3       4

1!$

$451 2") +)

)<'')"#,"## )6/ #'FB&@"$!



"$ 1$#*+ '/ )2#

2" +#' DBE   3 1# 5

$ -1 ) 5. 1

1 $ !"#"$"$!

 $  



%

& '$(# )*+** *"+,*+**-(3 "$

D<E #","1 +!3 ( #+ )5.5# +2"$;

$)*5 $ " "!

"##* 6

+$, + +)"$;1"$:"$; ,"$",*,( #("

!$#*, +-+"!

"$) G"# +5* # "#$ 5"$)"$; #*!3$ +"5*$ 1' DAE #","1

9"# !"#"$ 



"$ '$#!,")*+**   .  

  

' /  

   *(+,*+**(3 "$"$!,

) C ₹<9B@9 $ #"# +

# "G -* +9"# +"!

?

1( #*-3 1)5.

 5. 31)"$;

 +"5*$ 1 ( # $  5*$) !!

,"$",*,( #$ " "

/ 5*+ +"5*$ 1( I*"+ 1.J 2") ' 6/ "$# !"#"$    ( )"#,"## )2") +) +)

)A''&"$6/ "2"1"

+.'#'<=  "$!

$"

)$)"

$./","

)2 +#*# , +H"

+#' &'

1 + +  ' < *+ + !$

+"5*$ ++ )"$$ +)"$;1## !$#+ "*, ,"$+ *;3

$)- # 

)"$2"

(  !"#"$ $451

"$01  

2

 34 5 #"$2"

(  !"#"$"$678 

7  9

-    

(*"+- #@!1

+) "$

CA'=K"$#

) BK +) +"5*$ 1' ='  3  !$#")  #*5,"##"$#   1

+*# !+)' B' ),"

)1.9

)( #A.

+#  $))"

)"$ -+",  3"#.* 31

2"$;5 3"$) .*$;(")(9 $ .

+1)) *;3

D=E #1)- #'#- H*);, #$ "!

52 9 ##,   "$!,  )

#-

#$ " "

"$",*,7 9 F<"#$ , $)

+. # !

5 5

;*")"$;

+' 6/4# "$# !"#"$4# "$    ' /  

6*-+ ( )"#,"## )5.$451 '*+ +9 #-"

   #-*# 9 ,"$+ ) *;3

$) 1) - !,- $#

"$ $ !!*$    1##   !$#+ "*,9$1.  (")( (

+) )#'<9@ +)#1## #-*# 1!$#+ "*,'( +9

,"$+) *;3

+5 #- 1## -

$) "1"

!$#+ "*, C #'<9@

!3 "$ 2"

(   !"#"$ "$ 0 1  

  2   34 5' # "$ 2"

(   !"#"$ "$ 67 8     34 5  + # @ !1 +) "$

CA'=K"$#

) BK +) 5. +"5*$ 1' A' !!+)"$;1.9"$ 1";3   -#"

"$$

52 9 +) +"5*$ #3 #5

$!3 $. 5.( .  "$#

1) #$ ( ++ $."$

+2 "$5.

'( +9"$2"

(  -+2"#"$#  +) +<*1 &&  9

4# 5*$) +)H*# !,- $#

"$'!!+)"$;1.9 ,"$+ !3"1) $)1)- 1#3 1) +) #'<9@

!3 !!*$  1## -

1@ "1"

1!$#+ "*,5 #"$

-  !,- $#

+) ) "# $3 ) +, B K - $$*, CA'=K - $$*,' !!+)"$;1.9

1 "1 ) 5.  $#*+

$. "# )"#,"## ) (3"1 +) "# ,)" "

) "$ 2*+   4#!1 1) !,- $#

#- ,)" "!

+)'  .,  5 !!+)"$;1. , # "$ -+-+  +

" # +) ) 5.  +"5*$ 19 1 ##

DBE ., 9"  $. 1+

)., '--

1)"#,"## )("

,)" "!

+)"$ 2*+  #@!1 52 ' '6'7  *);

&'&'& #3

+#-

:"$;@+

#$ %  #@

-+

%  #@