Managing Director Punjab State Bus Stand Management Company Ltd (Punbus) And Another v. Smt Charanjit Kaur And Another




   
 

!"#$#%&'&()  * !(!+&(+&,#%",- .(/!01"!"#.'1"!($!(!+#2#(" 23!(45"$!($!("6#,  7733#88!("' 9#,'.' 6!,!(/&":!.,!($!("6#, 7 #'3($#("' 
 
  
 

,#'#(") '20&;!1$-- .(/!0,"6#!33#88!("' (#,"6#,#'3($#("' <<<
    = > 33#!8 6!' 0##( &8#$ !+!&('" !?!,$  %23#('!"&( 


@--AB"%8!&2!("A,#'3($#(" &#2"6#,"6#$#%#!'#$ 04"6# 8#!,(#$",%%&$#("'8!&2',&0.(!8-.,$!'3., 6#,#&(!"#,,##,,#$" !'C"6#,&0.(!8D (!%%.("$#!"6!,/&"1&(+6'("6#,#'3($#("' &(!2",E#6&%.8!,!%%&$#("(  6#8#!,(#$,&0.(!804"!;&(+ &("!%%.(""6#!+#"6#$#%#!'#$!'@4#!,'-04!3384&(+2.8"&38&#,

!($04"!;&(+&("!%%.(""6#&(%2#"6#$#%#!'#$!'
AB3#, 2("6!''#''#$"6#$#3#($#(%4!'
 --AB .,"6#,-04!?!,$&(+! '.2
 --AB(!%%.("8''8E#!($!#%"&(!($
 -AB ,.(#,!8#F3#('#'-!?!,$#$""!8%23#('!"&(
 @--AB => 5#!,(#$  , "6# !33#88!("' %("#($#$ "6!" !?!,$ ?!' 8&!08#"0#2$&&#$-!33#!8!88?#$!($%23#('!"&(3!4!08#,#$.%#$( "6# +,.($ "6!" !8"6.+6 "6#,# ?!' ( &($&(+ &( "6# !?!,$  "6# !"6#,

,#'3($#("6#,#&( "6#$#%#!'#$0#&(+$#3#($#(".3("6#$#%#!'#$ !($%23#('!"&(6!$0##(!?!,$#$(84""6#2"6#, ,#'3($#("

 6#,#&( -4#"($#$.%"&(6!$0##(2!$#(!%%.("3#,'(!8#F3#('#' "6#$#%#!'#$ => 5#!,(#$%("#($#$"6!"&(E&#?3!,!+,!36 "6# $#%&'&(  (D08# "6# 1.3,#2# .," &(

 !

"

 #$  %!&' 

($)* +* )*

+'*( ,,-.-/&("6#!0'#(%#3,"6# !"6#,"6#$#%#!'#$0#&(+$#3#($#(".3(6&2-&"&'(84"6#2"6#,"6# $#%#!'#$?6&'"0#",#!"#$!'$#3#($#("-"6#,#,#-G"6#&(%2# "6#$#%#!'#$&'"0#$#$.%"#$"?!,$'6&'3#,'(!8#F3#('#'
1&(%#-&("6#&('"!("%!'#-&"6!'("0##(3,E#$(,#%,$"6!" "6# !"6#,  "6# $#%#!'#$ ?!' $#3#($#(" .3( 6&2- "6#,#,#- (84 "6# 2"6#,"6#$#%#!'#$?.8$0#$#3#($#("("6#$#%#!'#$%%,$&(+84- G"6#3#,'(!8&(%2#"6#$#%#!'#$'6!880#$#$.%"#$"?!,$'6&' 3#,'(!8#F3#('#'?6&8#?,;&(+.""6#%23#('!"&("0#!?!,$#$ => !2.("6!'0##(!?!,$#$(!%%.(".",#3,'3#%"' ,.($'  !33#!8 ,#E#!8 "6!" !8"6.+6 "6# ,#'3($#("'A%8!&2!("' 6!E# !$2&""#$8&!0&8&"4"3!4.",#3,'3#%"'-4#"&"6!'

0##(%("#($#$"6!"G %."&'"0#&23'#$0#,#!$$&(+G#(6!(%#2#(" =>
("6#&('"!("%!'#-$#'3&"#"6#'!8!,4%#,"&&%!"#"6#$#%#!'#$ ?,;&(+ &( !3,&E!"# 23!(4 6!E&(+0##( 38!%#$( ,#%,$- "6#8#!,(#$ ,&0.(!8 $&'0#8&#E#$ "6# '!2# !($ ",#!"&(+ "6# $#%#!'#$ !' 8!0.,#,- !%%,$&(+84!''#''#$6&'&(%2#!"
 AB3#,2("6' !,!+,!

&E "6#$#%&'&((D08#"6#1.3,#2#.,"&( +'*( ($0

(1! *") (2 '"'+!3 #  4

( 2 !+&' (3 *+&!

$ ,.5 6  '#' .,,-- 3,E&$#' , !$$&"&(  G  "6# #'"!08&'6#$ &(%2#  "6# $#%#!'#$2&(.'(!%%.(".".,#3,'3#%"'-?6#,#"6#$#%#!'#$?!''#8 #2384#$!($0#8?4#!,'!+#

7 1&(%#&("6#&('"!("%!'#-"6#$#%#!'#$!$2&""#$84?!'",#!"#$!' '#8B#2384#$ !($ ?!' 8#'' "6!(  4#!,'  !+#- "6#,#,#- G  "6# #'"!08&'6#$ &(%2#  "6# $#%#!'#$ 8#''"!F %23(#(" '6!880# !$$#$( !%%.("  .".,# 3,'3#%"' ?6&8# %23."&(+ %23#('!"&( ?#E#,- "6# 38#!"6#!33#88!("'"6!""6#$#$.%"&(&'&,'""0#2!$#,2"6#&(%2# !''#''#$!($"6#,#!"#,-!$$&"&(&'"0#2!$#(!%%.(".".,#3,'3#%"' &'("#$"0#,#/#%"#$ =@> ("6#,!'3#%""6#2!""#,?6&%6(##$'("&%&(+&'"6!"!'.2 
 --AB?!'!?!,$#$(!%%.("8''8E#!($!#%"&(!($


-AB , .(#,!8 #F3#('#'  ?#E#,- ( !2.(" ?!' !?!,$#$ ( !%%.("8''#'"!"#,,"6!"2!""#,-8''&8&!8%(',"&.2

!,!+,!36@ E&&& "6#$#%&'&((D08#"6#1.3,#2# .," &(

,!(!4 1#"6&D' %!'# !($

!,!+,!36 * 

8"

9!(!

($0

(1!* +3 # (0  " '

$ &0& 0  "

(3*+&!

$3!1'3!3*(./ ,- ,./'('#'))!

 * -:./*;,./!,# ,#8#E!("&("6&',#+!,$
( E&#?  "6# $#%&'&( &( ,!(!4 1#"6&D' %!'# '.3,!  !($ !+2!#(#,!8
('.,!(%#23!(45"$D'%!'# '.3,! -,#'3($#("' !($ A%8!&2!("' &# 2"6#,  "6# $#%#!'#$  !,# 6#8$ #("&"8#$ " %23#('!"&(
 -AB(!%%.("8''#'"!"#&(!$$&"&(""6# %23#('!"&( 
 -AB , .(#,!8 #F3#('#'- 0#'&$#'-
 -AB ( !%%.("  8''  &8&!8 %(',"&.2 " 0# '6!,#$ #H.!884  ?#E#,- ( !2.(" &' 3!4!08# ( !%%.("  8''  8E# !($ !#%"&( &( E&#?  $#%&'&((D08#"6#1.3,#2#.,"&( ,!(!41#"6&D'%!'# 1.3,!  => %%,$&(+84- $#"!&8'  "6# %23#('!"&( " ?6&%6 "6# ,#'3($#("'A%8!&2!("'!,##("&"8#$"&'!'.($#,)B

6

* !

3$ "*0(+ $$!$$!3 <2 +&! '<0(

"*0(+ $$!$$!3 <2 +&'$*0 +


(%2#
AB
AB

6!(+#  

.".,# ,'3#%"' 
5 G
I
AB  "!8
(%2# !''#''#$
AB 
J
 I
 -AB  .8"&38&#,!338&#$

 #$.%"&( "?!,$' 3#,'(!8 #F3#('#' $#%#!'#$  
5 G 
 -AB  I
AB
F I
@-AB  23#('!"&( ?!,$#$
F I
K-AB @ #3#($#(%4

((.!884 
@-F I
 - -AB" ,#'3($#(" &# 2"6#,!8(# * 5''  5E# !($ #%"&(
K-F I
 --AB
 --AB 
5 K 5'''"!"# 
5
 -AB

 .(#,!8F3#('#'
 -AB



.:,,,=>

 5'' 

&8&!8 (',"&.2 
5
-AB

"6#,L,#'3($#(" 
-AB

!"6#,L,#'3($#("   *+



.?6:,,,=>



../.,,,=>
("#,#'" *G3#,!((.2 *G3#,!((.2 =*>
(E&#?"6#3'&"&(!'("#$!0E#-,#'3($#("'A%8!&2!("' !,# 6#8$ #("&"8#$ " !?!,$  %23#('!"&( 


-* -AB !' !+!&('"


@--AB!?!,$#$04"6#8#!,(#$,&0.(!8!8(+?&"6&("#,#'"M*G3#, !((.2?&"6##%",2"6#$!"#%8!&23#"&"&("&88$!"#3!42#("-8#'' 3!42#("-&!(4-2!$##!,8&#,
"&'.,"6#,2!$#%8#!,"6!"!3!,",2
-AB(!%%.(" 8''&8&!8%(',"&.2-0#'&$#'#H.!8'6!,#&(%23#('!"&((!%%.("

: .(#,!8#F3#('#'!($8''%(',"&.2-,#'3($#(" &#!"6#,"6# $#%#!'#$ '6!88("0##("&"8#$"!(4"6#,3!42#("6#0!8!(%#!2.(" '6!880#3!&$",#'3($#(" &#2"6#,"6#$#%#!'#$ &(!%%,$!(%# ?&"6"6#2!((#,&($&%!"#$04"6#8#!,(#$,&0.(!8&("6#!?!,$ =K> ##$8#'' " 2#("&(- "6# !33#88!("' '6!88 $#$.%" &(%2# "!F 8&!0&8&"4- & !(4- H.! .".,# 3,'3#%"' &( !%%,$!(%# ?&"6 "6# $#%&'&( &(

,!(!41#"6&D'%!'# '.3,!  = >  %%,$&(+84- &( "6# 8&+6"  "6# 3'&"&( !' ("#$ !0E#- "6# !33#!8 &' 3!,"84 !88?#$  ?!,$ $!"#$    3!''#$ 04 "6# 8#!,(#$ ,&0.(!8-.,$!'3.,&'2$&&#$""6##F"#("!'("#$!0E#  1N!8&!  .$+#   * !2&"


N6#"6#,'3#!;&(+A,#!'(#$ ) #'A 
N6#"6#,,#3,"!08# ) #'A