Magma Hdi General Insurance Company Ltd. v. Jagtar Singh And ORS
!"# #$%&'('
& )*
+' +
, ! "
"#$% ! &' ()
, !
()
#- #
#. ! &'/ ()
#0123
, -' ./0
* 67+0899+.:-8 + 74'
#.-.++.:-8( ,
* -8:0.:-8(
$
#
*
<
<
4
4,
,
$
#!=+>9 +00:>
; -8:0.:-8(
*
->>*
(-?@@(4,
*
( ;
4,( *
; ; %+
- ,
?:::3+ .
-.A?:::B -(:@(:::3+
0 6
!
9:C -:@:::A2:3-::B 92(:::3+ 2 $
-:@:::D92:::B -(>.(:::3+ 9 E @-(:::3+ >
, @-(:::3+ 8
-9 @ $
, @-(:::A-9B -.(-9(:::3+ ? * ++ -: * ) **
.:(:::3+
-- 6
"A
.9(:::3+ -. $
-.(>:(:::3+ 3
#012 ) *
+ 4'
;.0, * (
(
*<-9< 4
*<-@< = ( **
;
4,
F * ; *
3
#012(,4 7 :9:..:-2(
*
< <;
* ;
,
#!=+>9$+ >>9.
(
*;
( ;
4 (
*;
(
'
;
) ( ;
4
'
$ ; 4
4 -9(:::3+
,4
)
,
?:::3+;
,
( **
4
;
,
)
4
# $7+/$3 $3 +0:3@30-223 && (:@:?.:-> $7(&& (# #( (;
4
( ;
;
(;
,*
4
,
,(,
4
*
*9:C( ;
;
;
;
(
4
3 3 4
*
,4,
;
( ;
4
+
;
National Insurance Co. Vs. Pranay Sethi : 2017 SCC 270,
!"
" Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Nanu Ram alias Chuhru Ram & Ors., 2018(4) RCR (Civil) 333.
#-;
( ( ;
( , 4 4,
+ ,;
*
)
(
#$ % &' ( )"* +)
"! !
" )
)
4 4,
+
,
* **
)
4
*
)
) *
#4(
; $7(# (
;
; A
, )
4
,
*
)
* (
* # ( 4
*
*
)
(4 ;
,
)
;
,
)
(*
(-?@@ ( ;
( ;
4 4,
, ,
* 4
;
(
;
4, )
*
)
(
* +&
; &
) 4
&
$
;
,
)
, .:-0(
; * +&
; &
* 8.283+$
* ?:::3+ 8.283+
9:C
; *
(;
*(
; )
2:C
*
(
(
* 9:C2:C;
(
; ,.0, *
4
; <-@< <-9<= ( (;
* (
*
* 2:(:::3+ $ ( ;
(*
* *
A
(
+
; $ <4
Pranay Sethi's case (supra) F
* -9(:::3+ (4 * * 1*
A
4
*
;
4'
-:C
*
,
, $
(
;
-:C
Hence, the amount of compensation under the conventional heads stands modified to Rs.16,500/- each, for loss of estate & funeral expenses and Rs.44,000/- each for loss of filial consortium, for each of the two claimants, who are parents of the deceased Amar Singh. Resultantly, t
,4 ; *
;%+
- ,
8.283+ .
-.A8.28B @>(?>23+ 0 6
!
2:C @>(?>2A2:3-::B 02(8@>3+ 2 $
?-(89:3+ 9 ;
A
9:C 29(@893+ > *
*
29(@893+ 8
-@ @ *6
29(@89A-@B @(.9(89:3+ ? **
22(:::3+A.B @@(:::3+ -: 6
"A
->(9::3+ -- *"
->(9::3+ -. $
?(2>(89:3+
(
* ?(2>(89:3+
;
G@C
* **
*
H I (
, **
4)
,
1% -