← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2749/2012dismissed

Gurcharan Singh And ORS. v. Karnail Singh

2016-02-11Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Garg10 pages

 

        

  !"#$ % %&' ()

* +          

!#( !,-./#012 /#0//23 %.4.

  



      

   

  

  

     !

"#"#$#%&'( &



 

 ! "#

      

           

 )   *#+#+

      '

 

   ,&  %#'#%#  -    .#+/#++

'#0 ( ,1%

(

&2&  

 







  +#+*#++ #  (  4&        

 0 

#

   

 

0    5   #6 (& 

 (







 

  







 



  +#+*#++  (

 (

#* 



     +#+*#++&  #   

 5

   

#*  #   (   #7           8        #    (  

    

+#+9#++#6 (&  #+/#++&  # ( 

#   

8



#6 

  (







 5

 

 

&    (  # : #+/#++&

 

5   8 



( &  #8 



  8

      

  #:

5 &

 

 ( (

#     8   ( 

  

+#+9#++#: +#+9#++&  

    



% 

&"

      

  

           8&     #    &  

  

( 

    :0 

& 2#7       # ;(

     #  

  

 

 #   #  

 5

   #6&  

# <

   &     

#      # 



$    8



 5

 

  #7 

 5

    # 

# 

 



  

#   

5     

 5   # '

  4  4



  #

  



 5   

  8



  

 

    



= 

 ( #    

4       

 

           

 ) 



 

8







 #  (8 #    # ;

      



 



 

  ## (    

  #

(      # :

  

   &0 

 

  

 !> ?                    

  !"        "        $

$

%&     # 



'())               *

       "'

()+

 , " ,     

    " ,     

 '())

                   

 

" !" '()+ -      !  '

()+ -&   "  " "

 $ ,    .#! 

$  '()+&.

.  /

0 

&   

(     &  



 



   8        #      

    

 (

      

(  .#+/#++#' &  

 

&               

 



    







  +#+*#++         

  0   (          *#+#+#6&

 

# 7(  



 $   



    

        5

  

       #   

 



&







 

 

!> ?0                     %    !,   $   ",    $     

!  ,  '

!0 

 !"  ,    ,  

   

% $2.

$    ,      !'

0 

   ,1         $, !

   

   $2.

'

  %   

  !"   # ,     " '/ $  



   

0   

  (   

  

   (   ( 

   

  

#$     8





  

    7(

 



  



    #



 

   

  0          (       

 

 0 

  8

 

  

 

  



& 

0   

 (         #   

   

 

  

!> 34 5 ,$  !   1  ,*          $  ,     

         !"

         

    ,      

&                       !  #  

   

  6&  + 

    7 80  9  *



          



"$ 1   !

      "  !      ,  

  $  !  



   !

"!  

 !$ 

!"*

   ! 

!"1   80 9  ,  ,  "

 "     



          6& 80                           ,     ,      $   #

!

#    #  # :  8!0    , 

# #     , 

  $,  & , 

# #     :

80 ,      ,     

     #

!$  ;    < !      / 9

 



 ,



               !  !

"$  !        !        !  

 !"    *

   = 1       





$

 ! !"

1 = $  1           

 

  "

  ,   "                 #      "    !            #  ,     ,       9       1   

!#         ,        ,         #  !                

          ,   

#   #          > ,#    "  

$  

!#

 !"  1           ?

   

  ";

                         

 ! 

  

  "$  

  !"    # $  !  #   ,      

 " ;" !  !" !"  

  9 $

!#

 !"  1  

    ,     

$,    #! !"    

    # @  #$                  !

   ;  = # ,$=    *

 > A! 1  '  () *(*+,-,' . .)/ ) ," 0- 0)0,,"$&$, !   6& 39    !"@9@      !">

1 ,      #

 #

A,  

   

 "   

      "         * "

         #

A  "/

 " B   # ;,  $

2801 1 1$ 4$ > A!)*!

>">

1  !#  6& 39      



   "  

        !   C )  ,                     <

9 

  !"

 # 9 $ ,$ 

       " ,  !< !      

  

  ,   "       C 

  =     

" "  <" 



,      # ,    

80    9 

  ! ,   #  

 



"  *



    # ,         , ,  !#  !"  ! ! * 9, ,   9"        "         @  #$        #   #

  =  , 

    / =   +;* $ 1DD==

&0$)*!E, $ $> A!   !# ,     !    !"    "    $            !

   F

*

  !"

     E 9"! ;       #    9  >   +;$  01  1$FF$ #> A! 1           9      "

  !  G   # G ,+8  0 $

F80181 04

! > A! 1 =,  !  

  #

   #  " <

,      

   

!#

 !"      

,  "!  2  # ,!

#



$= # ,   1    

 ;!"

         ", ! # #  

       $          #

   4

9                      <

 

"$

          

                             <



 !

#



$ 

   ,            *

   

    

 " <

!","        

    !"     #       %        %     ,  9  

   !





,   1 ,  

  +   

   

  

 " <

#            

 " <

(    ! 



$  ,      #   ,  ,  

     

=       ! 



,    

$ ,  !   #!

  / 7( 

 (& 

0     

 

#$  



  

 

   (     

 & >  

>

 



 (   #7



0    

 

  0    

 



(    &



   ( #- (

 

       

    

#  -  5

 

 &  >

  5



& &



 

 

 

# - 

 #

# )

* + 5 6 %7879 (4 0