← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-AS/242/2019dismissed

Sukhwinder Singh v. State Of Punjab And Another

2024-11-28Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel16 pages





     

 

 

#&'()*'+,-,(./

  

  

 7*  

   '



   

 

  8

! /" 

   9   :::::

 !

"#$% 

 

  

       

    

! 



 ( .

2  "5

   "

 

  #$# #$$; &-

)     &

 "

     " 

 % %&' ($!   $! 

  ""

(!)

( ) *( !

 + +

)  !)

!,



!

#$# #$$ $;   &     -  .

 0&-12       -

;! 3



 4  )

"



 -

  

!

! """



"

  !    !"5 

.

( (

2 

"

4 -

 



   )

 

   ;  

#$#6#$$; &- 9/ " "





 "  

/ ""

 

 6 

 "5

/ )

     #

! 

      -

!   /

       -

! 



<)          )

    

 ) );

"   

"

=

!  

  "



  "5

 )    

 

;

"  



) 



) )"

  > & !

!



%&'

'!

 $!&( 

 ! =-)   9    

 

,

9 3



! ")

  .

/"

) )1

2

"   /

 &( 

  =



)



   ") ) =    

.

/"

)2!

$

 ) !    

  ? "

   C  %        "

" !3 3



@#A!

 B#3! 

 "

    

 , 

"

"

/"

) )!

 "/

  "   

 

 ( )  !   (  ! 

   +

 )   +  !%&'



 ( ) 

")

/ !



B# - -! B# ) )



-

")

  "

D       " ! "



    #$#! #$$; &-

  )

 

(.

2! "

 

 



 A  "

 

  

 - 



"5

(  )

"

"

!"

 

E " 

 

 

 -

  



  

       "    

 "





"5

& 



-

  /  "

"

)  " ")   ""

 -

   )

 

"

 )

 

 

    

"5

 )

  ""

" 

 /"

) )  ) )

 "   

   "

 

 "

/  "

 /"

)    

 



" 

(& 



-



"

"  "



)    !

-

  

"      "5

 ""    ) )

  "



-



)

 

"  )

  

 "

   %

)

" 

/ 

""

(  )   

/  "

 

  ")

 

E "

 

" / -

 

"5



" 

 

 "5

   

 $ &

    ) )   

   

 "  =

!

  /"

 !3   9 

"

 

(  =   ) )  )  )  

 "

 

  B

 

!   

 )  

    "   

   

  "5

 " 

  



 " ")"



  )   &    

"

"5



"

"



)

"



 

 -

F     4

 "

 

 



;

" 

 )

  ""

   

 -



!   

 4

"

/



"



= -



 

    "5

! /

     =F

 

-

 

      "

"

  $% 

%      

      

           !  "#





             !   #$     #$   

   % #$!    ! !                           !   "'     %   &        !          

0 4!

) <) " <  



 "

 



"

 



 

     

#$&-.



#$#&-2 

"

)

  

 # $$;4  /

  #$#  #$$; 



#$&-

 

; &'() * ++*  , !!  *

*+)-*  (                           (     !            !            (        !   )     ! !            !  !       )          ! 

         !

!          !     !

+  4     

   )

 

  # #$#   &     -  .&-2!

 ) )

)

""

!

!

"

 

4 "

<  

"

H( H H   H H

4"

)  

  



) 

)/  

 

"  !

"



4

)G G( I)





"

"

 )/  



 )     " " 

/

 !

!  !

1 "/"

)

/ 



 

 

<)

" 



"" 

1 "

    ) F

)/ /      4

 )

/

1" "

 

"

)

    "

 

  

  %

)

  

5

 "

"   J )

"

!

/   "

""

1"



)

1

&)

!"

)



))

! 

)  ) " " "

"

  " "  



  

 " )   =1



- -

)12 2    

. ("'/0 +  , 

"

/ 



 

; ,

-!

      !

! 

(

  !             !     ! !(        !              !             .  0  -1  * !    (      !      (          2 (!    (!   ! ! 

    -   ! (     (  !   (   ! 

.    !      (       (                             - ! !

                        2      !                        -         ( !     

2    (    (     !            2   !     (                    2    (      !         4                                          (   !        (

+ &  / !   "    

"

  "  

) )

/

/ 

  

"

 " 





#$#&-4 

5



  

 "

 ""

)

 ) F

  " &

)

)

"" "



 !

"

)/ )

 

  

)  

3

"")

 )

 

 

  /  "      "

"

 





/    #$$; &-

 

; ,''-0)34 * ,*  *!)'*  !

               !    (!    (     !               !

!      ! !          + 4  

#$$; & 

 - .&- -2!

)

/  

" " 



1"

 "

  ") 

"

" 4

/

""

 

)

/





 )

"

  





<

   & "

  

/

  /

  " !  " )

/

"



)  

"" "

 =

 "

   "

  "  "     

   #$$; &  )

)

  "

   )  " /  

"  ") 

)

 "

 

" 

"   

4

)

 "

 

"" 

 "

 

   "

<

  4

5

  )

1)/ "





  "

 

 

 

    

 

"  

" 4 

 

 



"

) <

 ) ) 

 C ! 



  & /  " !&/  

"

)   /"

    

  

 

 " 

) )  )

" 





   

-

  K

 

 !

   

  "

"

   

 



 "



  



      &    

;

"

  





 



 "

 " /" !  

 



  4 



  

   )

"

" !  "  



! 



)  "



   

 





! ")

  

 

/"

)!

B



!

 "

 C %    " 

" !3



 @#A !  B#) 

./"

)2 "  

 #)!  



 "

 " 

  

 

" "     4



!

!  

 )

 ) )

 

  "    

 &

 ! ")   

 

""  ( )     (   .

 (;

2!    

 

     )

 

 



  

#$# # #$$; &-4





 

@$! /"

) 

 "



 3 

   

   

 

 $ $>  - -  

   /"

)    ;/

 

 /  ) ) L<% & 

/    " 

  <) ) /

  "

      

   ##  - -  

 " 

 "

)

 " ") "

 

 

  

)! "

 ) 

 )

"   =

! 

 #  /"

) 

  K K;>       )   



 

< <) ;;" =

 ;

<) ) 

"

 "

" "

 "

" 

4 /"

) 

/

" / /  "

  @   ""

!

 " B# 3 3      )  

"

"  &  !  3





 !"



! 

  E 

(.

24



/

) E   3 !  -  ! ,

   

3)!

     "

"

    

  

 )

 

) "

")

(.

2    " "

  "

   



!""   "

 

 4    /"

) ) 

   $>  -  -

$! 

 5

 $ !     "       ""  .

 ( 

2 /

    ) 

 &" / /  

#$#  # #$$;

&     -  .&-2!

)

<

)  )

"

 

)

 "



 "" =

!

!  )

<       "

"    )

 "

"

!  "  

 

  "

  4 





5

  

    ""

 



 !       )

  )

<



F 

 4

"

 )

 "  

<!    ) !  /

<

    

5   )

 ")

  

"

)

"

 & "" ") "

!

) )  "

!"

! "

  

K

 "

 "

   )   

 ""     

"



!    ) <

 "

""   "" "

 



"

  "

)   

 4!  "

 )

<

"    "



/

) 

< <"



/

  ! 

      

) "

    "

) &  )  )  " ") "

!

=1



-

5,   

. 

 (""/0  + , 

('"



< 

  "

  ) 



 )

   ""   "  

<    

 

"" 

  "

 "

     /"

) 



)

    )

 

/ 

 



   "  "



   

*     

""

(.

2 

 

  # 

)

"

 "

 "

 



&/ @"

!K;!&( 

 !   "

  " / ! /"

)

  "")  

 ""    

/

"

" 4  

      &/  @"

!  

  ")

   

)



!

"

/"

)



$ $>- -!B# 

) 



   /"

) /



(.

2   

""

4 "

)

")

 

 

 "



 

/"

) )1







) )



  ")   



/



      "   

 

 /"

)  

   ""

(.

2



 "" > 



   )

 /



  -

   )  



" 

 



  &   !        /"

)  

  "  /



") !  )

/

 

 

 

"

(   ")

"

 

/"

) 



  )  "



( ( 

4  /"

) "  " 

(.

2

 "

 

/

)

" 

 4

 "  ")

 "

!"

"!

) )

"" .

.

(

2"

)

/"

)

/

   4  )

  " 

   ")   ""

(

 5    )

 

*  > %  "

   " ") ) "

   " !    



/"

) 

    " 

  

   ""  4  /"

)! 

 /

 $

     

 

 ! " )

 " "

)

 "   /"

) )



 

 )

1          !



4





  ""

 (     



/ ) A &

<1

!

 "")

 "" !       



  "

"  "

-

 "

/ 

  

   

   #$#   #$$;  &- /  

4 "



( 

)

 

 "

 /"

) ) "" "   ")  $

"   

  

 /"

) ) 

 

 ) "

 "



    "

 " "

" "

/

 

 /



1

 



  & "

)   



 

 



5



  

 





 "     

    "



)





/ "

""

/

 

  "5

  "" /  )

    3

/





<

 

") )

 ) )

 "

")



 "

"  /

)

! 

B %

)

-

 



 # #$# #$$; &-!   )

!

"  "

 )

4



 

)" 

"

3

/

 ) "

 "

) /"

)  

  

  &  "

     -

! 

    "



)

*) "  

 -

 

""

 

5

/   

  



 ) "

  & 



"

"

"

)  

 

 



 5

 



! " ) )







   

    

"

    

 

 )

  5 

 ""      &   

"

 "!

/ !"  

!  

< 



    "  ) )

  ) "5

"" "

 &

/  "  "

"

 " " ! "







  

  )



" 



/"

)K

/"

 



 



  ! 

   "    !

!    *

""

   "

 

")  ))

=

!

!



    

! 

  "5

!"    

)



/ .

( 

2   

 /"

) )       ") ))

" 

 



    "5

&    "

  )

 

"

 

  & "

 " ") "



"

 

  )

"     " "    "

  

""





   /"

)     

 

"  "

  "

 "



/"

)

""

   "  =

 -

 

"  

  "

<) )

!

" "





" < 4 - 



 "

 /"

)  



 

  

  /  )

  

  )  

  "5



-





 

     )

 

"

 

 "   

) " )

  4  

"5

   

 J   

 ) 



"!  "5 5

   

    

! 

!

'



!

)

!

  )     

" .2!

!

     (/ )

  !

% 

!> K

 *

  M *( K

 M *(