High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/359/2015dismissed

Vinod Kumar & ORS v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2020-11-10Mr. Justice Ajay Tewari,Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri30 pages

!"!#!$%& '%()*!&+ $!*#&!

& -.

* / .

& '

$&. !4)"&(%5 $"(+ "6& !4)"&(%5 $"(5#%&&"" 5#!%&

()

+ #,- ),./)012.3

- ),./)012.3 4& #,

* &

- ),52+.1,)012.3

% !

* &

6 "

-3- ),5.)012.3 #

- )7.0)012.3 #

- )525)012.3

* &

#21.- ).1,)012.3

8 *&

#2- )59/)012.3

- )5,,)012:

4& #2- )59/)012.3

-';'),10,)012.3

% *&

-3- )202,)012.3

$ %& *&

- )500)012:3

* &

#7 ,0- ),./)012.3

-3 -'

#2.0, 2.070101 ),./)012.3

#07- ).1,)012.3 #0:- ),52)012.3 #05- ),5.)012.3

%*&

#.+5- ),5.)012.3 #2- ),52)012.3

% '

#9*/*21*2,*2:*,.*71*72 - )7.0)012.3

<% 8

& ) #. -'

)2,5:) )0101 )202,)012.3

#,*7*.*:+9 - )500)012:3

8 *&

#22 25- )500)012:3

#.0:*.,1*.,2*.,7*.,:*.,/*.72*.7.* 5,5*5/0*:22- ).1,)012.3 #,.0 ,.7*,.5*,.:*,.9*,51*,52* 7:1*.15*.07*.77- ),52)012.3

- ).1,)012.3

#2 :

8*$8*

=== (+ "6&8( 2 &

#,./*,52*,5.*7.0*525* .1,*59/+202,012.

0110012.

" & "

&&&

6 > 6 &

';'#,10,012.

1.1.012. & "

#500+5,,012:

0/1,012:

& ' -

' 3 & &

6 6 '

' #202,012."

"&&

' "

& "

& & & > "

% &&*

% #,./012.A

';'#,10,012. #500+5,,012:

#,)

& '

#5C0115011:0115 925

+ '

6 -'

#003 "

& <&

*& *

* 6A + % 6 -"

" & " & * "

& *

021901156 > &

& <&

> > &

& D

& <&

E "

+ '

> > &

& D

> &

& &"

" 20150119

#,) '

$<*

6 & 6

& * &

2,1:0119A

211& & &> 0

% 6 >

" A

& &

%" )&

) &"

7 !

& &"

,1150119& &

& &

221:0119"

% "

$<*

6 6A

#,)' &

& &

& > &

) &

" "

&; 291:0119

" & 251/0119 07210119!

% &*

& &

,21:0119"

* & &

0.1,0121 *

& & * D51

% &> &

% "6

% & > &

> &

&*21H0*$

> &

#,)' *

& "

& & "

6A* &

& "

&& "

'G#2.5.50121

& 221/0120"

#2...0120

*&,11/012,

' #021, 0101*

*&19170101 5 ! &

* " "

6A %

6 - "

& &"

3 :

" &

& 6

& -6A3&

F& -

'G#2.5.50121

& "

> & "

' A

' &

" "

* & > &

& ""

& "

' "

" "& *

221/0120

() I

! "

# !

! !"

$%!

$%#

!!!! !!

'()**( !

+ !

" #

! ,

! + !

"-"

! !!

! #

! "

/&+&

" !

0 ,

" #

! !

! ! !

" !" "

! !!! +! " !

# !

! & "

!!" &

! !

12-)**2 !" "

! 334)*3* ! 1)' /&+

5 !

"!""

/ >

& 6A*

&& &

& " >

#2...0120"

%() I

! "

! !7

! 8 ! "

! " ! , 139*(* )*33 " " !!" 323))*33 "

*)*:)*3)& *)*:)*3);3'(< - :'

')*

6&! !7

*)*:)*3)!&

$% 5 )**( $)% $!% 2)28 $% 9

)**< 51''))**2./132(9'

)**4$% )*,)*3'=/513(24)*3)

!$/

> ?!

> %! "

" 8 ! !@! " !

" !!

& !

A B = #"$3<92%':(:

> / > 3<<:$:%=:9<8 $%C! &>5 / >

)**($'%=:<( !

8 " !! ! ! ! "!

! , D5!#> $)**(%'23<8 ! $%!#! #

!@! " " !

&! !7

@! "! " @

!!"!

$%A ? , 5+3<29':28 $%C1 7>= 1 ! $)**2%33:4(8 # "@ @ ! " !#

! !7

&@! 2* #

! '* #

! !

7 ! > $)**9%3=399" !

:*F

:*F "!

& ! !! !#

! 5 0

/ #&" # ! #!$)**)%23)98 @

! !!

! "!8$ % !!,

# "8 $ %!!,

$%/

" / A

B+ $3<9'%):4'8$%B+ #

$3<<*%

!:4:8$%,-# ?

5 "!A EA !EE !3<:3/=)'38 $% =

/ = ?!

3<<4$4%&3<) !

@ !

! "!! !

" 8

$%55!? G $3<('%'''8 $%1&? # /

> $3<<)%)='9(!

" !

" @ &@! !

E !! ! "!! " !

! !8 ! ! @ ! ! @ @

! @ @

! !

! " "

! / 0 !!

" !

0 "

8 0

! !

! D B A

A ! !

! !!! !&"

$% > )**4$'% 72338 $%,

> > )**9$3%=2(4" 6 21

$ !&

&&&

22 '

& & % 6 * &&&

'G#/25:0121

5!5 & % > &

% 6

'G#/25:0121"

> &

" &

& &

& "

- #7

& 4

& )

)

8 2, * " *

% &

& &

& * &

" &

% &>

0720129 27

& 3 #2,:50129 "

& $!&

01220129"

> &

" & "

& & 2.

$!& >

& 6A*

&&&

) ' #021,

0101

F& -

3*"

& &

" -

#,0

191701013() 3G

& " &

J 3G

& &

& & ' &

& J 3G

,1150119 & &

221:0119 &

" 9 & &

% 4

,21:0119 &

& & & & 09200115*"

& & "

& J 3G

% &

6A &

& "

* & &

9 & &

& &

& "

J 3 G

1,190119* & "

& 4

6A &

1,190119 &

' J 3G

' "

& &

% )&

&> &

"71 79:7

: /

& &

01 0: ,1

J 3G

& & &

& 0120*

6A &

686 & <&

J 25 *

" () 2(6 "

0(6 "

& "&

& *"

& &

21170121 ,( 6 &

,1150119* 221:0119 ,21:0119"

& & 09200115"

& &

& 7( 6 ' ) * &

& &

' *

" '

& "

,1150119*& &

& &

221:0119 &

,21:0119 & &

*" &

& && &

' .( 6 &

1,190119 "

% 1,190119 &

> &

& *"

& &

5(6

' &

&> &

" > &

" & 6

* "

$!&

,7 ,5" &

% &

& &

)& &

I &) &&

/1K

& &

& & 21

" )

&)) "6 &

& &

&&&

% && %

#5 "

&& :( 6 &

#5C0115 "

4 & &*"

& &

& *0120A "

& 2/9, 6A"

& & *

& &"

& &

* &

& & &

$ !& G* " *

#50115 &

& "

6 & &

6A*&

" &

22170121 & & 6A6

* " *

&> &

& 6 &

01150115 &

& &

092001156

% &011:01196 &

6A&

& *

G &

& *

& "

& " &

& "

#5 0115

& 09200115 6 &

& 2: ' &%

& "

& 4

6A6 *

> & &

6A" &

&&&

& &*

" &

& B

& 402190115

& 4

& 6A 29 & "

& *

() 36 & * "

& * "

& &

& & 3A

& "

% &> &

" 36

#,)' " %

' & 6 & %

' 3#& " &

& "

)

& & "

& &

& &&

&&&

6 " "

01 A

* %

* &

6A 4 02190115

& &

09200115

6A0212011:6 4

211&

& & > >

% " & 0.

%" % )& 6

0212011: & " *

& &

& "

22150119 4

011:0119 6A 6

& >

% 0.

% )&"

6 "

& 011:0119"

& &,11501196 &

201:0119*

' &

" " C;& * 0119 " *

,21:0119*

& & &

&201:0119

6 *

& "

" "

6A 02

* &

& % 6 * &"

'G#/25:0121

#2,:5012901220129

& &&

6 6A*"

% 6 F& 00 % !

* &

& 6A

& &

& "

& &

* &

&&&

#.7+:.

F& -

8 *&

#:7*"

& () ;94. !

! !

!!= !

! 3**4)*3*

!!"

! "

! ! 3**4)*3*"

! 33*4)*3* " ! ,)*3*!

! ! " ! !7

33*<)*3)

!!! "

)<33)*3'

!& !

!! !

5 C

G G , 5+3<2:3)<'

!!" < " !

!!"HE I<+ !

! " 0 "" !

! A ! IIMMMMMMM6 0. ;

* !

* &

% '

% &

-&&

& " &

F& -

& 6A

& % 6 F& -

3 05 A

& &

* *

& A"&

" &

F& -

&&&

& F& -

" 0: %

& F& -

& "

> &

& &

& "

& &

& #

& "

& C 6A

6 "

& &

" &

09 "

#5C01153"

& <&

4 & "

& " DA

& &

&* "

& "

& C"

& *

& "

%6 * ' % ' )A

& E

0/ A

& 4 *

#77+..

F & -

& &

> "() I44 5 /&+

! )(3))**2 !

0 )** # ): # ! ! 3<(' /&+&

! #:*F

! 4:F C 4*F G,& !

! "

! !

0 )3*3)**9 " 0 " !!

0 G 0 " !!

!! " " 33*2)**(" 0 " # ! )**9)**( '**2)**(

E+%"

?/G5 & /&+ G ? ! # ! ; !!

6 & '**2)**( "

;

6 !!0 5

" "

! " "

! 3**9)**(" "

! 12 )**2 1)'

E! ( !! " E!" # "

33*9)**(

! 1" " !

E! " "

& "!

" '3*9)**("

!!! ! !! " ! & "" 0 "*)*<)**( 393*)**( " "

::5 )**9)**2

! ! )(3))**2 " "

! ! "

! "J

!! @

'**2)**(" "

3**

! !

" 2*

! #"!

#!! ! 4*

! !#"! !G!

""!! !

! 8&

" " C

" 0 !

" . !

'**2)**( !

0 #

" !!

!!"6 ,1 A

#77*

"() ;'**2)**(

E +%"

?/G5 &

/&+G ? ! # !

; !!

6 ,2 &

& %"*

#..

' &

MM %"

#07+ 0.

F& -

& "

#07 + 0.

& "() ;)4 ,"

! !

" " " "

! #"

2* # 5 K ! '* # + "! ! ! 3**4)*3*""

! ! ):&

! "

! &"

0 " " E 33*2)**("

"" ! .

" " )****

)** # "):

& 6A

6 ,0

> "

& "

" N #7 + . -

3 "

& 3() 7( 6 ' ) * &

& &

' *

" '

& "

,1150119*& &

& &

221:0119 &

,21:0119 & &

*" &

& && &

' .( 6 &

1,190119 "

% 1,190119 &

> &

& *"

& &

& "

4 &

& 6

& &

#29 6

F& -

' 6 &

& &* "

,7 A

#202,012.-"

' 3*"

4 &"

& &

" %

)4 & "

* " "

& "

#,52 012.

& & & 4 ):"

&& &

4 B

& <& &*< *8

** * & &&*

& "

& 4"

011

% )&01

%" *

& B

* &&*&

* & & *

4 %"*

*6 * % 6 6 *

& - 4021901153"

& 4

*&&

$<6 & % &

&& &

6 6A"

C' 4

& ,. A

& &

&* "

F& -

&& & "

* " *

6 *

6A011:0115"

021901156 & &"

22C20150119

& "

211 & &> 0

% >

%" B

&" " 0.

%" % )&6 & 22C20150119"

6 ,5 &

,1150119*

& &6 &

+ '

6 & &

221:0119*

' &

)

&> &

201:0119 ,: 291:0119*

& ""

6 ,21:0119*

& &

,21:0119 6A

6 & ,9 &

& " "

6AF

6 F& "

& &" 6 &

6 *

& "

6AF& &6 *

" "

3"&

" ,/ ;

& &

" %

6 && "

#:7-

3 6 "

& A

& &

& " *

& " %

+ '

6 %

" %

# %

& " % & B

& &

' "

&* && &"

" 71 '> *

';'#,10,012.*

& (+ "6& (%*#" (5#%&&"" 5#!%& - 9 8

(%*#" -

% ) OC#

) OC#