National Insurance Comp. Ltd. v. Bimla And ORS.
!" ## $ % !&! '(! )*!+, ###**&&! -( '
.)#)&!
( ###/ * ! (0' 1+"
(##2#.()3
(**&&!#
(#.!
*5 &3
(( * ! % # !
6( 17 ( # ( &+ 3
( ! # # 93 7!
(:-7!
( ! & !0 ' (6 &!( ;(.!0 ('(!!0 )5!*'( (& !0 !(4!0 (0 ( !% #,,<= > 7!
(:-7!
(
(4!0 !( '(!0 '(
)*& +)!!
! ('
!(>1 '"*#)#! !(( &&
! ( !0 ( 5'(&3!)!&(' ?4!0 (0 ( ! % #;/99=@ 9 (! ( ( ((
!
!0
(' ?1!0 (4!1+/)/!A( * !% # !( !
!0&0!)!!(0 * !4 &
(
('& ) ) ** ( !!
1+0 !0 !( !0
( !( 1!0 (4!1+7!
(:-7!
(3 ( '&7!
(:-7!
( !
;(.!0( 4 )'&*&0(4 ' !7'( >!7'( ( () 4 ( ;
*&3 !*'(3( 7!
(:-7!
( ' ')1 !7'( '
( 1+)!( !!
&( 3( ;(.!0 ( (( 0(
( '(( ()!>
()&/(0( !1(!0% #
# # 9
(
! '!
(. ! $33@ 3@2 (0 ( 0! ( * !% # A/)/!3 (4(!
!(
!
!0(' ?# < *(!
7!
( : -7!
( ## .)#)&A) (!
.#/!.!0 ( 1( '0 &) * ! '!
( . ! ==
(- & 3 $ 0! ( * ! ##/)/!A (4( ') !(!
% !&! '(! )*!+! '((
!
!0(' ?# 3!* !3+ !!
0 1 '+( !
(?!0
4+0
4 &(!!0!) '!
/ #36*() !1 / #6 *(? 1!0 &+&& ! > &)! 1!0*(!
( *!
!'* ! (!!0 #<+*(+
/ #==& 10(! )# %
&) * ! 04! ( * ! # / * !% # !
**(3 ' *( #
B( ( * !% #A! '(! )*!+**( !
(!
)! ! !0 &) * ! ( !0 4( ' *(&)!(+
17 !!
!0!
'
!( &)!
1(!0 &)* !> &)!
!
4& ' !
* !> (4!0& ! * 1+( * !% # !4& !
!
4> &)* ! !
)!!1&!
) 1
(!
!7 !
(
! (+*( >() !
! '(! * & +(4 & 1 &4!0! '(!
)*!+ *+!+ !#!)( 3! '(! )*!+
! )(& ( ! ! &)* !3( (*!0 *& ?!!*(&)!(+ 17 !!
!0* !( !
&&' !( * !% # 0 & /(0 ( !
)(
(' ?!C' ! !
!4 &4 ! !!
&)! ( !
!& !+ !#.' ( * ! *(+
( ) &
&)* !# ! *& !0
*( 3
&& !0 ' (
() " # B( ! # # 9( '&!0!
7!
( : -7!
( .6 /! .!0 '(( ! '!
( !
!0&0! (4!0
4 &;/99=@ 91+( * !% # D 22# # B( &)! (!& ! *(+ 3 E!!
) )D22# # B(
!
!04 & !
& !04& !
4 (4!0& ! !
!!
4 &
@ 1!0 (4! ! 4 &
() !
! '(! * & +D2/# @# /& *( & 4 ! ! '** (
(( * 4 &) # ! '** (
( 3 &)!.)#)&0 ( )!( 2B 1 E)!!0/)1( 2B# ! (!
3( * !% #!
( *
*+
! '(! * & + FE#/ # ((!0(0')! 3<(1'!& ' % !
! 4 '(
&)! !
'% # 0! ( * !% ##/ '&!&+3 &)* ! * 1+ <(1'!&4 ( ## !
/ # @3@$36 ( &)! *+1&1+1 ( * ! 7 !&+!
4(&&+& !0!( : #9G*(!!')# &!000(4 1+ ( 3( * !% #A ! '(! )*!+ !**&1
( '(3!
04! ( * ! #/ * ! % # !
4*'!**(! ( '0 '! & !
( 17 ! ?!0 !! )!
!# 4( &(! '! &
(*( 1 0 !0 ( '0( ,(! '! &
(**&&!A! '(! )*!+
!!
<(1'!& ?!!
)
1 0( 3 '0 1&4!04(
&)!
9
(4(1+*(
!1'4!! !
)
&+0( 1/ #36*() !!+( 9 => '0!
()
;(+! H 4(!)! ,1 '( *()! !
# # 93)!)')0 !( *
!'! ?&& &1 '((( / # 3=6# B( &(! '! &
(( * ! 6 &)! '1) &)! *( 4 !( (! (4(3(
(3 !
) ?&& &1 '(( '& 41!
?!3 ! ()
;(+! H 4(!)! ,1 '( *()! # # 9 / #3 $ #$9 +/ #3 $6# ((!0(4& !! ! 3 !
<(1'!&1+ ) **( &
4 ! ( !0&+?! 1 &+ 0(#!)* (! & 0
! !
?
*& ! (4!0 !(3 0 (! (4(#< '((
( ! &)! 4*& !( *
*+
(4!0& !
FE#2@#*(' &
(4!0& ! 0
' (I (4 ,<-6;< # # @# 2B .)#)& ) (
0 ( &&+
(4( 1+ *(
4+ 0
4 & !
)*& + ! !(1(!0(0 ( !% #,,<=
! 1+5 !( (!0 )*!+3&#< '0 &)! *& !( ( (? ' 1+5 !( (!0 )*!+3&
7!
(:-7!
( (?!0
(4()0!0 &(+
/ #36*() !!
/ #6*(
= !01' ( !
(& '*
(( ! !
*( *(&+*( 4 ! 2( *( (
! (!3 ' ( !
** ! ! 1 E *( 4
')!#
+1 31'! !
( ') !
* ! ' (! (4(* !0 (4!0& ! (4 ,<-6;<-4 & #<<(1'!& &(&+ &&!(( (! 1&4!0 4
1
(( !!
*& ) (!!0 (
1!*& &#! *+
(4!0& ! 1!*& !( 3 ' *& ) ((!!0 ( !
(C'( 1*(
' #< ( !0&+ ?! 1 &+0(#; '& 41!?! 1 ?&&
*( !!
) !&+!
)
/ #3 $6!()
;(+! 4(!)!,1 '(*()!!
!( (( '*(# ' 3?4
1 (4(!
) !&+!
) 1/ #3 $6#<<(1'!& )
/ #9G
) !&+!
) ( ''(*( * #!()
' (+
!"## $"
%3!! & )*& + ( ! E &(+3!
@G 1) ( ''(*( * #.! !
*( 4 &
*()!!7 13(
(3!
9G ( !0&+) ( ''(*( * # ?!0
@G3) !&+!
)
) ' / # 3 6 $J9 $# .! 1 & (3 ! ()
(
' (+
& '
(
% )"## $" 39G ' ! 1 ) ( *( !&E*!
!0) !&+ *!
! +
&)! )
' / #=3 96 3 3!!'& *!
! + ) 1/ # 3$=6
=3 9E # <<(1'!& ?!0
1+( 3
) ! !
+ )
! ! (!0
1( )! ! ! (4!0& ! #<<(1'!& ' )'&*&(
!4
(
' (+
& '
(
"3 1! *( *(&+ **& #< & ) ' / # 39=36
3$=E
# <<(1'!& ( ')
/ #936 (
'!(&E*! 3/ # & &)! ! '!
&
& 4!
!##/ #3936#;
4(3!()
' (+
!"
## $"
% &)! (!& 0 ')
/ # 936 '!
&
3/ #@36 ( &
(')!
/ # 936 ( '!(& E*! # <' & ) '!
) / # 3=36 39=3J 93J@3J 93# <(
(3 **& 1+ ! '(! )*!+ && *(&+!
!( &)! ( ' ) / # @3@$3 / # 3=36#<!( 0(! !
(() !
(*+)!
! &&()! ) 04!!
( !4
1 4 ' !3 ( 17 1&
&)! 1!0 4
)( !
) ## $ (7
!"#$ %&"'
!()$* "&#
'# !+,
"&#