High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/65/2014dismissed

Punjab State Warehousing Corpn v. Baldev Singh & ORS

2022-03-17Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia,Mr. Justice Vikas Suri9 pages

!"#

$

%&$&'(( )*+

),"!

- --$. ,"!

- /0--

!" !

#

$ %!" !

#

&'!()!((!(*!(+!(, *,!-,!-. +, /&'0#*)(+ 1

!" !

#

&-!+!,!2!(*!('!-)!-+!-0++ /&''#*)(+

""

"#

"!

"

--$.1!2 3

4 # 5 /& '0''#*)(+"446 ##" 5

3

4 # 1 &*),.0#*)((! $ 4

#

! " (0()*)(* &(,0)# *)(* "

4 #" #

!"# # # &(,0)#*)(* 5

# # "

#

"

#

5

%!"

% ',7#

5

3 "4#

5

"

!

%5

# # 3 ##"

4

"

5 5 4

! -))'*)).! -()2*)((! -()0*)()! -((**))2 -(),*)((! 5 5"

%

8 "

!"#$ %& #

#'() *

+ (,-

.

'/ 01 '/ 2 $ ) &

&

!, # * .&

#

,-4 #53!"6

# # " *()'*)((5 5 "" # $ # 4 " &

! 5 4# %4 # 5 %"" # " # %# 6

#9 " %:"

! " 5

54 4 # ; $% &&'()*+ (3

2 44 "5+# 1 7* % 8 22 4 . $ ) ) &

9

4$ &$

,7 &.

#5/ &

&

.%& .

.& * )&)&

)

& # * ) #

9

*

# :

+

.

&

),7 &.

$)* $ 7 $

# *

.# ; <* 1 7* ;) ;

%

. 0 2

8, #1 7* & 5""+ = '+ 7 $

*

* 9

) #4

&

#

$) &

$ *) .

)

$& * &# .& $

# 4 . $ * &

.#. &

#4.. 4

) 6 &)$

# #&

#

.

$)* & # $ # *

%& #.

#

.

6 < !

%5 "

5# %= 1 !

> # ! "

5

#"" # 5 "" %!## )*)0*)(*5# 5 "

2 *

$ &

*) ) ## $

>- 5

4 & #& $ *

&

&

4 # #

# &

4

! 4

&

) 5/ &

&

# # #0 .# . 4 * & $&

#

.

# 1 7*

%&

4

&

) *$

&) # 9 *) ; <* %

0?1@A?A 1.

>%

0 >!'!5!6 < "

"

"

/ 1

%

! 1 "

5 4

(0()*)(* "" ##" "

! 4 #

" 5

!" #

55 " #

" # %"4 # 5

! "

"

" # " % 5 "" # " 4

# #"

"

%5 ## 4

"

% "

3 !#

" 5 " ! 5""

5

6

3

4 " # " # %

+ B

0 . # &

- .& ## # # 5/ &

&

.$& # 5'-5-!5! & *) ; <* % 2 &

$

##

# 4 & &

-.& 4 .

$ #$ & *

)

#.. * * # ; <* % *) &

-.& ;4

#

4$ &

-.& 4 .

$ .. # & # . $& & * # ; <* % #..$

# &

-.& 4

&

-.&

$$

. $&& *) #

& 53-3-!5 # &

- .& # . 4 . .$ . . 5'-5- !5! 9 *

;

)#

) ..

&

4&& . ' #

)

#

&& . *

.. 4

* * .

.$ $

*

6 <

5 " "

!

5 4

&*4 %?

5#" 5" "

*,),*))+

6 % "

$ 3 #

"

"

%5 % *))-*)(* <

"

9

0 %!

?

-()2*)((

# 4

#" *2((*)((@ 9

0%A5 5

54 "

%

43

0

@ 0 . @## B 5(!55#$ %& #

#'() *

"+',-$ ) &

&

!, # * . &

# 5+53',-4 #5"!556 9

5" 5

#" " "

4 ##

3 " 5

% ## # 4 =%$!

> & 54 5

%# 6

# ## 5 #9 "" #5 ## #

3

4

"" # "

"

$ 4 " "" ##" ##" #"

% 5 4

"%#

< "

%

1 !

" 5

# # 4 & 4

!*)((5

?

" 9

*3

2 & # #1 7* ;) ;

% 5'5!5!

%

1 A !3"'#!55@CB D$ #1 7*C@

4 . *

# &

& #$ A

$* !55 4 .. #

##

* & &B. 5!5

%&

5/&

&

$&)

# %& 4

*

4 E 3/&

&

#

%;A02F;;?

82A0?2AF;2A2 0?0>555!!5!

BAF2AF02?%@6

5" 5

4 4

(2((*)(-# 1 "" # #" 5 %-)-%

# 5 !5 "

" # " "" # #" # % < 4

"

5

4 "" # %%

(,)(*)(+"

# 54 #

53 "

4 4

&-),- -,)+#

* *)(, &-2()-2((#*)(,)')-*)(,"" # #"

"

!

#

!

"

! " " 4

3

" (,)(*)(.

G . # && &)# ##

#

4$ .

*

## . 4

9

. . >

4$ .

*

## . H

4$

9

&

.)#

9 ) .

) *

## . 7 55!!5" 1.&)# * &.

# .

. . 6 < "

! %##

# #

B?

! #

> # ),)**)(.> ##

3 ##

.$& # ; <*

% ##

*

# 4

# $&)

4$ .

*

## . 4

9

. .

$&)

4 .

*

## .

$&)

4

9

&

.) #

9 ) .

) *

## . . ##

,- + 2 &

$

$ $ . # 7

4 &

7 .

&

, $&)

. )

I )% .#&& %& # . 4 * &

. *) ; J* %6

# 5 5

$ "

4

%

"

%

5" "

;

94 !

&+4 %&

-((**))2

"

%

5 %*((**)((3 9 %5% #

. $ * . $ */ 0 $ 1

/

!"

5' 5"(( !

0

5(!55 !( !5!

5"!!"

%F04

5'!5 355"""

+ AD*

55!!( 5!5!!55 5!!!3 '

53!55 !3!!5!

5 5 5"

"

5

"

*)),4 " # 4(.22!(...

# 5 5 " %

"

# "

## 54 "4

"

"

" "4 "

!

#" " "4 "

! # 5 %5 # "

!

"

5

5 "" ##" 9 " ! 4 5

>

4

%

43 %! ## 9

5# 5 5 # 4 $ # 5

# " <

" # 4

5

% #

"#"

% #

"$#" %

" 5 %" 5 $ ##"5 #

## !# "

" "

#

5 "4 "" # !5

"

# # 4

% # #4

# "

4

# 4 > %! " "

" " $ 4 %

%!

5 %4

!

4 " !#%!

#"" % B&?C /< 1D?B> (,)-*)** =< D < : 1D?B>

: $ :&

:&