Rohan Kumar And ORS v. Ut Of Chandigarh And ORS

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH CRM-M Date of d M No.43312 of 2024 decision: 01.10.2024 ROHAN KUM U.T. OF CHAN CORAM: HO Present :

Mr M Mr MANISHA BA
  .... Petitioners MAR AND OTHERS

Versus

NDIGARH AND OTHERS .... Respondents ON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE MAN NISHA BATRA r. Sohrab Dhanda, Advocate for the petitioners.

s. Simsi Dhir Malhotra, APP, U.

.T., Chandigarh.

r. Kanwarpal Singh, Advocate fo or respondents No.2 to 5.

**** ATRA, J. (oral)  



 '    

!./   

       

 

   //!//!  

! +

  


+   "#

$%
& &   ' 

  

 

 + '

 .//!"#

$% & 2.

  (   0 //! 

 

' 

)

 1 

 

    )

 *  

 

  

 

   

   + 

 ('    #

   ,  )



+     



 

 -  '



  +   )

    '

    
 0//!

 

3312 of 2024 -2-   '  ' *

 ( 

 2 *

2 

 

   

   

 

 

  

  

 +  *(+   '  ' *

  

 (

'    

   ! 3 

  *     

/

4(

    ' *

 5 *(+ 

   (2  

 6   

' 

  

   

7

  '25 8' 

 "4 $ * +$!+
  

      " 1+$  ! $3$0 0  

  

   ! !  "#$%$

 

&' *    "4 $ * +$ !-$0!/01 

   (  *'2+

   ' ' (  

    

     

(

2    6++ +

2

    +
.9"&'

 



2  

  ' 

/ 

 

 +
0

"& 4 3    

     

(

 7

 '25 8'#$ 

*+ !  " )* +$ ,   4$+$$ $ !  "1+$ 

(, -.

. /011!)

2 

' ( +$ $ $  !   " 1+$

,       *'2  

  



  ( '     

 

3312 of 2024 -3- 

 

'2 

   ' 

2

(



 '6 (

 (   *' (  * 



 2   

 6

 

 



 9

$

  

 

 

7

  '25 8' 

  $!  " *0 13

 & &&*'2

 '

' (   * :
 

        

      

  



 

!" 

   

  #      

 

  

$

  

        %$&  & $'

  

       (#   &   



 )!    

 

 #&   ##

# $&   *    #$

 



   #$   (

 +,  #   # 

 



   #      # 

- .!/ "    +  ,        $ 



     #          +      0  $  +  ,      *

         

3312 of 2024 -4-  #

        $#    # $     # *     $(   #&

    .!!/ !/ 1           #     $



  #

 #    

  # $  - ./ '

  ./   $

     

  &   1 # (    *      

$'  .!!!

!!/ +          $  (        

 # 

 

 #&    #%       &   +           

 &+##&

  ##  $   #   #% % " 2 2  $& &

$# + # %      &    $  #&    $      $         .!3 3/ 4          #      # #& &  5#&#   ##&     #          #

3312 of 2024 -5- # #   #&  

# $

        #       #  .3/ 3/1 #( 

 *  (



  

$#&  $#%     # 

#     

    

'

( '

 #$

  $&

  #  .3!

3!/4 +  !"

" ###  &   

  

          $ ##& &       & &    # # *   * 

#   #& & $ 

  +   !" 6!7                ! # $     *

(   +

!"         %            ##

        # #         +  !"6      #$   *  $&  '

&

  

  '

&   #     #8#       $&

  

9 # '



 $&  # ##&$ 

 4  $

  #&

 * (



         

$#&          $#%!  

3312 of 2024 -6-   

     #  

   #  

  #   #$

$#   *  #    $    # # $      2        # $

&$&     #$       

#  &$    & &    #  .3!

3!!/1 #  ( (   + ,   

  ##& ##    # #&    ##  

         ##         *     & $ #$#     

 # 

   # 

8   ! 

$ 

    

     ##        $#:%   

    $   &      ##  & 

   *    

$ #( 

 $#& $    

     8#$ 4                 #  # #

          

  ##&   *    #    (       + + ,        

   #  #$     ##&         #

       

3312 of 2024 -7-   +  !" +##&       #&$& # 

           ##   $   *

      $      #  $  

   

#  

#    #&$$& & # *  

  +  !"  #&   

  

  

 

  

#&

  ;   ( 

  *    '



'  



'2 , )

 + (   

  7 

  '

(+ (  



  

 +

 

    

'7

(  

* 

  .

 * 

  5        *

  * * 



%  '      

 

!./  *

    

(

'    *

*

 

   7

 2 2

 

 *   *  5

 

  

 

   

    

$



7

*  

  *



2 

  5     

 * 

 *  '    

 2

  7

*

 

 

  





 



3312 of 2024 -8- * 



'     *

* 

     7

+

  

 



   *

 

  

(+  5    * *

7

   

 

  



$  ' 

5 8'

#$ 7



 0  $ $+ + !  "*0

13

('   / $!  " *0 13 

$

  ' 0 ( * 

  

 

 

  +

 





 

  * ' '   



         

 *  2 2   *

 '

     

 '2 7 

 

 *

  

2 

 '2 

  *  ' 

     7

+ *

    2 '7      

!./  # 

2+ 

 *   

 //!//!

!  

   ! +

  


+    ' 

 

 

 + 

'

  

 

'  0//!"#

$% &


 

 2

   

'

'2  

 

  '   , )

  (M MANISHA BATRA) 01.10.2024 JUDGE Jyoti-IV Whether speaking/reasoned:

Yes Whether reportable :

Yes s/No.

s/No