← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19479/2023allowed

Ranbir Singh v. State Of Haryana And Others

2025-12-24Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil25 pages

   



 !

"

 #   "  $

!

%

&&&&& '%( ) % % %  

 #  "

 %&

&&&&& %"'%(   *    + ,

&&&&& '%( ) % % %  

 #  "

 %&

&&&&& %"'%( -$ 

 * ) + ,

&&&&& '%( ) % % %  

 #  "



&&&&& %"'%( -  - * % + ,

&&&&& '%( ) % % %  

 #  "

 %&

&&&&& %"'%( - 

 - * . .% ") &&&&& '%( ) % %

%  

 #  "

&

&&&&& %"'%(  ,/ 0!. , &

% % " , ".

 

   

     

       

 

 

 

  

 !

  "

#  $ 

 " #

  ! %

&  " #

''''

% " , ".1 &'2 3( ( )  

  



*+ 

  

 ,

  -

 



*



   

! 

"

! .

 



*

   ../0..1



2

 

 

 

, 



  0   .( 3. .3.4 56 +(.7

   8  





*  

*  

!





   



  







 

!

* !  !

  

!

 

.:

 !

 * 

# $

 $% 





* !

 (;;<

!





 



  = "

# 

!

 3( (3 .3340(3 3. .33=



0 !+

!

   



43 3; .334 *,!     (< 3/ .3(= "   

" +

!     * *  9 

    

 !

*   * )   3( 3< .3(= 56 +47

   !

 

!

 *



 

 !

 !



 .3 3< .331 56 + =7





 8 .4<

:

#  >  9 

-!0  .3(< 

    

  .= 3; .3(< 56 +:7





? 8 (<41

.3(; 

 

.4 3( .3(;

56 +/7

 

 

>  @#& 

! 

 '"

>  

/  

     >

A      4( 3( .3(;

56 +17  





? 8 =(;3

.3.3 B (1 3. .3.3

 



 

A  56 +<7 

>  

( 

)

 

* +, -

' "



  3( 3< .3(=

  

>

A   

  (/ 34 .3..

 

!

  

 

A



        .( 3. .3.4 56 +(.7  

A   

4( 34 .3.4     !

  



A   

 * 





   C !

? 8 =(;3

.3.3  

 .= 3< .3.4

*!











 



<     

A 

* ! 



 *  





 >



*









    . 



/  ;

%  



*





  *!

 

!

 3( (3 .3340(3 3. .33=



   -  (;;<

*

+

 

!

(3 2

  *



   (< 3/ .3(=

    3( 3< .3(=  



!

 *   

!

* 9



  2





  9



>  !

 * 



*

 !

 >

A     

*



    

0 $ +1/, +

 *

*      .( 3. .3.4 56 +(.7  

!



  







*

 

 (( %  

 

   ! 







 *

 * 

 



*  

!

> * 

(.

2 !



 

 

  .= 3; .3(< 56 +:7  

 * !

     45 6 5 27

(4 %  

 

 *

  

!

  

 



 



 

 $ !

(;;<

!









!

  

 #



!

!

* 

 

  * 



 



(= %   *

!

 3( (3 .334 , !

   ,



43 3; .334

 *





  





* ,   

  

 .=3 !

2 

   !

!

  #  





  

  

 , 

  ,   





*

  !

!



  *  

- 





!





 , ,    



*



!

(:





*



      

1   3

2  

'

+ ,   "



).5

56

7

+ , $ ''"8   * 

 

!

   

+  !

    





  

 

  (/

2

 *



  



*   

   

  >

  !

!

*  !

 

 *



   

!



  *!



* 

(1 %  

  *

 





  !

 2







 





6   !

 





  

(< #  

*

 39: (;

 

!

*

  

*







  



  

 *    

!



 !

 



 , 2;: 6

772:

:

<::

22 : .3 -  >    

   ?

 

  ,  ,

!+* 6  !

 * * 

+

  

!





* !    

 6 

, !

.( 2 29 :

)

5 +*,  *"

6 



* 

  

   !



! >  6 





*    

 



 + 





     , !

   ..

?



 

 6 



 

     >  











   51

 7 6 

     





  

   

 

  



          

$1 !

 $ 1"

; .4 2

  !  



 !









D  





*

 ?



 !

      

   

    *

 

!

 * !

$    *!

 !

*

$ $ 1"



 !

 

  

 

 ,









 ,





>! * 



 *!





 .=  





* !     (=

(/



!

* !  

*  





 



!

*  



 #





 

 .33/ !

   0C

2 9

 0

0 0  0 !

! 

 

 * 

!



:3:;

=

">:

.:

2 .33/

 

 



< 9

)6 7 +

',   "

 ,

 !0

 0 0 !

! 2  

 !

)6 +1/,

   !

 

**0 9 

 

 !

  



 E )6 +1/,

 

 

 

!

  * 





D

  9

 !

,  



  

   !

  

   

+ 6





   





 



  

./ F  @+  G

*   

  

 2

< 9 =

;

< '

( % 1  

  



   



 6

!

*  !



*>





 F! 



 

(3 

  





!  



 

 



!

 !



  *  2





 



(3  (3 3= .33/  

     

  * 

 ,     9



  ;

< +1/, 6   !

 

  

6 

!

 @

G  





 

 * !

 + 6 !

  *    *  

  

!

!

 * !

   !



   !

! !    ! @ > 

    

 .1 2

 

A 

 !

!

 *

   !

  #  



   



 !

  





  *

 

  6





 

 !

  !

A      

!

   



 )   3( 3< .3(=

   !

 

!

 *





 

    F 

?+(<41+.3(;

     .4 3( .3(;

   

  



  

     

       

    

  

   

    

 



    

  



       

     !                "#$%%&$%'(  )

 * 

 +, * - 

 ./

0#(1     2 3%4%%%, 

            





 "

       5 .< #  

  



 





 



* 

 





    >  

 

 !

   4( 3( .3(;

56 +17  

D

6     7#/8 '%& $%'&   

 "#8 $%%& $%'(   

 %9'%$%': 

                

   

  4 

 $%'$%'&  

"#8 ':; $%'&  2 * + * -

   

    5 .;

*, 

  



? 8 =(;3

.3.3 B (1 3. .3.3

 



 

A  56 +<7 

>  

( 

)

 

* +, -

' "



  3( 3< .3(=



)  0   4

< 

=   >4?

   

                  !      * "

       * 8 8

 +, * @#  

 $%':.91*"

($



 %'%:$%'9./

0#1   

   

 5 #  

>  

 !

  (/ 34 .3..

 

!

     

    .( 3. .3.4 56 +(.7 



  

  !

 ! 

#   H !









  # & 

$>

8

 



*

   (;;<

4(  

   43 (3 .3.:





 "   

 .: 34 .3.4 56 +(.7     #

(; (( .3.:





 



* *   

     

 

 #&$8%

  



,



H6

 #&$8%

3. (. .3.:

 



4.



*



>





 

  





!

 

   

* 

  !

*> !

   )6 7 +1/,

;

<+1/,  A





 

  



  *!

 

> !

 

 



 !

  

 6 

 >



! >

 "

 ?*?   (; (3 .3.4    



.334

!

   )6 7 +1/, !

*  !

! *



6 

 !

 6 

* !





, !



   (/





 

 !  







    

    !



 



+ !



   

     

  



, !



, !

!

  

!   

    (= I (/5(7

 F

  

+

.$16 



  4       4



     

  

           

                .1/  4

    

   

  

   

  %''%$%% 

'%%$$%%9  A    - 

          4   





      

     

       







B        .91        " 6+     

   



    $%%

        4 "



     

   

         4     4 



   

   4

   (C   



        

  

  

 



   5 4= 



   

* 6

 

  > *

 

!

  

!



   

 



4:

   

  

 )6 7 +1/,

*, 

 



 

 !

 6 

!



 

 

+    ! 

 

  2 

+   !

 !

    





    

 

 

   

,





  *

  



! 2     !

!+

     +



+

 



!

:3<2 6 %  4/  > 

  9 



 

 



 

    ?

 6  

 

 @ 

 

G   

 *!

D   

   2 @(   .

=

14  .

  3// (

'

?

"  

 

!

  









 

 !



 9



    > 

*





 $  /

   "

  









   

 

6 

 

* 

0   *

    

   

*

 

    







*





 6 5 =739 : .<25  

!

J@

)

5 

08

  .; 

* ' 



 

)6 7 +1/,



 ! 

 

  !









   6 

> 



'%-  



   

  



  4



  D



    4  

0



  4 

                     

         

                   

                             '( 

  D

      

      

/

      

            > 

4   0

    4

 

4 

*  4                    !

          

 D               

      

 

!   EEEEEEEEEEEE '&6     

  D  



          

                      



  0



                    4     B  



  <    4   

4        

  $%6      

 @<.  1

 

    

 

   

 

  

*                    !

   

   

        



 B   - 4    

    

     

 F4F

     

     !



  

 

 

 

4

         

     

       #

 4

   4

        !

 B

   4 4      

     

 

      "

 +

?

> G+  @

  6

  H  > 34                  

   

  

     

       F

F    

          



 

    

          

  I

- F( 



    @<.  1 -"



 

 B 

4

    



    



     

              

       

       

  

    

      

 

  

 



  

  B 4   

      

  4              

      ! 

     

      @<.  1 ;               @  <  .  1  

     FF

FF

  

       

     

   

   

         2 

#  4

              

    

  0 

        F EEEEEEEEEEEE $$      

  

 4 0        4                   ! D 

 6    4             

              

       4   !   4  4

  *             0    !  



     

  A     

4            

  4 

  

        0     

           



 4



    

   

 

   

    

     



EEEEEEEEEEEE $3  6       

       

    4

     

4    

  0 

       



  

    



   

     

                         





             I •21

A-6/ !A ;%G      !

   4 4

   

   

         F

F   F

4F          *    

  !    

 4  4  

              4      !  •3 !

-6 %

  B 

      

4        

  

          

   !    

  4   B  

  •;$9

   %

    

  0  

    ! 

 4

 

4          

  4     

    4 



  B    •) .1 1$  %6 

              

  4   

  0  ! 



   

 

     0 

   

       



  

$ •7

#$   # %

       

         

  

4  4

 4 

      !      

  

  4   

  4 4        $(    @<.  1  

 !

  

 

    



    4       

       

          

                      

FF  

 FF  

   6          

  4       

 

   

      

 4   

  

 

  - 4           





   

      4    

  

4   !               A   

        @<.  1  

   

0   

  4



!    D 0 !

      

 



   



      D    



4    

         

 

      5 4< 

)

5 =

<

=4 3 . "8

* % .: % $   3= 3. .3.:

 

*

 )6 7 +1/,  

 > !

6  





  ! 

 

 !



$  6 



  

 * ? !@<4.$%%(19*""'      

 "

 * 884

 A 4.$%$3177*"'3

     

   0                     

!       

4;

 



@<.  1  



6 

 ! 

  

  

(  +1/,    

> * 9 

    







 



> 



 0 ! 

 * 



 



 

=3  @6 

)

   .

 + ,  ?'"

 >  

 

 )6 7 +1/,

 9

 !

  

(3  



   *  

!

*  





! 



 

    

  



!

 

  * 

  

4:

>  F3      

    

    %9%       

 /  !  

!    4

     4             

    A    



     

 "

 *4 * ? !H> @<$%%(.91*""'  "

    

 

    



         "

D

 4  

   4         6    4     !          6 





  



 

  

   4      

F =( 2 

* !





)6 7 B $ +1/, 



!

 +





 







!

0   0

0  0  !

  (3  

=.

  

 )6 +1/,  

!

 8  + , -

 

   

 



 !

  6 !

*

 !  



 !

  * 

 !

    !  *0,  

 

!

*  !

  *

!



*

* 

 

  

* 

 * 

2



 $3)     !



   

 

    

 ,

   A   *

 

  4      4            

   0      

     



   6   

4          ,

      

* 

   

      

,

 6   4



4 

 

4    





    





  !            !           ,

  *

4  

   

  

 

 J  

            

  

  

 4               

      

 

   0      

4  

      0   

 

        

   6 

 

         

 

      0 4 







   B  /'(     6   4  

    





  





  

 

    

  /  B 

 



 B





       6  

4  

  

      

  4          

          

   

B    

        

 

 

 

      

 *

 

    *    4

 

        4      

     

    



    4  

     



    

  6

  



            

    4   4  5 =4





  

+C 

  

!

*  *

> 

   *

     ,

  == F   



 > 

8<44 

!

?

+, - '

"

 !



 !

  2   6



!

 * !

  





 

 







,

 6 

   

2

 

9

 

  *> 

+







 

  *  

 +

!

    6  

 *

!

 , !





  



 

 



 

    

 

"3

.

5 =:

      



 



  !

 







 

 

 



  



  

  =/



  "

 

* 

!  

*

  

 !

  

 



 !

  !

 *    *

 ! 6 



    !   !

 !

*

  

 

!

2 

   6 



 !

 

  



 *!

 

!









 

  

 *    * 



  *

 

 



  *!









  

 !

 !





  * 

 



 



 *    * 



  *

 





+ *   !

 

 

   > 5 6

36 2 %  =1  

!

  *

 2  

 

   

$ >



A

 !



    A



B

 6 !

 

*



 5>7    5+!7

* 

 



!    

 " A 

*



     *!



 !

   !

 

 !



 

 

  

9 

 !



  * 

 ?





 

*    

 *



   *

  !

*   * 



*

   



 =<  

!

 *



  





  !



!

 * 

  

   



!

,  

  

 !



 

  + 6  )6 +1/,

6  ;

< +1/,    A   !

* @  G    6 

 

 



 

 





  

 



 *

 

>  (= I (/



2  !

!



* * !

   !

* !

 

 6

 

!   

 * 

! 







*



 



 

=;

2  





 

    



 !

   8  

6



  



   *  +





   6 * 

# 

 * 

 

  

6

       

  *

 

 *>

   3<: :3 F   

*

 



  

 





2 



* ₹



6 *



H6

 #&8% 

:3333

 

  

> *

# #



 

:( ?









*  



*!

 &    >

A  



!



 > 





  



 :.

 

*!

 9



 

  

!





 *   *  * 



.334

.3(( :4 #

 

 

*

 *

  



(3 

   .= (. .3.:  



 * 

:=  

   

 , *  

6

!

  



 K /L





  *    

 9  6

   

 





   !

>  ::



 57

!   

:/ 

 !







    '% " , ".( & & *

"    ! ,

IK ,8



 IK ,8