← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1685/2016dismissed

State Of Haryana And Others v. M/S Dlf Utilities Limited

2016-09-0510 pages

       !   

   

                         

                    "#$  $%&'&() *   !"# "$%&'( )!' ' *"'

 "$%&'( )!' '+ ' ,$   - # * . , /0 1 * / 

  /

     + , -    

 2   

 

 2  -  3

.$ 456 454

 74 &   3  

1 .

 9.8

  .(. 77  74 2



 :

 1 8 1

8. .

  3!



;;

  )  81/5<<:    

  %1% 2 18 2 !

 8    8 = 8  

1

;; = 1 3 2# >   

         

               

    

 

       

 

     

  

 

  

    



         





     

   

         

 

 

          

  

     !          

  " # $        !      % &  &    

  '

       

    

  

 &  ( &  ((()

&  &  #  *+,+) *+,+-  % .&        

           

 .

      &  

   /  

     01             - 01         

     

2 -   

 !

8 

  2

  

 :            6?/ 6@   </7</;?7@  1 0 

  0  .     8 :!

 3

.

8   2

  

 :  1         2 

;;

12 

  0 A 

 82   1 8 

 

  / !

 3

.

8 0 3B

  



1

 8/ 

 2 

 

?C@

12 1 .  03 0 A   

     1

  ;;  2   

 

0 A2   3      .  (.   1     1    

   .     8  

  1   .

0  3       1  

   

.1 

1 . . 0 3         0 A    

      1

?C@

1

 /    0 2B

9.8

  .(. 1   1!

2  8 2   2 = 9

 1



;;  ?C@3 / >3 1  

8D  .

 03  1 3   . (.  1 .    1

  ;; 

  1      0  3      1

  ?C@        8  

 



8

  .8/ 1 

             8   31    1 

  .       . 0   

  3     

  = 3!

/ . 3        3 1

8.

.

 . 

 , 0 1 1 

322      .8 1  0  1

?C@

18 3= 1  # >/0('#123$(#'2(4$15"62$478#9$4$"6#8&#7@ :)  )    .



.  "

1  

     .



1/<75/2  .



.   8  

.        3 0  0 

 

1  

/ 1 8 3/   3 

   8/8 / 

.



.1  8/    8 !

  



0 

1  

/ 

  1 8 3E     3   :  "  1  

  1  3@1

 :)/ 

  /    .

.           3



 

3 .      . B

 18   8 3 1

33 8   1/           

   

  

 

/  3  &  

         



 1  4   

  4              

  5     

   

             5

      

  4   6*,7+    

                               

   

    

       

                       

  

&                                                    

  

          -     

      

  "

   # &         

 

   0

. 6  6*,8/

 

    

    

       9   *,::    ;  *,87 <6

     & 

       /  





     

 =&

  > ?* 

  

    

       6 2 1 8 0   .

;; ?C@

 1  0   2    1     0  .        3   3    1 8  

  2 1      

3 1

18 11

;;8 2 

 8    8

 

   

 8    8    8 2 

= 8  1 0   8  1 2  8  2     

  0     1

8     1



 B

3 2 

12  82 

 =1 . .

 1

  .

       .1    1

2 38 B

  .

 

 (.

 !

 !

 = 8 

8 /

   A

   /   81 .

 0 3

   8      1  

    1 .       1 . !  F))

!  FFF)/

!



 - /5<5, / 20 / 1 1 2    1

8  



?C@2  18  

.



3

.



."

1 /2      

3 0 0 

  

1  

/  1 8 3/  3 

   8/ 8 /  .



. 1  8/    8 

  



0 

1  

/  1 8 3 !

  1 

1   1  /  .

.     3 

 

3 .

      . B

 18   8 3 1

3  3       1/       0  

 

 

    

1

 



1 

 3  33   3  1  )  8 2 !

  8

1 

    1

8)1

* 

.



.



  

1 2 9

 1

  

 

 

2 1 391@8 

  8 =   2   1 3 02    

 

.





   83@1

:?

1

?C@ 3   ..

0

 

  3

 

   3@1

  :  

 3@1

  :; 

   2  

 

8 



 3

 

   /   1

3

?C@  3   1

8 0  . 1

;;

1)     



 2 % 1   

. %3  3  .  %3 1  

8% 8     /  3  01 

 2 12  1 1  )       1

3     1    

  B

2  

.

  2 1   8 



        .

0

  .

   .   .  9 1     

;; 2 1 1  3 A 0   1  1

81

?C@ 

  2 1

0

 

 A   

 



   ..

0    1   0  3  1 .    .

    

.

  0 

   3  .8 

      11 9.81 3 1 

   

  



          / *0

 2(:"9 */ 1 8  .  3   1 3  1

1 

 * ,8     1 

.

2 1  031 38 1 .

 81   

 

  1

 1

?C@ 

1

  ;;   2 1 

 11   

.  2    .  B1



    /2

   3   8

 3 1/ 1 2  

3   03 B  . 2  3     1 .

  

?C@/

  0  . 1 



3 1 

  3

  2 

1 1

 1 2 3  

!

, 



 

.1 

1 .3

1   8 A 82 1 

 113 ,   1  1 

    1 13

 !

 2   1

;;2  @ 0  

  .8 

.

8 3 1 

     3 2 33 31 B1

1  8 8 3 1 

 

  9.8 &

 .2 9.8/28  1     

   2 1 03

3

    1 2 2 1 13

  . (. 2 3

 !

 1

;;2           2

  1   .

   3         1 .

?C@&  



.  0



    3   2 

 8     3

3 

  

C?  1 

3   2 12   1     8  : ' *"' ( *'

767< 74: '+ ' ,$  ( *'

 @ 

'A 

 B A9 @  

 B A9