Dharam Pal v. Subhash And ANR.
!"# $%& &'()(*+,-,)%. / 0$1$2 $3 44&33$*% 5) ,60$)0$*7$*%0&1 &)4*7&*%)
0$1$2 $3 &%(%(*&1 5 $*78$3$*7$*%0&1 &)4*7&*%) "+ 9 8" "8
!
"
#
!
$$$$$ "8. &" !'() !* !
+
)'*, !* -
.&
&
.
+
& *( *( !* , !
/
0"&
!, *, !* !
1 2"& % # " # .
0"&
2"& 4 15
*( * !**6
" - *- !* - &
" )
, 7 #&
*-*
&
8" "
0"& 2"&
-
#
0"& 2"&
& 9/ :;/('
:
"
&
"
&& < 4 5 1
. 4 "0 .5 -* *, 6=) >9
? "
"
"
.
+ .& =! 6@/ ,6!,@/ + +
0"
4
# 5
& !(=@/ + "
: "
" &"
+
:
/
, *- 66)
+ ." ".
; #
# &
." +
& 4 * *6 66(5 8" " ".
"&
&
".
, B "
# ""
.0
.
+
"
+ ."
+ > ; # ?
"
C 5 .&
,*
: "
4".
+
5
, *- 66) &
.&"
" "
.& &
+ & "
/
.
+ , 9
% 4 .5 6'' +
#
D "
; # "
6)(
+ &
+
& ."
.
6=- "
"
; #
" + .& "" ""
"
,*
) ;
) *- !**!
&
2"&
+
&+
"/
&
"
. "
6''
"
&
. "
:
"
-* *, 6=) ."
"
& / 4 ; # 5 " " @ 1
. ; # "
*) *- !*** &
7 "& ".
: "
.+ !
7 ; #
"
!
:
# 8"
.+
!
= : "
4+
"
.
"5
"&
+
, *- 66) "
( 1 ".
+ " &
.
/0
/0
<
#
#
; #
+
"
'
D
; #
4 ".
) * 66' &
#&
0"
>
8" ?
: "
#
; #
#
".
5 +
: "
/ 0 4. 5
4; # 5 &
&
!***@/
."
&
&
; #
: "
; #
."
+
8"
; # C " &
C
,*
" +
" .+
& B "
+ &
+
#&
#
&
;
*, !**-
" 4 "& " 5 + " -'6 66(
+& " +
2"&/ > +
F <
!
: "
".
<
-
"
9/:;
('
9
F <
, ".
& " F <
)
" " "
0"F < ".
=
0
/ 0
F < ".
(
.+
; #
+
7
F <
'
, *- 66) .
"
" <
; #
0" & & &
>; # ;
F ; # * ?
*
A
E
!
A
E)
A
+ 1
+&
& A
& +& "
!
"
!
# $%
!
&
!
' (
) *
+ #
, -
. $
/ + ++++
/ '+(++!
!
"
B"
"A . "
#/
C A
% 4 5
# "
"
: & " 1
+
+
".
4 * +5
+& "
/
#
0
0!
*
01!
.
0'
0'
#
0( 2
01(
3 01( ) 4
01( + * 2 ,
01(
: *
01(
01(
&
01(
*
01( *
01( !
#
01( '
01( '
* " *
01( ( #
0) 0+ $
01+
01+ -"
01+ #
01+
#
0
0+ *
0 0'
." !
B
&
2"& "
.
& + 4GA 65
-* *, 6=) "
+
1
. :
.
"
& / ".
; # / " !!- 66'@!***5 "&
."
; #
- &
C
"
"
C9
C
" +"
, 6''
"/
>, . &
4 5 "
&
& + "
4!5
&
+
"
& + "
4-5 &
/
"
"
.
4.5
" &
"
.
" +
" ?
:
2"&
+
. "
"
+
+
8"
.& +
"
"
."
"
+&
"
&
"
+
&
"
, *- 66) > & ."
?
, &
&
+
"
& 4GA -5 +&
& "
&
&
+
& "&
: & "
"
& "
B"
4 5 GA -
GA ,
+
"
.
+ .
& ) <
" "
GA (
"
" "
+
& + "&
"
"&
5 ."
"
" +
" GA ' +
GA 1 1!* " "
"
= "
&
+ " @ 1
.
1 GA 6 .
#&
+
8"
"/
" &
" +
( & ; #
"
.& " + (@/ 1
. "
"
:
"
8"
. 1
"
1
" 0
&
+
'
& 0"& " " %$%&
$;$)%0$*<$1 03(*-0
4!*** 4!5 2" 4 I 5 ,-) 45
3" 9 " $*7$ (*-0$*7$*%0&1<$2$1$(*(*-0 6)6 7 -(,
2"&
; # 4 " !!-@ 66'@!***5 "
.
" +
" 1
.
"
&
1
+
.
" "&
; # C ""
""
" +
D
""
0"
"
" + A " "
"
2"&
8"
4. & -'6@ 66(@!***5 + H "
!
4&
,-@!**-5 + +
+
-* *, 6=)
, *- 66) A"
"
"
.& & +
; #
A
0"
"
. "& +
; #
+ "
"
; #
!* 9 " " -'6@ 66(@!***
0"&
*( * !**6 >+ .
@
"
!
?
"
0"&
"
"&
&
. +"
"
2"&
+
"
" "
" -'6@ 66(@!***
#&
8"
"&
. 2"&
"
/&
" /"
0" " ; #
" +"
C +
!
"& .
" "
"
0"& #
& " 3(
17&1-& (*%<"0&*$<$$*7%0&1) : !**) #
=( ".
&
&
0"&
.
+ " & 0"& 1
& " "=)(160$(*-0$*7*)8%7<"=) &0$1(3$3 &*(
&1)0$7
66(4 5 " =
0"&
0"& " "
1&2(&1>1&8(2(%&7<?&1$3$%$%&$7 1$*)41%141$%(*. 66- "4!5 ,= "
"
& +" .
8" "
" +"
!!
3+& 0"&
0"& " &
&"
/ &
+& "
/
!-
4 !'() !* !5 . "
." -J
!6 *) !* !
.
" * *6 !* !
"
,-@!**- " !/"
&+
#&
*-*
.&& 0"&
/ :
&
&
4. & '* !**6@!* 5 . 1 2"&
&& 0"& 2"& *( * !**6 ."
&&
" -'6@ 66(@!*** "
&
"
+&
"
&
0"& "& +
&
" /"
"
!, 1 2"&
+
- *- !* - &"
" & +
45
4
/ C
5
!, *, !* ! ."
" "
"
"
#+& *6 !* ! A
8" )'*, !* -
- *- !* -
+ !'() !* !
!) 9 "
"
)'*, !* - "
!'() !* !5 ".
+ "
&
0"& !, *, !* ! !'() !* !
& . "
"
&
.
"
" "
0"&
&"
/&
" "
&
" @
&"
"
+" " . "
:
".8"
.
" "
&
&
-*) !* ! + -
!
&
*6 !* !
!= <
" "
& ".
".
@
&
&
'* !**6@!*
&
".8"
"
&
" "/
.
'* .
"
: " ".
1 2"& "&
"
&" &
&
!(
&
&"
"
"
0"& + " & '*
&
" &"
/&
" "/
+"
'*
+ +
0"&
C. " " 1( $*-$(5(*$>$-$1&243&$*7$*%0&1<"&&*$@)0(22$3 $*7%0&1)
4!* )5 - =!,
"
&
+"
.
" +"
" "
0"&
0"&
!'
&
+ :
& 1 2"&
: " - *- !* - &
4 )'*, !* -5 &"
"
B".
." +
&
&
*( * !**6 " "
4
!
!'() !* !5
A
&
." "
+" " @
, 7 6=-
+/ AB'3,)(* %(2& 41'&&7(*- (* ,1%C(%0,%;,1()7('%(* K4 5 : "&
"&
"& + " &
&
"
A" &
"
" &
"
0" "
# " " . 4!5 : "&
"&
"& +
" &
&
"
A" "
& " &
"
0" "
# " " . 4-5 + &
& " !
< LL:::
" 6*'
4) 6*'5 "./ 4 5
" &
" " "
< " & &"
"
0" " "
# " GA K 3 " //
A"& "&
& &
& "
. "H 4.5
&
"&
&H 45
0 "
"
# " + 0" ?
!6 "
. +" +
""&
+ " &
& "
.
&
".8" &
" ""
A"
:
@
&
"
&& " ; # 4 "5
"
+ "
+ +
"
.
&
&
&
0"&
& 4+
+
2"&5
&
+ "
"
!'() !* !
+
.
" "
." -
+ "
&
&" + " &&
:
."
" "
"
-*)@!* ! *6 !* ! +
*-*
"&
+ "&
"
!
& 0"&
" + " "
A 0" "
4 )'*, !* -5 " ) 7 + ,
&
"
&
-* < .
, 0"& " "
" %&&3 141$%(*
22())(*&1 &*%1$3 B'()& 4!* )5 ( )'
+/ >)*
!
"# $ ! " #
$
$ $ $
$
%$
&
% '
$ ( ) #
*$ $
*
( )
$
%
& % '
%&'%
( % #)% * + ,-.
# $/
( )
$
$
) $
( ) $+ 4
)* 5 0$)($2 0$(%$2$(*( 4 66'5 4!5 45 -
&
"
" :
&
& " .&&
" < !
" *-
" :
7
&
& ""
& 0"
" " . , 0"& & 0"&
" " ."
, 7
" .
&
""
& ." "
+
" +" " >
0" "
# " ?
& "./ 4!5
7
- 8" )'*, !* -
+
"& - *- !* - "
*-*
& -*) !* !
. 1 2"& #
& "
.
"
-!
& !'() !* !
0"& !, *, !* !
"&
0"& " & '*@!**6 +
" "
&
&
H
+
&
&
" "
" & "
+ "
&
. & '*@!**6@!*
&" + " &&
-- 8" "& 0"&
" !, *, !* !
#
"
&
& & "
. '*@!**6@!* -, :
.
" ."
/
0" " ; #
4 "&
& 5 " !!-@6'@!***
&
"
&
."& " <."
+
" +" #
" +
.&
"
&
"
% +" " & +
"
-) " )'*, !* -
!'() !* !
.
+
& -
--
.
"&"
!, !* =
!"8# @ #&@
D . D