← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/444/2015dismissed

K D Sharma v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2018-06-01Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari,Mr. Justice B.S. Walia17 pages



      

   !"# $% & '()*( ++,--(.# /,)"0" #(#,()1(.( #',)"  ,"+.2,.#"

  %3 

)0.4(-5( (.#',) ++,--(.#" /,)"0" #(#,()1(.( #',)"  ,"+.2,.#"

   63 

07'("''(.2,)'(0'(. ++,--(.# /,)"0" #(#,()1(.( #',)"  ,"+.2,.#"

/   3 

.58,)"(- ,259" ++,--(.# /,)"0" #(#,()1(.( #',)"  ,"+.2,.#"

/  6 

()5"''(.2,)-,9#).59" ++,--(.# /,)"0" #(#,()1(.( #',)"  ,"+.2,.#"



/   6: 

,#'5()*,.#" ++,--(.# /,)"0" #(#,()1(.( #',)"  ,"+.2,.#"

/   ::: 

0);# 5.<' ++,--(.# /,)"0" #(#,()1(.( #',)"  ,"+.2,.#"

/  66 

7,)5()*,.#" ++,--(.# /,)"0" #(#,()1(.( #',)"  ,"+.2,.#"

=   63 

(5)),"",) ++,--(.# /,)"0" #(#,()1(.( #',)"  ,"+.2,.#"

=  6 

,.#(--5.59 ++,--(.# /,)"0" #(#,()1(.( #',)"  ,"+.2,.#"



=   6>> 

(9'2,8( ?,,#0", ++,--(.# /,)"0" #(#,()1(.( #',)"  ,"+.2,.#"

=   %> 

*)5#(5-) ++,--(.# /,)"0" #(#,()1(.( #',)"  ,"+.2,.#"   !  @

     @

  4  

   

       ! "#    

$

   % %  !

#&   "  &!   

 "  '  "'   (  && 

     ) &#  *   )' " (+*    $ , - 

 &

&&   .

( .   && 

# " && 

 ') % * &  ) #  / *   0     

*#   %

"

  %&#"

 1#"%

     &

   23,224,5 .      " 6#" (  # 



(9#"! 2 - && 

   .        &#. 

 7%.86"!9&

" #"   

  7  +" 6" ! %. 

9 -       

:

%

- &&  . ( && 

    "#  -     &&     "#  & &  . #     

  %

  -   &

     

 .



 "   (   % "   %

     " %  %

 "   (   

#  ( 

.  "#   

. # (  &  (  &

 "   3 -  .;  & #    

      # " %.

%

   & &   .     &&    &#. . # (   %

% .    & 

#&  "&#.  .    (   -  

%  .      

#  ( :

 "  <    . 

 "  &#. # .   "(       #   &#.-   &#  (&#.&& 

. ( &       :%&  5 -   "         %.86" !

     +"86" ! %. 

     .# %%    #   &  +=4>>(,==?@    ( ,A  & 

(   #    244=   24,4  $ # (   &   (    "    #    #  .  %&   %  &  (   &#.   

  

#  &#   %

 "(#

" (



 &  (   "    # (%,==?-      #

      &%        # %

    %  

 .  #

   &&    1. 

#   (

  &#.   "    .



(      +   *"   #  ( +*

   %1 (         %

 : & (  &

&& 

  (( 

%

  #   "" 

#      " % .   %

.#   

 

# . ( # -  &

 

        

%

% .   % 

#  - 

#    &

&&         . ( && 

 >    &#  ( %%  %

(   "        +"6"!%.

 ,==?

    #    & 

(*  #. %

 B  0     !

 !      ,=A2 (  % (

%

    "   

      (  (   %

   # . 

# (  .

( (&#. " # #   . .

%  " "% &#

"

 #   :# "& $     %  ? )# "  &  (    &  . (      "  6#"    #  ( %  # %

    %    #   

    

   (   &   -      "  6#"  :%   ( # & 

            +,3A     (

(  "((  #   

       

                

 



           

  

    

 

    !

  "  #

$ 

         !



 

   

                 

  

 

     !

  



   

    

 % &&&'      

 

 

    

 '%       (')*  + 

     

 





  

   

         

      





  ) 

 

  

       

   



  

  

   



  

      +     

            

    

  

* )   

 +           

   



     !

     



        ,  -  "    .



   



        

      

 / 

       



        

                    

 

          





   

  ) 

 



 #      !   

   

      

    

      

 0       

    

 )

      1

        

 /          2* *' 

 

         

     1

       



 (   

      

 



   

     

/    



 )3 

 ( 4 +    

 

  



  

    +         

      

     

 5           

 -       

          

    (*6((6(  

        

!  "2             



/     . 

     

       

 

   

   #  -



       

 

   

    

      

 

   

   

 

         

         

      

             



   )* /               

      

         +   

  

       

    

        

   

 -                  

 +   

   

   

          #  -





 

       

              

  

 -  

     



         



  

              

   

         (*6((6(    

        

  )    

       



    





 

    

  

    

    

      

  

 

 

           

        

 !

                $

  -  &$

  -       1

                



          

    

                   

   

    5      

        

          

    

   

      +    

 

      + 

    -              - 

 

 

      

          

        

        

    

 

   

7     

         

         

        

       

  



       

         

    -       



     

   



          

  8 

 

        

     

  

   

    



 -     -



 A * "      .  (  "

 ( (       " 6#"     ( " # 

       )

    

   



     

 

     



     

     

     



               

      3

! "24, 



       



   #  -





  

        

      

  (*6((6(3

! "24  

     

   : .++,(-" C (   "  #

(  &   "

( 

  # "   . 

(  && 

  % ( 

&&  " 

 #  % %  # %

%   ( "  ,C4>24,C   &# . 

9"      

   0'   

- 

    $ -  $  ;

        

 

             

   &           )%        

    ,           



   

     





 0'      

      

 % 

   )%   - 

 

 

     

  

$ $            

(  

%        

  

 7         



    $ $   

  





                 3  4    !    )%   +





     

     

   

   

     8<     #     7

 

  

  

           

   

  



    

     #   7           3  4    !         

    



       

   

    !    #   7  +

  





  

 0  , 



 

       

   

 

          

        

/

  7  



 # -



 

    

        

  

/

         

-     ('6%(6=



          

    (66%(6= (6%(6=    



    

 

   

       

  

    

    +  

  ; 



 

 

                  

  

     

 ;

    



              



         

  



         

  < ('6%(6=    

   



         /    



 7    

   !



  

  4; ; ,

4;  >  

4,"5  

 : = # #

   (     #     &     

 #   &    & &  (   %%

 ( : ((        

#    

#    ,=4>24,C  %& 

 (  (  # * ".

   &  (   &   #

 (   && 

    &&      & #     

  

   #.%



#" && 

8) ' ) % * &     &#  .#  

 (   (

(  &     :

(,3A>     

&  (    && 

           #  # 

   .

 "   %

 ( A (    = (      

 %

((      # %

*   ( 



  

  

   & # &    (  

# .  ,3A> (      

 .  

     -    #

(    && 

   &#  &  .#  

 (   ,3A>(  ,4 &&  (%   #.%



% .   #

(

 &     (  &#. D#

  (%

&  & - % 

   &     & ()')%        

  .  ,3A> (   " "    

  %   (    /      

     &      & ()')%  (#&& 

   ."52,)(#5.! ,, -   &  (  .    %%

 . (  #  &# #

   ,C4>24,C .



    % EF<( 

(    -     #

     (    %  ((   344>24,C   &

  #

(&& 

 ( #

 ((

  /  " #"  

   ,2 -     #

 (    &

8     +*

#.%

   %  # %

  %   &

 # (%  (% "   %

. ')%* & (A(  0

  #"      (%> ,2( 

         (   #.   &  %

.    &  .  

 ,3A>( -     (   && 

   &     %  & #"  &&  

 ,3 -  :

 "#%

   .      

  

#

(  && 

8')%   && 

   % .   (,3A>( &&   &  

 %

 .

  %

 && .     #

    #

(  +* " 

%  # %

  %   . %   &  (   & (  && 

8') % .  

  "     

            &      *  (#   #.%

    (%   "  .  +* 

/) 

    

 ,3A>(    

        ( 

      "  6#"   %1   "          :&      # 

*    #.%

   &     #" %  # %

 .

 (   & E  ?   %  %   .

 &   && 

 "    "

 .     #

    #

(  +*

#.%

        %

 

   

  (  

  ( ,3A> (  .  %  #     %  (%   "  &

 :

   % G&   

   " 

 % & &  & 

    #. .   &      %

 (       (   (  &#.   -    #

(    #.%

  " G

 &

 (# #     .     (   &     "    %  # %

    #       

   

   && 

8') %<   &  

  " %

   

  .  " "     %

(

#  (&#. 

&    :

,3A>(  ,5 /    "  # 

#  

     

  %

  (  (%&     & # &       & ()')%   && 

< &   

      .  ,3A> (  (   &#&  ( 

#   ( G&#.(    %

  

(,3A>( (  ( (# (&#.  # #   "  (  .  "  .  . -  &# .# %  # %

  %   .

#. "  #  #%. ( % -  &

 & (#  .   %%

(   

  % . 

 #  .    # G

 %

#%

/ (      %  # %

 %  #       &  %  EF<

#.%

  #  & (        .     #  #%

   (  (  " #   "  &

  &

 (   "#  %  # %

  % 

- && 

   &

# "%  # %

- %  # %

  % 

 .# . % (%  " G

 &

 .

(#  #  .    #  %  -   &

G (%   "  .  /)  +* &  

(&& 



 .   &    . #      # G #  & %

(   "  %

    #

  (         -    # G #   & %

   :&    # %

   -       (# ((   (  "

((

% ##  " .       " 6#"   %     :&      # 

    

 . 

0 (')%* & #  

  &     8 &#  &        8    

.    %

  

  

  ( ,3A> (  .  %  #  (%   " G

  &

  /   

  ( # .  "    #.%

 % . 

 

 %  # %

  %  #. %  &     8 (

 && 

8')% (%  " &

%      && 

 ,> -    " 6#"    (  "

((

 "      

 .  ,?   #  %  ( " 

  B+555(24,>B+CA4(24,>B+?2A( 24,> B +A>, ( 24,> B +5?5 ( 24,> B +?=> ( 24,> B +=== ( 24,> B +5?? ( 24,> B +5?A ( 24,> B +5?> ( 24,> B +?33(24,> B+C3>(24,>  %

  - 

 #   &    254>24,> %  EF< (  .   &

8   (( (   &'# ) &# %%

  %.  "

  %& %

 (    &  %  # %

   %     &     : &      (

    .  ,3A> (     &    ) ') %< * &  & (  && 

   -  %  .     +*

  - 

 # D#"

.   # 

#     % " (,44?24,C  .   && 

 % 

  %

-   " (      . %  ( ,,4?24,C      +* # . 

     &

  (  

   &  

   

%   

    





?

 4   7   

&   @ 0 7  "   @ 0