← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1266/2018dismissed

National Insurance Co Ltd v. Sat Narayan And ORS

2020-01-21Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh9 pages



    



    

 

  !"

#

   !

 "  " $  % &"

' (  % ) 

 ( "

  "



 "# *"

  )  

   

 )   )  +

" ,"

-. "  ) 

 "

 

 /

 " 0  12

 3 "   %

 ) * ' "0"3 "  )       +". '

"

( +)"." * " 0 )565470 "

 " 68 

))"

/"  )    9 ")  :

 "

/ %  &"

 ' (    3"  % ) 

 ( "

 "   *"  

 ') 0" "

  3   "    0  (  ;3

//

<#7

=17 7>=6  0    2  )   25= "   " / "/   ?

")

/@5=  ) "

/    ) 

;) /  "    )   0 " "    " 3   7( 3 "  ; 3

/ /

 <#7=17 7>=6= +

" ," 

/  ;-. 3

/  (   "  / /  3 &;

/" 0"

" ;0 0 3 A')B/

0 ""

 C# 5 @5=    

 26  >57  $ +DE$ . 0  /

 0 " $     

 $  +%" ". *"    ) " "    0  /  >> 3 "  0"

""  0    "(  ) " "    0  

/  =47  ) " ) "



 *"  (  0   " 

/ ;

"  "  3 0"

"

  )" C#0 //



 

0 ""  

"  3  " )

*" *  )0



7  F""" @5= 

" 

')         "  / /   (

/   ; <#7=1 >=6=3

G?$$  F"""    )

 

0"E  )0")G?$$

> F"" " ("



 H  0  3

/  (

(  ")  

"



     G?$# 5 #  *"  E)

  $F770

" ;) $F7 ( ) DE$ DE$ ?

""" 

 " (

/



 DE# 0 " ;  #F7 (#  "  ; DE#  )  DE#>   DE#5 

   DE#=

  (DE#1(  " (

/

DE#2     "

 (  ?

 " " " 

 E)

(     DE#@   DE#6    "

   DE# *"        "  DE$' 

H "" ) / 

/ 0 3" *    

  " 

 "   07

 / ; " ) / 0C  "/ " 

 " " (;    C#" 3 //



 

 0 " "       ( " H )  )

0

/" 3)

" )/

 )

  

/"

30C#DE$      2>$DE$'"(3  ( " 

  

"

  

)



 " /

() )"



" 3   3"   *  " /

  

 "   )   "

( /

//   (" " / /  "  (  " 

/  ; *"

  ;

 ) $ %&'(%

%)*+,- ./-&0%(&+1.%&2-!03%&30,-.+  " 4#0"

"  "

"()0

/3 (

7   



 

   

   

 

      

     

 !

         

 

"

  

 

   # 

 !  

    

  $ 

  #   



#  

#   

  



     # ##     

 !

    

         #       !

   

  

 



       



             

  



#

 %&                

       '()*+,+-./+-01 -00,.0      1 2%  *   

  3  ,     # 

   

   '  5   (  %%    6 #

7      

 

     

        8             

  

 

         

   1 , .%

0 20!

    #    

        "

  $ 



  



   ( 

    # 

 # 

        !

 999 ! #!

 :



 

             

# ;  ! !

   "

  

 

 

 $  

         #   $#        "

   #"

  ! #

       

 0    <     "

   1 , 4 

, . 0;=   



  

      

 !



  

 

 :



 # #

  

        

     

    



  "



       

#

 0          >



 



?

          

   

     

     !

       



 !

            #    

#

  

 



 @ *" "  )  " 

 "   " " (;    / 

 0"

"

"3 ( "" 3  (3" *    

  " 

      " "  )  "    $F7 " "    0  /   >>   3 



" /"3  (  (" )

  

  " "  )"

 " "    0  0;

/     ;  (  ;

 ( 0 "

 )  (   3

/ 

  

 ("

 ;

 // ("/

/ =47  ) " 

 3 

    " 

   3 

3  A *"/") " " 3 /"3

("(  ;  (   "

 ) )  3 "       " )     DE$   DE$  // (  "   " "   0 )   (0"

"

   " /

, ;

3-'

( 0"

0 " 3) "  0"  

 (  0  

3 "" )  "))

"= 

3 

3 ""

/"

 "   A  *"   *  "  " )

 3 "

/""* 0 

0 ""

/   "  3=47 ) " "  

"

)3 ,

;

 3-   3 (   <  B( ) 

"0/ 32147 ) " ""



) 0  ;   3  647 0"

"

 "

/"  A   *"

 



"( 0"

" /""

(  "



0"A   3   "    

 "    "  

   

((

/ ) ("

    )    " " *  

 " " A

   

      "  )   "

(

  % "

  6@@ +  )    . 0

3   "  )  DE$   DE$   (  "   D(    

  " 

    "

   3     ;  3 " 

 "   )

 ( %("/

C# 

  "3 " /"3

("

(    "  "      "

 (   )3   ( 3" )

*"    0   3 " /   >>   *"    "    

"

  "0 " " 0    " )  ))3   0"

" "    " 

<"  3  (" 0"( 



))  "

0  ; E    ))

 0 " "

    0"

" "  

  A

 

3" *  *" *  "   /" 

 )

  1   " E

 "

0  ; )



( 0" )3 ))3  "34>

4 

3

/" " ""/  "( "  "  ) )

/""(3 0 "", "

 ) / -,

 - ,

(  )

"

- 0"

" 

) ) "

/

 "   

 "/   

( 0"



;

)

"

)  )

3 )   " "   

   

 3 H 0 "

)")  

    

   ( /   )

" 56547 

3



 A  / "

"

/"H 3 A

 "

 3

" ""0

 " 68 

))"

/"  )    9  " )  

  /   (    

  "

    (

"

"0"( )

 0   3 )  3 /    A  



( 3"

*"0

)

0 /

 " (    " 0   "      

 *"

3

/" 

0 ")  

)

   "   %&1%.5#

 F""

;

/4   I 4 F"" 3 I 4