High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/3907/2017dismissed

The New India Assurance Co Ltd v. Veerpal Kaur & ORS

2026-03-06Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja8 pages

(

)

/ &- &- &- &- +&-!-#!2

+&-!-#!2

"# $% !4 "# $% !4 "# $% !4 "# $% !4 56 56 56 56

- - - -) )A98 )A98 )A98 )A98-1 -1(9 (9 (9 (98 8 8 8: H5= : H5= : H5= : H5= I++

I++

+-!

"# $% & &'

"# $% !*+&-!-#!2

"# $% !*#+,-

- "# $% !*#+,-

- -!,0-+ &-1 "# $%

-!,0-+ &-1 "# $%

939( 939( 939( 939((9( (9( (9( (9(@

9@9999)(9(@ (9(@ (9(@ (9(@ -! .*

-! .*

-! .* 9@9999)(9(@ (9(@ (9(@ (9(@

!* *+&-!-#!2

*+&-!-#!2

#,,

-& & 1#,,"# $% !*

-& & 1#,,"# $% !* 04*1 !04-1 +&-!-#!2 4*1 !04-1 +&-!-#!2 04*1 !04-1 +&-!-#!2 4*1 !04-1 +&-!-#!2 !-

-! -1

-! -1 11#,, 11#,, 11#,, 11#,, - ++,*2

- ++,*2

- ++,*2 75 75 75 75 5 5 5 5

!6 5& 1-& 5& 5& 5 5 5 5 .*% !0# ,04 '-2

!# &% 4 '-2

,4 '-2

1-& 1-& +-!

! DDDD 4 4 4 4 +&

, .

!+&

.0 0 !E!#& -%+

*,*!$

89((98+

5--&22*

!, *% ,4 *!

:1-&-&4; ,<=4 .02-%+ *-!- # #!

(48(4999 9>E ,-!$ **!

F8G+

!!#%1&-%

-11*,*!$ $-1 *%+ **- -!*,,&

,*?

*-! .

-& +-!

!--/ -!

22-#!-1

-1 &*+ ,*!$*! %--&'

*2#,

((((

!4.

*!$ ,&

-1

&*+ ,*!

!$4 1*,

**-! #!

2*-!@@-1 5--& & 24ABB+,

-&C*!$ &E2#%E &-!&#2C- E9) )JE A3B !(393 (9@4 *, +&-2

*!$1&-%

%+#&

!C-4 * 2,

!.0 0& +-!

!-3E5 $

"*!

!% !!

-#-12-!&-,!

&#$*+#& - C &#2 2C *! ,,-1 -#

#11

%#,*+, *!"#&*

&#2 22#%.

- ))))

,4-! ++& 2* *-!-1

-22#&&

- -& &*'*!$-1 -11 *!$'

2-%+ *-!

!-*2

.-'

4 1 !*!$ "-* *! , ,* .*,*0 #+-!

&4- !

& 5 5 5 5

5 ////

2-#! , 1-& !>!#& -%+ *,

*%+#$!

+&*% &*,0-! $&-#!

4 - & ,,*!$ $*! -11 *!$'

*! 2*0-1 &> &4 !-1 ,, * *! %.*-1

K+& *-!;

!0+ &-!< 2-!

%+,

2*-!/8-1 24 1- -& ,* .*,*02-#, !-

#+-! &

1#& &2-!

+ & ,-

&-1

!*!L# *-!-22#&&

%+*!$- & 02

4 #4

!* , *!$&

! -1 & &*'*!$ 2-%+,

. !

2-#! ,- &$#

&*.#!

*! ,

*!$1##&

+&-+ 2 *, *!$ ,--1

!20 ,04*

#.%*

1#!

,.&

2 -1 **-!-1 +-,*20 0 4 2-! !,04

!>!#& -%+ !- -*!

!*10

5 5 5 5 /> /> /> /> 5 5 5 5

3333

2-#!

&*!$-!.

,1- 1& +-!

!--/M2,

#++-&

&*.

.#!

#.%*

#+- -! 2-&& 2 +&-+ ++& 2* *-! -1 -& ,,

-2#% &0

*, -!&

!-2 ,,1-& !0*!

* -#&

2-!

,0 & ,,*!$ *! -11 *!$'

*2 *! 2-#& -1* %+,-0% &E2#%E &*

4 2-#, !-.

$& #*-#+ !$ &N& &4*& &*C

#-&*,02 2-'

2*-!/8-1 5--& 24ABB4-

K !-1 ,* .*,*0 &**!$- %+,-0

2-#! ,1#& &$#

1*!

-1& &*'*!$&

#,0#++-&

-!& 2* ,*!

- &

0 2 !- .-,'

*% 4+ *2#, &,0 -#-12-!&-, &#2C *! -#

2-#! ,-#.%*

**-!- 1##& +&-+

&*$,0$&

*!'* -1 - !

!.0 -!P., #+& -#& -!P., #+& -#& -!P., #+& -#& -!P., #+& -#& &*! &*! &*! &*! *-!

, !#&

*-!

, !#&

*-!

, !#&

*-!

, !#&

-%+ !0 *%*

0 * - &

0 * - &4 2-%+ *-!

&*2,0*! 22-&

+&*!2*+,

,0 2-!

!- 2-$ ! -& &

!M !#& -%+ !0-+&-'

!0 *,,1#,-&1#!

,.&

2-1

**-! -1 *!#& +-,*20 4

4 ,

&*.#!

, &*$ ,0

,* .*,*0"-*!,0 ,,0#+-! &4- !

& H H H H H H H H @@@@

2-#! ,1-& &*

&E.--C-1 O O O O 8888

$-&*2 ,1*!

*!$

*! *-! -22#&&

-! 22-#! -1 & !

&*'*!$ -1 -11

4 *2 1*!

*!$ * #,0 .-&!

-# 1&-% % -& ,, -2#%

*, -! & * .0 !-

*! +&-2

&**!$-#-1 **-!#!

2*-!@@-1 24 L#*&

.,* *&2

-! -#2-!

-1+& +-!

-1+&-.

.*,** !-

-+*!$ & &*2

-1 +&--1 * & L L#*&

*! 2&*%*!

, &* , ! *'*, *'*, *'*, *'*, ++

,-()3 ++

,-()3 3B-1(99A 3B-1(99A 3B-1(99A 3B-1(99A &**!$-#-1 : : : : =-(B9-1(99@ =-(B9-1(99@ =-(B9-1(99@ =-(B9-1(99@*,

;*% ;*% ;*% ;*% *%, *%, *%, *%, '* ' *%

'* ' *%

& !+-& -&+-& 2

& !+-& -&+-& *-!< *-!< *-!< *-!< -!P., + K - -#&

#-&* ,0 &*2

-1+&-- 1*!-& L#*&

*!%--&

2, *%2 ,*2-%+

!- *2-!2,#*-!-! .

* -1

&* ,+,

-!& *%*, &,04*!*'

'*,++

,-(/AA '*,++

,-(/AAE(399-1(9 (399-1(9 (399-1(9 (399-1(9 (9B (9B (9B (9B

&**!$-#-1 :*'*,=-(B/ :*'*,=-(B/ :*'*,=-(B/ :*'*,=-(B/E/(-1(9 /(-1(9 /(-1(9 /(-1(9 (98 (98 (98 (98*,

;5 !$,

%' ;5 !$,

%' &* &* &* &* , !#& !#& !#& !#& - &< - &< - &< - &< * !-!E& $*& *-! - 2&*%*!

,2 -& 2L#* ,-1 !!-.

2-!2,#*'

1-&

&%*!*!$!

*!2, *%+&-2

*!$ 8 8 8 8! !2 2

'0'

!-#-12-!&-,

&#2C *!

-# .0 * ,1 2 -2&*!

-1 & *+ ,-L#*#&4 *2 ,,0 %

! ; *!$ +

C 1-& * ,1< +&*!2*+, * *!'-C

*! *# *-!

#& -1

!*# #2 * -#, !- -22#&

*! -& *!

&0 2-#& -1 ! *-# !

2*&2#% &

.,0+-*!- -1 &-!*!2-!&-, ,-1 !

*+&*!2*+, *

.#&

!*1#+-! &-

K+, *!

! -22#&&

C*!$ 2 2 #*-!

K+, *-!-#$ $-.

!1&-% !-#-12-!

&-, *,

%+*!$ $- & 02 !-*!

!0% !!

*+, *!1 -1 !

4 1 1-& &

-! * *!2#% %.

! #+-! & -1

%--&'

- -& $#,

*!+&-+ &2-!&-,- -%

-. &#2*-!-! &-

+& -1& 02 -! +#.,*2&-

* * ! #!1- -&

!-& ! #!

2*&2#% - - 2-%+,

K-!

& 1&-% #0 -1 2 !

! #24 2*&2#% 4 ,- -1 2-!&-, -'

& '

* ,1 *

%-!&

-1 , 2C -1 2 #*-!

-! !,04 1*!

*!$-1!

!- -#11 &1&-% !0*!1*&%*0 * .0 11*&%

O O O O

B B B B %*

& ,,*!$*!

-11 *!$$-- '

*! 2-#& -1

&**!$-#-1* %+,-0%

&E2#%E

4 !!-.

$& #*-#+ !$ &+ &-!-& ,,*!$ $*!

$-- 2 &&*

*!*2 2*0 %+,-0

*2-'

#-&0+-, ,*20 - K ! - -1 ,* .*,*0 1

+&-'**-! -1 %+,-0

P -%+ *-! 2 !*-!& *

-!.

,1-1 ! #2 2 &-! !- ,, **! %.*-1 K+ *-!;

!0+ &-!<-22#&&*!$ $*! 2*-!/8-1 5--& 24ABB* %*2-!2

2-!& &0-

+-**-! -1, !; *-!

,!#& ; *-!

,!#& - ' !*!$4< - ' !*!$4< - ' !*!$4< - ' !*!$4<& +-&

(99/ :)= (99/ :)= (99/ :)= (99/ :)= (A8 (A8 (A8 (A8 -!P., #+& -#& *!#& & * #-&*,0 ,*

- *!

%!*10 *!#&

*! & + 2 -1 *& E+ &0 &*C .#&

!- ,* *,,1#,.&

2-1 +-,*2 202-!

**-!,* L# ,0#+-! & 2-!

+ -1 ;*& + &0< &

#-&* *!

&+&

*-!

! *! ;

#+ * #& ;

#+ * #& &- %

* '

!"* *!

&- %

* '

!"* *!

&- %

* '

!"* *!

&- %

* '

!"* *!

!!*!$ H *!$ - '

4< +-&

A88 8)3 A88 8)3 A88 8)3 A88 8)3 *! *

-. &'

+-,*20 **!

-2-'

& &*C-1+ &- -!- &

&4 !0 0+ &-!& ,,*!$*! * 2-! !-1

- & !-

+ 2*1*2 ,,0 K2,#

4 -#,

,, **! %.*-1*& &0 0*! K-12- -%+#,-&0*!#& B B B B ! &-# P# *2* ,*2*-!

!*!$-1 -& Q*&

&0 &*CP .

!$* .

,- 6 ; *&

&0 *C & & - ,

,&#2#& *! *!#& *!# #& &*-!

&04 +-,*20-,

&* &04

.0- && *!$ $,* ,*$ !# -1'

2-!*

*%.0;*& &* < B( B( B( B(

&*'0 -#!2*, *! ;-$.0 ' ;-$.0 ' ;-$.0 ' ;-$.0 ' , 22*

*& #&

, 22*

*& #& , 22*

*& #&

, 22*

*& #&

-&+-& *-!4:A -&+-& *-!4:A -&+-& *-!4:A -&+-& *-!4:A A/)=(4< A/)=(4< A/)=(4< A/)=(4< ,-*!

&+&

-& 7*& &0&*C7*! ,*!

&+&

*! &-# 7 # *2* , *2*- -!

&0 !

1*!**-! $*'

! *! 2*-!/3-1 247*& &07*

1* 1*!

-*!2,#

&!% *& &0&*C+ +-,*202-'

&,* .*,** 1-&

-&*!"#&02 #

*& -! -&

-+&-+ &0-1 *& &0

&**!$-#-1 # -1 %- --& *& + &0 +-,*20 *4 4 *

& ! 2 -,*20N * 2-'

& .*,** &**!$ $1&-%*!"#&0-+ &-!-&+&-+ &0-1 *& &0-&1&-%

-1

*& &0 &* *!$-#-1 # -1 5--&

2 -,*20%

+-,*20 0 *2**#

!*!#&

-&0+&-'* **-!-1 2 B) B) B) B) ! ! 2 4

4 .

%+,-0

& ,,*!$ *! *! 2-!!

2*-! * -&C -1 - !

&4 L# ,0 1 ,, **!

$-&0-1

&-! - &*C* #-&*,0& L L#*&

2-'

-! !,04 &$#% !

*!-2-'

& K K+& *-!;

!0+ &-!<*

-1 &* * 22- -& *!$,0& "

O O O O O 5 O 5 O 5 O 5 AAAA&

L# !#%-12-%+ *-!

!4*-#&1*!

*!2-% -1

++,*

++&-+&*

%#,*+,*

L#**

#2*-!& &*2,0*! 22-&

+&*!2*+, $-'

&!*!$ 1*

**-! 1##& +&-+ 2 .

*!2-! -!

* - !

!.0 -!*#*-! !2-1 -!P., #+& -#&*!; *-!

,!#& ; *-!

,!#&

- ' 0 *4<

- ' 0 *4<& +-&

:(98= @ :(98= @ :(98= @ :(98= @ @B9 @B9 @B9 @B9 *! * .

#-&* ,0 #2

**-! * !

&0 2-%+-!

! *,

&%*!*!$ ,- -1

!20 *C *

2*-!-1 %#,*+,*

#2*-!- + &-!

,*'*!$ K+ *! #!

* +

& , - ! *! ; &, &%

; &, &%

' < < < <& +-&

(99A:)= :*'*,=88 (99A:)= :*'*,=88 (99A:)= :*'*,=88 (99A:)= :*'*,=88

2-#! ,1-& !-.

- -+-*!-# &*% *2 ,%* * -& !0, ,*!1*&%*0*! 2-%+# *-!-1 2-%+ *-!-%

,*& - +,

-1 .&

2 -1 +-,*2 20 2-!

**-!4 K2 + 1-& & **!

!$ .

$# &*-!4 !- 2-$ !4 &

-& 11*&%

! .&-#$ -! & .0

!M!#&

-%+ !0- .,* &-1 -11 *!$'

* *2,

!--, *!$ $ 2*'

&*'*!$, ,*2 !*% -& !02 2-!2*-# *,1#,'*-, *-!- -1 **-!-1 +-,*20 0-! &-1

&%-1 - !.0 -!P., #+& -#&*! !*!$P2

!*!$P2

:#+& =4 :#+& =4 :#+& =4 :#+& =4 .#&

!-+&-'

# #2 .&

2L# ,0 0,* #+-! &4 *! . -1 !0#2+&--14 #-&0 ,* .*,* 0 - *!

%!*10 *!#&

!!- .

! '* -1 $-*!$ *2# *-!4*-#&*-1 2-!*

-+*!*-!

,*.

#+-! 2-&& 2 ++& 2* *-!-1

++,*2

,+&*!2*+, !-#11 &1&-% !0*,, ,*04+ &'

&*0 0-&

&* ,*&& $#,

&*0 !*!$*!

&1 *! +&

, 9 9 9 9-!

!,04 +&

-1% &** .0 *%*

89((98 +

5--& 22*

! , *% ,4 *!

* .0#+ *!-- %-#!

4*1!- ,&

4 ,,.

*.#&

- !>& +-!

!--/*! 22-&

2-!

**-! , - ! .0 ,

&*.#!

, ,, +

++,*2 *-!4*1

!04 ,- *+-

-1 : 5 = : 5 = : 5 = : 5 = &2 &2 &2 &29@4(9( 4(9( 4(9( 4(9(@ *C

C*!$>&

&& +-& >-