High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2908/2012disposed of

Makhan Singh v. Pritam Singh

2019-03-26Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan8 pages

! "#! $

%%&& '"# (")! "#! $

% ("

* +!",- " %%&&

)"",- " "%

....

/! -0 (")! !"11 %"&1&!! )1"! "+ 23 ,2 43 # -&&! 5 5&, 6 & 6" 6", )"", %&! &)",0 "-& 0 0"!#&% 247#"# "+ 23

7#"# "+ 43 ""# "

6 & "+ 23 2 43 8 &%& 1"! "#)1", 09 " #% &)#"! &)"&1&!! %& 0 #9"! :&!!!"- %& " ;#"1909&! -&#

%%"&0") ! #,"!%"&)"918 %& "0 #&< #0%"%"&9-&#" %#"%;#"8#"< "!&&9/! 00" & = ! )0 #! < )# "%0-#" #! < /! -&-#% ! , )# "!"0< /! -"!" & >

> &&&# "+

# 2 4 # 4 "#) 4,3 (")! ? )! = 32 " # "

! ? )! = 32 "< #17#&9 #! && )"&&1"! "+ 2- "!"&

4(")! "

,3< (")! %"% &0"< 1#" &) &""% #&< %&"#! & -!"# #!1#&! %"%"9%# "&< %& 11"-! "! "#1# "918< %&&!0 #!

&&#-&9! &%"19)%&!(")! %"9)#0 "!"%" 1 #!

")!&&!, %"9")& #

%&! %", &&0! # 0" ")

@ " %&&"%%"9"A ((

@ "%& !"0 #&(") ! 1!0"%&" #& %#" ) "#! "!"& >

B A (

@ "#%"%"&9-&#" %#"%;#" 8#"A (

@ " 10"! )#%"0" &&!&&9A (

B""%"- , %&! ) "" (@ 1 =)! ; ! (@,

! 0"! ,(0"C&7(@ , C"1 8! (@2, /&-! (@4,

8! (@

" , =) 5#&0 ! @ , C"1 8! @, 5 )"! @ , C"1"! @2, (0! @4, C"0"

! @ , (")! @>, D0"! @, 5#&0! @, $ 1"! @ , #1! !

@ , 6") ! @ , (") ! @ ,

2 $1 ! @ 2 D!-! @ 4

" "!&"#&" %", "&;#" #+ ! %&,#+

! , # + 2 ! #&&9, # %&0) 6 0-8#!)"

:&! !!"- 19 8#!) ", %& &%%& ;#""D#!,6"6" 0 0!&"D#!,6"6",0 - 8#!)"4 ) )

/!0 8#!)"%19 ;#"1&0, %& " ;#"19 09&!"!#&"%%&%"9! )1%, )%#!8#!)"%19 ;#"1&01 # %&1"

!! "!#&" %%&, "%3 %%"1" ;#" "#! #&

B%") " "% =%" 1!"%"19 &!&"%"-

B - "&"#&" %"1!! "#! ""B %#7# 1 %"%"%%"%")"

6 %& &) )& 1 0" 5 " + 23 , 2 43 # -&&!55&,0 " 10" 8!& -! "

4 + 23 2 "! %&, " #% 247#" &#5 "+ 23

7#"&# "+ 43"-&") )""%" 6 "&;#" "8 )""%"

6 %& =) ; ! ,(0"(@ ,0 %"# "E) " 9"24%9"%"+ >2

4 (@

! 0" ! , (0" C&7 -&&!

" %

4, &!0 C"1 8! , 5#! ! % )" & 1"! " + 23,2 43019

! /! )""%"0""%"+ >2 " 9"

24 C"1 8! , 5#!%%"!(@2 %%& ! 6 &",0 0)" ), ! %""#)" "#)1"7#)!"9 "& + >2 (@4/&-! (@ 8! %"!"!

-!"&&!&"#-" &%& )#"! &)"&

6 "&;#" "8 "%" 5#!" &&0!"

8)1 " 9" F= " + 43 1""0" % !

/! 1##"*" #)" " 5#! 1&0 "!" "" & 0 )0 0%

)#") 1""##!G"1<

5#! )#" "%"%"8! #%"%"9<

- #%"%"91"! "+ 23 0&19 # ! -#" (") ! , ""

! 0&0 9"! ,&"" "#)1"-0)#+ -!1" 1= !)19/! -#" # ! <

- %"%"%"#"0&&019(@2C"1 8! , 5#!0 &""# )" $"&"D#!,6"6"%%& !"0 "&;#" "!" #! %"+ & #+ 2/

!" 0-#"

%&! /# 19&#!! ) )&10"!#&%"1&!! %& 6 %%&&;#" #" "1"- 1& )&10" %"%"9%# %="&)19 %&, %& ")9&#"%" /# &0"%%&&;#"&! 0"), ) #)

> %" -!%&)# 1 ", #! &&!!&!&9! 0# ) 6 &0"%%&&;#" """H:"/"H%& ""F= ( ,"#&0 #" & %0 #1H; HH*" #)"H1# #)0 "8" " )1!#"!%9 # C0-", " "&;#"" ;#"&" D#!,6"6" #! %"%"%%"%"! & )"!"%"%"&8# "-"9 10 %"

B)9"-00#&1 "8#, %"%"%%"%",&&9 %#10 %", &!)" "#! ;#"

6 8#!)"%19 ;#"1&0" "19,0 "#& ") "&;#" 0 " %% ) " -# " -!

=%" ""9! # )" %"""1&9 " 6 &"3+16 &"- %""9# )" "#)1" 7# %" C! ;#" "#& "" "#:&;))",(#81%9)7# 19 %&,0 1")19 "&;#" # " &&- %"!-!#1 %" ""9#)"#1)! "%" ;#" 6 ;#" )9 &&0 &! 18, 9, 19 !!"- %"9 "" =) # "-# " 0 "

"!1 %" " 19!-!#0 !

6 %"""%%"1" "&;#"

@ 1- 1"-, %%& % "!&9

/"8

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#