← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/719/2014dismissed

Anil Kumar v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2022-04-06Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia,Mr. Justice Vikas Suri14 pages



   

!"#$!$%&'   



            

   &  (  )))*  (  )+,))

 

 



    

 



    

  

))-%$.-/-0#- 1 2-0 

   

  

 !

   "# "# $"%&

()*+ ,,,"$"%%  (

  '  - 

 !

     "# ".

$"%"/ 0

1$2 '  (

( 3

 4 ' 

 '



5  '



 '  6 $/(27#    ) / 7

2 %8,6/  9%8,6  92

'   #%%/$2/(2 ):  $

-

       '  

    '    3

   4              '      ;:  + ,6    $& "& $"%"  &.% #.& #6<=:) (



      

     

     (

 

       3   4 > '    ''

'  

  ''  -  

 

33  %< "$ $"%" %8 "$ $"%" 

   

- '

 ) 1? ::: 

'

 

  

 '

 '  (        

    

%8 "& $"%" $"

"& $"%"  

   $$ "& $"%"

-    ;:' 

 

  ' 

    (           '

 ' 

 $& "& $"%"

-  '  

 

 (   





 @

  '    '  

'        '   

 ( '

 

 

       

'  ( '     

  



0 

-

    

 '  

 '    

 5  '  '       '  '(    

#

) 

   (    

   

 (

(   

 '  

   

(  

   (  

 A :    (   

 !

    '  

   

343 A   (-0/#%$!2)#%5.+6)7-7! 8%9-:-%$ 7.!26(1  '    )  ;;1 

  (        

   '  !

  A  

0)   (-6/-%7)#%5.+6)7-7! 8%9-:-%$7.!26(1  ) 4'1 

      A 

 !

A (  

 (

  

 

 

  

&

)        (      ( '  

 !

A            



        

        3  =   A  =(  )  ( $-<%-7.#2=!< +6.!#2!"72!%!2-01!%72-0%$8672#-0)!"82#7< 2"!1 ) !-$>8-27!26-%$7.!26(1  ) ;1(  '    

   (

   -   '   ' 

 (

 (      5  

     



'    

'  (  '

    1 0    -



  



   ( 

 

       A  ( 3  =        )    (-0:#2  )#%5.  +6  !%72-0 $?#%#672-7#@!2#:8%-01.-%$#5-2.!%".1.-%$#5-2.(1

3

 )A;1'

        '     - (    '  

'

   (

    

 

    1 0      

    5   '     

    (

 

    



    (

    A      (#2!"721  -@$-<-  +#$<-0-<- )-?#7#+6-::-% 2-6-$-$-@(1  4);'A-  

  1 B& - - ( 



  





 

  5 

 %& ))  (

'

 



        (  

   

     - ( 

    

     A     9(   

) 



   3

+        = ((   C  C  $""& /$2)D4&""

- - (    



'5     ,%/=2  4 )  '( '

  

 

5

 '( D  99( 

 )  -  - (          

          '= ((   C  9  /

2 (

  

 

.

*



  

 1

     

 '   

        : (    

 

 

    

   

 1

 '



3;3           -          

5

             '

      

 

    1 0      

  5 '  

 (

 

     :  (     

 5  (

   

'

(  5      

      

 ' 

    -  

 



5

 (              

  '  

 5     ' %& )) :

. A = ((    C  9  /

/

29( 

)   ' '    

    '



 ' 5  E.

 

5

 ) (    

1    '

   

 -



/%2  5 F8$2     5    

 

'    

 F/#2    3

 (   5    

 ' 

   F/&2    3

 ' 

  5    (

 (                   

    F  /.2



 '

 

  

  E < *   (  

   

 

'

 



   ' @ ( - (  

           

 1



    

  (      3

3'3 .

:    '  (

(   A                

   

  

  '   5   

 "8 %"

$"%"/ 0

1#2  -    

  

(

 ( 

 !

 (   

  ''  

 '  -

   -  

      ' 

 ( (   ) $% "8 $"%"

  

$< "& $"%"



 @  

    

    

( 

 '



  

  H       ) (  

   0      <



 

  

  ' ' %% "# $"%.

' ' 

1 B3    



    )      (

  ;:  + ,6    $& "& $"%"       &.%  #.&    #6<  :)



                   "8 %"

$"%"  (        !

    '  

*  

       

 =     A        /

 2     (

  5

*      5  '



 



 /   2    @         

33 ( 

  



      

         3

     

    5        ' 

     '



    5   

 '( 

  0  



A  #"

$"%.

        

 

     

D+ ,86#$"%.

   '   $.

"# $"%.

(

'   



'  '   #"

"8 $"%< -



  '  A  '  ()  

   A   %"

".

$"%< -

'     ) 

  + %""6.    $"%<  '        ' '   $.

%% $"%8/ 0

1<2  

     



 ,

:    

 

 5   (

                 '       

 ( 

    3   )

 ) * 

   

  

    '(

A      

 

   '    '  (     

-

  6 $/(2 %8,6  

 (   

     #%%/$2/(2

3A3 ):

  1 B6 :5 ( 

   

  /%2*

A 

 (   /:5 2  %,."

    A

  (   

'   

 (        (

   

 (

'     

(  @ 



/$2-

' 

 @    (

      

 

'  (    '

 



'    

' 

 

(         '  

 @     

               (

5

  ' 

 (    '

        

'    

     '  

 (  

 

  :         '    (

 



 

  

5  (  '     (

   

 

  -



 (A    ( (1

 /#2 (    0  ' 

 

   '  

  '

   >   

5  

(

'



       '  -

          

            





  1 / 2 ( 

    



 @  

     

  (

 



33   /(2

 

 (1    

'

  A

 

(    



  '          

    '



 

   @       

 (

('





 (

 (   

'    

(  @ 

 

                  

  

          

     

F

00000000000000000000000000000000000 B#%% 3 

 

  @



     H   

/%2+

'  (     H   1:            H      (  

 (   (     ('  ' 



/$2+ 

  

  ( 

 

  @

   5  '   (

   

    

 (

 ( 



      

        '

   

   5      

   

  (   ( 

      5   (

  

 

 @

 

 

  

     

1 / 2'

 

 



  @

  '          

F

33 /(2  '

      '

   

  

 

  @     

 (

(         '



      

 (

 (  5 F

/ 2'



  

     (

    

    

   5 

/#2: 

  

  

  5   ' 

 (

 (   5  

   /$2  

    '



  

 

  @ (  G

%"

*   0  

   ) 

   ' ' ' 

'           (      

   3

    

'  3



''

  ' 

  :(    

'   "# "8 $"%"      ' ' 

"8 %"

$"%"       



     '  5 :

 

  '  '

      '   '(    - -  )    

   D



  ' ' '   ' (

  

        '

%%

:-::-% 2-6-$-$-@ 68B2- 1 

0)  

    ) '

  

33             (

       '  

  5 ' '    

  '    (

   

 - - (    

 

  )

 



 5   





 

 - 

0)      '  ) (     

  '

   '

 

  5   -    (    5    

 '    ' 

  5    (

  (       

 '

 

' 

    

  A 

    B6 *

 '   ) 



   - (  -  5



  '    ( 

 

-     

   

5

             (         

   '

   

 -



/%2    5  /$2     5     

 

'   

 /#2    3

 (     5    

 ' 

  

F/&2    3

 ' 

         5          

(

 (           

       F/.2

33

   

    '

    

     

  %$

:

 

   (

3

'

           '  (

    -

     '  '

   

(

    

   '

         ' ) 1?(  %6

    ( %% "8 %88#

 

 '  ) 1:::

:  (

 ( 

 !

      '   (

:     

 

       0  

   



  

 ' 

  5      ' '





%#

:   

  '    ( 

-  )       

   

  

  

  5   '      (

 

          "% ".

$"%"

/ 0

1%2 : (

     3    

   ' (



   

 >   '  

 

 



   ( @(  @                           (

343 %&

:

   

 '(

'  (     

    (

  5   '   '       

       @  



-   A  

(     '         

:    

)   

    ' @ ( )   =   -0:#2)#%5.(6"-6! 68B2- ' ( 

 (        

 

 %.

-  A      -0/#%$!2  )#%5.(6  "-6!

68B2- '   

      '   

   

(  '  (  ;:

  #6<7."<:) ' '

 '      #%%/$2/(2 ) :

( 

  5  (



 ' : '      '    '(   

  5   '   

- 

0) -6/-%7)#%5.(6"-6! 68B2-     

(

'

 

     5 

 (

  5    

         5 

 (

 (    

'

0 -

 (  (

A

( 3

 4  : (   

 

3     '  (

      '    (

 ( -  )    '  @       

 (  @  

;:  (



- 

   

'  (    

          3

    4         

0 A  

 ' 

  5  

 %8,6 

'   #%%/$2/(2  ): -    (             

   





 !

 (     

%<    '

 

  



     

      

    

 ))*   

+,))

  B2#0'1  

* 

@ I

  I+ * 

 (  I+