Chief Engineer (Nh), Punjab Pwd (B&R) And Another v. M/S C&C Construction Company Ltd. And Others
!""#$%$&'() *$"&+$&"", - .&/ 0 1 &,
2%&%!,.#!$&%34 &56!7 ,% '( 86
9919 ! "# ! $ % &&& 919-
' %! ( )*+, - )./ , (( ( 0 1 (*( # 232332$4 ! 5 67 )3, ! % $889 ! # 3:5$2532$6)9, ' ! ( # ((!
! -
! ( !" .
' * ; (' )*;',!< ! !
62$$3229% # < ( # #< (3= ! ! # # 23$$3229 > >; $889! ! (?# @
.
(A %
- @ % $889 )! >% $889>, # # $889 )#!26$$$88:, $=!.
( A %
- @ ) ( ! B % !
, $889)! >.A%- $889>, -! . <
# !
! !
(!
!!# @ 33!.A%- $889 @#
!! ! 0
!
# ! D ( E D% % E#
!
!% $889%
$88= *! 93322= '
% # !
! # #-! . !
!.A%- $889( !
.
(/ A %
- @ ) ( ! B % !
,
<
!# 72/
93!.A%- $889
*! 2$$2322= '
$$$$322= !.A%- $889 .A%-
322=% $889%
$88= !
(
! +# -! . $= ! #
# ! !
(
!! #
*! 62273228; !
@ ! #! $$$$322=.
(
! # #!62273228
# # # # <
#!322=3224; !
% $889 #%
$88=!
%
D
% E# !
# !
# @
(
@( #
% !
( ! (%
#-! . '! 322=
#! $$$$322= -
(% F$G!
( ! % # # % ! '
(
# # 3:$232$6# !% !
0
% # #
!
( ! % 0 ! ( 0 1 ( # # # # ( *$
# H
I !
!
.
(A %
- @
% $889) ! !
% $889,+ ( ! !
265$$5$88:
$889 )#! 265$$5$88:, #
# #!23$$3229 (
H
I!
!! !H
I; ( ( +I %
, 0* : , "775 &7 #34 &5 ;",%.% 9! !"
7*5 , 7"%* &7!*",% < 9.4,"3".,!# %"%<) 6, = A 0 ! *$
( (% !
$88:#
!
!
! 7293!.A%- $889 .
(A %
- @ ) ( !
B% !
,
322=# # !
# !
)$,
)3,!322=
+ !
(
!
# 0
!
(? 5 #!
$$2322= ' 1 ( # ( # ! * $ !
( #
! !
( 67 64! % $889 ) ! ( % !
( @
! ! ; H
I
!
!
265$$5$88: ! !
% $889)% ,+# !
# !
(! # ;# ! ( +I %
!
!(
<
(# ( 72 93!.A%- $889 *! 2$5$25322= !
!!
$$5$$5322=
!.A%- $889/% $889 ( 322=
; % $889 # %
$88=
% # !
% % 5 ( )! *! 93322=, # -! . ! !
!.A%- $889 -! . < #! 62273228 *! *A$45%345895$=53228 .A%-
< 2$5$25322= ! :35%2345$8895 72935322= 2$5$25322=# !! !
# (!
$)3,!322=
'
$ )3, D
E ( % $889 ! ! $ 2$5$25322= #@ !
% !
(!
J
( -!
. $=!.A%- $889 ! 62! 3228B !
% $889 # %
$88= H
I# ! (
$$5$$5322= < ' ( % ! ( ( ## ( > > !
@ !
#
#!2$$2322= %
$$$$322=
>0
% >
!
' !>
>#
!
( ! - #
! $$$$322= # < @# ! D% E ! ( % # ; !! #
!
@ ! (
!< ( ' ! ! %
# !> >#
!
! %
% #! (
( ! % !$889!
)<
$3# , ! # < ! % @#( < (# !
@ !
H
I ' # #
( !(( C < !% $889 @( ! > ; ! %
#
$3243224( # (( 322=3224 # # @ 2$52853224# #3= $45$2532$3 ; # <
!- @% 97!
% !%
< (
( ! # ! % 0
#) (
, ( # ! #!
% J
( % $64!
% !% ) %%,# @
!
(!
(# ! (
!## # ! !< (#
(
! H I# !! ! !
3= ! ! 5 62$$3229 ( ( @(!# @#!2$52853224
# 23$$3229 ' ! !
!! !
# # ( # # # ! H
% I !H
% I! #
$$5$$5322= #
## @# # 3= ! ( !H% IH%
I# !
5 ! ; # #< ! ! ( (( +> %
66! ( 33$%%$&",-"&!, ?@#$%".%!3%-A", ? ;%6 ,%"& .0,6$3$!"7 &7#&&"#!"73 !!",% < 9.4,"3".,!
%"%
; #
!H
% I ! !
! ' ( H% IH%
I# < H. I
+ !
% C !
@( @
H
% I ! @( # !! ( J
%
!% !
! # H
I ! # @ ! '
!( @( (
' % # (
( !
5
!H
I !
# ( # H I#
!
; (
.!K ).AK,
# (. # >
># ! ! ( ! # .AK #
! !# @# # !% ! + #!!
#% $889# !
(!.
# <
# %
< !
!% ' !(! ! 50# % ! !
# ( ! % ; #!
! ( ! # 3:$232$6 '
L (232332$4 1 (*( 5A (%
#
! )919 9"4!"30",)!*-