High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2930/2012allowed

Surjit Singh v. Avtar Singh And ORS

2019-11-18Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan11 pages

!"

##$$ % & !"

"

#

!! "#

$#

%%%% '$( " " #$ & !") + !") ,$" !") -"& !"

.+ /

00 10 !") $$ %$$! / $) ,"$ # " $ ! !"

" &$$!) -!

$ " #$ 0 # $ 2!

-"03-" 4 3) -" 4 53363

)

)

33 3

) ) &$$! / $) ,"$ #

8 -!

$) "( !" $ #+ ) !

" + !

0"# 0"# # #$ & " $

8 " $&) #$ !" $ # 0 " $

& '(

) *( '

+

,, '

'

! (

-' .

/*!-

- *

( (

'

& '( !'

'

0

!*( *

! '

! 1 *

(2 344 !!( ".!' '

1 !!

(

43

(

! & '(

!

-!

* *!

! *

! ( '5 2 ,5

2 55 5 , 5 55

!!( ".! '

0 ! (

! '

!

! -1

7( (

!

'

( (

!* - 1.

' *1!

1- '

*!(

7

* & '( '

(! '

!1

! ' .

/*!-

!

-

(

!'

!

- & '(

!!-

" !'

*

*

'

43 0

-

*

'5 2 ,5

2 55 59: ; ,9 <; 5 9:; 593;5 9; ! ","<

2 455:9 ;1 (

5 2 35,

.*1

- :4' (

& '( #

!

' . !!( ".!/# ::0

!=) 0

* 43 '

(

$'

!>

*!

*!

!(

* & ' ( ( ! * *

!

-*

(

!'

( 1-1

& '(

-1 (( * !(

- 1

* * ! * 3,>

'

! 1-'-

-

* '

43 '

!-1-!6 !&( 9 ) ;(

<<:

! '

(

! - '

'

!

* . '

! *

-'

'

-0

!

!!

5.(* 4!!

!

<

:!

46 6*

1- .(

*

!6

*

*

*

1

!

-!

'

1-

?

*

* !

(

!!

'(

@

!

! -

A7

@

!

!

* . -

A7

@

!

- !

A7

< @

*1!

*A ) 3 @

1- '

!

(

43 !!

'( * ) : @

!

!

A7 ) 4 ) (

!2 ( (

@ !

- .*1

- :4B+ B+

5( ' B+

- .*1

- 4 4 B+ <

- .*1

- B+ 3

- .

B+ :

-

5( ' B+ 4

- .*1

- :4B+ ,

- 2 <:

3 $

1!

.( (

)@ +* )@

!(

)@/ .

(

C( 0

!7

)@< ."* 6 *

6!

)@3" !( D*1 )@:

( 1 ( )@4#

( 1

(

*

( (* !6

2

2 '

!

2 '

!(

-

* . (

2 <'

!( ' *1!

*

'

(!-

(

2 3 '

(

!( !

- ( !

2 :'

(

!(

!

!

!

.(*

<3 '

! !

'

! 1 ( -"03-" 4 3) -" 4 53363

)

)

33 3

) ) E!!( ".!0

!=) -

! !

- 0

'

- !

! ' '

*

(

:

- !

(

* .

(

*

(

' *

?

!( ((

1- .(*

.(

!1

) &( ( 4 !'

' *

!

(

'

!! !

1-'- !( (!

!

' ' (

(

! $

!

!

( (

(

!6 ' !

( (

!!

'(

(

0

B+) . *

*

(

1!

?

!-

(

!'

!

1-

B+) '

1-

! !-1

'

!(

B+)

! B+)

! '

(

' *

*

4 0

' *

1!

1 (

(

* 1-

4 ( 0

B+) !

5

4 (

*!

!-

(

1!

$1 (

B+) 1

.( 1

!

'

- 1

-

B+) 0 ' & '(

B+) ' '

& '( D ! (

''

!

!'

! 1

! '

* 0

!

- !1- & '( '

!1

-1 (

! 0

-

! (D

& '( '

!

'

!

' !!1!

! (

* . 1

!

!

-'

! @

* B+)

-

,

!$

' !

*!

-

( 1

1 (

(

*

1 !

/

*

*

* '

!

( !

1

( !

*!

-

(

1

( !

!

!!

* *

* B

'

!

*

1!

.1

*

$ !

1-

0 '

'

(!-

*

(

*!

-

(

.

(

*

( * !

-1

1

' !

$

>

1 (

1- (!

.(

'

'

, 0

- ! 1!

.1

8 !-

! !

(!!-

*

1!

!

!

"#$# %& ' (

) *

%+,-.(1-) #

( 7

!

!

(

1- '

> /

0

/ %&("1--2 3 (%1- (!

.( '

'

'

* 1-'

*

(

(

!

/

!

!

42

* %1- (!

.( '

'

**

1!

-1-

!

! **

1!

-

5

*

1!

' * *

< ( 0

* '

(

!-

0

- 1

( !!

'

<

(

*

(

* *

1!

1-

B

- ( **

1!

-

*

$'

'

' !

1

*

!-1

!

(1

$ !-

!

*

1!

.1 (

*

*!

-

( 0

*

/

!(

*

!

(

*

*

'

-

*!

-

( 0

* B+)

-

-'

* (

!-

(

1

1 '

*

( '

! 1 (

0 * * !-1

1

!

'

' '

((!

(

!!

* B+)

(

1

0 '

*!

!-*

'

(!-

!'' !

(

! *

!-

( B+) ' *

1!

1 !

0

!! ) &( !

'

! . *' !

*(

1- !6 *

( !

!(*

(

.

0 '

!-

0 * 1

!

0

1

0

' 1 ! 0

(!- !

' !

(

!* 0 !

0 *

(!-

0

1- '

!!- !

1- (

. ( *

'

, ) 5"0""6 .7089 @

(5

@

1!