High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/507/2015allowed

Sarabjit Singh v. State Consumer Disputes Redressel Commissione Punjab And ORS

2015-09-10Mr. Justice S.S. Saron,Mr. Justice Rameshwar Singh Malik11 pages

! "# $%%&& '() *

+,-%,)&+--.,! # )% +) /01()2* 34+(/(35*3 /01() 2* 34+()2)/*5)5

!"# $$

%& % % !!

!"# '

(% )

$! *( +! , !"# $!- ..... /(35*3.2 / $ $$

(! 0

( 1 !#! , !$ !)2 ! , &# 0( 3

+)2+$#

,,! !

$, $! - $ ($!' !677 !((## ( / $$

$! - $ !$!

+ $ #

) !6# "# + !# !

)2!8#0(8$(9!

:( ; $( <( 6= &( + #!, # !!

$ ! 0( 8$( 9!

0 (% ) , ! ) !6# "# 2, ($ ##(

(% )'"!

/!#!! )2 ! 0 !

<( 6 , !) !6#"#/ "

< # !

(! >;!"

, !"

,* ; $(; (! #

(,(!-!#

; ! 2 #( , $ 7/7 ; $( ; ) $$ ,,

8#:(; +?! @ #

, $ 8# 0( :( ; $( $!

= 33=4 33A !#) 43!

2) ; "# + ,(

B! $($ # )2 ! 8# :( ; $( "! ! !

2 )

! "#&?

$##(

(% ) '" ! ;# $! ( !

) #(! $($ $ ; 09 , '! 2 '! ( !, << << << << $ 2 $

#! ) )2 ,2 ! , ) $

4 ;+" + ," , !+?! , $!# :(!6#) 43!

2) $! = 33 =4 33A;!6#"#+ #(! # )2!8#0(:(; $("!!!

:(!

)$ !)2!8# 0( ( ; $(

+#+ $!(#!) ( )2 ! , "+ / ! + ($ !!

! ,

$!(#! #$2 ##(

##!,+# !6#$!

)#(! $ " + !6# "# ) #(! $($ #)2! 8#:("!! !

"#+

# = 33 ),(

- "# ! , = 33 ?

2 )"

)% , (,

)% , !

+?! /2$C, $! = 33

33 !6#8#0(:(

)( ! , !%! @( #

, $ ! ; $(

)% , ! ! %! !

2)(

)% 7, + +?, /2$ 2

)% )#(!

33+ 2 ! , ) #(!+

# = 33D /#

,#E(

! $ $! - + $ ( +# $ $$

/ ! $$

+ ! )2 $!+

,(! "+ %(!, ;F) ($0(* (, "G 7! ! = 00= A ;

2 "% , !

4 00A-- !6#"# $ 2)#(! 2 7 +

! + $ + $$! /2$C, !6#) 8#0(9!

!+ $$! @( #

, $"!!!

A 33A ! $! - + $$!

, $8#0(:( ; $(

= 33 $( 2$ 25 !6#) ; $$ ,(

) + (! 33A 7 # ,#

2 ! "# $! - @( #

, $ = 33

= = 4 33A+ #(! $($ # ! $! )#(! 2 ! , &#!!+$

,(! $$

2 <( 96

/ 0( (! ,"

# $$

2 2 # ! ($ $! - )2 #(,

!6# "# / 0(

(! $$

$!-+ $$!

+E(! C$ 2C<# , ! (# $$ # + !! $() #$ 25 $$ 7+ # !

##(

2 +# + $$!! <(

H " ! !#( $ ! !$ !)2 ! , @(!,( / # 2$# #9( !,""##! $ 2 # (!, $#!( $$ 0( 8$( 9!

0 8# 0( 8$(9!

:( ))(,(# ! #( $$

! (% ) 0" "# '

!00! "#9( 33= I 9( F$9( 9( I 2F9( 4 9( )2 , #(("# (#<$ $$ ,(

) # + 9( 7 ! #$

#(, !6#"# 2

H ! $$ !6# ) )2 ?, 2 C$ 2 C<# , ! $() # $ 2 / , ," )2 ! , &# $ 2 !6# ) (, $# C$ 2 C<# ,E( $() #$ 2 / # C$ 2 C<# ,

($ "

# # / C$ 2 C<# , 0$( 2 # # ## 33)( 2! $ 27 (2E( ? ,!+C$ 2 C<# ,)( $() #$ 2+!$() #2)2+ 2 $() # # ,", $$(2

,) # !!

$$ #! #+

+7 "

!2 /

00 - ) ! #

, C$ 2C<# ,!E( # =

A 0( 7! 7+ !

+6 >47

$$ 9$! + !)

2 !" 2+$ $+ ";# $$ # $+"!7 ! ,

$$ #!, # !!

( $ )2 #

, $ 2<# ,!E( # =

A 0( 7! !

!" #$% &'$ " " #

(( )) *

+, " -. %"/ 0 %))

*, ! -1"2( 2 #) 3

/( "+ )" + #!!$ 9$! + $$!

+,$#!( !

2E(!)2

! (# $$+ !!

# =

A 0( 7! "

,) # !!

" )!$"! ,)#!! $D 9 # # ) ! %(!, ;F)

($ 0( $! # 2 * ?

! " 8" ! A= 00 ++ !

#6 >A/$+ $ 2 ! $"

$ 2 (# ()%#!#(

!# )<#! ) 2 4

- . %# - 3 0(,"'"$+ (

2,!+#! "#

!#( $) $$!$() #"# !$ ## +

G 2 /

# #$

! +,($ $#!( !( ,(

#( ! ,(

"# #! $$

$$!$() #$7+

#?+ !,! )# ( $# #( "# #

!)2 ! ! $#!( +# $# 2 # 2 E(

# !

$$ # 7 ( " ) ! (! # - 3 0( '" # ? $$ 2

#+( / ) ! $ 2 / C$ 2 C<# , 0$( 2 # # # # 33 + #! ( E(

$$(2 $ 2 ?/(,# 2) , $ 2 $ 2 $ + ") $!)2 $ 2 <# , $

# ) , $ 2 2"

# #

( !$

, ($ "

# # ! $#!(

2 (2 ( ! (!

+ ,", $ 2 7 #,! ," ! # ##(

# ) ()(! (2 ( ! (! (2

+ / )# (

+, 2 #( #( ! ) ! ( (# +

!$"#(2 ( !, E(

2# !#" "

(! #(

# 7 2 " ( , , ##$!"#%($(!#/ + (2

( ! (! # - 3 0( +# < ("

!$ ? $$) ! ( ! <<< <<< <<< =- /( # !# ( E(

2 $() # $ 2 ) # ( (0( !#(

+# (0( 0(+( !# 2)! !

$ , !($ !, "

# =!, " ?, !#$ 2+E( #

= ! +# A 0( / # + # $() # $ 2 0( +

2, !+

+ # 2 ! ( $$ "

(

$$#$ ,E(

!$ +( !# 2, $$JJJJD 7# $! ) ?, !6#

$$ 2$() ##+ (! $$(2+ ,"

,) # !!

#!,

,) # !!

$# #+ #( !/ " )#

2 $$$#!( $$ , $() #$# )

!+(,", $$(2

,) # !!

$ 7

# !#% ,F# ($ ! )2$!+ (#($ ? )2$! !6#"## )#(! 27

!# +

# !!

+ $$!

!6#) 8"&# 0(!#!#(, !6 # "# $($ 2 )( ;F) ($ 0(

+! $$

! !!$ !)20( /0( (!

7+ $ !!# $! 2!#( + $!(#!) ;,0(+ '" ! !! 3 9( ! $+! 8# C!(#

# ? $$$ 2#

/ , 7(# !;!/ #E( #( + & ! + !$! + )2 (, # (! $"

(A # !

3A -G ( 2 ;,0( " ?!

# $!+ $$!)2 #$ (2 #!

! )2 & ! 2 + $

#! $) / ## ( #!! )2 ;,0( $!F

$$+,(

! !#"#+ )#(!

< 2 ,

2((

, < 2!")#!!

, 7 9( 3 39( 2 ) "# !, #

$ ! 5!#

, ! $ 2 E(! ) !! )2 !

# 9(

3349(

2!+ 2 ) "#

)!!)2

, #(( "# 2 $ / $! +

$$!$( !#) < !2#(! " !# 2#

/ ,7(# !;!/ #

B "#+ -/ 2 #( ! ) <! (! 9( 3 3 9( 9(

334 9( )2 #(, "# !

$$ << << << << -

! %(!, # ) !

2, !+ $$

+ $+ $$!$( !#)

<!$!)2 (2 +#$

? ,(

$$ "# ! (# $$

!)2$# !#(, ,#2 ! " !# "##(! < 2/ $! + + $$! !

()%# 2#

/ ,7(# !;!/ #$( !#) +(

+,$#!($#)!(! 39(

! " 2 <! )

, "# #

2 + ! !#,")2 ;,0( < $!F2)2#(,

!#"## ) $$"!D / 0(

! @(!, &# %(!, $! ;

2 ";

2 2;/ #

79 0 - + ) !6# "# !! )2 $! $($ , $ 26#

##( ,(

"#+ , !/ ($0(< ! E( , , $ 26#

!, 4 2 ,(

"#:(

&# 0(9 ?*( ,

" ;

2 33

! !6#"#)#(! , , $ 26#

)( ($ 0( ! / "

< # ! ! (!6 >J/

!+0#(

( ),(( !(E("#

!# ,""

+( !) !,#

!# ! 2#$ 2

2 ,(

"# ( () $ ) ! , # , ! ! K # ! $ / ), $ +

(! !+"#!!)29 ?*(

34 +#+ $( 2 !#) !+

# + (2 ( # ) ? ##( #$( $!

2 !# !0#(

/ %2 %(!, ;,0(#!()2E( ,<$ L,(

"#M + L#(( "#MM 7 ( #!! $ (! !#! 0#(

!@( 343

A 2 33 $! 9 ? *( +( ! ) ! ),#!! " #' !#$

3@ ( 2 +#!

+ $$!!( , $ 2 $ C, ), #! )2 () #

"# 0 ! 2 $ /

## ( %2 %(!,

"( 9 ? *( # )( ! << << << << AJJ/( $$ $!9 ?*( +

$$ # + (2 9(

() #

"#0 !%(!,!( ) 2 !,(

"# $!9 ?*( ()#(! !

% $$((

$$!

3 ! $ "# !! )2 ! # ) # ) ! ) ,(

"## ) ,,!

"# , ) (!'"0#(

!@( 343 +

# 20#(

A 2 33 /## (

%2%(!, ;,0( +

2( # )( !

7"+ (## (

! %2%(!, (% ) !;

2 ;,0( !!## ! ! ! !

2 $! $!9 ?*( #( !)#(! 2 ), ,) , # ' !(!'"0#(

!@( 343 +

# 20#(

A 2 33 /0" $$

!)2 ;

2 !

+!D H ! !# ! 0( 8$( 9!

0 (% ) !, #(, !6# "# 2 2(#(%(!, !($)2$!+ )( , +

!$#$

+ H

! #$ $ #(, !6#"#+ !# !

"!<(6= !##( !6#"#()E( 2)2! 0+ #!,# !!

$ ! # # !!

!E( !#/( )

!6#"#, !$!-

(+ ! (

+ H

! $$

#( ! ")6(!

2 ) # E(+# ), (!)2 ! , &#+ ) !6#"## ), !$!-(# E( # !)2$! %(!,+

# !($$$$# "

! 7"+ !

# + ! %(!, !

, &# 0( !

! 3

+ 0E( 2 ! 0E( 2 $$

+ $

+!/!$,$!-<(6A !64

! !$! !#!#!

,($ $ ($!' !677 #+

I8'(