High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/985/2011dismissed

Ramesh Chander Sharma v. Poonam Goyal And ANR

2018-12-21Mr. Justice L.N. Mittal20 pages

! """# "

!"#$%&'

#$'(

$ % & '( ) *"+,' % -# '-)*"+ ."

% "/,-)*"+ ." " 000

''..4

''/!

/' +"+! -!/ + (# "! ( ", '..+".+

''..4

!' ." +'.'+ ."+ ". / ." ,' +"6!' '. ". '-!+'" "'" .'"/"

"57 5889,'

''..4

' + ". !'/ 5988 6 #

""!". ", "(#. ." " +"''" ". 9:984; 6 # ,'+ !

' #+"!"( 2)<=):9)8884;

"#" !". 29 +, '"."!/ +6! + +"''","( '/'

"".' ! .+!". #". "# " ! ". 29 + " . , " +''/"

57 1=3 ." '/ '" / "

5889) . '" +"

("'" / " 2:

588< ,' %4 > "!'/ * "

?'' ." * "

+"!+'" ". '' +"

>4+"

"#"* !'/72@ = ."(''/ '++.""*".# ."'+"

("'"/2:

588<) . , '

" "

" !'/ A29< 986 #'+"

>4+"

"# ," (>+!/'(#.,''."!" .

!+'/ ". +"

"# . @'/ 6!''

''"4 '++"!

"+"

"#." "* ". #

''.. .!

"*".#/ '++".." ."' ."+*' 5A 5889 .,'

".'+"

("" #%4 > "!'/ * "

?'' !+ '' +"

"# . "(''/ 6!'' '++ ' " ". !#) 5887

''..

/, ,##,'

'/" ." ' "."( '/'")(!./"'! 8= 8= 5887."'*"+".('+'" /"">'/!'"*".#

. ,"/ # '+" " !;5 ". / /" '! 8= 8= 5887"!/'*"+(##'//"

57 5889"">'/!' 1<3 .+"!'(#

/'/!' ,"''(

''.."+!".+'"" .'

","("

''..(# ." #./'/

"* '+". ." "* "!/ ' (!'

%4 > "!'/ * "

?'' '+ '++,"/).") + ' ".

''.. (+" '.!+!"! . " !' , ( ." ';-"' ". +#

'"*".#%4 >"!'/ * "

?'',"'

#. ' !'

. , '

" !'/ A2:5 98 6 # ' +"

> ." ' (!'

%4 >"!'/* "

?''" #.

" ".

"* " .) + ' ".

''.. /

" !'/ 5988 6 # +"!

* ( , '+ 6!'' '++ , " /"(!'

).")+ '".

''.., "('/ ..!

''.. '' +"''""./"

'+!

#+"''""

5),'', +'.'+

#+' '. +"

"# , " !+ ,'' ."! ")

"# ". 29 + ,"!

( .! (# ."

''..,'"!',''29#).'

'/ ,'+',"!

(+/B25C !" ."'"#'

' 'D'" ,"+' " ..+ ,"!

(>+!/'(# .,''."!". !+'/".+"

"# . /'/ 6!'' '++ ." "* ++"'/ " .) '" ". ."! " , " ( +" ! ." ". / "

57 5889 " . !+'/ ". +"

"# " "(''/ 6!''

'++.""* '++,'

,'(# (!'

.""*."),"+! ". +'" *'

( "

''..

'!+ ". / "'+ 8= 8= 5887 , + ' " ( /

.4 #",@ (#'''

." !(' '" "! " ++ + ". +'" +' '/"

" ',"' "."

",'/'!$;

''..>'' . E;2)"

@') ''+ ",

) "'

E;5 . '/ /"

2)"'+>

5)+"

("'"/ >

=) +"

' ". !

." # 2AAA;5888 >

< >

9) '++ >

7) =2 5889 >

: '

F)+ "*'+ 1:3 " ) . >' - E2+"

#". @2 ""+"

#".

'++@5 1F3 ' "!'+!'!"

25"/ +'("'! #/'

''..">". ''

'/ ' ." '. ". +'.'+ ."+) ",*) '* '.".+"*#"."# +' ' / "

, / ! "

= , +' ' .*"!"..)(#"

''.."

".'

!'." +'.'+ ."+!', " ''( +"6!+ ". +''" ! ."' '!) !' , # + " > ". '

''.. " +"* "! ". 29 + ,' 'B25C !."57 5889!

"8= 8= 5887 'B7C !."".''!'"".!''

.' 'D'""."! ', ."('", +"

1A3

''..,'.'

(."?",

"!/'-!/+2F 5828 (# ' "! ?",

"! " ..' -!/ + ". ' "! 2F 5828 (# '''/

*' -!/ + =8 ' ",) /!

+"(.'

' "! ,'

'/ ,' # " 2A 8A 5825) '

" ."

",'/ !(' 6!'"". ,$; '( ) * *

* '( ) !

'"( + *

'$(

& * +"! ." ' ?'""! ."

* # +" !' , " +' # " ( ''

#(+!', ;!"".''!'"". !')'.(#','+"(.' "(# '"!,+

"" +)

''.., ."!'

" '.+ ' '' ".!'" /"!".'('/ ;!,"!

*(*#". -!'+ '+!

''.., '

"+ ",' +>+!'""./"

, "* ' (# .) +'.'+ ."+ ". +"+"!

*(/",''/#.! ' +#'/ "! +"+ ,'' +'.' '" " ' (+".#'

('/ "-+(#

''..' ".+'"58". +'.'+ '.+ ,,"

#'6!'( ""/ '.,>+!'""./"

# "*'(, '' ,"+".+"+ +"'/+'+" '/"

(#,#".".!

+ !,"!

" (!..'+'"#.!'".+'" *'.)+ ! , '/"

)',"!

"(!'" ('".+ ! " 12=3 ? '" "! ' !

" !!"# $ % #%$ & '

()*( +, -( , &./0 # %$1/1 2+++, * +, )+ 34 &.05 # %$ '"0 6

37(,

(( +, !&!#&'$ %% 50!

( ,

, ( 8, +, &./0 # %$0''

+, (+ + 7

+, (+ +, &.1' # 74,$ &'" 7 9 9 &.11 #

()$ 1 +" "! +"! *

+"''" + ." +'.'+ ."+ !(-+ " > '"('//(#!"'#"+"'/.+", +"

','!(6!/ "!+"!

*@ -!'+' "'+".!(6!*)*'.),''" " ( . ".

'++ , / " 2= 8< 588: ." 5 # ,'+ > ' " 25 8< 588A 5A 5889 , " # ". ' '! (# "*".#" '++ 12<3 ?'""! .! '!

" +"''" '",'/"

/, >+! " 57 5889 +"''") "+"!

* ' .57 +"''"".+"

("'"/2:

588<) .' #'

.,6!'"/

"* '+". !'/59886 #.""* "!/'(!'

,""!!#".." ".!

.' #.'"/ "

". ("* '"

"* '+ ". !'/ 5988 6 # ,'+ , " (

" " ." "* ". # "!/ (!'

( + "!

,"(+'*/'

"".("*

" "* ,' ' ",'

'/ " +" # .' #!+" #'

'. +"

"# ' " ( !+ ,'' ."! ") ' "# ". 29 + ,'

( .! (# .4 " "

''..4

,'"! ' ,''29#).'

'/,'+','

(+/B25C

! " ' "# ++"'/ "

) ' + ! , "' + ! ' /',+''..' #@" '.'/'+"''""./) +" # ,"!

(.!

# '(# " / +'" +"

"!/ "+ ". "! +" > ". .' # ? '" "! !(' 8= 8= 5887/"'!(#."!/ '*"+,'

" ) +"! ." "*#* #!('%4 >"!'/ * "

?'',"/+"'/!"! " ( 6! '.' ." * "

'/ +"

"# .) * "

,"!('

'+'"!

"(# *"+!" "*".#.""(''/

/".

'++,!(-+"

"* "(#","!#

'/ ". # "* . .''/

'+'" " ( +"

+ .!

'".(#"* .) '++," (/"%4 >"!'/* "

?''

". ' , .' ." '++ ,'+ , " ( /.+"''" +'.''? ,+"

(# * "

#+)* "

*"(( ".!

".? .")* "-+"./ "

' , " +' " ", !+ ' (!' '/@'.!

'/".? ? ,/(# "*"5A 5889+"'25-" '!"(.!

(#* "

? ," '++ + ' (#

''..) ",*)

''.. *# +' # ' / '++ , / " # " 2= 8< 588:

" ('/ ", ' " * # +""

"*"*',%4 >"!'/ * "

?'' " # ," , '

" !('

'+'" ." "(''/ '++ ."

", !

,/ %4 >"!'/* "

?''," @

,'"! '*'" ". "

,"> '+'

" '/ "

"!'# "' '# " @ ".'"!".+'"'"(# " ,' %4 > "!'/ * "

?'') '" / "

57 5889 ,' " " +"'/+# ('

" '/ (

" " "

,' ' ! '

'/+ ''")

+!+ +!

"'""(')+'" ,'."."!"" #." !+'/".+"

"#' !;5 "./"

)',+''.+"

"#,"

!+ ,'' ."! ") "# ". 29 + ,"!

( .! (# . "

''.. ,'"! ',''29#'*"..' !),''B 25C ! '

.' 'D'" ". "! ' /,* '."."!"" #> ' "

'. # . 5889)

''..4

"'/ " "" , '

" 'B25C !""!". 29 +

' " ,'* "! ++! " ' ' . 59 " "'/ " /' (# @ '/

29 +,'.")"!/'*"+)# /"'! 8= 8= 5887''// !"#,''B25C ! *'/ ! ! "

5 ". / "

12:3 ? +"! ." " . " : %+ ;+ ,(9+79 : ()( + <+

!&&#'$ % #%$ 1.' +" +'.'+ ."+ ". +"+ ' '+'"# '.

' ,"+".+"+ E/, +"'/ !

" " 6!') *" , ,

,''''/"'+"+.""; ."+".

".+"+ E+"6!+".";+"

'" ".+"''",+''/"

,+ # "!'*".";.!

"." +"''")'+'"# '.". +'.'+ ."++"!

" ( / ++

'" ". / , -!

' (# .

''.. , " '

" +'.'+ ."+) '* './ (#"!( ",,-!

''*',"..+ +'+!+". + 12F3 * +"' !(''" (# +"! ." ' 12A3 ' '+'

". , ' + ". +'.'+

."+ ". +"+) '+'" ". "! ' " " ( >+' #(+!'' ,.!

"""

"!'" "( '/4"( '/ ("! " / !+ '.) (! '+'""(>+'""!"( /"! /!'(#-!'+' '+'

,'++ ( ".('/+"+ (# "! ".

' ! "+ >+!'" ". ,.!

/ ' "* -!'+' +"+'+ ". "! ' '.')6!'#/"! ( ."+)"/ '* '."./"

''..

" ( ' 6!'# ! /'* '. , 6!'# G, ,

H '/ ","*'"

+"''" ". / +" ( ' " @ */"*" #'6!'# ."'+">) '" ' ", ' ( ( -, * 7 &.11# $%#+$' 5 2+++, * +, )+34=9+#7>,$+( ' !''+'"". "! " + +'.'+ '. ' '+'"# ! ( >+'""!"( /"! !''+'"+" (+!'

(#.'>'/!* '6!'/ "*''" ' ". +'" 58 ". +'.'+

'.+'>+ '""!

"./". '.". +'.'+

."+) (! ' ' . +" ( +"! ("

"!"( '/">+''6!'( -!''+'"'+""+,' '+'

". , '+'" " ( >+' ' -!'+'"! * '* # (#

''.. ' !' +" ( +"!"(,'*"("".'+ ' "(-+ ". "*''" ' " *"' !

!! '

" " #,'

*"''/!!/'"" ."' '+'

'.' '/"..+" +"),,"!

('/'* ."+". / , +"'/ !

" *'

'# ".

!+'/ ". +"

"# , " +" ' ('

/ +"''" ". ."! " , +' ' ' #) +"

"# , " !+ ,'' ."! " ".

/ "

57 "!( #) ". /, !'/59886 #, "("

(#."

''.." #"

"". (#(!'

./'/

"*." "*".# ,

/" ( ." , " " # !

" ' # '

(!'

," , " * "

"#) (! " " ."!

# '

". # ," , " / '++ " (!'

'* "

'!')" ". # # . , '

"''" " +"

*# +' # ' ! " " '@ ( '.) ' , ? , '! " 5A 5889 I>

:J) , ' , " # ? 6!'' '++,/" #"2= 8< 588:I>

7J,'+ , * ' !

" 25 8< 588A) (! +"

"# , " !+ ,'' '"".* ''# ?+"! ." " "." 2, +, (, +, 6&...#1$ % /!1 ' '/.'

!".' #'

(!'

" "*

"".,*'! 'D (#(" ''".>+!'""./"

#'."". !;5, "*'(#

''..4

' !+ " ," . / "

' . , *# !+ '* " '!'"+"'/+' " '."!

!;5

,'"

# .

'('

'#". '.". +'.'+ ."+(# ,#".>+!'"/''"". ".

" ,''/"

).")

''.. +"!

" '* # (.' ." +' -!/ !;5 + # "*''...'

" !++"

"# ,''."!")"#". 29 +,"!

( .! (# . "

''.. ,'"! ' ,'' 29 #) .'

'/ ,'+ ' ,"!

++! B 25C ! " ' "# ' #) +"

"# , " !+,''."!" 15=3 ' '"". !;5'/,"!

/'*!('/!"!'/'.+"

"#," !+ ,''."!")"#,"! (.!"

''.. ,'"! ' ,'' 29 # . ,' 'B25C !

''..''+";>''" ' ' . " ( "+ /! .! '"*./"

2J ".

''.. '"".."!","+"+ ."/". '++."'/!

"+"

"#) +" (

+' , " +'.'+ '" ' + ! ,'+ , . (#

''.. ' .

' " ". + ! ' ' '' ,"!

" /'* ' " # !+ +"+ !'"'('/ "-+(#

''..4

! '''( # '. +"+ ". '

'" ". ."! ".""./"",'

15<3 .'

'/". !'" 58 8= 5887* (."/".

'++ " 2= 8< 588: , ;! '" ". =9+#7>,$,"!

"( + ."+ ". / , " " # !

" "( '/'" ". .) (! " " * "

".#,","'

#.'!'

+"'/+'+"!

"* ( +! (# . ' (+ ". ."'/

'"+'" *"

@')''+",

'/ E 5 ' " , / ''" ." '/ !

'' +"

"# " 2= 8< 588: I>

7J ' ". ' I>

:J) " , " # +

" " .!

+' +"''" (." '!+ ". '++ +"+ ". '

'"".."!" "

"!(#

''..'.( '*) . / ". '++) "'/ ,"!

* ( . " .! ,' ." ." !+ ". +"

"# ' !+ *! '#) + ! ,"!

* '/ ,'"!#"(-+'*'# +"(#' !,'/ " "

"''" '+'-!/(#

)(! " !+ .+" '*"

* ' + ('

/ (, ' , " # ." ."! " . > '# ". ' (+ ". # '++) " # #*'

( ,'

''..,"/'"#

(+@,'"!''.,"( ',''29# ,''. *', ". ."') 6!'" ". , ."!

' " 2A 8A 5825 " " ' ' ,'

'/ " ".

''.. +" (

+''*',".+"'//

''/". /' .'!//'*"..+.> '#". ."!"'*".";

'/".*."/ ". '++) # , " # " +'* "# (+@ '"'/ ". '" ". ."! " +" ( +"! " ( + ". +"+ ." '/ " +'" *".";.!

".+"''""./".

'++,''' +'()+'","!

" #( +"''" +'" , ' , " + ". +"+ * ",' ' + ". '"*( "

#) ' +"(+".+"+'*',".'" '",(# "K( >"!' ( %#+$) ( 3(#+$) &..5# $'/ '!".','

'/". ' " "' ' + /' . , !

" '"".."!",'','+

'/' + ". / ". '++ , " ( +'* .) (" ' /

''.. ,"!

+'* "#,'"!',''29#,''

. ,

' / ". ('

"( '/'" " , !+ '" ,''/ 6!'" ". ."+'/ ""').")6!'""

5""'

15:3 '/ ". +"'/ .+" +" ' /) .'

'/ ". !' ! /) +" (

''.. +"+ ". '!+ ". '++ ( " ( ". '!+ ". ? !(6! /)

''.. ' ."' ."

# ' ". '!+ ". '++ , 2= 8< 588:

'/ ". !' " ."' +"+ "'") ,"!

" '

''.."@#6!'( '+'"# '.

+'.'+ ."+'"("

!'/".

''.. +(''+". ! *',". ("*)6!'""

=< """'."+"''" ".'"! *'.)2, +,=9+#7>,$, + "(

' 2= 78 , 7 # !!'$ / 7>,+(+ % 7, %+ /'.)'

''..4

""*#!++"''"". +'.'+ '.

15F3

) .." ( (#

".'

'+'""

+"+""+! " (' ". ,'+ '++ , . ." "* "

"%4!#",'

* ?

15A3

'+'" ! +'" 292 '

AF=9;".5825,.'

+'/"+">! ;2 I '++J >! ;5 I" ." . ". '++J '

'+'",''*'"2A 8A 5825 (#"

'+'",'+"+'* '(#, /'*"

''..".'

'+'"! <2 !

5: ." @'/ ''" " +'* " "+! ''" *'+ "..'

'+'") %"

2272<;".582=,.'

+'/"+"+"

#".

'++2= 8< 588:+"

#"." ''/.".

'++ 8:

'+'" , .'

" 5= 582= "'+".

'+'",'!

'+'" , .'

(# " '

'+'" , /" '' ,', " 2< 582< .) "

'+'"'

22F=8;".582<,.'

"'+ ".

'+'" , '! " " '

'+'",""( ' "/,''

'"57 8< 582:)',"(*(#'/"!

'+'" ! <2 !

5: , " .'

' " 2A 8A +"

". %"

22F=8;".582<+"(+"'"*("* " '%"

AF=9;".5825%"

2272<; ".582= 1=83

" " +" '("*) +"+! .''/"..++"(#"!( ",+"( "

( !

". ''/ ". *'+ " !.. ,' #

*'# " , "' ," +"''" ' '*"

* '

'."!"("

#*"'".' ' ++"'/ # '' ' . " ( '",+" $'( $%(# 582F

'+ E "4 @'/ 4" E "( 4"