Deepak Bhatia v. State Of Punjab And ORS
"#
$ "
%& '
#(
' #
)
' * ' +
%,-.
/
0
)
11
2)
3
#
+
4& #) %"5 !
5 5
6"#
4& #) %"5 !
# '
7
! "
# $%
# &
#
'
( )!
'
( )! (
* + ,--.$/ -0 '1 '
( )! '' ''"
( )! (
* + ,.22$/ -0
'3 ( )! (
* + , 4/-$/ -0 '
( 5( '5
( )!
( ' ' ( )! ( ,6( -($44/ ' )
( )!
'
( )! ( ,$/$ '
( )!
' ( )! ( ,4& -$* + ,--.$/ -0 ' 7 ( )!
' ( )! ( ,4& 46 '7 ( )! ( ,-& -- ' 1 ( )!
'3
( )! ( ! 8 ,-6 6 ') ( )! ( ! * 1',&--. + --.$/ -0 88
% )
8! ( + , -..(.22 4/- $/ -19
+
) "
!
: $/ - " 7 (
" )
; 1 ,$-.6/($6& /($6&2/($62:/ $/ 41 , 2 $/ -<
$ ) !
!
!
!
!
" !) !1
(
; (=
><
$/)!!
) ) ! ;?@!
) !
< ) ! " !
&&A !
(
!
! & $/ 4;
@B&<!
!
)
,. 6
! ($/ & ;
@ B < "
1
% ! !
!!
"' @
"
1
& $/ 4
% " ! !!
!
)@ C8 , !
B '@
' * 5
! 0 1 "
* /D$ 0 // $ ? 1 "* /D$ 0 // & ?"
-/ 4 5 8E *3 "( 5 "!
"0 $-/ - 5 8EE *E 1
F
"( 5)! E
0 $-/ 6 5 8EEE *?! "(
!!
"E0 $-/ 2 5 8E *!
! F %!
"(?) ( )
F!
' $-/ : E )
-/ -
8 + -// &
)
($4(///!
"@
$&/&$/ 4 G
( 4 4 ! !
" @
! ) %
@
;
< $ & ! ! ) %
!
" )
4 % !
)
@
"
(! @ !
!
!
!
!
E
@
(
! H 4-!
&& ! "% H
&&A
!
B3 )(
!
(
!
@
"!
G
!
E(
)( "(
*0 // (? *1 "0*G0 //
(?"*0 -/ 5 ) 4!
!"
$-/ % "( )
' @
-/
) B) )8)! !
!(!
) " 4-A
!
5! "! 4/A
!
!
1 !
% % ! )"
8
&&A H "! !
!
!
# - + 7
!!
)
!"
!
' @
( &&A
!
)
"
!
!
& $/ 4 3 )(
!
8
" "
&&A
!
)"
5
!! "
"
8&!!
" ! ) B) )8)! 6
)
: $/ -(
+
1 2 '
( !
8
1 ! 7 !
"!!
)
!!
!
!
8
!
!
@
( )(
&&A H !
!
!
)
( ! !
!) )8)! %
!
!
! !
!
) @
!!
(
!
1 "
!
!
!
E
( ! !
!
3I 1 '89 ::
58,; <) '-) &)5)=/ > ?
5!!
2@ " * <) "9- 5A/ 3>2?
5!!
21 5 * ")) <) -= '-B- - 5A/ C>?
5!!
) 3 )( 7
!(
8
!
"
:
( !
!! )
!
"(
" !
!
!
! !!E
( ! !
!
3I 1 !- -;
- - <) 5;,8 5,;8/ >0?
5!!
1@ <=- 6,B- <-B - <) ,:8 5-D !BB/ "-; -/ > ?
5!!
@
-9 6,B- # - <) ' 6,B- .
-/ !
)03 * 3/ 5!
!
1 (A- 5A (D <) 5 *
-./ >?
5)!) ) C >')&)?
<=.- - <) ,=:
,:8 5-D !BB/ >?
5)!) ) >5)&)?
) !
(
"
B!
! (
"!
!
"!
"@
' @
"
( !H ! !
)!
"1 3 )(
!
!
! "!
"
&&A
)
! "
!!!
@
%!!( !
"! )"
(
) (
1
)
(
)
?@
! (
@ "
!
!
! ( 7 !
)
) "
@ E
( !
!
3I 1
8 '- <) 5 * #= -/ C >3?
5!!
@ 5.) > 8?/ '9)
*
8 <) '-) ,-/ 0>0?
5!!
C) % !
! "!
!
!
!
)@ " " : $/ -(
! (
!!
) "
! "!
)" J
!
! . '
(
)! 5(
+ !
"
1 : $/ -() !"
1 ( )
!
' (
) B) )8)! !$2$$/ -
(
4$/ - 3 )( ! "!!
) "
!
"( "(
"!"
+
/
(B )
( 1 (
( 5
( )!
! )"
))
=!
>=> 3 )(
""
'( ! !
(
!! %
!
!
!
! H
&&A !
!
2E
, ;:<;.< !; <
=! !
' ?@
>
!!""8
=!
>"
=>
, ,$
! !
' ?@
(
"
( =! ">
!
! H
@
! "
! &&A
5 !
%
!
) !
!
)@ "
(
!
!
% ! ) !
&&A
!
)"!
5
) " % " !
@
;' < !"
!!(
! &&A !
;4 5 < $ + !
!
)
E
( ! !
!
3I 1
B & &,88 - <) (A- #- -/ 0>2?
#)!)#) >!D8?
21/ 5!@
" * - <) &-=
5A/ >C?
5!!
2@ !* *-B !BB-) - <) 5 * 9,- -/ > ?
#)!)#) >!D8?
213/ 5!)
% K!
K ! KK !
! E
( ! !
3I 1 E -B ,- ) - <) 5,- EA &- * / 2 # >5!?
20) & % @ !
" !
)
!
!
"
1
'"($/ -(
K!
K
"
KK%
!
@
" H &&A !
!
)! " 4 +!
! "!
8 "
!
!
3 )(
!(
!
!
8 " - + !
! !"
J!
7
J!
!
)@
!
)(
")
8
K!
KKK%
(!
)! !
3I 1 E #=- 6,B- A-8 <) 5 * ")) -/ #
5!7 2
D 6,B- - <) #=
- FA -/ >0?
/ 5!!
0 ) 6
( ' 5
( !(
)
! ) !
&&A !
K!
K !
KK(
2 ) !
! )
)
: !
( !
! )"(
)
! )" ))
C8
! H
&&A
!
2! "&&A
!
!
# $
"!
!
# &
"!!
!
")"!
"# 4
" 7 (
"
)
)
!!!!
@
)"!
#
)
) , $
! .
@
"
!! )
(
!
" !
H )
! H "!
!
)@
!
1 ) ) !;?@!
) !
< ) !
) !
@!
)
!
" ) !!! %
!
) !
) !
"8
!
8!
)"
! % !
"
1
!
! !
!
)@
) % ) @
1
!
C8 = " !
" K!
! (
!
"
!
!
) (
(
)
! )
"( !
)
!
! !
!!
!
! "
!
)
)
)
)!
> $/ % !
"!
! " !) !
!
"
!
)
" ) )
! "(! ")"!
!!!
!!!
)
@
% (
)! "
!
" " $
!
! "
1
(
) )
1 ) ) !;?@!
) !
< ) ! ? !
@
H H "
@
! H
!
!
3 )()
!
& $/ 4 ;
@B&<=5 >!
! !"
$-/ !
E !
!
@
!)! "
) !
5 E !
!
! H &&A
!
!
%
!
!
!
1 ) ) !;?@!
) !
< ) !
6 $$/ &;
@ B <
(
!
!"
! !
)
! )! E
!
& $/ 4;
@B&<(
=!
B>
) !"! "!
) ! "
!
(
? 5 $$ +!
) )
) !
!
!
!
H
(
" H
!
!
3 )(
! )" )
!
L "(
!
!
1 ) ) ! ;?@!
) !
< ) ! ) !
!
" )
5)
(5 !
)
,
5 !) !
8E
"(5 "!
"M 8EE
E 1
"(5)!E
M 8EEE
?! "(
!!
"E8E
!
!F %!
"(?) ( ) !
' $& %
!
5)
!
1 ) ) !;?@!
) !
< ) ! )
!
,"!!
!
" ! (
!!"
3 )
!
'( "
"! % !
!"
!
! "
!!! , " ! "
!
!
""
!! 3 )(
! (
!
!
! H
)! "
! !
(
!
!
(
=!
B>
!
& $/ 4;
@B&<L"!(
)
=! !
' ?@
> ! C8
&?) -
,-
B
*-
B
+ , !
B '@
' * 5
! 0 1 "
* /D$ 0 // $ ? 1 "* /D$ 0 // & ?"
-/ 4 5 8E *3 "( 5 "!
"0 $-/ - 5 8EE *E 1
F
"( 5)! E
0 $-/ 6 5 8EEE *?! "(
!!
"E0 $-/ 2 5 8E *!
! F %!
"(?) ( )
F!
' $-/ : E )
-/ -
8 + -// , C8
!
)
!
"
!
( )( @
"
!
$ % !
)@
!)! "
& 1
)
( @!
? 4 1 @!
"(
" (
) ? )
! "
!
!
! ( "(
) - % H
? 3 )(
"!
" *0 (
H
!! " 6 " ! @8EE 2 E ) !!
"
!
H "
!
!
) @
!
" : , !
)
B 4-A
!
*4/ A
!
!
1 !
% 0 ! &&A !
!
)
" !
) @
(
! 4-A
* 4/ A
!
!
1 !
% 0(
1
"
!
! 4/A * &- A
!
!
1 !
% 0( )(
! !
!
!
. ,! ! )H
!
) @
4-A
!
@
! ) * 4/ A
!
!
1 !
% 0 @!
! " !
) @
!
4/A * &- A
!
!
1 !
% 0 "
1
!
H "
!
"
1
/ L
!
)
'
@
( !
)!!
)
!
! " !
) ( )
( !
! ) (
E ) , H !
!!
@
)
CE
)
E )
' ?@
! H(
! !
' ?@
' ?@
!
!
H(
! !
5
' ?@
H(
!
$4 +!
, :.
=!!
' ?@
>!
!
( @B&(
!
&&A !
!
:.
!
!
! )"
H !
!
3 )(
!
!
!!
!
!
, :. ))8 !
, $(
!"! C8 =$% !
)@
!) ! "> $- % )"
!
!
!
!
;
@ B&< !
(
!
"! '(
!
) !
@!
H !
!!
E ) !
) "
3
"!
"! ( ! ! !
5)
!
!
) " 3 )(!
) ) "!!
)!
H" ) ""! " % !
! )
"!
! )"
5 !
!
! "
!
)""(
" ! ! !
!
(! H " + "(
! !
!
) @
!
" )
!
"@
$&&$/ 4
;
<@
7"( $/ 4
@
! : $$/ 4
'!
($/ - % "! !
!
! )
" !!!
)
"3I 1 E !- -;
-4 <=- 6,B-4
,9-) $6 %
!
( (
1
"!
!
" ;
(
<
1
@!
!
&&A
!
!
(
!(! "
) % 1
!
!
)
)
?@ "E
!(
"
1
@ "
!
!
) "
! 8 G
(
3I 1 E 8 '-4
,9-
(
3I @1 )C8 =G "!
!) ! "
)
!&/.
1
!
( "
!
)
!
) E
) "
) !) ) H
)%
!%
!
! !
! > $2
" !
)
!!
!
! H
!
(
!
&6$/ -3 )(
!
!
@
"
(
"!
! ( !
(
!
&6$/ - ) )!
"
" $:
" !
!
! "
! H ! "
)
!
(
!
"(
!
! @!
!
@
!
) !
?) " !
!! ! "
( ! !
! " ! "!
@
;, ,$<
,
H
! " $. E) ) ! H
, $ , :(
! )
! H &&A !
2 ! "
"!
!
)
)2 &/ , (!
,&
"!
!
")"!
! %
! "
!
!%
!
!
! )
!
@
E
!
!
!
!"
%
!& $/ 4;
@B&<
)
!
@
!
@
H "(
"!
!
! ))"!
!
)
)3) & +!
)
7 "@
!!!! "!!
!
!
) )" !
3 )( !) !
%
! )"
!
!
) !
&$ E!
)@
(
!
! ) H ""
H ( !
@
?) ! ! )
@
E;
6,B- (D <) 5 *
-. -/ > C?
5!!
3 1/
3I 1 E 8
@
! !
)
@
% ) )
3I
@1 ! C8 =
!
!
@
" ) ) )! (
! ! )
@
( @!
!
(
!
)!!
> && 3 )(
"!
!"
1
! !! H )
) % "(
" !
)"@
!!! !
!" 7 (
! ! )
( % " 7 ! ")"!
3!( ,4 !
)
&4 E) ! (+ ,-..(.22 4/- $/ -
: $/ -"
7 )
8 &-
!"
!
!!
>5 5
6"#
?
>5 # '
7 ?
%"'
%"'
%,-.
/
0