Rajinder Kaur & ANR., v. Shakuntla Devi




 



 

 

 

 



   !

""## $  
!% #&  "






!"#



"$ '

  ' )*&*  !""##  ! ("#*&   "  '

%! *&*  "  %!+!"

*&   !'

,!% *&*  "- ....

 

 

         

   

   

  

    
 
" %
& /!"

""#0  !, #  ,1         0  !  0(  

2

 "  ,1  #     3 0*  "0 * 4! ,1""# #,1!"# 0! 0(      -

 "  ,1  #  +&#  3 0

&*  "0  4  "      !    4

(! 4! !   !  ,1  0&0  ""      ,!  !  "     # &# 5656) (,1! + 

'# 
!% #& #   #  " ( !0  !! ' 
0!

4(

    ! 0!

       ,   (  !  4#%          ' 
0!6' 
0!



7

4!&0  #4!! 4 6  ' 
0!!"

!  (,   "# ( 5- #"

!"#27*'!656*

0 *!# 4 0 ! /! ,0 #8  ! 4   !* ! "# *! ! 30
0!1 0 , ! /! ! "#4  "

"  ! (#1'# ,0 (! #0#!  ' 
0!4#! ! "

" 1" ! ! !# ,1! #! ! ( 4! 5- !,% # ,1!/!! # # (!,%  0 ! ## ! #,# ( !


*

*

96 

     4   #,#    !   !  (      #,# "

" ##14!!"#     ! %!1" &##!(   (  (  5-#" !!  !#*4!! #(#1"

("!"#  #!  :  5 /! 4,1    ## ( 1"#  ##0!!"#  ! ! ,    ,4 

! ! ,!1#41 0' 
0!    ##            !   0!    /!1  0' 
0!%#:  !#% 41!"#4!"

&   ! ,  !"# /!  ! !# 4(  !#&! &0 ! ! ,!# #"#3#! ( !;"   -         ##0  !  ! "# ! ! ,! 0!*#  ! ! !# ' 
0!* "0(* ; !<## 5-

 " ! !

(&,#((&,#"

"  &    '# *! ! ,1 0 4 # ! <##/!! ,#0   ;# &#1

- !14 4  !(   #( !!( ##!"## & ! (    !"#   - #4 (!##00! #  !"#  #! /! 4#(, (,# ' 
0!!"

!=#;+!

=#4'#1 ( -   ( 
*

*

964!

 #"

( (  
5 *>

96"  ( !"#1*!  ( #04!##! ,  4 ,"!  !4#&  !

   *  !   (  4 #  ,  #    0  !   (  " "#1*     4#0! ,     !  "#1    !  !    '  
0!* 4! ;" 

7

 >   "#  4  #   / #  +   (  ! ##40 6 ?

<!! !"# #!  # "

1  @''

<!! ! "#  # !    " ( "

1  @''

5 <!! !+ !

 1 ! @''

- # A

 2 '   #  ! "& &    ""    !   / #4!   #1 !(0!"# B 54 0!  &  !"# ,1!#0 !!+ !

 1! ! ,  0       *"# 4 !### " ( ! ! #"

&! *4! * 4 ,# "

&  !      !4  !       4  ! (        '  
0!      ! ; <##!  &   0#1*  !"# 4  (  ,1 !   #  +   &  0(       -

 7 =#000 &0!   0(  *"#  #""#,  !#4 ""##+ 

)   !#4 ""## + *"# 6""## !!  (1  0 0 <##! 4  !"# 6""### 1 , #&! '#   !& ! (*##0,<## !* ;(#0#" ( *!( # ##! 0  <##( !!!(4! !" 0 (4!!!0  ,  

> 4 "

$4 (10#* ! ( # , ,<##1" ( 4!& /! 0  4     !  <##  4   !  , !     ! ,  1    !  <##    !1  ,0     4* (%!<####1!

 4!(1    ( /! !"#!(1    ( (! <##"

 !<##,!  #  "0 ( ! 

 4!1(1     (!  !#+#6B!  ##  !#  #   4( , 0  ! 0# ( 1""# 

#0 1&4(&

 6 "  ""  !  "#    ! ""##!0  !!<## 5-

;  ,1' 
0! &    !  0!

#4 # (!&0,"

&,1( 0#4  !<##  !&   4 ( 0 0!<##, !" %4! !! *!   * 0  <##4 #4 # 0,  4! C4 ""##+   !! 0  ,1! 4 "

( #1 , "!(" 0<##4!! , #4#,1 !"# /  (1 4! 0  <## 0! #!&,0&,1! 

 4!!4& (

C4 ""##  +   #  " 
'(
" 

 
)*
 *
+,&&
-+.


-&.
-"

.!#! ! 4!!0 !" !(   0 &!"#0/!+ ! #  9"4!! !, (/! 

# "!<##4 ,#1;"  (!   ( <####4!"# 6 ""###& , # !<##
!  ,",##14!"

"  4 (,1! # +  /! "

!#&#1 !<## " , #&4 ,1!"# ! "    ;     <##  C4 ""##  +   ! 0!   ""

"

 ( 5656)! ##40 ( 6 ?56 <!!  !   (    5-

"

"     ,    0 (9  <##     !   <##4; ,1! '  
0!    &    "6      !44##*  @' 56) B  56"

&4!! !  (  "

" 0    ,    <##     '  
0!    !

   ,1   "    (@''A



5 /!   *  #4 ""##  +   "    ! ""#  &  0(    2

    !    4

(!   0!  ! 

"

&0 ,# ""      ,!  !      # & ""  ! 

- /!!4!"

""#0!

0( !#4 ""##+ (, #! + 

 B!&! #  #  !" !& #" !( #  4!!,# ,!!

> C  #  !""## !&!(#1    !  !       (       1  ! "

&   - #  5* # 56 # +'+ ( !!! 41!#"  !#4 ""##+ ! & ! 0## !   (0 # *#4 ""## + ! #!&%   "     - #  +'+ (! ! ( 0!!&, (  C  #"# #
$ 
)* $
'


 *%

&//&
-0.
&12! 

(0  *  "

  ! !""## + ( (# !! ! # +     4 0   B  !    *  !  ""#  !  ,

" ,1 (0# !!,

(! 

2 C  # # " '(
" 


)*
 *
+,&&
-&.
 
- )(.
342   "# ;"# !4!!" 4 !!

#!&#1 ""  !  ,   !  ,1!! * !& #1* ,         4 #    ,  #    4 #    , " (,#  " 1 ,(!! !,(6 # !"

0&

 C  #  !""##  ! "#!, #* #0  "# ( ( 4!!,4 !4  (   /!   *  "#    <##      !  4  (     #1  (  ,1  !  "#  ,1    #0

"#!   * (4##1 4



7   !  !  !*  #    #    !

"6"# ! 0 !!<### 

  ,1(1    (( !!!(    0<##!  ( 0 (
 , !<##! ,;( 1(  !" !, 0&/!04 !<## #, ! , !     !  4 *  (#1*  ! 
0!    &

0!  ! 
0!  !  ,  ;(    <6   /!

,  1 !<##"

&!&%&"  ;  !<## C  # ! &#1 !<## 5-

!,,1! "# "  ! & ! #4 ##1(,#  4 "#%! "#/!  !" ##1%!"# <##"  !4 (4!!!,,1!"# 

C  #  ! "  !! (! "

( #1! 0

      !   54 &  !"# /! 0      4 "

( #1  !, <##4!!

 4 (<!! (0  5656)* 0   !&, 0!#1 & ,1! #4 ""##+ 
! 0   54  !# &  !"# *!   ! 41

& 0! 0   5B41* 0## ! #& !&, & ,1!#4 ""## + !!, 0!#1 (!    0  !  (   !     "

&0  ,# ""      ,!      #     /!   :  #1 ##  0 1   - # 5 +'+
  <##!"

( 1 * 5656)  ,!, &#%#1,#

! /!   *! (!""

"

 (1  ##0  "     - # +'+
   <##4! *!   *"  #0##1# #& , #!  ""

"

0 !  #/!;"!(   '(
" 

 *
5*
-* .! " %4! !

! ! (0   :  ""#,# !( !!& #,#,1 !"#    !#( ",1!  !4 (!, "

"  !   #0  "#( ( 4!!,!4 ( "# #&  "

   4!!  "   "         

104!!,  0!!

 0!4 ( /! #0  "#,((" &#1   #( #,1! 

!  "

"*#  #  !

" # ")
" 
-5*%



*

*.
)*
#
75(

88** 
-66(*.%
 %

  

 *
+,&9
-:.

9/2
-0.  
'

"
 & $ 6*
 8

(
+,&&
-:.

2& =#0    4   (    ,  :   4!  #0     #(    /!    #0

"# #! !""##

 C    #  #  !0!#0!  !  (1     ( !<##4!!,  1%&"  ;  !<##!04 ! # , !  !,  16   
 ,! ,  ;(  /!  <##  4   #1  !##0    ! ;(66!    C4  ""##  +   !  

#1

("

"  ##0#1,"  !  

5
#4 ""##+ ! & ! 0     * 0  54 # 1 &  !"# * # & #  #& 0,1!#4 ""##+ !    ##  !0 1   - # 5 

- C4 ""##+ !! 0   *  (  !      !   #  +      !

0  4  :      ,  &   ,1  !  #4 ""## + ;"#( , 0 !  !""#,#1 "

"##4'(
" * 5*
-* . /!"# "

4!! # ##1 %40! !   4 "

"   #&  !  ,1! 
 , #!& ! 4#,1 !"#   4 "

"  *!   *, "

 (!!,  4 #, #

4 #    ,  " (,#    !   "#    /!     "" #1*"

&, (6 #!"

0  &  /!  & 1 &#&0  ! 0  !<####0#1; ,1' 
0!*   *   #  +     #0##1  :      0   ,# ""  !" #&!#  5656)!"# # :  # & , # !<##: 
 !  ",##1,  ! *!   * ( ! !#,  

 B&4 !   ( !* ( !""#!((
-

"$.

!;$

5 
,3%
+,&: