Sarla Chawla v. Iqbal And ORS




     



 ! "!#$%$&'

( )

* +,-./--$%+,-.0- 11!--&  2!,%3% 45-&" .!,% !%1&"!& % 



 


,!%!& ' ,6 $-%31 7"0# ! , .!11!--&  &! ,,!%1&"!& % &""!%1$ !%!,0$#! ,+,,7"0# !/$ . %!.+.,67"0# ! ,,!%1&"!& 89&%3,&#! 61&:






.$% 11!- .% 5!!& $-!" 5: .! #-$6& 911!--&  %!!;$&< !&.&#!6!&   .!#61!&% $&/,"!" .!,5: ,##$"!& -$6% ,$53&-7
,$"5" =,$53&-> , %.,  0$"! /," " !"

 

 & ##3&  "! . 35:./-$&6 ,0!.$#-!##$"!& &

 (

? .!#-$6& 7/.$% .!6 .!,  .!"!#!%!"7 $-!"1! $ $& 3&"!, +!# $& ??   .!  , 2!.$#-!% #  %!!;$&< #61!&% $& & ##3&    .! "! .   .!, "3<. !, 35: ./- $&  6 , 0!.$#-! ##$"!& /.$#. ;1-#!&

 (

?


" !"

 (

?/% ,!<$% !,!"3&"!,+!# $&%

)&"8 @ -$#!+  $&-"
,$"5" <$&% ,!%1&"!&   /%1-!"!" .  .!"!#!%!"  .! $6! .!, "! ./% (:!,%-"+.!%3

!,!" A1!,6&!& "$%5$-$ : ,$<. %$"! .!,5":$&#-3"$&<.!,,6&"-!<+.!/%/,;$&<%!#!1 $&$%  /$ . 9% -3! B3C
$&! .!6 &"$7 +!# , 7
,$"5"7 !,&$&<

 %

7 9@1!,6& .+.!/%3&6,,$!"  .  $6!61!&% $&/% .3%1,:!" , .!-!,&!",$53&-&#&%$"!, $&  .! # %&"!0$"!&#! &,!#,".!-" .  .!##$"!& $&43!% $& ;1-#!"3!  .!,%.&" &!<-$<!&  ",$0$&<   

!&"$&< 0!.$#-! 5: $ % ",$0!, .!,! $% & "$%13 ! ,!<,"$&< .!50!%$" $&"$&<  .!-!,&!",$53&-& .$%$%%3!7/.$#. .%  $&!" $&-$ : B!,&!" ,$53&- 3, .!, %%!%%!" .! <!   .! "!#!%!"  5! ? :!,%   .! $6!   .!, "! . .! -!,&!" ,$53&- %%!%%!" .!$&#6!  .!"!#!%!"%%

9@1!,6& .% .!%-,: #!, $ $# !C?/%1,0!"&,!#," !,"!"3# $&< .!.3%!,!& ! #7 .!6& .-:$&#6!  .!"!#!%!"/.$#.#6! %?

9@/%,3&"!"

  %?* 9@ !"3# $&   ( A /% !

!# !" /,"% .! 1!,%&- !C1!&%!% !,11-:$&<63- $1-$!, 87  -"!1!&"!&#:/%%%!%%!"   %(78 7 9@ /% ,3&"!" 

  %(78 7 9@ & .!, %36  % ( 9@ /% /,"!" /,"% 3&!,- !C1!&%!% .3%7 #-$6& % /!,! .!-" !& $ -!" ,  - #61!&% $&   %(7(?7 9@ -&< /$ . $& !,!%  D

(A1!,&&36 ,6 .!" ! $-$&< #-$61! $ $& $--,!-$% $& B!,&!" #3&%!- , .! 11!--& % ,<3!% .  .!,! $% & ##%$& , ,!"3#$&< .! $&#6!   .! "!#!%!" ,6 %

7 9@ % & "!"3# $&%#3-".0!5!!&!

!# !" ,6.!,6& .-:%-,:.!,!$%& "$%13 ! ,!<,"$&< .! "!"3# $&   ( A $& $&#6! /,"% 1!,%&- !C1!&%!% /!0!,7 $&#,!%! $& $&#6! & ##3&   3 3,! 1,%1!# % $& 0$!/  $&-&%3,&#!61&:B "2%,&:+! .$&" .!,%7

$0$- )$%%3<.  $% .3%1,:!" .  .$%11!-5!--/!" &"#61!&% $&/,"!"5!!&.&#!"

8 B!,&!" #3&%!- , .! &%3,&#! 61&: .% ,!

3 !" .! 50! %$" ,<36!& % /.$-! %356$ $&< .  .! $613<&!" /," .% #,,!# -:5!!&1%%!"&"&<,3&" ,&:!&.&#!6!& $%6"!3   .0! .!," -!,&!" #3&%!- , .! 1, $!% &" .0! <&! .,3<. .!,!#,"/$ . .!$,5-!%%$% &#!  $%& $&"$%13 ! . "!#!%!".""$!"$& .!6 ,0!.$#-! ##$"!&  /.$#. ; 1-#! &

 (

? "3!  .! ,%. &" &!<-$<!&  ",$0$&<  .!

!&"$&<0!.$#-!5:,!%1&"!&  .!#-$6& 1,0!"& ,!#," .  .! "!#!%!" /% ",/$&<  %-,:   %

7 9@ 1!, 6& . /.$-! /,;$&< % !#!1 $&$%  /$ . 9% 9% -3! B3C
$&! .!6 &"$7 +!# , 7
,$"5"EF:G36, . $7, &!, 9% -3!B3C
$&! .!6 &"$7
,$"5" 5,3<.  .! %366&!" ,!#," % /!-- % %-,: %-$1%  .!"!#!%!"C   .!"!#!%!"/% ?:!,%-"  .! $6! .!,"! .!,$&#6!/%%%!%%!"%%?* 9@/.$-!"!"3# $&< % ) 9@%.3%!,!& 7%

9@%#&0!:&#!--/&#!&"%(? 9@ % .!,--/&#!1!,3%-  .!%-,:%-$1,!0!-% . %3#."!"3# $&% ,! &  F3% $ $!" +-,:   .! "!#!%!" $% 1,0!"  5! %

9@ 1!, 6& .  3- $1-$!,  * $&% !"  8 .%  5! 11-$!" & 0$!/   .! <3$"!-$&!% -$" "/& 5: .! &>5-! +31,!6! 3,  $&  $&- &%3,&#! 61&:B "2%,&:+! .$&" .!,%7

$0$- )7 A $&#,!%! $& $&#6! .%  5!

,"!" & ##3&   3 3,! 1,%1!# %

!"3# $& ( A /,"%1!,%&-!C1!&%!%.%,$<. -:5!!&!

!# !".! #-$6&  $% !& $ -!"  % (7 9@ !#. , -%%   !%  ! &" 3&!,- !C1!&%!%$&% !" % (7 9@ /,"% 3&!,-!C1!&%!% 11!--& @#-$6& $%7 .3%7!& $ -!" #61!&% $&7/.$#.$%,!@ /,;!"%3&"!,'@


 

  

 &#6!

9@16 $!7 77 9@1!,&&36

  -$&#6! !,""$ $&  .!, !  A&##3& 

3 3,!1,%1!# %

77 H( ?  77 C A I 7? 9@ 8 &#6! !,"!"3# $& ( A &##3&  1!,%&- !C1!&%!%

7? J 7 7*  7? 9  I 7 7* 9@   -"!1!&"!&#: !,11-:$&< 63- $1-$!, *  7 7*  *I *7 7 9@ ( B%% !%  !

(7 9@ ? B%% 3&!,-

(7 9@ 
 

*77 9@ .!63&  #61!&% $&-,!":/,"!"  .!11!--& 7 &!!"-!%% %:7%.--% &""!"3# !" ,6 .!63& #-#3- !"%50! 11!--& %.--5!!& $ -!" $& !,!%   .!, ! (A1!,&&36& .! !&.&#!"63&  ,6 .!" ! $-$&<  .!1! $ $& $--,!-$K $& E$ . .!50!%$"6"$ $# $&$& .!/,"" !"

 

7 1,!%!& 11!-$%"$%1%!" 




  +!1 !65!, (7

* %./, E.! .!,%1!;$&<9,!%&!"'@ !%9 E.! .!,,!1, 5-!'@ !%9