← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1852/2016allowed

The High Court Of Punjab And Haryana Chd Th Its Registrar v. Jaswant Singh

2019-09-03Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Rajiv Narain Raina,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu28 pages

       

  

 

     

  !

#$ % 

()'    *$(')' +""

 ,  - !)'  "

  !

"#"$ !

#  !

" "" 

  . !'# +

 '

""

  . 

/"

+

 '

 "

   (+1

2!1 /(!1 (3   &'45  ''$

    6     !

#$  7 -'

$-'

# ) '8



+""

 5  ' $  '

   

*)#    '  %&'"()*+(,,-."/%/0 1)&%2$33 45 "67 -'

 '$

'

 '  '

"'#  -'

- 

#" 

 " #  "

) 

           

 

    

    

   "

  

- ""

  9!

 

  " %7 ( -)  '""

 #   ' )'

  "  '  9!

   ')'  % ( -    '

()'      7( -"

 !+   :

!"

   / ;11 < !"

   / ;1  % ' - 9)!+  '

-  - ' ')

'

< #"

  #* "

   )  )   + ) 6-'

,   <:

   "")     - ' #   -#"

"

  '#  (  "       ""

   -' '       < 9)    - '

 "

 -#   '  "")     - '

  #   1 -

 '

"'#  #"

'

 $ 9  ' "'#    = !'

)  '

##  * "

       -"

!"

   / ;11 <: "

  -"  - " #  "

) )  )  '#  &'

   !' 

)  -  "

   !"

   / ;1 %:<&'

  "

  -

  '

    '"'#  - #:7

%<+  '

>"  ' "

  '

"

  -"

 !"

    / ;11   <    !"

    / ;1   : ( $#  "     #      <"  '

  ""

 >   '  '

"'# #"

'## $ 9 #  

7   ') ;'

&'

 "    - *

     7 ( $#  "     : 6  ) '  '

 $  "

   '

 "

    !"

    / ;11  -  <:

  '

   -'

  '  ##   *    !' 

)  - "

    '  '

 $  )      6    $     ) "  "

  +   )  $ 9)'"

  "")     - '

  #    $ 9

 ) ##    

<   ') '

< -'

 '

 )  -

( -  '  '

"

     "'#  $

     #     <  &'

  "      - *

   % < +)) '

 

 -' ''$

 - &'

8!) ) '

 '  '

"'#  -  $ 9

" "

  -' '- $   ') ;'

  <( '$



$ "

 !"

   / ;11-  <:

-'

'* !'

)- "

- '  6  $    8!) )    '

 %&'"()*+ (,,-."/%/0 1)&%2$33 45"67 -'

 -'

 '  '

"'#      $ 9   "

   -'

  '

 ?  #   -

## 

 ()'  "  8



 +""

&'



6  '   !

#$  7#  '

""

    *)#   8!) ) 1    '  '

" "      -    .*   !)'  /@    -    6   ;

       -)  -"   

                 



  !

     " 

"   

        

                  

    #                $ 

   %  & '            (             

  

$    

 )     

   

    $   *  + $&, &

-$

(!..

/!0&*1 23      & '         

   + $&,4  /  )   

 %  5   "  %   

        %    5    

 64  * '  +  (   

      $        %  & '    

   &' '

- '

# '$

 $ 45  ' "/%/0 1)&%2-.%&'"()*+(,,$33645"   !     *)#   

  .* !)'/ '  '

"'#  #"

 " #  "

) -  $ 9 "

 #   -'

 '

#  -

  -   '

  $ 

   '    %       '

    .*   !)'  /  -  '  '

   '

-'

$ ) $ 9- -""

  !$;

 2)

 '

*$!

 2)

A $  9

" #  B5C5 ';11!

 +)  <( -

# 7 ' !

#$  <+"

*$!

 2)

 1  A5CB  7  !211 )

- )$  "   !2;  1  )'        ") " #    >#    &'

 "

    '

  $ )$  

    " !2;1-    #"

 )'   !2;11+    '

5 9-$

$ -   : +#

)  ! 

) ##



             "   -  '

   

#$   

#$  &'

"

  '

- -   '

-

- 6 "

)) '#= 6- "

   :

-   &'

 6"

  "

  <% -' ' ') ;'

-  "

'# <:&' 6'$

#"

 '$

     #"

"'#   "")     - ' #   (  ' ;

    " $) '

- "

  1 -  '$ ' '  '

6 "'#   '

#"

- 

$ 9   <%   '

#     <:-'

 '

 ') '

-    $  9      " - 

  : -' '#  : 

"  '  -

$  9     8!) )  '   1 - $    D>>> >>> >>> "          (7                       1       

           

 

 

       

8    

     

 

    !.

2            

       

   !.

9   #    / 

 

       





 0 



 +""

  '

) -"



*)#   "/%/0 1)&%2-.%&'"()*+(,,$33645"  &'

*)#     !) ) -"'

 1 -

$   ;

 1  (

   (

 



   + $&,(   (     )( (       (                  (  

   !.

2



!.

9(   #       !"      :   -.* !)'/@ 

 '  '

"'# #"

 " #  "

) $ 9 "

 -'

 '

#  - ## -'

 '

 ') ;'

-   

8

  - ' '

- $ '

( @$ !"    )     7     ' - #    

    



  +   '  #$ 

  

  - ' ' "

$  ' $

    -     < 6       $ !"   - "

   ")"' *)#     1  )       

 



  $           *  

(  )    :

/!0  

     

            

                 ;/ 0

                     

 ;/201

 

                < 

               

;  1                            (     

              

  

     (            

        )  

     6  (     

  

   )   - !"    E  

 :

  

            

            

    ; -   $  

  -  '

6    '  '

  1    !  "   '

 3     1    '

""

 ' ' )  '

)

 $ '

  5  '

   +#   &$ )*)#   45  '

&$-'

$ '   9 - - "    =

.

#

??< 2 A+B %   $ '

/ #   1A

" #   

  C&)B  '

$*

"   -'

  D '

 "

 F' $

    -   $  )  -'

#   "?

  "

)  -

)  ) #    1 '

# # '

  -)"

 - - 2/0/ 0  7    

                

       

           

( / 0     #

   

       

                     

    /01 

       =   

- *

       

 

  /0   <              (   =-*     

  

 

    

         /0     7    >  ?

       (   

      

( 

 /0    (    =-* 

    7 

   

   (        =-*    

   /0  "                      

3 =   

  -   *

   )   =-*(  

(            =-*                      (    

    ?       

       

   7        (                (       

  (         < 

  

  ( 

  ( (

    

      

             (    

         /0   

            

 

  < $

    1                 (        $ 

 (            

 

 (       



5       

                 

 

  7                

      (            

  

1  ?                 <

=-*                  1  <  

   

           

      

     

    (  > ?                  7       

   

    (       

 

   1      



   

                 < 

              +"

")"'AB  '# #  '

) 9 "  $ '

" #    ##



"

    " #  ?   "

) $ 6

       '

     '

      )  '

 "

   '

 "?

 "

) "

)  -  6   G  9

" '

)   = '

   "?

 "

)

#$ 1   - #"



>  "

  ) '    -#"

   "

$     '  "  $     '

 "

      '

 "?

  "

)  )  '#  -   $  

#   - '

"

  AB) '# '

) '



?

- ' " ' > *

 '

$   ' "

  &'

   - $ ) "  # '  $    "- "$ '#  '

"

  " "

) '

 "   1"

 -#"

 '

   

 ""

) '

- )  '

 "

) ) '# ) '

 ?

-  $ "

  G   " - '

$   '

  >

   -' '  #

    '

  #       '

      '

  "?

 "

) % &$  9 - '

  -)"

   '



 $;")"'   AB ")"'% 7         

       

      (            

  

  1 

 '  '

"

)  "

  "



 '

$   "   -

  '

)  '

)'       "

  #"

1 -'

 ' ' # "  $   $ 6  

"   '

    : 1  '

  '   #     '

 #     "    '

$ 6  

#   $ *

"$  $ )   +   7       7 &$

 ' -'

 #" 

 - '      ""

) '

'

$   -

  '

-'

 '

 "

 -  -  '

  -

'

   '

) '

 

 #"

 < ( @$ !"   '

 '  '

&$- )'   9) - '

"

  

$;")"'   AB ")"'% .

#  1 -'

 '  #" 

-'

'$

 )   #    $  

"- ' '

#" 

-'

-

   ) &'

-  #  -'

 '

# " '

 

  1 - '

'

 '  #" 

 $  - - ' "

 "  # -'

 '  $  '  '

"

       ) '  '

 " #  $

*

" '

 ' -'

 #" 

'

) "

 

 "

     '

-' ''

"

 '

  $  ' $

$*

 '

"

   '

 

 " #" 

 '  #  - "

 $ 

  6 '   %    $         #"

 (  1     

          (

    

    



         



  7      

(            

 

      

 1      

           

 

     

 @  (

    (         



          



  

 "      6                  1    (  

 (      

1)  (  

 <

    

    1

   <

         

 

      "

7     

 

                       

    1  (    ( 

 

 ( 

   1 

 <

  



          

 

   

 



        

         (    (

 

   

     (

  

 $

     

 "      

         )   

7 

(        

   

  



           

 

     (   

   $  7(  (     

   

                    

(  

  



       

   





         (

        

       

   

    A    (     

 1              #     /0  2    +   (    (        1   %  &$ ' -'

"

 #"

 #" 

    ""

) '

'

$   -

  '

-'

 '

 "

 -  -

6  '

  -

'

   '

) '

   "

 #"

' '

   )$ 9 '

"

 #"

   

 % &' -- "" $ '

!"    %% 4 #  '

$       9#@    '

   -) "    $  9 ' $

  AB + #" 

-'

 - '"

  ""

) -'

  -9 "    $ ) "  # '

)  AB+ #" 

 )  #    $ " " - ' '

#" 

(  ' $  

  &'

  #  -'

 '

# " '

 

   AB! ' #" 

  $ ) "  "

  #  -'

     '    $  '    '

   "

    "    1    -      #" 

 -'

   '

  )      " #  "

)  $ "

   '

-' ''

"

 AB 5 " )'#   '

-' ''

"

 '

 $  ' $

$*

 '

"

   '

 +  "  '  #   "

  $ 

  6 '   AB'  )  '

      #" 

     "   '

" )   '

     9        '

 "

       -    '

#" 

   '

 "        '# "  ' )  AB&'

" ) '

    9      '

"

  #"

   "

) " #  "

) -' '

         " -'

  '

  '

 

  '

" 

  % !"    '# )  '

"'# #"

 ""

)  )$ 9     )   "

 "  # $ #"

   &'

"'#    9   # '

 #"

 #" 

 "  $   9)  "'#  #"

 '

     %:  - '  '

 #      "  

$   ) '

    "'#    "

 -'

 '

"'#  -    '  '

 "'#  -      #  '

       #"

      H      '

  " #   "

)       #          '  $

      $ 6     %7 1

$%$ & '& &(   

)*

#+* '

 "

  -- 9)+  !    = &'

!

'  "

)) '# #   '

  < 5   7;; "'#    "")  '

    - '

  #   -#"

'#=""

 '

"'# -  +)   ;6-

= '6

# "'#  -#"

$"

) 7;

; &'

"

   -          "    '

 "

   

" 



) '

  %;(  =+

% 

$

+#   &$ .&'

=+- - $ '

  7;7;

%1 



   '   " - ' 

 # %;+ ) '  -  '

-"

- '   #%;; 

 %< 6    $ !"   - -'

;

    "

  G"   '

  %;- ) &'

&$''

 ' "  $ - ''



  #"

  "

  "'#    "")  '

    - #   D $ *

"F % + -) '

""

 !

& ( @$ !"

 '

  ) 

  7    

   3#!

#!.B (                           3#!!#!.B (                  ,     1     

   )C 2 C   

   =

 &

 (  =    =

    &

             

 (           

    <

 ) 7   ( "

&

 @  

=  =

     



   D      <

 ) (            



 ,"5    '  * D7  EF'

 (/"7C

 !B( B0    :

/&**!

2( .0 "

 (  1     

             (                

           

    

       

7  

(      

  

       

1      

  

       

 

8     

 @  (      (          

          

   

 "    6   

   1      (      

   (        

 

1)  (  

 <

            

      1

   <

   

    

 

        "             

 

            

   1  (    (  

   

 ( 

    1 

 <

    





           

 

 



 



                   (

   (  

   

     (    

 $



    

 "       

      

 )   

7

(   

     

   

     (        $  7(  (        

      

              

                 

(  

  

 

       

 

 





     A    (     

1         

   #     /0   2   +   (    (     1   + 7       

          

 

(    

  

            

 (          

           

       D        <   <  (   

    

    

 @   (   

                C      

D   

 

(           

  

     $    

#  

     

"   !"  !   " !3  *  %  1    # &--*

)  '

"

  -"

 #( ""

  '

 6   "

 +  G  -' ''

- 5 '

 $ "

'

- )  ""

)- "'#   - ''

)     "

   >#  '5   '"

  '

 "

'#- #" ( ""  '

  +#   &$&'

&$ - '" '

) ' '

-    $ "

- '   #

#$   - '  6  $  1 -'

 '   '

 " '##    

"'# -' ' "

#$   ( @$ !"     *)#   $ )    *1             C !9   - 1   +  G F 777(       

   

     

                  

   (       

   

   1           

3  

       $      

      

            

    1       $     

 

   C !9     

&

           

    (     

  1                         

 

       

      (                  )      1   

    

  

                     

         

      <  

  C !9 7  

 

C !9  

      $

      

     $       

 

  $ 



      H       $  (

    

   "    !    !3    * 7 @     (   



              $ 

    #  

 1  $  (    (   )7  

           

 <  

  (        

       <  &    ! (  !..  7 

            

      

&  !9(!..(        )             ) 

  1     

      



  1 

 

.  /0 .

1

& 2 ,+

,*  "

  - #"   '

 .) /  !     - '  '

 ""

 ;59   " "

)  -

  ) '#=;:; <'

-#"

"

     $ "$ '

 ) &'

""

  '

 $   %;<;

  '

"'#      $ "$  ) &'

 -) '

 $    ;%;

      '

""

  '

   '

)"'#      $ "$ '

 )    "

  -   " .

.)  / !  11A'

   I../!;11GB- '

  #;; 7 - $#  "

   - $ '

""

 ;59 '

# " 1   "

     -  )  #   "

 "  $  !C 

 

     G1         

                       %  "

    - "

   ' ))  '

 "'#   ' ;

    " ../!;11- '

  #;; 7&'

()'  '

 '  '

 ;

  

"

   " ../!;11) '

"

  '

"'# -        )'  +   7

    1 -'

 ' "'#  -  '

 "

   '

 ""

) -    '# #$ )

 

  " ../!;11- '   #;; 7'

-

- )$  $ )  ( - )

$   "  1""

( @$ !"   '

  9+ 1    )        )    

        

     

  #5 (        <  

 

        

            

   

     

1)         *    D   7  EE  7 

               <       

            ( 



       (     C !9   -  1   +  GF777   

 

           

            

 

      

        1* (       C (   :/&**9 (  0  

    

         

       1         $     

     C !9  

   &

               (



  1                     

              (                

          )   

  1   

    

  

           

       



         <  

  C !9 7  

 

C !9                   $

      

    $         

  $ 



     H        $  (

  

"  !  !3  * 7 @     ( 

 



       

     $ 

    #  

  & (D7 EF'

 (  *   :/&**!

2( .0 "     





             

    1  (    (  

   

 ( 

    1 

 <

  





           

 

 



 



                   (

   (  

   

     (    

 $



    

 "       

      

 )   

  6

           (     

                      ++,&#77        



  

     



             "   !3    * 7   6*   $             #5 

1 

    6*   

       ++,&#77 

!#B#!.B3  

    (    (

 7  1     

I    134 5  - /

04 (

6

- 72

8 , 

#, ( @$ !"   '

 ' -'

  ; #;   '

   #"

  "

   "")

   ;

     '

#" 

$    " ) '

    "'#  ) '   '

-  $  ) )"'#   1 - $    9"     

  



  

     (   # 

 

        (   $

       C  !3(          

     # #             1         (         

 (          

    (  (  # #  6 (   #

#     (           !#2#!.BB     )(          !#2#!.B.( (  B# #!.. (#     H      

 

                 

     * )  (   

  & "



  

     (     

    &                

  (              

    1   ($

  

  & "

6     

 

  6 (                

 6 

    !#2#!..  : 1 .4     +

,  '

"

   -  - 9)       +      '

   +   !

  / #   1AJ 9  B5   <;; :"  " #  "

)"

  - ''

)          "

     -     -  #"

    '#  =  '

##  

 '

-"

!

 +   $

   ;; < - '     # <!$ 6   $

  %;:;

 '

  -#   '

"  "

  -#    #%    # '

-' ' '

"

  - ''

)     +)) $ '   '

 "

  A=+

< 

B$    +#   &$ 5) 5  '&'

"

  - - $ '

&$&'

&$''

 '  '

 "

  -"

  "

 

#$  <- '   # < '

 '

' ')  '

    ' "

  - $ *  $  

 '

#   )"  #  

" &'

&$

 '  '

"

"

  $ #   < 7 3 1""

$ !"   &'

  3 1- '  '

    < " ) '

 "

  !

 +   -  < -' '

"'#   - ''

)  -    #"

'#-

  -   '  '$

)'   $) ) " - %    '

-' ' '

"'#





- &'

""

- - &'

*)#   &$  6')  '

     %:

   )  '

  "  "

  !

 +   # # <

% -   ( @$    $    9)1          

 $   * D7 E E   7 

    *            C !9   - 1   +  ( F  777(        

       

    

           

         

        1  $    1  

 

           -  E   "   1  * (  

    $    1  (   :/&**9 (  0   

    

         

       1         $     

     C !9  

   &

               (



  1                     

              (                

          )   

  1   

    

  

           

       

        <  

  C !9 7  

 

C !9                   $

      

    $   ,1  

!!#!!#!.B      

  & "



  

!# #!.B ( 

               

( (    ( 



  

          

!#2#!.BB( (  

      

   

 +1    (

 ( 

 

        *  *    &     7  C   E,&5

    *  

 <      "  !23 * (    *                          (   (   (  ( <

(

7 

 

 

*       

 

  

 

   (     

 1          

         

  2#9#!..

  

      !# #!.B

!#2#!.BB (    

    (

   

         

    *     "   !23      *   1  $    1  

 #2#!..9   @"I!!!

!..  

 #.#!..9  C"I9.

!..9  (    (    )   

 2#9#!..    

 & 



   !# #!.B   !#2#!.BB        1    ( (  )      < 

           & 



 

     

   & "



        

!!#!!#!.B  B# #!.BB < +  5  '  '   1    0 

 8  # ,

$##    ) *)#   ' 5 (

/00!  '

 '  '

$   #  '  '

"

 #"

-  $ 9 -'

 '

#  - ## -

#  '

"

  #      " "   ""   -      $     !3@      

 

 (  

9      

 

     

   

   



   =-*" 

$ 

              <        

(    *         

      

 



 

     

  

    

 

7

  



  *        

         J       

     

       

    

  1   

                 J      

   

   

 )           &   

        

   

       $    1 '

)'    '

 $ '

 '  '

*)#  .* !)'/'

) '  '

"'#  #"

 " #  "

)D-  $ 9 "

 -'

 '

 )

 

 ?#  - ##   -'

 '

# -

F 

  - '

 -&'

"'#  ?"

    " "

  # '

 #"

     + ) '""

 - &'

*)#   ""

  &'

- "

  #  4#"54#54 "" 5       "0:/0;20' 7$

3 ) '

!"

9)?  K '

  $

K