High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/839/2014allowed

Dilbagh Singh v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2015-01-29Mr. Justice Jaspal Singh,Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal9 pages

!"#!"

$ #

% & " '()*"+ &,

"-- '.$,/ && &, 0 %

"- & 2"-- ""! " &-& &#!&!&& 3 &.!"4- - & "--"!!" &&& 3 567 8&.

!".%&9 ."-

# 72- ",!

&! "&-. : "&!".;"--&", - &

"--4 &.&,& &67 & 7-,

"--"

&! && "<: =

"!&-. : "&!"--4"

" ,&!".

"4 4"

", - && &! " :

" -- & " "! ,& !"--% """,4

4- "- 4""!&&

/- & & ", & " & ! " "! ,&! " -- ", 6.& ;": - "

.&"

"--!

""!,&!".;":

- &" : &

"--&" : &

"--&, "

&, & " " .&

"---&!!"--" : = " " "&

" - & " ,&" -

" "

"-- & &"&!"&-.:

"4 ", -- & " "! ,& ! " -- % &"

,&", --& &-.- &!& "

" &! &&

" <: =

" : - &

"9 % " &"" &

"--4"""&,&-".

.- &- ".

".7 & 4""4 "&

", ..& ".

"- .&

" <: =

% -- " &

" --&" : &

", & -- % " &"" &-& & #! &! &, -"& & " -- &.& > ", && " . .& "

"-&4"" ",!

" !"

" &

)

"" (.,#!"

#"-#!"

$!&4 ;"& (" &- & -

.! .. "& &/&+ /4"" 4& ".% &

- &" &

"- ,"4"".

" % &--

"#-&

("!""

"9". *"'$!#.-'&&",! && #%=*.

(. *" #"" " "4 -

&".

&&!

-!4"".;" /&". " .+ / 4"". &" /&". 4"

,"4"".

" >""4-

. - " )! & " & "! &" &

".% 4, " &"."-

4",!" ""

& "& ..&" % "

:& " " . :& &

-- - / @ ="-- -. : 4"& - #-&

0"& "

: - "!7"&&

4,&- "--;"! !"--4" "

"9".*" $!#.-'&&

(.,4/& "--7#2 !"#!" + /&" 4"

"- ,"4"" .

">"(.,&- &! &

"4"" .

"--- ! ".

" -".&" ! /& ". 4 " ;" . 4" " &

4! " " -- - " " .

2- *.(. #%= # "&4 - -! "

&- ""& ..&

&- !..

&-&

& "

-" -" *! &* 3 *- 4 .& " "!7" " -- 4"" 4

& & ! &-. : 4 & ! ". #6 - 446.&

4""

#2#7>&#2 #-#!"7>"& - &&" &4"!& !&",7

"--2- *.(.7 > 4"

4 &- & &! " :

- &! 3 4"""&&"#2 !"

#!" 5--8&(., & /& ". - & " &

"- ,"4"".

"".

"-- 4 .4"".

"+ /!

!" . 4"" 4 /& (., & "

4& "

;" -- " & - & (.,24 &

4 . ""2- *.(.&& ""--"&"- "

(., ,"& " (*.7> !&

$!&44 - 4" " . !&! " -- .&

(., 4 && " " % & "

! 4 ,& !

" -

"$! .!&!-! "

4&&% &"".4 && "" "!"!&4 &

-+#!"7>

%# - #-&

- 4"

"&"&"-. : % " 7 6. &"""&:& ". .#%=

# "& & " 4 -

&- &!"-- .% &.& " .-4,&!"--4""4 & # "&6-

" .- 4""4 !:& (.,B$/ 7>@ " .- &"" "& & .& .

" " &

-46& ".%"&&"" "" && 4 / ! "-- .&

". " ! " -- &&

.& " .-(.,#!"4 & ;",- &

47 ) &

" 4 , "#%= & " -

. . " " 9*

4"#"*.(.#%=&*" #""

&"!4".& "&+ / .. ;" "& /&. 4- ,""

">"2& 4!"

. -&.

"2. && "! 2& / 4 4"

-&&.

"% 4, .

&"-

4 ",! " " "

& " ..&"D -

" , 4 & "

4 " "

4"!& - ",! --&". . 4!

4"".

"- ,">""" 4""4 4!"4"".

. -& ".

" % ! & & "!

4, " &"-

4",!" " "

& "& ..&"2 : . & """" & 4 "-

*" &#""- .#%=*.(. !- " - *"&#""", 6.&&!" &-. : ;"

(., 4"

-4""&

/- " .& &

& &

""- 4"

"& " - &&&!": = &! " ,& " " . &! " &-.:

&""4 4"

", - && " : - &! ", -- & " ! !"--A"!

! " .- --""- 4"

- "

" .-

44!" ""

& " --&.&

"! 4# 72- & "

4 & 4! ""

& "

"4 4"

"&&- &&!":

" &""--"&- "

" .- (.,;" "

4"" &! &&!" -- & +&.&- 4""-

"<: =

& !!

, ,& & ! " -- *"" &! & & ,& 2 " "&

+&!. " #-.9 ""%!"9 4"6!+& &@

2& 4 -- "-

"<: =

% 4, 4"4" " &!: - & ,& "9 :& & +& -"+ 4""" --&

2 "

!"#!"$ !

% $& ' '(!)*+%""!" ,--./0,121 " "& #-.9 ""9 4"6!4+& & 4" " &! && &! " &-.: ! ,"& &!-- "

&""+& .&% 4,

6- ", ,& " !& 4"" & 4

"%!"9 4""& .: ,&

&! ! & ,&" - @ 2"

!( + +'*( $$$&!3

!$(&"'

5 8#99

" "& "#-. ""

&!&-.- &!!0 ,. .-

.- !-". " !

.7 &&"# *"

:7+& - &! ;"-".

.7 & .- & 4""# *&--

+ ;"

- & &"9 &

9, &

&"2&<,& 3& -- "& .: "--

+ :& ,& ;": &&

& &": - . "

"! " " " "! .& ! " &:

&- ,&!"&:

2" "9 66 & 4+&

3 4"" &!" &&

"<: =

- 4"

!,! "

4" --, ,&".7 &&",& "

4""

" &!", &&!". 2,4

" , "--- 4&;" +&!.-& "&#!&!" & ;"-

"<: =

@ 5678 " :"& ! & ,& : "

" &&& 3 567 8-& #-&

(" &.

!"--%& ."-

# 72- &" & && 567 8-& "2- 0

(*! (7--"

&" & -& "&& 0

&. , 5678" :"&;"--"& & : 4""4 & & ".

4"- &

" ."&

" & / / 0 +"45-51,6 -+