Krishan Malik v. Executive Engineer (C-1) Ccs Hau Hisar And ANR.










 






 
  



















 




!"
#$%$!&'() *)

+ ,-$%.

&
 /$0












1 -%2%
3 #2$4
&5$& -

6

$% -
&7
&!. -



 

'

89
)
6
6
6
    
 


   


  


   

 
  !!!!

6
6

:
)
- /  "
 


#




  $% &&$ '



#(


 
) 
*
+ 
,#(

 #-  
#(

 .



 
/0


#   
1  
 
223
 
 


4 


 
#  5

 & 6



#


 
,  

#




#5 


5
,
7   # ,

 .




  (

   
 

,9
,
 




7
.&  
$'$3&$


,

 



$


&
(



 


 


5
- 

+ 1

$.: $ (
 

,
15

11+8
+ 
+
#5 











 
 5


,9
 
$'$3&$ 

,

 
  



;
,

# 5


 
    ,

#

#(

  (


 

,
5  

;

 
 
 

 

.



    



     

 

 

   !      "

# $$$ $$$ $$$ "

# $$$ $$$ $$$ "

#% &'

()*+,-.  /(01 "'

 $2

3

  4 5#6 / <

 


 

#5 


( 
 

# 5
, 7

#


,

 




 ,


#

#(

  (
#

  (  


5


 .



 = (





#
  

 





#
5 
 5
"5
,



 
  

,

#
5 
, 
 
 
5 



,(

  
 
# ,

 
 
5 
,



#  

6
#  

 


5




  (





  


#
  









5



 0 6

#5 



 

 
,9 
,
 

7
.&
 
$'$3&$ 

  .

8  (





 
 


7
 


$%$3&$  ,

 


;


,
 
#

5
,
 


 9,







#








(


# 5




#
5 

5
#   

=

#
5



  (

(









 # 5

5
,

 

#(
5


 

,


 


5





;


#




  
  



,

,



5



,( ,

  
 

5 
,


#  
#

 #  


 

  





    <



#- 

 
/0
 

5
,  

 
#(


 
) 
*
,

 #- 

 
/0

  (
, 




  

.

(

# 5
<
 






#(
 
 
) 
*

#5 


,
# 


  





 
,  9




 



(




,#(


 

, 
,
 



;

 

 
# 
,

 9


#(

9



 
# 

5

' &$

>7   
>




 
,(

# 5 




 

 
5   , 
,

5


  






,
  


 
;


#

,  9


(

' &$ 
 

,


 
#
(
#(

  ( 

 .


+
#5 


,


# 
 5




#(


 
) 
*



, 
#

#

  ; ?

 





#

   (
,
 


 
, 
,
 
# 

1

(



 
) 
*
#
 

 
#  

#5 


5
, 
 
#
 
#(
 











 


(









 5 
+
#5 




#


7
.&

,9 
,




$'$3&$
,

 

, 


 
# 

#
  

#


(
7
 


 
,






 .




$%$3&$

5
 >> 1 : :+1:<.%&/:0//2.0;
, 
 
5

 &


#   
+
#5 



#
 


 
,
,

 
(
7
 

 
;


,
 


 
,





#(

>7   
>



  (



 
 .



, 

#(
,(


 





,(
,



#
5 

9






   
,








9,




#  

,








5 

 




 .


5  
"
 
 
 
$%$3&$
, 
 


 # 
 



 &


 
 

.

'31723'38 9  23$ 43

 " #  

  2 0



 14   1

:; 5: 

  :<)/;(/)+<),<=/(; <(= :33" ,//,,>-); :0//2.0; 8?*)*(;*//  ?- >  ..   /*//@/;5. 

  .  . ..      '/*-,/*5.

  :.

 

 








+  ?;(** 

7  

 := /)-;= +(;*//

A 4 2 :"

#    B   @  

    ,- 3$ 43

 " # 3 <
 


 
 


#5  
 

 
;

 

 


(
7
(
 5


5
 

 
#

#(

>7   
> #(
 

 


(




,
 5


 
 
 
$%$3&$

# 5
   
   
"
 
#   

5 


 


 0;




# 
 

, 
 

 




#(



5 
 
>7   
>


  (
9
7  

5 "
 

 
$  $&$
,


  


,9
,
  
5

 

>> 1 : :+1:<.%&/:0//2.0;
 
$%$3&$

 
 
 
5#
, 

#
 
# 


5




, 
,
 

#(




,
 


,  


(
 

,
 
 


,9

#

5 



 
5
#  



(
 

. # ( 
5 

4@9
=(4
+
#5 

 



5 


, 

 


  (

?

#
&$ 

,




#
5 

9






,



9,
  



 


5 
,

 #

@9
=(








( , 
5




 


# 5
5

 

=( 

5

  (

 
 


9
#(
 

 (
5

  




 
  
"
   
 
$  $&$


 0;


# 
 

 
 
.

8*/,/*,// 2 23$ 43

 " #  

   ?

3$

  C>   ..   /*//@/;5.

 

.  . ..   A    '/*-/*5.

 : .

 

 C .;+;;*/; ',  24   

4 

  :33"7#,//,,>-); ,= <-= *)*(;*//2  .

 .;+-;-;*/; %  .

  

4 

     5  -4



5 0

 5  

 D  5   .

   5.

 $ .;+-;-;*/; 2

5  ,-  



'
+
#5 


 



, 

#
 
 
/'


, 



 (
5 











; 
 
) 
*
,
 

#- 
  
/0


(

, 

 





,



 #
, 




 
#- 

, 
  


  

 
/0


 
(
 
 5




 
 % A
 






   2
"




  



 

,
, 


.

5 


,9
#(

 
, 







,


#
5 
, 

5  
"
,9

,
 







7
.&

$'$3&$



 5  , 
5  
"
,

 



 

,9
 
# 




5 

 
 5 

 # 5
,

#

#(


  (

 
,
  5 


;

 
?

(
7
(


$%$3&$ 

 
,




#(


  (




#(
,(


  



 


 
;

 
A

,(
 # 5
,
 








  .

8  (
,



#

#(


  (
A
,












 
 
,

 
9,



#  

,

 
 
,
  


 
 
 
$%$3&$
,
,


5


#









, 
#(
,(


 
 
" 5
 
#(








,


 9,


 
, 

5 
5




  
55  
#(


5 


,
 

 , 


  (

$  $&$
#(
 
  










 
 
 
#(
 

5
55
5#


5
 
  


#

 5



,

,

 
  $ "

 
) 
*
,
 
 #- 

 
/0


, 







'

 5



,

,

# 



, ( 


  

# 5
,  9



 "
1



 
,

 (





 
/0

 (
5 
"
#-  
#
,



 ,

#
  

(
,

5 
, 
 
#


  

   (
  

 


A

 


 


#
#


 
(




, 

 5 

 
/0



,

 
#

 
" (
5
, 
,
 
#(






,



,

 



+, 

 


 5
, 
 #

 

#(






  (
,

,




5

 
#(







 
 
 
,



9,

5 
#  

   
$%$3&$
,



#(
,(



 



,


 




5
,
 
 

#(


5 

 
 
 
$  $&$
 
# 
" 

,
 
 #
, 


 
) 
*


 
7   , 
 
 

,
& 5(




 
/'



 
5 
A



 
,


1

 
-  
,


  

 # 
,








 
/0

5(








* 



7 5



 5 



  (






 
 



5(
#
5


-5

+4# 5
1

B
         

              

 !"
,

,






   




 
/'


,
  
  
,
5



-5



#(
+C#
5 1

B #    $% $   &'(  % )   " * !+

 

,- ./'

&   )01 $2 3 (

.$  " 4 !5


 
 


 
-5


  

  6  !

& 
 

.

=   .    ..    +    

  



 7  #    $7% $    8(  %

  

?"E=+)#
/  2 

     $  5      

       = .          

  .



5 



5

    

 F        2    

                                        

     

 

 G   ?

  %

     .  )/  .   =;H  2      

  A

7..   +     ...

   4  

    

.  

 

5 .     =6








  ".



 

..

#   7 - .  /'   &     8  )0  1 $ 3 . /)

  

?"E< #
/) 5 A

        +   5 

  2I4JI
9

 -  




 
/0
  .   5  ..    + $    

  

 

 

   

A              

 

   =6 / D5




 5  



 

 







  



 
-  



1

 



5

#(



9
    1 = (


5


 


5

#(  5



 

       < 
9  E : < 
 #  E :