Chander Shekhar v. Binder Singh & ANR
!"
# $% & '()( '
!"
$!*!+*, - * & )()( '
./!
0 0 !*&
()( '
& 12
3( 3 3
3
!" # " $ %
&&&& 3
3
(
'
(
) %* +, %+'* -
"(
" '** #
'.,,/
0( 12 " "
" '
3+ +++45/
2 / 6.
**+45
- "2)73 89 "
-"#
%* +, %+'%)"
-
!
"# $ %
%* +, %+'% ") -) ")
-) " : " ;
++ ) - " "
- - ) - $ <5', 5+83;)- " - $ '
)- )
) " " ) ( " - ) ) )" = " " = ) ) "= >?- !!$ %* %3 , '%) : "
$ '
@ "
) - "
4 "
;
A" ( "
)5
! "#$% &'% ()* ! !+
" ) ,-.// 0 " 1
1 1 2
-.// ,
"
1 -./# *# 3
) (
( ) "
"4
=) 8+9 "
))
4 "
- =
3
2 32 3 *
B
C " ( )
-
))"--
= "
)"
- )-
- D : " - $ 'C
B
"
) - ( E
"") - E
- " ,
> " -
)"
) -"
.
$ % )
"-)- ) - " "
-( - ( - "
'+ : )
''
) ) 5 045". 6 0 1 '0
52'7'1
1 1 1
8 1
+ 9
+
0 1 !*
'81 +
& !
1 1 1 +
+ +
!
"#$% &'% ()* +
!+
"1
+
:
+1 ; #
; 1!
1 ' ; / ''< 1
1
52'7'1
1 1
!
+ '0; + ==#52'79
#
; ) 9/1 2
1
0 2
1+!
: 2
!+==#52'791
1 ! #
+
!
+! + " 1 !
!
!+
"0 ! : *
'8 1 '
:
==#
!
+! +1!
1
+ !
"1!
! !
":
+!
2
!
1
+
1
!
"
!! :
'
! ! +1 + !
"3 '%
"
) ( "
- "C
$ '/5 "5)
2
'6
A" E -
) F )"- (" ( "4
)
G5'
-
$ <5', +83;) - ")-
) ="-"
';
( (
-
" " ) -" G -" "- " #
) "-
" - ?)
'8
: /2 ) ) -"
( "
) "
-
:
- " )
'*
- $ '
( ) ? E- - "" (( ) " -
"
'3
: ) - - " " "
( E- - :
',
:) - ( - - ) ( " - :
-
E
- $ '
5 "5)
)- "
'.
) "
) -(
" 5 32 24
3
%+
=1 " )
"
) - (
? 6+- $ 7#( 5 6+- $
*0 *! 9 $
3+.$ - !+$ # # )) 5
:
%
(: 8 >'16
?@'@ A
!1
12 !1 +
B +
:!
+
1 1
!
B !
: !
!+
2
+
+1
!+
B 1 !' +! + +1! +:
!
!+
1
!+ + + ! 1
!+
? <!
0+ :<
"
1'0#6) ,) 1#= ;
/ ?0
AC 166(?A
((
!+16) '
* )A
:
+ D "
&
!
' ?A52 1 E 1 1
1 1
2
?AC
?
A
! 1 D ?
AC
F ?!AC
!+ ?A G 2 " % +
?& = A ?A= 1
B ?AC ?
7 A ?A C 2 ? +A
+ 1 !
+
?A1?A?
A
?A0 +
+1 !
1 !
+
?A?!A1 ?A1?A
?A
!+1 2 1
?
7 A
2 ()*
+
,-
;
?A' ?
! A1
+ ?A:
!+ ! + 1
! !
+: +1
+
!+?2 1 : !
!
1
+
!+A ?A :
%
2 !B + 2
!+
+
2
!+:
+ ! !+: !
+ ?A :
!+ +
+ 1
1 !1
1
./* 0
, ++ + 11D: 1
1 , +
#,
7% ' = @ 1
!+ !
B +
H
B
!+ B
, H:
+ !+: !
(H !
1 !
+ 1!
! D
A'
! D#,
7% !AC
?(H
AD #(*
7% A8 ! D)
AC
D?(*
2)AD#61
7% 121 D: , + 1
#,
7% ;
!+
H;
! ;
+ + !
+ !1 + + !
: : !
+ )(H
! D
A'
D#,
7% !AC
?)(H
AD#)
7% A8 ! D)
AC
D?)
2)AD#*1(61
7% 1 1 D: (+
+
' 1
1
:
! ) H'
B
1
+
) H: ! D
A8
! +
D#
7% !AC
?) H 2
AD#*
7% A8 !?(+ A D
AC
D?*
2 AD#)1(
7% I" D :
?'A
?9A + : 0 ?
A !
'
< 8 ? AJ %'
=1 "
3*4*"
5 *<
'
3 ':= ) '** '*65 '*, #
'.,, ) 5 ?'A =
2
?9A
?
' !
+ F ?=A #
!
1
+1 1
2 1 ?5A G
D
!F %+ 2 + ( " 5 H: 1 + 2
!0
!
1
+1 1
2 ! #(1
1 #*
#(1
+ :
! 9 ! % B
% !
B
!
!
+ +
! H
+
! ! +
3 %%
=1 " $
"
4* $0 * *3*././ 6.(7)85 ): B !2 !+D & '
1(91 1(:1F : !
,+ +
"
0
+ C /
+
. 1 )'
$)
? A0
* 1 9 + ! ! > ?A
. =:
'
1
6'
$6 ? A0 (%( + 1 !@ @ 2 !+ : + !+
11 !
!@ @
@)@ &,'3
+ ,
;(*(< 1
! $
8
K. 1 '
$ ? A
<
'=
K'
1 )'
$6)6 ? A2 ! $
? A
L 0 + ! ! !
'
+ !+ !+
:
1 D ?A / 1
F C F ?A :
!+
F ?A 8 2 +! B
F
?A C 2 L I J : ! E
1
<
? +
+ ! B
+
!+
1 2 !+ 1
7 E
!
+ M+ ' $
+ ,:
!
D L D ?A
?A
!! ?A
!! ?A
, 1*K(
?A !
?A
?A
!!
2 +
1 !+
9 +1
2 G 1 !
,
<
? A + 1
! 11 B +
!
!+ ,H:B
!
"
0
C ? A1 +
?A1
1 !( H + &'
(.< 1
6H
$
N ? A.
1
1
!+
6H
!+
3#
: + 1 !+
1
( + 1 !
D = + C
?#*1 * 22,7
#61 16) 7%
) G ?(
#*16 67% 8 2
1
1 # 1*
*7% C #(1
7% C 1
+ #1(
7% /
#1
7% : #*1 ,7% :
11! #*1 ,7% 6H
+ %6
"4
) %%-"
" " ) ) -
= " /I? ' '6'2 "
) ") "
%;
J )
-
"4
"
)") -(
)
" )#( >>? "
" "-) - ( =)
"8+9 " '
3+ +++45 )" ;+ +++45 - ( -
%8
:)
) () %* +, %+'*" ?" %*
-=1 " !
>! 2 4*
4 ;
) '
?*4
4 *
3+.$ - !+$ # # >
4 "7.9
" " " " D
%3
%5: "
- " "
/ % 3+ +++452)) ( ) )" " - " (( "
"
)
"4
(
"4
(
%,
=) - $ %5: "
- - " "
" )5 " )%* +, %+'*
%.
-
3
3
)()( '
+$ % $!$
G 45 K4$ G K