High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3058/2012dismissed

M/S Satnam Agro Industries v. M/S Jammu Commission Agents

2015-08-17Mr. Justice Amit Rawal3 pages

!"##$%&%'()*)&" +, -&!"'!.*/'0)&"/%#&,!'0%)/)1!/!1!%,%&"/%$" #/2#3)/ 33#44!'"

5#/&)& -&!..)..%&&%'*#'"&,!'0%)/)1!/!1!%,%&"/%$" #/2#3)/ #&3'0#'"

"#$%& '( )* & *)+%,'(-.&

61#"1#/ #3/"#/&4$!43!3#/&.!78#!449#0"&##"1#:)0*.#'"; 8#/##//#0""1# #3/"#/&/'";

61#"1#/"1#:)0*.#'"&1)408#/#3/"#0%'"1#%*#&";

/#&#'"( / )**!44,0<$!"#, /"1#!33#44!'" / #=1',0<$!"#, /"1#/#&3'0#'" >>>>> *)+%,'

1#$1!44#'*#%'"1#3/#&#'" #*)4!/#$'033#!4%&""1# :)0*.#'"&!'00#$/##&8"1"1#)/"&8#49,91#/#87"1#&)%"/ /#$<#/7, ?, +-@!4'*9%"1%'"#/#&"!""1#/!"# A3#/!'').

/.B "%44/#!4%&!"%'#'"%/#0#$/#"!4!.)'"1!&8##'0#$/##0 / )**!44,4#!/'#0$)'&#4!33#!/%'*'8#1!4"1# !33#44!'"@0##'0!'"&)8.%"&"1!""1#34!%'"%,/$4!%.%'*"1#/#$<#/7 "1#!.)'",1!&"&"!'0'1%&9'4#*&!'03/<#"1#0$).#'"&!'0%' &)33/",/#4%#0)3'"1#3/<%&%'&#$"%'C"1#'0%!'<%0#'$#$" "$'"#'0"1!""1)*1"1#8=&!$$)'".!%'"!%'#0%'/#*)4!/$)/&#

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

33#44!'"@0##'0!'"1!&"!=#'"1#!0<!'"*#!'

&"/7 .!=%'* 3!7.#'" "1# )"&"!'0%'* !.)'" 87 9!7 $!&1 9#<#/,"1#/#%&'3/"1#&!.#!&'/#$#%3".!=%'*3!7.#'"1!& 8##' 3/<#0 ' /#$/0 <#' "1# !$$)'" &"!"#.#'" 3/0)$#0 87 "1# !33#44!'"@0##'0!'" 1!& ')44%%#0 "1# 0##'$# !& %" 0#& '" 8#!/ "1# &%*'!")/#!'7!)"1/%&#03#/&',.)$14#&&"1#34!%'"%1#!44#*#0 3!7.#'"!.)'"1!08##'"1/)*1$1#D)#&!'0#<#'"1#4!&"3!7.#'" 9!& !4&"1/)*1$1#D)#1# &"/7 3!7.#'"&87$!&10)/%'* "1# %'"#//#*').1!&'"8##'8#4%#<#087"1#)/"&8#49!&'0$).#'"!/7 #<%0#'$#%'"1!"/#*!/01!&8##'34!$#0'/#$/0!'0,"1)&,"1#&"!'0"!=#' 87"1#!33#44!'"@0##'0!'"%'"1#9/%""#'&"!"#.#'"1!&8##'0)473/<#0 "1"1#)/"&8#491!<#/#'0#/#0!%'0%'*!$",91%$1%&8!

&#0' !33/#$%!"%'/!4!'00$).#'"!/7#<%0#'$#!'0,"1)&,"1#!33#!40#&'" %'<4<#!'7&)8&"!'"%!4D)#&"%'4!91#/#%&'%44#*!4%"7!'03#/<#/&%"7 %'"1#%'0%'*&/#'0#/#0878"1"1#)/"&8#49 1#!33#!4%&!$$/0%'*470%&.

2/3 '(-.&