Kulwant Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS




   
   ! "#$ %&  '()*)+","#-   ./01'#(2"#34 566)00'#( 7)8,/, 2('() /#9':'#*'#(4)8 55 ),6#*)#(,   -  ;  2
 2
  ;  2
2$


8),)#(- 8 '1'#./<'8=0'#)>?*@+'()8(4)'66)00'#( AAA
   BC 4'00)#3)"#(4","#(8'D+/8('66)'0",(8*)8*'()*   *",<",,"#3(4)18"(6)("("#+0'"<"#338'#(4"34)86'>,+'0)#(4):',", #(""+'("#*'()* & 14)8)"#)+4#"+'0E2)<"D,="00)*$8=)8,1)8) 38'#()* 4"34)8 6'> ,+'0) # '++/#(  6,,),,"#3 +)8(""+'()  '(8"+/0'("#'#*(1>)'8,)+4#"+'08'"#"#3)8(""+'()8<
#*/,(8"'0 8'"#"#3
#,("(/(), BC 4) '66)00'#(? 14 ", '(8"+/0'() 1"(4 (48)) >)'8, "60<'? 1', '66"#()* ', "F/"* "(83)# 0'#( 6)8'(8 #  &&  # ()<68'8> :',", 14)8)'()8 4", ,)8@"+), 1)8) 8)3/0'8"G)* #  &

H

)+8/"(<)#(  (4) '66)00'#( ', "F/"* "(83)# 0'#( 6)8'(8  #  &&  1', ', 6)8 (4) /#9': #"<'0 /,:'#*8> #D "#",()8"'0! 0',,


?2)8@"+) /0),?&& 4)8)"#'()88))88)*(',I(4) /0),;!"#(4)

,'#+("#)* 6'> ,+'0) 
&% D

  # 8)+8/"(<)#(? (4) '66)00'#( 1', 38'#()*'8),'"*6'>,+'0)','0,(4)6'>8)@","#'(('+4)*1"(4(4)6'> ,+'0),/:,)F/)#(0> BHC 0'"<(4)'66)00'#(1',:',)*#(4)*)+","#'"@","# )#+4(4",/8("#+',) 

&("(0)*',2('() /#9':'#* (4)8,@ '9"#*)8 '0'/('<'#*(4)8,14)8)/6#'3)#)8'0*)+","#1', ('=)#@"*)0)(()8*'()*H 

  ##)J/8) D!(38'#(*/)60'+)<)#( "#(4)6'>,+'0)
 DH

('00(4,))<60>)),144'*#("0)*18"( 6)("("#, BC 4)$8"(/8(14"0)('="#3"#('++/#((4'((4)+0'"<(4) '66)00'#(1',838'#(4>6(4)("+'060'+)<)#(1"(48)(8,6)+("@)))+( )@)#14)#4)1',#("#,)8@"+)?*",<",,)*(4)18"(6)("("#:>40*"#3(4'( (4) 68'>)8 1', (('00> <",+#+)"@)* ', (4) *)+","# "# '9"#*)8 '0 '/('<;,+',) 2/68'!1',"#(4)+',)6)8,#,'66"#()*#(4)6,(

/<6 6)8'(8,"#(4) /#9':)'0(4)6'8(<)#(:)(1))#(4)>)'8,& ( &  '#* 1', "# (4) :'+=38/#*  8),6#*)#(,E18"( 6)("("#)8, (4)8)"# 6,,),,"#3F/'0""+'("# '(8"+/0'("#'#*+)8(""+'()(1>)'8,

'#* 6'>,+'0)
 DH

#(:)"#3)J()#*)*((4)<#(4)38/#*(4'((4)> 1)8) #( :8#) # (4) +'*8)  ()+4#"+'0 ,('  2"#+) ', 6)8 (4) '8)<)#("#)* 9/*3<)#(? 4"34)8 6'> ,+'0) 1', 0"#=)* ( )*/+'("#'0 F/'0""+'("#? "( 1',4)0* (4'((4),'<) +/0*#(:) *)#")*( )<60>)), 141)8)#(:8#)#+'*8)()+4#"+'0,('4)0)'8#)*$8"(/8(4)0* (4'( (4) +',)  (4) '66)00'#( 1', )#("8)0> *")8)#( ', '( (4) ("<) (4) '66)00'#( 1', '66"#()* #
  :',", "# (4) >)'8 && ? (4) 6,( 1', +@)8)* :> && /0), 1"(4 ' ,'#+("#)* 6'> ,+'0) 
&% D

  00 ,/:,)F/)#(6'>,+'0),?',8)@",)*?4'*:))#38'#()*((4)'66)00'#('#*"(

 4'*8"34(0>:))#4)0*14"0)*)+0"#"#34",68'>)8@"*),6)'="#38*)8*'()*

 H ##)J/8) D !(4'((4)'66)00'#(+/0*#(*)8"@)'#>:)#)"( 8<(4)*)+","#"# '9"#*)8 '0'/('<;,+',) 2/68'! B%C $)4'@)4)'8*0)'8#)*+/#,)08(4)'66)00'#(*<"(()*0>? 8)+8/"(<)#(  (4) '66)00'#( 1', <'*) "# ()8<,  (4) /0), "# (4) ,'#+("#)*6'>,+'0)((4)6,(
&% D

# && #
 :',",4)8)'()8?4)1',3"@)#'00,/:,)F/)#(6'>,+'0),',8)@",)*8< ("<) ( ("<)  4) 6)("("#)8, "# +',) $   %&  &&  ("(0)* ',

'9"#*)8 '0 '/('< '#*(4)8,@ 2('() /#9': '#*(4)8, 14"+4 1', *)+"*)*#H  %

1)8)'66"#()*#(4)6,( /<6 6)8'(8,"#(4)

/#9': )'0(4 )6'8(<)#( */8"#3 (4) 6)8"* &  ( &  
# (4) :'+=38/#**)#"'06'>D,+'0)
 DH

((4)6)("("#)8,(4)8)"## (4)38/#*(4'('0(4/34(4)>/0"00)*(4)F/'0""+'("#,?>)((4)>1)8)#( :8#)#(4)+'*8)()+4#"+'0,('?"(1',4)0*(4'(,"#+)4"34)86'>,+'0) 1', 0"#=)* ( 4"34)8 F/'0""+'("#? (4) ,'<) +/0*#( :) *)#")* ( (4,) 141)8)#(:8#)#()+4#"+'0,('1)@)8?(4)+',)(4)'66)00'#(", *",("#3/",4':0)',(4)'66"#(<)#((4)'66)00'#("#(4)>)'8&& 1',"# (4) ,'#+("#)* 6'> ,+'0) 
&% D

 ', '*<",,":0) ', 6)8 (4) /0), '660"+':0)00,/:,)F/)#(6'>,+'0),',8)@",)*8<("<)(("<)1)8)'0, 38'#()* ( (4) '66)00'#(  4) *)+","# "# '9"#*)8 '0 '/('<;, +',)

2/68'! ', <*"")* "# '66)'0 ", #( '660"+':0) ', "# (4) +',)  (4) '66)00'#(?4",'66"#(<)#(1',/#*)8(4)&& /0),1"(4','#+("#)*6'> ,+'0) 
&% D

   4) +0'"<  (4) '66)00'#( ", *) 48, (4) /0), '660"+':0)4)()8<,'#*+#*"("#,'66"#(<)#((4)'66)00'#('8) 8)3/0'()*"#'++8*'#+)1"(4(4) /0),4)+0'"<(4)'66)00'#(",8 38'#(,+'0)+#(8'8>((4'(14'(",68@"*)*8/#*)8(4)2('(/(8> /0),

 4)8)",#+4'00)#3)((4) /0),'#*)@)#(4)81",)?(4)'66)00'#(+'##( +0'"<8)0")8)+<<)#*'("#(4) '><<",,"#8)68(6)8('"#"#3( (4)>)'8& 14)#4)1',#()@)#"#,)8@"+) C

8(4)8)',#,8)+8*)*':@)?1)"#*#38/#*14'(,)@)8 ("#()8)8)1"(4(4)8*)86',,)*:>(4)0)'8#)*2"#30)/*3)*",<",,"#3(4) 18"(6)("("#1"(4+,(,
 ?

ED BC ++8*"#30>?(4)68),)#('66)'0",*",<",,)* 
  
         '<"( 
$4)(4)8,6)'="#3E8)',#)* - ),E


$4)(4)88)68(':0) - ),E