Lakhbir Singh v. Presiding Officer Industrial Tribunal Patiala & ORS
!"# $%
&" ''(()) *$ ,"$
&
$-#+$.+$- ) "$ '/ ./ 0123/45%,6.3%%%/ 0123/45%,6.3/3/46 $ $/78+ "
!-9- $"(()) %%%$ -4 ," $ (() " #
) #: !"# $ %
&" (()) ;$!< &
" $$ =
= (
#: " )$
&) 4+&
.>
;"$#: "
( &
";$ ?
@+$(
#:")$ $
&
$- #+$ .+$- ) A#+$ .+$1 $ "$ $ " #
#:&$
&(:< /
B
) +
,"(())
$$ ")$ %
&)4+&"@ "$
) &;
""
C+ )#
" # )
) & ;
" " (()- ) <
)) + (() - .
-" #
) !
& =:
1 ):
&"(()2
- )<
)) + (() - .
-" #
) !
& :
1 ):
$
&"(()
>"9"$)$ +
) $"(()) ;
""
& "$+&""$$ " ," (()) ; ((
,+#;)) ($$#: " $ ($< 0 ;$!
= ))
$
& " (()) - "
;$ ))&)): $<
;
"+ : -"$& "- (: <(
," (()) &&$ 9 &
"
$<
- $9 <
?/ ($
;$$$ +-";9$-" ;$+
+
+)0
(+
$< % "6 + $ )
(+ - = A1 $ "$; $$" )$ #+$ .+$ $ #: " #+$ .<<
$- + 7#-." &$","$ $ $$; "
D>""$ " ;$!< !"# $ %
&" ;$ $<
($($ 7+
<
$#:"< &< -;"$) ;$!<
)E $
&"(()) -" < $<
"
-"; &
&< "): )$: /
B "
7+
$ ;$ $
;"
)"; $<9 0()"" "$<
+ <(): ; -"$ $- )#$
;
"
: +))#!;& ," ! #: $ ; " " ;$!< ; && ): ;& #
;
= ?
- "
- =
=
- =
,"$ $-"; &&+ 9 )# : ;$!;
"" $ ($< $
& " $ ($< - "
;$!< (()) " <() = :
++
") ) $:$ 6; ) ()""(()) "$) $
) )
" < +#7 <$ ;"
" ;
<
#: " .+$ )$ .
) 4+& %
$
- )
,"$ $- "($ $ $ ; <
#) ," )$ #+$ .+$ $
$ " 9 <$ ) $$ ")" $<"($+ ) <+ $ $)) 3@ ? 3@ 3@ ?- 9 "";$!< " <() <$ " = :
" ) ($
& :$
<< ): # $ "
$<
6 - <$ ) %
&"- %3 > " $
9 "
9 3@
;"
""( "";$!< (()) ; && ): ;& #
= " ;$! +(
;
"
$< #$!
($ " $C+ $< " ;$! 0 ($9 " <+ $ $)) 3@ 3@ ," )$ #+$ .+$ $ # $9 " <$ ) %
&"- %3 > " <
"
< :"";$!< (()) $ 9 )$: $ =:
) ;)9 < "
<< ): ($
,"$ $- ; ") " " $<
" (()) <+ $$ "< 9
;$
++ 9 )# : ;$! ;
" " ($< 6 ; + " "$ (:- $ $$ "< <(
; ( " (()) #: " $ ($< ;" "
;$
(
;
" $
&):- ; ")""$; 9 ) "($9
% F " ,"(()) ;$!< ; -";9$- ") ) $$
=
6 ; # $9 " <() " ($9
% F " )"+&" <: ) &$ $) $
;
" +))#!;&
:
9+$ " $$ " ;$!< - " < ;+)- ";9$- < " +" $)
#&$ +< )):$ <$ +$ ," )$ #+$ .+$ () $) 0$: % 3)$
9)(< .$($ 9<
-
%..= = 0 1#)"%+($<.+$
<
";$";
)# $ #: $
&"";$!< "))#<(
#: (:< / -
B
$$
;
"#!;& ," )$ #+$ .+$ # $9 " " $ ($< &9$ #: ;
$+) $&+)
" (()) $&+)$<(): "$ ($< $($ ($+$- ; ")- " # )); ;"
) &
& "
< <():< 6 ; +$"$ ") " " " (()) ;$ $<
($ ;)9 :$ " )$: )( ,"$ $-";$!< ; ") ) $<(
/
B ;"
" ; $ # ( " ;$!< #: " $ ($< ," ;$!< (()) &&$ 9 &
" $$
?
@+$(
#:")$ #+$.+$$
)(
"
.+$
&" $$"@ " $
" # & 9 "
< ," )$
&) 4+&()$) % "$ 9) 8+<$*$<-
%.. 6 -"$ ((
$< +$:$+) 0; ) :$&+)$ ) (:
" : ( 6 ; ") #: 0 1#) " %+($< .+$ " $
$ ): " +) "9 # $ # $&+)$ G
"9
& $&$ " .
+ 2 "
%$$:- % 8$ !95<9 "$ -
=%..6; ")"" $
)((
< ""
$$ #
))&) $$&+)$- " ;+) < ;
"
" @(
$9 + #: " .
+ 2 "
($ 5< 9 +($ 0 - " #+$.+$-6 + $ ),$ #+ ) ) "0 &".+$- ")-;$
$$
$
& $&+)$
" $ 0;9$-!(
9 ;"(+) $ $+< " -
")""
$ 7+ ;+)# +# $9
$ " :#
;"
"")$:# & 9 "$ ")) # $9$H #
- " # ( +< /
B ;$ <(
," )$
&) 4+& ) () $) "
3
$- /7 " 9)(< .$($ "$ 9 I <%
&"-
%.. 0 1#)"%+($<.+$-
-")"# $@$
7+ )
$ + $% " )) $)9 $ -
)+
& " < <
$ ((
< - +$ <():< -) &" -"&$+ ;"
" "$<
"#
"):
$
&"
+ $ )
(+ ;$ # !(
9 ; # $ &$ $)
+ $ )
(+ 6 ; "
" # $;
#; ): ;&$ <(): ")
& $&+)$ ( $ " (+$(
C+ )$) 6 " ;$ +)$<
):;&$ ;"";$! $ "$($ -";$
+) #
#($($$) $"$;$ <(
+" ;+)#
;
""< 7+ 8(
9 ; " $ $+< - " )$
&) 4+& ") " " ;$!< " <() = :
($
& "
$<
($ 9 :$ " (
" $)
"
( <():$B<(): ; 9$ ,"$ $-
(
- +< /
B; $$#&$ "(())
) +
,"(()) "
)" $$ $ &$) " # () "
0 1#)"%+($<.+$
4 <$ %
&" 9 % 0$: "$- .
) (() =
-
6
+#< "
9 ; " $ +< 0 1#)"%+($<.+$-"(())
)$
>"9& 9 +$"+&" +)
$ "<$ " )$: #
% "$ 9 ) 8+<$ *$< +($
3
$- /7 " 9)(< .$($ "$ 9 I < %
&" +($- $
;$!< ;"" # $$ "
#+< $ <$ +$ "$ $+< $ ) # !
$
)+
& " < <
$ ((
< - +$ <():< -) &" -"&$+ ;"
" "$<
"#
-H#
-
#$;
#; ):;&$ <():")
&$&+)$( "($ -"(()) < ): ):;&$ "; ((
;
"
$< #$!
0
((
< ")
#:")$ #+$.+$$ # <($($
<+"
# $9"($($($+$" # ));;"
)&
"
< <():< %+" :(
B<($$: ((
< #
$$:"($9
$ ) = ".
+ - ")# ))&) "# ")#:0 1#)"%+($<.+$
5< 9 +($,")$ #+$.+$$
$< ;$ ?
")$ %
&)4+&
$< $$ =
=
$"$
"(()) #C+ $)( 9 :$ ;" "$)
"
( <():$ <():"# 9$ $ +
) $ " (()) " - ";9$- () $) 4 <$%
&"1 +($ $$
"(())
6 -$
";$!<
;
$$ 0;9$- " 6 + $ ) ,$ #+ )+<#+$ .+$-
(-
$< ;$"
"$$ $<
(
&
" ;$!< $$ "
$
;
"
:
+)) #! ;& ," ;$ " 6 + $ ) ,$ #+ ) ;
) #: " <():$ #: ;: ;$ (
"
.+$ ," %+($< .+$ # $9 " " ;$ " # ")) & #: " <():$+$&
&+ #)
""0 &".+$@$
7+$
$$:"7+&< "%+($<.+$
" %:J!#98%/"!$
"
"$ - =%./= 6/ = %. == - ;"
" ; $ $$
" 0$7
$ %
&" 9 + 7#%>$"+
&.$($ -
%..
$ $ ; ) <"
" (%"$<93@+ 9
$-+#) 0)"
-
(0$: -
%..
? = -")"")$ %
&)4+& "
2 " &".+$$$
@$
" $ +($9
$:(;$ + $$ )
".
+ 6
&
"
& $$ " # "()
9 $$ 6 ;
9 ; " ); $ $$
" $+< " " "
&
" ;$ " + $ ),$ #+ )#:")$ %
&)4+&;"
";
$<#:
2 "; ")#9
); <; $$: "7+&< "%+($<.+$$ $$"$
,"$ $-
" $+< ;"$"#+$.+$+< + $ ),$ #+ )"$$$
";$!<
" - ;"
" ; ") # <($($ #: "
.+$- " " %+($< .+$ $ $ " ;$ " #+$ .+$+<6 + $ ) ,$ #+ ) "($ -")$ #+$.+$
$
(($($
" $+< $
" (()) B;$!<
/"$ ; ") " " $ $ " $<
(
$<$" :$ "
$ 7+ ;+) # +# $9
<(
/
B; $#( " ;$!< (()) #:"$ ($< ,")$ %
&)4+&
"($ " +(")" ;$ " )$ #+$ .+$ " " <+ <(
/
B #: ")
&"" ;$!< " ;$! ): $;:$
< "
"$)9 (
<-
=
- "($ 9 :$ ")(
"$)
"
( <():$ <():; 9$6; ")
# ;"$";$(
#:")$ #+$.+$" #
,"$ $-"$ "7+&<
4 <$%
&"1 +($;+) (():" $+< "($ 2
-"
#
$ ;
$+< ,"$ # $ 7! $<+)
"
$&$"
&- $ )( <$" ?:$ - ;+)#C+
C+ + <($($ $$ $
" (()) - ( )): ;" " )$
&) 4+& " " " <+ <(
(:#) "
< /
B/
B;
"
$ "$ K($
+< " $+< - ;
<$
" (() ," C+ ):
& $
&"(()
" $+<
):< $
&):- " (() " ) <
)) + (()
!
& ):
& $
&"(() $
<
%%%/ 45I3 /3/46 45I3
/< "B8+ )